Pub forced to pay family £75,000 after false 'dine and dash' accusations
A Facebook post from bosses at the Horse and Jockey in Tideswell, Derbyshire, condemned the behaviour of Peter and Ann McGirr despite them paying in full for their £150 meal
A pub which falsely accused a family of running off and not paying £150 for their food bill has been ordered by a court to pay £75,000 in damages. A Facebook post from bosses at the Horse and Jockey in Tideswell, Derbyshire, condemned the behaviour of Peter and Ann McGirr who had been dining with their adult children.
The post claimed the group of four ate two £27 10oz ribeye steaks with all the trimmings and two £15.25 Derbyshire gammon steaks, and drank real ales and lagers. The post included CCTV images and was picked up by the media and used in press reports where they were referred to as 'dine-and-dashers'.
It later emerged that the family did pay the bill in full, and a mistake by staff member meant it was not rung through the till.
At Belfast Crown Court the family, from County Tyrone, Northern Ireland, sued the pub, saying they had suffered significant embarrassment and reputational damage.
The family's barrister Peter Girvan told the court: "These articles contained serious and defamatory accusations that the plaintiffs had engaged in dishonest and criminal conduct by deliberately absconding without settling a bill of approximately £150.
"The allegations were entirely false. The plaintiffs had not engaged in any such conduct, and the statements made by the defendants had no factual basis."
The pub accepted there was "no basis whatsoever" for the allegations and apologised, the court heard. It agreed to pay £75,000 in damages as well as the family's legal costs, as part of a settlement agreement.
Reading a statement outside court, the family's solicitor, Darragh Carney, said the McGirr's had been "vindicated". He added they were "very satisfied with the settlement" as compensation for "defamation of their character".
A statement issued by the pub in July last year read: "We want to sincerely apologise to the people involved because we have now learnt that they did in fact pay for their meal.
"There was no dishonesty involved from our staff, it was an honest mistake but we have dismissed the member of staff responsible for the error."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South Wales Argus
an hour ago
- South Wales Argus
Former cannabis factory helps Lliswerry pond into bloom
The fertiliser has been used to create an explosion of colour in a picturesque part of the city. Officers took ownership of the unused fertiliser while dismantling the cannabis cultivation in a disused factory last year, leading to two arrests. Gwent Police donated the fertiliser to Lliswerry Pond and, during the winter months, leaseholder Ben Edmunds used it in raised beds and borders around the Aberthaw Road site. Police Community Support Officer (PCSO) Joanne Spiteri, from the neighbourhood policing team at Alway, visited the fishery to see the marigolds, busy lizzies and wild flowers flourishing at first-hand. Sergeant Chris Hopkin said: "PCSO Spiteri and her colleagues work closely with Ben to help keep the area around Lliswerry Pond safe from anti-social behaviour and associated crime. "Back in November, our officers dismantled a cannabis factory at a disused warehouse in Kelvedon Street and we were delighted to donate the unused fertiliser to Lliswerry Pond to help with their outdoor floral displays. 'By re-purposing the fertiliser, it has certainly helped to bring some additional colour to the site and puts items that are often thought to be used for criminal purposes to use that benefit our communities. "Lliswerry Pond is a jewel of the local community that many residents enjoy visiting, particularly when the sun is shining during the summer months. 'I hope that members of the community are enjoying these floral displays too.' Ben Edmunds and Leanne Bill lease Lliswerry Pond from Newport City Council through their company, Angling Watch UK. He said: 'We pride ourselves in being at the heart of our community, and we're delighted to have benefited positively from the dismantling of the cannabis factory last year. 'Our floral displays look fantastic – the marigolds, busy lizzies and wild flowers from Keep Wales Tidy are flowering beautifully in the raised beds. "We have an excellent working relationship with Gwent Police and the neighbourhood policing team at Alway and I want to thank the local community for their continued support." If you have any information on drug supply in your area, no matter how big or small you think it might be, please get in touch with Gwent Police. The production, sale and supply of illegal drugs can have far-reaching effects on our communities, and we'll continue to do all we can to take action and protect vulnerable people from harm. Anyone with relevant information can contact police via our website, call on 101, or send us a direct message on our Facebook or X channels, so that we can act. You can also call Crimestoppers, anonymously, on 0800 555 111, with information or visit their website.
Wales Online
2 hours ago
- Wales Online
Man responded to Facebook post and it ended up costing him more than £1,200
Man responded to Facebook post and it ended up costing him more than £1,200 James Joyce claimed he 'did everything by the book' - but it turned out to be untrue A man has been ordered to pay a total of £1,274 after taking away waste despite not having a licence to do so (Image: Neath Port Talbot Council ) A man has been ordered to pay more than £1,200 after responding to a Facebook post asking someone to remove waste even though he was not licensed to do so. Unknown to James Joyce, 45, of Llangyfelach Road, Swansea, the Facebook post was part of Operation Walt - a joint "test purchase" operation to combat unlicensed waste carriers by Neath Port Talbot Council with partners South Wales Police. After Joyce responded to the social media post, he removed the waste advertised for £40 from Lonlas Village Workshops in October of last year. He assured a member of staff he spoke to at the workshops "he did everything by the book". Don't miss a court report by signing up to our crime newsletter here . After driving away with the waste, Joyce was stopped and spoken to by waste enforcement officers. A check confirmed that he did not have a licence to transport waste so he was issued an Fixed Penalty Notice (FPN) for the offence. As payment was not received, a reminder letter was sent to Joyce who made no contact with waste enforcement officers and as such a final reminder letter was sent out via first class post in November last year. Article continues below Later, after the FPN was not still not paid he was prosecuted for carrying controlled waste, contrary to s1(5) of the Control of Pollution (amendment) Act 1989. At Swansea Magistrates Court on Thursday, May 29, Joyce pleaded guilty to the offence and was fined £615, ordered to pay costs of £413 and given a £246 victim surcharge - a total of £1,274. Councillor Scott Jones, Neath Port Talbot Council's cabinet member for streetscene, said: "The cheap and unlawful removal of waste by unlicensed persons, has an effect on the local economy in that it presents unfair competition to legitimate businesses and this case shows the council and its partners will use every power available to them to bring to justice anyone who moves waste without the proper licence being in place."
Metro
3 hours ago
- Metro
Rough sleeping to be decriminalised with 1824 law finally scrapped
Rough sleeping will no longer be a crime in the UK as the government abolishes a 'cruel' 200-year-old law. The Vagrancy Act 1824 was introduced amid a spiralling homelessness crisis after the Industrial Revolution. Most of the act has been repealed, though some are still in force in England and Wales to police begging and rough sleeping. But the government announced today it will scrap the bill 'for good' by Spring next year. On any given night last autumn, 4,667 people were sleeping rough, a 164% increase from 2010, according to official figures. In 2023, 298 people were convicted under the act. The Deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner said: 'We are drawing a line under nearly two centuries of injustice towards some of the most vulnerable in society, who deserve dignity and support. More Trending 'No one should ever be criminalised simply for sleeping rough and by scrapping this cruel and outdated law, we are making sure that can never happen again.' Matt Downie, chief executive of Crisis, said: 'This is a landmark moment that will change lives and prevent thousands of people from being pushed into the shadows, away from safety. 'For 200 years, the Vagrancy Act has meant that people who are homeless are treated as criminals and second-class citizens. It has punished people for trying to stay safe and done nothing to address why people become homeless in the first place. 'Ending the use of the Vagrancy Act recognises a shameful history of persecuting people for poverty and destitution, something that figures like William Wilberforce and Winston Churchill warned against in their opposition to the Act.' Got a story? Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at webnews@ Or you can submit your videos and pictures here. For more stories like this, check our news page. Follow on Twitter and Facebook for the latest news updates. You can now also get articles sent straight to your device. Sign up for our daily push alerts here. MORE: Sizewell C nuclear plant gets £14,200,000,000 green light from government MORE: Seven predictions for what Rachel Reeves could reveal in her spending review MORE: Government finally reveals who will get winter fuel payout after U-turn
