Sycamore Gap accused claims 'best pal' did it
One of the men who denies cutting down the world famous Sycamore Gap tree has told jurors his co-accused "best pal" admitted doing it.
The tree had grown in a dip on Hadrian's Wall in Northumberland for more than 100 years before it was felled in a "moronic mission" in the early hours of 28 September 2023, Newcastle Crown Court has heard.
Daniel Michael Graham, 39, from Carlisle, and Adam Carruthers, 32, from Wigton in Cumbria, each deny two counts of criminal damage relating to the tree and the Roman Wall.
Mr Graham claimed Mr Carruthers had previously "mentioned" cutting the tree down and the morning after it was felled, admitted he did it.
Jurors were previously told the tree was a much-loved landmark and had global significance for its position on the former frontier of the Roman empire.
Live coverage of the trial
Mr Graham's phone and Range Rover were both tracked going to and from the site while a video, which prosecutors allege show the moment the tree was felled, was filmed on his mobile, the court has heard.
A wedge of wood was taken as a "trophy" and photographed hours later alongside a chainsaw in the booth of Mr Graham's car, prosecutors have said.
On the fourth day of the trial, Mr Graham told jurors he had nothing to do with felling the tree or damaging the Roman wall, a couple of stones of which were fractured when the sycamore toppled on to them.
He said other people often used his car, and his iPhone 13 must have been left in it when someone drove it on 27 September.
Mr Graham said he and his co-accused were the "best of pals" in September 2023, with Mr Carruthers often working for his groundworks firm with tasks including felling trees.
He claimed Mr Carruthers showed him a piece of string in 2021 which the younger man said he had used to measure the circumference of the "most famous tree in the world", jurors heard.
Mr Graham also said Mr Carruthers had "mentioned" chopping the tree down when he bought a chainsaw with a bar "big enough to cover the circumference of the tree".
The morning after the felling, Mr Graham claimed Mr Carruthers called him on WhatsApp to say he had cut down the tree, but Mr Graham did not believe him.
Some time afterwards, Mr Graham said Mr Carruthers visited him one night and, when discussion turned to the tree, his co-accused asked him to "take the blame".
Mr Graham claimed he was told the police would be "more lenient" on him as he had mental health issues and he would "get away with it", but Mr Graham refused to do as Mr Carruthers asked.
In cross-examination, Mr Carruthers' barrister Andrew Gurney suggested Mr Graham's claims were "not true" and a "complete fabrication".
Mr Graham replied they were "110% true" and Mr Gurney was paid to portray him as a liar.
Asked when he decided to turn on his good friend Mr Carruthers, Mr Graham said it was when the accusations started to harm his business.
Prosecutor Richard Wright KC asked Mr Graham why someone would have taken his Range Rover for the job, with Mr Graham saying it was because it was a "4x4".
He said his co-accused had access to his phone and car and was "capable" of felling the tree.
Mr Graham said he had been asleep the whole night in his caravan.
Mr Wright asked why his "large and vocal" dog, which would surely have gone "berserk" if anyone entered his yard and took a vehicle, did not bark and wake him.
Mr Graham said it was a windy and noisy night so the dog may not have heard anything, besides which it would not have barked if it heard Mr Carruthers because it would have recognised his voice.
Mr Graham also said he had not heard of the tree until Mr Carruthers mentioned it in 2021.
Mr Wright challenged Mr Graham, saying he had reported a car stolen from Steel Rigg, the nearest car park to the tree, in December 2020.
Mr Graham said he had parked at the car park to go for a walk with his dogs but did not know about the tree, and while he had seen the 1992 movie Robin Hood: Prince Of Thieves in which the tree appears, he did not know where it had been filmed.
Earlier on Friday, the trial heard a man made an anonymous call to Northumbria Police in August 2024 to say Mr Carruthers cut the tree down and had the wedge of wood taken from it.
Det Insp Calum Meikle said he immediately recognised the voice of the caller to be Mr Graham, with investigations revealing Mr Graham's phone had called the police's 101 number at that exact time.
The officer agreed with Mr Carruthers' barrister Andrew Gurney that there was "no uncertainty" the call had been made by Mr Graham.
Mr Graham admitted he made the call and said police were not doing a good job of catching the real people responsible.
The trial continues.
Follow BBC North East on X, Facebook, Nextdoor and Instagram. Send your story ideas here.
HM Courts and Tribunals Service
Sycamore Gap accused blamed pal in call, jury told
Video shows felling of much-loved tree, jury told
Sycamore Gap accused kept trophy of tree, jury told
Sycamore Gap jury told to 'set emotion aside'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
5 hours ago
- Yahoo
Some Mother Emanuel Families Say the Focus on Forgiveness Has Cost Them Justice
Malcolm Graham says that his sister's body was still in the morgue when he noticed that people were rallying around the importance of forgiving her killer. A librarian who loved her community, Cynthia Graham Hurd was one of the nine Black worshippers who were fatally shot on June 17, 2015, at Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal Church in Charleston, South Carolina. She and other church members were in the middle of a Bible study session when the gunman walked into Mother Emanuel, sat with them for 45 minutes, and then opened fire. Malcolm Graham, who moved to Charlotte, North Carolina, for college, was getting ready for bed when he saw a news report about a shooting at the church that's been a haven for his family for more than half a century. After he learned that his sister had attended Bible study at Mother Emanuel that night and couldn't be found, he began preparing for the worst. Within days, some of the victims' family members said that they had forgiven the gunman, stressing that 'hate won't win,' and political leaders praised this spirit of forgiveness. Graham underscored that he respects that everyone walks in their faith differently. He also appreciates that, sometimes, forgiving is more about helping a victim's loved ones to move on than about absolving a perpetrator of their sins. Even so, in the 10 years since the shooting, Graham and others in the Mother Emanuel community feel as if the focus on forgiveness has come at the expense of crucial conversations on issues such as the ongoing dangers of racism and political action that might protect against hate crimes. 'I didn't forgive then, and I don't forgive now,' Graham, a member of the Charlotte City Council, told Capital B. He added that 'we need to ask tough questions' about discrimination and hatred — for instance, examine the radicalization that continues to occur through fringe online platforms — even if we have to sit with the discomfort of the answers. But that hasn't really happened, he said, 'because people want to race to forgiveness.' The other victims of the 2015 shooting were the Rev. Sharonda Coleman-Singleton, Susie Jackson, the Rev. DePayne Middleton-Doctor, the Rev. Clementa Pinckney (who also was a state senator), Ethel Lance, Tywanza Sanders, the Rev. Daniel Simmons, and the Rev. Myra Thompson. Busts memorializing the victims — who are known as the Emanuel Nine — were recently unveiled at Allen University, a historically Black school in Columbia, South Carolina, where many of them had connections. The university's Boeing Institute on Civility, which sponsored the project, said in a statement that the occasion 'represents both an act of tribute and a renewed commitment to confronting hate with hope.' This is a mission that the Emanuel Nine Memorial also embraces. Like Graham, Pinckney's wife is adamant about grappling with difficult conversations. Jennifer Pinckney and the couple's younger daughter, Malana, who was 6 years old at the time, survived the shooting by hiding under a desk in a church office while the gunman slaughtered the worshippers. In the years since, Pinckney, who has said that she has struggled with forgiveness, has been in the vanguard of a push to hold social media companies liable for how racism is incubated and spread online. The Pinckney family has asked the U.S. Supreme Court to hold Facebook responsible for allegedly radicalizing the gunman, challenging legislation that broadly protects platforms from having to answer for content published on their sites. The family contends that though Facebook 'does not create extremists out of whole cloth,' it 'also is not just a fabric store' — its algorithm gave the gunman racist propaganda that 'led to the real-world consequence' of mass murder. Earlier this year, the family experienced a legal disappointment when the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 4th Circuit ruled 2-1 that the law affords Facebook immunity from liability for the content its users post. A strong opinion from the dissenting judge encouraged one of the family's attorneys to appeal the case to the Supreme Court, according to The Post and Courier. It could be months before the high court decides whether to hear the appeal. Alana Grant — Simmons' granddaughter — also is frustrated with the attention that forgiveness receives in the conversation around Mother Emanuel when political action in response to the shooting has lagged. It was a powerful move of the Holy Spirit, Grant told Capital B, for Nadine Collier to forgive the gunman mere days after he killed her mother, Ethel Lance. Lance was a church sexton, and just after the shooting, the cloud of despair hanging over Charleston was still as thick — and as oppressive — as the city's humidity during the summer. 'However, I believe that we have to stop weaponizing forgiveness and trying to use it as a tool to circumvent accountability,' Grant said. 'The Lord asks us to forgive, but he also asks us to take responsibility for our actions. I've been on my journey to forgiveness and healing, but people don't realize how much more difficult they make it when they focus on forgiveness, or they suggest that there's a certain way a community should respond to victimization.' Something Grant wants, she explained, is state hate crime legislation. Though most states have laws that explicitly address hate crimes — or acts motivated by bias against an identity category — South Carolina is one of the last remaining states without such laws. Reported hate crimes in South Carolina have ballooned by 77% in recent years, from 65 incidents in 2022 to 115 incidents in 2023, per the U.S. Department of Justice. On its website, the agency notes that 'even if a state or territory does not have a hate crimes law, hate crimes can still be reported to the Federal Bureau of Investigation,' since there are federal hate crime laws. One of those laws, the Matthew Shepard and James Byrd Jr. Hate Crimes Prevention Act, is named after a gay Wyoming student and a Black Texas man who were murdered in separate acts in 1998. In 2017, the Charleston gunman became the first person in the U.S. to be sentenced to death for a federal hate crime. Still, many want a state hate crime law, given that the federal government has limited time and resources and that states conduct the vast majority of criminal prosecutions. Grant's husband, South Carolina state Rep. Hamilton Grant, said that it's unconscionable that South Carolina has no state hate crime law a decade after the shooting. Such legislation won't root out underlying prejudices, he acknowledged, but it can offer Black Americans stronger protections and options after experiencing hate violence. 'There seems to be no appetite to pass state hate crime legislation,' Grant told Capital B. 'When a hate crime bill has been introduced before, it's been introduced in the House, and it would pass the House, even with a Republican majority. But then it always gets hung up in the Senate. Just imagine the disrespect of a senator [Pinckney] being murdered — and his colleagues not even giving the bill so much as a hearing.' Opponents of the measure usually say very little, allowing it to quietly fade away, according to the Associated Press. Grant shared that he wonders whether some legislators worry that backing a hate crime bill might be viewed as supporting diversity, equity, and inclusion and 'wokeness' — which the Trump administration is fiercely pushing back against — and invite a primary challenge in the ruby-red state. 'I don't see anything like this passing the General Assembly,' he said. 'And it's sad and frustrating because though people might believe in the legislation, they feel like they can't publicly support it without losing their power.' While progress on the state level has been glacial, Richland County this month became the first county in South Carolina to pass a hate crime ordinance. This makes it illegal for someone to cause fear, intimidation, harm, or damage to a person or their property because of their race, gender, sexual orientation, and other identity characteristics. In the decade since the tragedy, Mother Emanuel has become a point of pilgrimage, a destination for people who visit Charleston. 'The church is a very special and tragic location,' Bernard Powers, a professor emeritus of history at the College of Charleston, told Capital B. 'When people visit friends or relatives who live in Charleston, those residents will frequently take them to the site if they haven't been there. If you're showing people around, this is one of the places you don't want them to miss.' He added that the church has become a site of activist meetings, particularly those intended to promote hate crime legislation and stricter gun-control legislation. 'What we didn't appreciate — and what we couldn't appreciate — at that point [in 2015] was that similar events were in the offing,' Powers said, noting the racist killings at a supermarket in Buffalo, New York, in 2022; a Walmart in El Paso, Texas, in 2019; and a synagogue in Pittsburgh in 2018. 'There's a murderous trajectory that we've been on.' It's this deeper appreciation of the wider environment of hate that Graham, the Charlotte city councilman, hopes the country will embrace. 'Martin Luther King Jr. said when he gave a eulogy after the 16th Street Baptist Church bombing to pay less attention to the killer and more attention to the system that produced the killer,' Graham explained. He added, 'What system failures let this young guy become filled with so much hate — and then get the opportunity to act on that hate? My sister would have said, 'I know that I bore the brunt of what happened that night, but this attack was against all of us.'' The post Some Mother Emanuel Families Say the Focus on Forgiveness Has Cost Them Justice appeared first on Capital B News.
New York Times
a day ago
- New York Times
Enzo Staiola, Who Starred in ‘Bicycle Thieves' as a Child, Dies at 85
Enzo Staiola, who played the staunch 8-year-old accompanying his father on a quest to recover a stolen bicycle in Vittorio De Sica's classic 1948 film, 'Bicycle Thieves,' died on June 4 in Rome. He was 85. His death, in a hospital, was widely reported in the Italian press. The father's character, played by a sad-eyed real-life factory worker, Lamberto Maggiorani, is the star of the film, which was originally released in the United States as 'The Bicycle Thief' and is routinely cited as one of the greatest films of all time. But Mr. Staiola (pronounced STY-ola), who played the child, Bruno, is in many ways the emotional center of De Sica's work, which is considered a founding document of Italian neorealism and 'a fundamental staging post in the history of the European cinema,' the film historian Robert S.C. Gordon wrote in his 2008 book, 'Bicycle Thieves.' The story, set in impoverished postwar Rome, revolves around Antonio Ricci, Mr. Maggiorani's struggling character, who must get his bicycle back to keep his new job hanging advertising bills around the city. The job requires the use of a bicycle. But he must also retrieve the bike to avoid disappointing his trusting son. The character of Bruno is portrayed with poise and vulnerability by a little boy who, until then, had been more interested in playing soccer in his working-class Roman neighborhood than in acting. The father's quest, unfolding through a series of sharply etched mishaps in the streets of the city, takes on weight for the audience as the despair becomes not just that of an adult but also of a plucky boy with expressive eyes, the young Mr. Staiola. Want all of The Times? Subscribe.
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
Disgraced pastor turns down year offer and now faces a jury, life in prison
Eric Readon, a controversial Miami Gardens pastor arrested three years ago on charges of stealing an elderly man's Northwest Miami-Dade home, turned down a plea deal from the state Wednesday and now could spend the rest of his life in prison. By turning down the state's offer of a year in prison and a decade of probation, Readon, 49, could end up behind bars from anywhere between six years to more than six decades, for the crimes he is accused of committing. Before Readon decided to leave his fate in jurors' hands, Miami-Dade Circuit Court Judge Christine Hernandez warned the pastor of the vast gulf between the state's offer and a guilty verdict. 'This is your life,' Hernandez said. 'It's a decision you have to make with the consultation of your lawyer.' Readon, who has been out of jail since his February 2022 arrest, quickly left the court hearing, his attorney at his side. Hernandez set a trial date for July 7. The pastor is accused of swindling retiree Edward Fuller out of his $267,000 home on Northwest 19th Avenue. The scheme, state prosecutors said, involved Readon guaranteeing a loan to refurbish the home in exchange for the senior signing over the deed to the property and paying Readon a $15,000 fee. Readon is facing charges of exploitation of an elderly or disabled person, organized scheme to defraud, conspiracy to commit organized scheme to defraud, theft from a person 65 years or older, and grand theft. The disgraced pastor — who court records show served probation for strong-armed robbery and grand theft over two decades ago — led New Beginning Missionary Baptist Church in Northwest Miami-Dade. He made a name for himself fighting gun violence, often showing up at rallies and seen comforting grieving family members. A call to the church Wednesday said the number had been disconnected. Readon reached a plea deal last month with the Broward State Attorney's Office over allegations that he also fraudulently stole properties in Davie and Lauderdale Lakes. The Davie property was worth $1.7 million. As part of the deal in which he avoided admitting guilt but agreed to a punishment, Readon paid one of the property owners $150,000 and the other $46,500. He also agreed to two years of house arrest and 10 years probation and to repay all restitution before he can be considered for early termination of probation. Both victims won back their properties after legal battles. Readon was also arrested in April in Pembroke Pines. Charging documents say he used false paperwork in a wire transfer when he bought a Range Rover from Miami's Braman Motors. The case was later closed. Though the state prosecutor indicated Wednesday that if Readon didn't agree to the plea offer, the stolen vehicle charge could resurface.
