logo
Two California judges file suit against LADWP, saying utility failed to prepare, respond to fire

Two California judges file suit against LADWP, saying utility failed to prepare, respond to fire

Two federal judges who lost their Pacific Palisades homes in the January firestorm have joined hundreds of their neighbors in suing the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power, claiming the utility failed to properly prepare for the wildfire and respond when it broke out.
U.S. District Judge Dean Pregerson, who currently sits on the Central District of California's court, and Vijay 'Jay' Gandhi, who served as a magistrate judge in the same court, filed the lawsuit last week along with their families.
The suit, filed in Los Angeles Superior Court, alleges that the Palisades conflagration 'was caused by both LADWP's water and power assets, specifically empty reservoirs and energized powerlines.'
The lawsuit cites reporting from The Times that found LADWP's Sana Ynez Reservoir, located in the Palisades, sat empty during the firefight, having been closed months prior for repairs.
'Despite dire warnings by the National Weather Service of a 'Particularly Dangerous Condition-Red Flag Warning,' of 'critical fire weather' which had the potential for rapid fire spread and extreme fire behavior, the LADWP was unprepared for the Palisades fire,' the complaint said.
A request for comment from L.A.-based law firm Munger, Tolles & Olson, which was hired by LADWP to handle Palisades fire litigation, was not immediately answered. LADWP's most recent statement about pending litigation said it expects plaintiffs to continue to join such lawsuits, but it dismissed claims that the utility provider wasn't prepared and could be held responsible for the fire.
'While our crews and system were prepared for situations that might strain the system, no urban water system is designed to combat a massive, wind-driven wildfire of the speed and scale presented by the historically destructive Palisades Fire,' the statement said, an explanation that several experts have backed up.
The utility also said that 'long settled law and precedent prevent water utilities, and their rate payers, from being liable for wildfire losses.'
The current and former federal judges who filed the suit as residents, not in any official capacity, disagree with that line of defense. One of the judges worked as a mediator in prior fire settlements between Pacific Gas & Electric and residents.
'The city must stand up and claim responsibility and do right by the residents of the Palisades. And that's why I joined this battle,' Gandhi, who worked as the mediator, said in an interview with the Los Angeles Daily News. He called the Palisades fire a 'manifestation of risks that were widely known but ignored. And the city needs to acknowledge that, because it can't happen again.'
The judges' lawsuit was recently consolidated with more than 10 other similar cases against LADWP, brought by more than 750 other residents, according to one of the attorneys working on the cases, Alexander Robertson. The long list of cases against the utility continue to pile up as homeowners seek compensation for damage they believe was caused by the utility's mismanagement of water resources or its power lines.
The suit also alleges that most of LADWP power lines remained energized during the fire, causing 'additional ignitions and fires in Pacific Palisades during a predicted Santa Ana wind event, ... [which] accelerated the rapid spread of the Palisades Fire,' the complaint says.
LADWP 'knew about the significant risk wildfires posed in the event of ineffective infrastructure management, delayed repairs, unsafe equipment, and/or aging infrastructure decades before the Palisades Fire,' the complaint said. It called the nearby reservoirs and electric lines public necessities, saying that 'failure of one critical infrastructure can potentially have a domino effect.'

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Los Angeles Restaurants Step Up Amid the Ongoing Anti-ICE Protests
Los Angeles Restaurants Step Up Amid the Ongoing Anti-ICE Protests

Eater

time2 days ago

  • Eater

Los Angeles Restaurants Step Up Amid the Ongoing Anti-ICE Protests

Since Friday, thousands of Los Angeles residents have taken to the streets to protest U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) immigration sweeps throughout Southern California. On Saturday, June 7, President Donald Trump dispatched the National Guard to minimize protests without the consent of California Governor Gavin Newsom. As of June 10, the Pentagon deployed 700 Marines to protect federal agents and buildings. It's a contentious time for Los Angeles County as LA Mayor Karen Bass and Gov. Newsom claim the Trump Administration has intentionally provoked the unrest. Through it all, fruit vendors and restaurants have been assisting not only protestors but also law enforcement. The Los Angeles Times reports that a street food vendor who sells aguas frescas and bacon-wrapped hot dogs assisted protesters over the weekend. As protesters found themselves battling tear gas, vendors Cinthia Soriao, Edgar Hernandez, and Sesarin Hernandez poured milk into their eyes. The Los Angeles Times report also states that the vendors fed protesters, as did other hot dog vendors. Across town at Compton's Pupuseria La Ceiba, workers aided deputies who were hit with tear gas. The Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department emailed Newsweek the following statement: 'Without hesitation, the restaurant employees stepped in to assist the deputies, helping them decontaminate from the effects of the tear gas.' Restaurants temporarily close during protests Citing safety concerns during nearby protests, ICE roundups, and police activity, Mermaid bar closed its doors temporarily on Monday, June 9. Other Downtown restaurants followed suit, including Chinatown's Lasita and Redbird. The Ranch House at Calamigos Guest Ranch reopens After closing during the Palisades Fire, one of Malibu's restaurants reopened in early June. Calamigos Guest Ranch's on-site restaurant, the Ranch Club, is located 12 miles away from Pacific Palisades, which was devastated by January wildfires. Until late May, access to portions of Pacific Coast Highway was closed except to residents, construction and cleanup crews, and emergency responders, leaving Malibu somewhat isolated. The Ranch Club team took the time to revamp the restaurant's interior and adjust its menu. The family-owned restaurant is typically open to members only, but is now available to the public on specific nights. Reservations are available on Resy. Din Tai Fung's new shaved ice Those obsessed with Din Tai Fung can taste a new dessert starting in July: shaved snow with fresh mango. The condensed milk-based dessert has a fluffy consistency, gets drizzled with mango sauce, and is topped with fresh mango. RYLA's ramen night anniversary RYLA chef Ray Hayashi will celebrate his third year by hosting a Ramen Party on June 11 from 4 p.m. to 11 p.m. He'll feature ramen chefs from Zoku and Mogu Mogu with special ramen bowls for the evening. It's safe to recommend making a reservation.

Los Angeles Restaurants Step Up Amid the Ongoing Anti-ICE Protests
Los Angeles Restaurants Step Up Amid the Ongoing Anti-ICE Protests

Eater

time2 days ago

  • Eater

Los Angeles Restaurants Step Up Amid the Ongoing Anti-ICE Protests

Since Friday, thousands of Los Angeles residents have taken to the streets to protest U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) immigration sweeps throughout Southern California. On Saturday, June 7, President Donald Trump dispatched the National Guard to minimize protests without the consent of California Governor Gavin Newsom. As of June 10, the Pentagon deployed 700 Marines to protect federal agents and buildings. It's a contentious time for Los Angeles County as LA Mayor Karen Bass and Gov. Newsom claim the Trump Administration has intentionally provoked the unrest. Through it all, fruit vendors and restaurants have been assisting not only protestors but also law enforcement. The Los Angeles Times reports that a street food vendor who sells aguas frescas and bacon-wrapped hot dogs assisted protesters over the weekend. As protesters found themselves battling tear gas, vendors Cinthia Soriao, Edgar Hernandez, and Sesarin Hernandez poured milk into their eyes. The Los Angeles Times report also states that the vendors fed protesters, as did other hot dog vendors. Across town at Compton's Pupuseria La Ceiba, workers aided deputies who were hit with tear gas. The Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department emailed Newsweek the following statement: 'Without hesitation, the restaurant employees stepped in to assist the deputies, helping them decontaminate from the effects of the tear gas.' Restaurants temporarily close during protests Citing safety concerns during nearby protests, ICE roundups, and police activity, Mermaid bar closed its doors temporarily on Monday, June 9. Other Downtown restaurants followed suit, including Chinatown's Lasita and Redbird. The Ranch House at Calamigos Guest Ranch reopens After closing during the Palisades Fire, one of Malibu's restaurants reopened in early June. Calamigos Guest Ranch's on-site restaurant, the Ranch Club, is located 12 miles away from Pacific Palisades, which was devastated by January wildfires. Until late May, access to portions of Pacific Coast Highway was closed except to residents, construction and cleanup crews, and emergency responders, leaving Malibu somewhat isolated. The Ranch Club team took the time to revamp the restaurant's interior and adjust its menu. The family-owned restaurant is typically open to members only, but is now available to the public on specific nights. Reservations are available on Resy. Din Tai Fung's new shaved ice Those obsessed with Din Tai Fung can taste a new dessert starting in July: shaved snow with fresh mango. The condensed milk-based dessert has a fluffy consistency, gets drizzled with mango sauce, and is topped with fresh mango. RYLA's ramen night anniversary RYLA chef Ray Hayashi will celebrate his third year by hosting a Ramen Party on June 11 from 4 p.m. to 11 p.m. He'll feature ramen chefs from Zoku and Mogu Mogu with special ramen bowls for the evening. It's safe to recommend making a reservation.

Officials look to quell Pacific Palisades residents' security concerns after PCH fully reopens
Officials look to quell Pacific Palisades residents' security concerns after PCH fully reopens

Yahoo

time27-05-2025

  • Yahoo

Officials look to quell Pacific Palisades residents' security concerns after PCH fully reopens

In the wake of the Palisades Fire in January, Pacific Coast Highway between L.A. and Malibu was shut down for months – except for local residents, businesses and emergency crews – due to damage from the fire and subsequent mudslides, and now that the critical stretch of coastal highway is open, those living in the area are worried about security. Officials, however, are ensuring that all precautions are taken as more and more people travel through the area. PCH officially reopened on Friday, ahead of schedule and just in time for Memorial Day weekend. Up to two lanes are open in each direction with a 25-mile-per-hour speed limit through active work zones, and security checkpoints along the highway have been removed as the California National Guard demobilizes from the area. As PCH reopens, Malibu urges beachgoers to be safe and respectful Speed limits and worker safety aren't the only things on residents' and officials' minds. Burglaries and thefts in wildfire-affected areas have increased (including in the Eaton Fire burn zone in Altadena, where officials say burglaries are up 'several hundred percent'), and now that the general public is back in the area, concerns are heightened. One way that local leaders are looking to ease those concerns is the decision to hire a private security firm that will provide 24/7 armed patrols in neighborhoods affected by both the Palisades and Franklin fires, officials announced. Approved on May 21 by the Malibu City Council, Covered 6 was chosen since the firm has 'extensive experience patrolling neighborhoods' and that they have worked with local deputies in the past. The service will cost roughly $260,000 per month. Speaking on the price tag at the city council meeting, one resident opined that 'it's a lot of money to spend…but I think it's a time to spend it.' Los Angeles officials tout record progress in Palisades Fire recovery as homes start to be rebuilt 'The patrols are intended to supplement law enforcement efforts by the LASD Malibu-Lost Hills Station and ensure continuous public safety coverage during a critical recovery phase,' Malibu officials said on May 22. 'Fire-damaged areas face heightened risks of burglary, vandalism, theft – particularly of construction materials – as many properties remain vacant during rebuilding.' 'Looter suppression efforts will be intensified, with zero-tolerance to crime and traffic violations,' officials added, piggybacking off Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman's policy on wildfire looters. During the May 21 Malibu City Council meeting, Scott Wagenseller, the founder and CEO of another private security firm, Gates Security, said that on the previous day, officers with his company found a man with a gun in the backyard of one of their clients' homes. Another man was found with a knife, and a 'squatter issue' involving a man on a previously burned property had recently been resolved. 'These are transients walking into the environment,' Wagenseller said. 'Raise Pali' golf tournament supports wildfire recovery efforts for local high school Residents are encouraged to 'take an active role' in protecting their properties by filling out a Letter of Agency at the Malibu-Lost Hills LASD station; the document authorizes deputies to enforce trespassing laws on private property in the owner's absence and officers to take action against unauthorized individuals without contacting the property owner first, the Malibu City Council said. Property owners are also asked to secure their property by ensuring that gates, doors and windows are locked. Any suspicious activity should be reported to authorities. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store