logo
Pahalgam attack: A leaf out of old Pak army playbook?

Pahalgam attack: A leaf out of old Pak army playbook?

Hindustan Times23-04-2025

ISLAMABAD : It was long apprehended by peace activists in Pakistan. Now, it has happened – a terrorist attack in Pahalgam, Kashmir.
Well-meaning elements in Pakistan were on tenterhooks when the secessionist Baloch Liberation Army last month attacked the Jaffar Express, killing dozens. At the time, the Pakistani ministry of foreign affairs (MOFA), without specifically blaming India for the incident, accused it of 'sponsoring' terrorism in Pakistan. The peaceniks were worried Pakistan might retaliate, thereby triggering a spiral of tit-for-tat. They hoped that Pakistani chief of army staff (COAS), General Asim Munir, going ballistic in a recent speech would be the response. That hope was belied on Tuesday.
But why did Munir suddenly go off on a tangent with a volley of hostility towards India? And what can be made of the strike in Kashmir, the worst in years?
Salman Raja, the lawyer of ousted Pakistani PM Imran Khan, contended, 'His continued incarceration is fuelling public anger and alienation.'
The Pakistan Muslim League's Nawaz Sharif, as prime minister, attempted to prune the army's powers, but without success. However, the confrontation between the army and Imran Khan, leader of the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI), who is now in jail, could have caused an erosion in Pakistanis' goodwill towards their army; and its General Headquarters (GHQ) seem to be struggling to combat this slippage.
Indeed, the development has been seen in some academic, media and political circles in Islamabad as a reason for Munir's surprisingly sharp rhetoric – an attempt, in other words, to regain favourable public ratings.
Besides, as Raja put it, Pakistan's foreign policy is 'guided by the vision of the armed forces about the requirements of national security'. Thus, the diatribe against India.
A former director-general of the Pakistan Army's espionage wing, Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI), said GHQ was losing patience over what they believed was India aiding and abetting the Afghanistan-based Tehrik-i-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) – which a United Nations Security Council resolution says hopes to 'overthrow' the Pakistani government 'to establish an emirate based on its interpretation of Islamic law' – and separatists in the western Pakistani province of Balochistan.
Sitting across him, a retired senior officer of the Indian external intelligence agency, Research and Analysis Wing (R&AW), who narrowly missed becoming this organisation's chief, challenged the ex-DG of ISI by saying TTP was too small an outfit to pose a threat to Pakistan.
There's a kind of hush in Pakistan; especially in its twin cities of Islamabad, the country's capital, and Rawalpindi, where the GHQ is located and which is looked upon in diplomatic circles as the nation's nerve centre. People at best converse in whispers.
Raja is a graduate of Cambridge University and Harvard Law School. Now in his 50s, he's reputed to be a skilful attorney, and defended Sharif when he was ousted from office in 2017 and his family was accused of having links with off-shore companies. At present, he is not merely counsel for Sharif's arch opponent, Khan, but also secretary-general of PTI.
On a balmy late March evening in Islamabad, Raja drove up in a white SUV to collect me from my hotel. It was after dinner. We went to a café in a parade buzzing with customers at restaurants and other retail outlets, which have mushroomed in Islamabad. A stream of people came up to greet him, reminding him of messages they sent to him, or sought an appointment for a future meeting. In today's complex Pakistani politics, Raja is a quintessential Opposition insider.
Khan, an Oxford graduate, celebrated cricketer and captain of the squad that won Pakistan's only Cricket World Cup in 1992, took the plunge into politics in 1996 by forming PTI.
For over 20 years, he languished in the wilderness, barring winning his own seat and making gradual headway at the provincial level in the North West Frontier Province, now known as Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. Then, in a trice, he became the flavour of the season; with the not-so-tacit backing of the puissant Pakistan Army.
There were always competing opinions about Khan's abilities as a politician, even more so about his eligibility to be prime minister. Yet, the men in uniform saw in him an alternative. But within six months of his election as prime minister in 2018 – suspected to have been engineered in his favour – the aforementioned DG, ISI, said the choice was seen as a mistake.
While the kingmakers pondered over how to eject him and whom to replace him with, Khan and PTI's head start in the sphere of social media and his anti-corruption stance enhanced his popularity, even penetrating into significant sections of serving and retired armed forces' personnel and their families.
There arrived, though, a moment when GHQ decided it was time to act. With a chunk of his lawmakers abandoning him under pressure from the powers-that-be, Khan's coalition government was defeated in a confidence vote on April 9, 2022. 'It reflected the basic fault line in Pakistani politics…including the functioning of parliament,' said Raja.
'Every election result is manoeuvred by the Establishment (code for the Pakistan Army and its allies in the top echelons of the civil service) to ensure that no single party is able to form a government on its own. There is always an Establishment-backed party, with sufficient seats given to it, that can help topple a government once the main opposition parties have been given the go-ahead by the Establishment. The PTI government headed by Imran Khan was brought down with the Establishment shepherding the process,' he said.
Asked about the general elections on February 8, 2024, which independent observers were convinced wasn't free or fair, Raja alleged the vote 'was massively rigged, not during polling but through consolidation of results'.
''The actual results recorded at polling stations in nearly a 100 national assembly seats and an even larger number on the provincial assembly elections in Punjab, Sindh, Balochistan were changed. This is universally accepted inside Pakistan. Imran Khan's PTI won a landslide victory,' he said.
'The PTI was disallowed from participating in the election as a party. Its candidates were declared independents. Even so, PTI backed candidates won over 90 seats. The actual number should have been closer to 180 seats in the National Assembly,' he added.
Raja said Khan's arrest and detention was part of the latest effort at political engineering by the Establishment. 'Cases against him are silly. The entire judicial system has been assaulted through the Establishment mandated 26th Amendment to the (Pakistan) Constitution and a campaign of intimidation of independent-minded judges.'
Reacting to the amendment enacted last October, the secretary-general of the International Court of Justice, Santiago Canton, indicated that the changes incorporated in it 'bring an extraordinary level of political influence over the process of judicial appointments and the judiciary's own administration.'
'Six judges of the Islamabad high court wrote a letter to the then Chief Justice of Pakistan complaining of surveillance and intimidation to which they had been subjected by the agencies. The main object of this assault on the judiciary is to prevent Imran Khan and his party members from getting justice,' alleged Raja
In the past, the Establishment has done deals, whereby an accused, convicted or imprisoned politician has been let off in lieu of leaving the country. Is such an understanding in the pipeline? 'There is no formal offer. However, Imran Khan has himself alluded to offers requiring him to go politically silent in return for his freedom,' Raja said.
The Pakistan Army and MOFA did not respond to a request for comment.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Bid to revive J&K tourism: BJP leader plays cricket in Pahalgam; watch video
Bid to revive J&K tourism: BJP leader plays cricket in Pahalgam; watch video

Time of India

time26 minutes ago

  • Time of India

Bid to revive J&K tourism: BJP leader plays cricket in Pahalgam; watch video

Screengrab PTI NEW DELHI: Jammu & Kashmir BJP leader Ravinder Raina on Tuesday played cricket with Pahalgam locals in a bid to revive normalcy in the Valley, which witnessed a sharp decline in tourism after the April 22 terrorist attack at Baisaran meadow. In the clip, the BJP leader was seen bowling and batting with the local kids of the Valley. The efforts are being made from several quarters to revive tourism in Kashmir as travel agents from across the country will converge in Kashmir this weekend to boost tourism in the Valley. The Travel Agents Federation of India (TAFI), which is one of the country's biggest umbrella organisations for agents with over 1,600 members, will be holding its meeting in Srinagar and Pahalgam from June 13-16 to instil confidence among the fraternity. Srinagar hotels and flights commanded a big premium before the Pahalgam attack as Kashmir was seeing unprecedented tourist footfalls post Covid. But after the April 22 attack, tourists already there left Kashmir in droves and those who had plans to visit cancelled the same. J&K is currently focussed on ensuring a safe Amarnath Yatra as they hope that will send out a message that tourists can return to Kashmir. The yatra duration has been curtailed to 38 days, instead of 52 days in 2024, and will be on between July 3 and August 9, 2025. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Your Address of Pride – Signature Global SPR Signature Global Book Now Undo A total of 581 companies from various Central Armed Police Forces, along with personnel from the Jammu and Kashmir Police, will be deployed along the pilgrimage routes to ensure safety of the lakhs of pilgrims. The tourism industry in Kashmir has been badly hit since Pakistan-backed terrorists killed 26 civilians in Pahalgam on April 22. The attack sent a shockwave across the nation, prompting the government to take kinetic action against terror camps deep into Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied Jammu and Kashmir (PoJK). The Indian forces, in a big action, destroyed the terror camps of Jaish and Lashkar located in Pakistan's Bahawalpur and Muridke.

Students living in U.S. being repeatedly mistreated but PM Modi is silent: Congress
Students living in U.S. being repeatedly mistreated but PM Modi is silent: Congress

The Hindu

time29 minutes ago

  • The Hindu

Students living in U.S. being repeatedly mistreated but PM Modi is silent: Congress

The Congress on Tuesday (June 10, 2025) slammed the government after a video emerged showing an Indian student being handcuffed and pinned to the floor at a U.S. airport, and demanded that Prime Minister Narendra Modi should immediately talk to President Donald Trump to appeal for intervention on the 'mistreatment' of Indians in America. Congress leaders shared the video and pictures of an Indian student handcuffed and pinned to the floor at U.S.'s Newark Airport before he was allegedly deported. The Consulate General of India in New York has said it is in touch with local authorities after the video surfaced online showing the young Indian man being handcuffed and allegedly being deported. 'We have come across social media posts claiming that an Indian national is facing difficulties at Newark Liberty International Airport. We are in touch with local authorities in this regard,' the Indian Consulate said in a post on X. U.S. crackdown on students | What are New Delhi's options | Worldview Congress general secretary in-charge communications Jairam Ramesh alleged that the Modi Government is continuously failing to protect the honour of India and Indians. 'For the first time in history, a foreign head of state has declared ceasefire between India and Pakistan in India's absence. US President Trump is continuously claiming to have ensured a ceasefire by pressuring India,' Mr. Ramesh said in his post in Hindi on X. 'For the past one year, Indian citizens and students living in America are being repeatedly mistreated but Prime Minister Modi is maintaining silence or it should be assumed that he is unable to muster the courage to speak,' Mr. Ramesh said. He is the Prime Minister of India, it is his most important responsibility to protect the honour and respect of India and Indians, Mr. Ramesh asserted. 'We demand that Prime Minister Modi should immediately talk to President Trump and appeal for intervention on the mistreatment and atrocities being committed against Indians in America,' he said. Congress' media and publicity department head Pawan Khera tagged a post on X carrying the video, which was posted online by an Indian-American social entrepreneur Kunal Jain. The video shows the Indian man pinned to the ground by Port Authority Police and being handcuffed. 'I witnessed a young Indian student being deported from Newark Airport last night — handcuffed, crying, treated like a criminal. He came chasing dreams, not causing harm. As an NRI, I felt helpless and heartbroken. This is a human tragedy,' Mr. Jain said in his post. Tagging Mr. Jain's post, Mr. Khera said, 'This is too painful, too humiliating and too distressing to watch. As a country, why should we tolerate this humiliation?' 'From the days where we showed the muscle to the U.S. during the Devyani Khobragade issue to now seeing our citizens being treated like animals, do we have no goodwill left in the world?' the Congress leader said.

Explained: China's monopoly on rare earth minerals spooking the world; what does it mean for India & what is it doing?
Explained: China's monopoly on rare earth minerals spooking the world; what does it mean for India & what is it doing?

Time of India

time30 minutes ago

  • Time of India

Explained: China's monopoly on rare earth minerals spooking the world; what does it mean for India & what is it doing?

China's firm grip on rare earths, essential components in the production of phones, automobiles and missiles, is giving a headache to countries world over, including India. (AI image) China's firm grip and worldwide monopoly on rare earth metals, essential components in the production of phones, automobiles and missiles, is giving a headache to countries world over, including India. Despite mounting pressure from countries including the US, EU and India, China remains steadfast in its stance regarding export limitations of these critical rare earths. Recent reports have highlighted increasing worries within the Indian automotive sector regarding the limited availability of rare earth magnets. These components are essential for electric vehicles and certain parts in conventional internal combustion engine vehicles. Furthermore, India's industrial sectors have expressed apprehension over China's decision to restrict rare earth exports, particularly germanium. This plays a vital role in the production of semiconductors, fibre optic cables and solar panels. Critical minerals and metals, including cobalt, copper, lithium, nickel and rare earth elements, are fundamental components in manufacturing environmentally friendly energy solutions, from wind power installations to battery-powered automobiles. What's China's hold on rare earths? China has established control over critical mineral deposits worldwide. Rare earth minerals comprise a collection of 17 metallic elements. While these elements are found across various countries, extracting them is expensive and environmentally damaging, resulting in substantial pollution. The International Energy Agency reports that whilst China produces 61 % of globally mined rare earths, it dominates 92% of worldwide production output. Following Premier Li Qiang's decree implementing export controls on rare earths, China has reportedly intensified these restrictions after US President Donald Trump levied 146% tariffs on Chinese exports. Recently Trump said that Chinese President Xi Jinping has allowed some rare earths to flow to the US. In a recent column in TOI, Tanmay Kumarr Baid & Pranay Kotasthane of Takshashila Institution argued that by restricting shipments, Beijing is lifting prices worldwide and incentivising countries to set up processing elsewhere. 'Once the capital is sunk into new refining in the rest of the world, even a later U‑turn by China cannot quickly claw these customers back,' they said. However, experts Ajit Ranade and Shardul Manurkar believe that China's rare-earth dominance is not a fragile or accidental monopoly, it is a product of deep, deliberate, and sustained strategy. 'Attempts to counter this dominance must acknowledge the scale of the challenge,' they say. Also Read | Move away from China: Shein & Reliance aim selling 'Made in India' clothes abroad; to list India-made clothes on US, UK websites How much does it impact India? The Indian automobile sector continues to face challenges as China maintains restrictions on critical rare earth magnet supplies, even though nine parts manufacturers received endorsements for their import requests from the Chinese embassy. The flow of supplies remains halted, pending approval from China's commerce ministry. These magnets play a crucial role in the production of electric vehicles and are essential for various automotive components, including gear mechanisms and drive trains. The Society of Indian Automobile Manufacturers delivered a presentation to Indian government officials on May 28, urging immediate dialogue between India and China to expedite stalled approvals and simplify the complex procedures. The automotive industry body emphasised the need for bilateral discussions to address these regulatory challenges, according to a Bloomberg report. Saurabh Agarwal, Partner & Automotive Tax Leader, EY India says, 'The recent actions by China have significantly disrupted global supply chains, particularly through their increasing export control over critical commodities. This underscores the urgent need for India, and indeed any nation, to foster a self-sustaining economy. We must prioritize developing our own critical mineral resources and building an end-to-end domestic supply chain, especially as the world shifts towards greater self-reliance. ' 'Given the current trajectory of our growing economy, it's imperative that the government introduces a Production-Linked Incentive (PLI) scheme specifically for rare earth magnets and critical mineral recycling. This will be crucial in the mid-term for establishing a robust domestic supply chain,' he tells TOI. 'In the short run, we must leverage our diplomatic channels to engage with the Chinese government and resolve the immediate challenges around export control licenses. This is essential to prevent production stoppages in our industries,' he adds. Also Read | 'No longer any question..': Donald Trump says China's Xi Jinping has agreed to let rare earth minerals flow to US; sign of thawing tensions What India is doing India is currently negotiating with China regarding the procurement of permanent magnets made from rare earth minerals, whilst simultaneously exploring alternative supply channels for these vital components, according to commerce and industry minister Piyush Goyal. The minister confirmed that the administration maintains regular communication with domestic industry stakeholders to accelerate the development of indigenous sources. "There is a concern... our embassy is in dialogue with them (China)... commerce and industry ministry is also working," Goyal said, adding that the government had already begun work on developing alternate sources. The minister addressed concerns regarding China's halt on permanent magnet exports to India, acknowledging its impact on the automotive sector, white goods and other industries. He mentioned that whilst some companies have submitted applications, they anticipate favourable responses for permanent magnet approvals. Additionally, the government is collaborating with Indian Rare Earths Ltd to accelerate domestic resource development, Goyal stated. When questioned about potential production-linked incentive schemes for magnets, Goyal confirmed discussions with the automotive industry and expressed confidence in finding a solution. He noted that ongoing dialogues with innovators and startups indicate their willingness to support funding requirements and price adjustments necessary to stimulate sector growth and expansion. Also Read | Economy in dire straits, India's Indus Waters Treaty blow: Can Pakistan avoid the 'begging bowl'? Regarding alternative solutions, the minister highlighted potential technological developments within India. Goyal emphasised the collaborative efforts between government, industry, startups and innovators. He acknowledged possible short-term challenges but expressed confidence in achieving success over medium to long-term periods. Goyal recently said that the world must acknowledge the dangers of critical minerals and their supply chains being concentrated in a few geographies, as this concentration could impede economic progress of countries. He said that India has initiated measures, including support for startups conducting research and development, to discover innovative and alternative solutions, he noted. This will help reduce "our over dependence and over reliance on certain critical minerals," Goyal said. Critical minerals like copper, lithium, nickel, cobalt and rare earth elements play a vital role in advancing clean energy technologies. These critical minerals are fundamental components in the manufacturing of wind turbines, electricity networks, electric vehicles and batteries. As countries worldwide accelerate their shift towards clean energy, the requirement for these essential minerals continues to rise. The government's initiative for recycling critical minerals, including copper, lithium, nickel, cobalt and rare earth elements, is approaching its conclusive phase, according to a mines ministry official's statement. The National Critical Mineral Mission (NCMM) has received Rs 1,500 crore in the Union budget for recycling critical minerals, Dinesh Mahur, Joint Secretary in the Mines Ministry has said. The government's earlier approval of the National Critical Mineral Mission, with a budget of Rs 16,300-crore and a total allocation of Rs 34,300 crore distributed across seven years, aims to boost self-sufficiency and expedite India's shift towards green energy. The mission, which seeks to encourage exploration of critical minerals domestically and in offshore regions, anticipates a substantial contribution of Rs 18,000 crore from public sector enterprises. The primary aims of this initiative include enhancing exploration activities, lessening dependence on imports, securing mineral deposits abroad, advancing processing technologies for these crucial minerals and establishing recycling mechanisms. Stay informed with the latest business news, updates on bank holidays and public holidays . AI Masterclass for Students. Upskill Young Ones Today!– Join Now

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store