NI legacy: Lawyers got most of £25m to settle cases, says PSNI
The Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI) paid out £25m to settle civil cases related to the Troubles in recent years and most of it went to lawyers, the chief constable has told MPs.Jon Boutcher said lawyers received almost £18m - more than double the amount obtained by victims who brought the claims.He was giving evidence to the Northern Ireland Affairs Committee.Mr Boutcher described legacy as "a green field site for lawyers" due to "an attritional approach by all the security agencies around information disclosure".
Mr Boutcher said the PSNI was not properly funded for legacy issues and the costs would pay for the recruitment of hundreds of extra officers.The PSNI's costs cover not just court cases, but also operating its Legacy Investigations Branch (LIB)."We are spending just over £20m a year. That would be about 400 police officers," he said."But we've been left with this millstone, this anchor, that holds the PSNI back."It is a considerable burden on us."The PSNI is currently dealing with 1,100 civil actions - in 2014 the figure was 150.
'Today's budget' for 'yesterday's cases'
The head of its LIB, detective chief superintendent Claire McGuigan, said: "We don't have anywhere near the resources to deal with those, nor the money to settle them."We're in a position that is very, very difficult and it doesn't build trust in the community because it looks like we are stalling."She said the PSNI continues to have "obligations" despite the Legacy Act passing Troubles' cases to a new body, the Independent Commission for Reconciliation and Information Recovery (ICRIR).The former Police Ombudsman, Nuala O'Loan, also gave evidence to the committee.She told the committee it was unreasonable to expect the PSNI to use "today's budget to fund yesterday's cases"."The government really need to be ready to set aside a specific budget for these matters," she said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BreakingNews.ie
39 minutes ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Gardaí to consider bringing in full-time cadaver dog, says Commissioner
An Garda Síochána is to consider bringing a full-time cadaver dog into the force to avoid being 'entirely reliant on others', the Garda Commissioner said. Drew Harris said that the services of a cadaver dog are rarely used, and in his tenure has only been used on three occasions. Advertisement Speaking to reporters at Phoenix Park on Monday, Mr Harris said they will look at acquiring one. Currently, gardaí use the services of one cadaver dog which belongs to the Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI). 'A cadaver dog, thankfully, are rarely used, and on these islands there's only a small number of these dogs,' Mr Harris said. 'In my tenure here, we have used these dogs in about three occasions. So, we work with support of the Police Service of Northern Ireland. We will look to see, in time, should we introduce a cadaver dog ourselves, because we don't want to be entirely reliant on others, but others may rely on us if we have that dog available. Advertisement 'A cadaver dog is not out every day working in the same way that a drugs, or firearms or money dog would be. 'It's a very specialist resource.' Mr Harris said using dogs in policing operations required specialist training, and that cadaver dogs are a subset of that which requires specialist work. 'Not often required operationally, it's not a usual thing that we would need a cadaver dog,' he said. Advertisement It comes as the Minister for Justice raised concern with Mr Harris over how long it took to find the body of murder victim Tina Satchwell. Jim O'Callaghan also said it would be preferable if An Garda Siochana had its own cadaver dog to help find human remains. Asked whether a cadaver dog should have been brought into the Satchwell home in 2017 during the investigation, Mr O'Callaghan said 'probably, it should have happened'. He said he also spoke to Mr Harris about the effectiveness of cadaver dogs. Advertisement 'They're a very specialised dog in terms of trying to train them, there is one on the island of Ireland, the PSNI has one,' he said. Ireland Garda vehicle numbers rise to more than 3,600 afte... Read More 'That dog is sought by many police forces in Britain as well. We got the use of the dog here and he was of much assistance.' Mr Harris said that the 2017 investigation into Mrs Satchwell's disappearance is being reviewed. 'But what I know from the report I've seen, is that this suspicion was that harm had been caused to Tina Satchwell but there was no suspicion that her body was there,' Mr Harris added. Advertisement
Belfast Telegraph
3 hours ago
- Belfast Telegraph
Police launch investigation after agriculture minister says he received a death threat
Speaking about threats against those in public office, Chief Superintendent Stephen Murray said it is 'totally unacceptable' for elected representatives to face abuse or threats for doing their job. Last week Mr Muir told the Assembly that he and officials in his department had been the target of 'vile' homophobic, racist and misogynistic comments on social media over his department's proposed Nutrients Action Programme (NAP). However, speaking today the minister said that the situation had 'taken a disturbing turn' in recent days after he received a death threat. It comes during heated opposition from the farming community to Mr Muir's NAP proposals which are currently out for consultation. Mr Muir has been urged to scrap the proposals which are aimed at improving water quality and the wider environment by reducing and preventing pollution caused or induced by nutrients from agricultural sources. Opponents say the proposals could devastate agriculture, reduce livestock numbers and undermine food security. Speaking to Cool FM on Monday Mr Muir revealed details of the threat which he said did 'not reflect the farming community in Northern Ireland'. 'As minister I have been out and about, I've been welcomed into the homes of many farmers and (had) very respectful engagement around what is a consultation,' he said. 'But things have really taken a disturbing turn last week when there was a zoom call to discuss the NAP proposals and consultation, someone decided to post a comment which essentially is threatening to have me shot.' He added: 'I'm very disappointed, I know this does not reflect the farming community in Northern Ireland, and I think it is really important that I say that. "I know the police are taking this very seriously and it's important that when we are engaging in what is a consultation about draft proposals, people lower the tone a bit." News Catchup - Monday 9th June 2025 He urged people to take a 'step back' adding there 'is no need to issue death threats against me' or for discriminatory comments aimed at officials in his department and people working in the agri-food sector. A spokesperson for the PSNI confirmed that an investigation had been launched adding that any reports of abuse, harassment or criminality directed at elected representatives would be thoroughly investigated. Chief Superintendent Stephen Murray added: 'It is totally unacceptable that anyone should face abuse or threats simply for carrying out the duties of their office. We will thoroughly investigate any such incident. 'We will continue to do all we can to ensure that all of our politicians are supported, and that they can undertake their role free from fear and intimidation. 'We regularly engage with our elected representatives in order to provide information on personal safety, how the Police Service can support them and, crucially, when to report an incident to police. 'We regularly engage with Assembly and Parliamentary officials, and the Electoral Commission, in regard to elected representative safety.'
Belfast Telegraph
3 hours ago
- Belfast Telegraph
Former H block boss suspects collusion in jail slaying of loyalist killer Billy Wright
McKee was at his desk as governor of the Maze Prison on December 27, 1997, the day the INLA claimed their biggest scalp of the Troubles. It was the final weeks and months of negotiations that would lead to the signing of the Good Friday Agreement and Wright was seen as one of the remaining obstacles to a settlement. Vehemently opposed to the peace process, he stayed at the head of his LVF sectarian killing machine despite being behind bars, orchestrating and ordering attacks with the help of his trusted second in command, Mark 'Swinger' Fulton. So when Christopher 'Crip' McWilliams, John Kenneway and John 'Sonny' Glennon intercepted Wright as he made his way from his cell in the Maze to a visit from his girlfriend, they removed one of the biggest obstacles to peace. Armed with a pistol smuggled into what was supposed to be the most secure prison in Europe, the trio climbed over the prison roof and shot him inside the prison transport van. In October 1998 they were convicted of murder and possession of a firearm and ammunition with intent to endanger life. They were sentenced to life imprisonment for the murder and 20 years on the firearms offence. Within two years they were free men, under the terms of the peace accord. It was a day that was to leave a permanent scar on the mind and soul of McKee. As the man in charge, he found himself thrust into the spotlight. He was to discover he may have been an unwitting pawn in a bigger game, played out by MI5 in collusion with the INLA. Collusion Inside The Maze is the title of McKee's newly published book, a novel that teases out the conspiracy theories that still surround the death of one of the most notorious and dangerous killers in the history of the conflict. 'It's a 'what if' book,' McKee told the Sunday World. 'I have to be careful, I'm still covered by the Official Secrets Act — as far as the facts are concerned, I can only stick to what is in the public domain, but what happened has never sat well with me. There are too many coincidences and unanswered questions.' He said his decision to address those questions in the form of a novel is an attempt to highlight certain issues, including the role of the security services and why he as governor was never informed of intelligence that pointed to a planned attack on Wright. 'What is fact is that during a bugged INLA meeting on the Antrim Road, a plan to assassinate 'King Rat' Wright was discussed. That meeting was 12 days before Wright was killed. 'When Wright was transferred from Maghaberry, so were Glennon and McWilliams. I was never told that there was clear intelligence Wright was going to be killed. Did they just let it happen? 'It has festered with me for a long time. Wright was a very bad man — he had been linked to 20 sectarian murders — but even given that, he should have been moved out of the Maze.' Republicans were threatening to take retaliatory action against Wright's LVF, which would have put the entire peace process at the risk of collapse. McKee said he was in his office when he got the call that there had been a shooting in H Block 6. 'You just know what to do, it's not a question of 'oh my God what next?' Your training takes over — you know what to do. 'People always asked me to tell the true story, but I don't know what the true story is, so I decided to write a thriller that was loosely based on the murder, giving possibilities that may account for state collusion,' he said. Much of what is in the book is drawn from his imagination but unmistakably grounded in real events. 'I used Billy Wright's name but, under the Official Secrets Act, I couldn't use anything that was not in the public domain. 'The killing of Wright is a significant part of the book, but there are other incidents as well, including ones connected to the IRA's Nutting Squad, Stakeknife and the Disappeared.' He said he has shared the book with a number of former combatants who have given it their seal of approval on what was a decisive moment in our history. 'One combatant told me, 'Mate, that's not a novel, that's a true story'. I hope it goes some way to shedding some light on what may or may not have happened.' Billy McKee joined the Prison Service as a 22-year-old never intending it to be his career, but he quickly rose through the ranks, eventually finding himself governor at Maghaberry and the Maze. At the height of the Troubles the job was fraught with risk. He had to move house three times at short notice because of death threats. 'I'd get a call in the middle of the night from the security services telling me, 'Get out of the house now, they're on their way to kill you'. The police couldn't come in case it compromised an informant or agent. The government would move us to another house until it happened again.' The pressure was too much for his marriage, which collapsed. His mental health suffered. He recalls leaving Maghaberry in the back of an ambulance believing he had suffered a heart attack. It wasn't but it was a panic attack brought on by the pressures of dealing with a failing marriage, death threats and being head of one of the most notorious prisons in Europe. After a near 30-year career in the Prison Service, he retired on medical grounds but to this day struggles with PTSD. 'I've had 66 counselling sessions learning to live with what I call my 'black cloud' — some days it's there some days it's not. When I was in the Prison Service I was known as Billy, since I left I introduce myself as William, I'm trying to leave that person behind. 'Revisiting the Wright murder has been cathartic because as I've said the circumstances have festered with me for years.' These days William spends much of his time talking to youth groups and often to former combatants. 'It helps me, but I also think it helps young people and even those who went through it all in this country to listen to someone who stared it in the face.'
