Lawyers for a journalist accused of hacking Fox News blame AI for error-filled legal brief
Timothy Burke is accused of grabbing unaired Fox News footage using someone else's credentials.
A judge scolded his lawyers for misrepresenting and making up legal precedents in an attempt to get the case thrown out.
A lawyer for Burke admitted to using ChatGPT and Westlaw's AI features without checking their output.
A lawyer for Timothy Burke, the journalist indicted over leaked Fox News footage, admitted in a court filing Monday that he used ChatGPT and other AI tools to write an error-filled legal brief.
Last week, Judge Kathryn Kimball Mizelle said a filing by Burke's lawyers contained "significant misrepresentations and misquotations" and demanded an explanation. On Monday, the lawyers, Michael Maddux and Mark Rasch, said the errors happened because of Rasch's research and edits.
The judge cited nine examples of "non-existent quotes and miscited propositions" that appeared to come from federal appellate rulings and a Congressional committee report. She also said their brief had six errors that may have been less egregious, as well as other "miscellaneous problems."
Rasch's process "included the use of Westlaw, Westlaw's AI features, Google, Google Scholar, as well as the 'deep research' feature of the Pro version of ChatGPT version 4.5," the brief said. The lawyers said Rasch used a feature on the legal research platform Westlaw called Quick Check to vet the brief, but didn't do so again after accidentally adding unvetted sections from previous drafts.
Maddux, the lawyers added, was busy with another case.
Maddux, Rasch, and Burke didn't immediately respond to requests for comment. Neither OpenAI, the company behind ChatGPT, or Thomson Reuters, which makes Westlaw, responded to requests for comment.
The proliferation of AI and the high cost of legal research has led to a number of attorneys being called to the mat by judges over errors in their legal arguments, often a result of generative AI systems' tendency to "hallucinate."
Often, the mistakes are made by solo practitioners or lawyers from small firms, though big firms have also been found using AI. A Latham & Watkins attorney said the AI system Claude was to blame for giving the wrong name and authors for an article cited in an expert's report, though the content was otherwise correct. Last week, attorneys from the firms K&L Gates and Ellis George were told to pay $31,000 after their submissions were found to contain made-up citations.
Burke, a former Deadspin editor now working as a media consultant, faces charges of hacking into a streaming system used by broadcasters. The case has attracted attention from press freedom advocates, with his lawyers arguing Burke committed no crime since the URLs he visited to download clips of Fox News footage were public.
The footage, which included antisemitic remarks by the rapper Ye and behind-the-scenes comments by Tucker Carlson about sex, his "postmenopausal" viewers, and issues with the Fox Nation streaming service, was never aired on the network. When the clips appeared online in 2022 and 2023, it aroused suspicions that a Fox employee had leaked them. In 2023, however, federal investigators zeroed in on Burke, who was indicted last year.
Read the original article on Business Insider
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Forbes
42 minutes ago
- Forbes
New Attack Steals Your Windows Email, Passwords, 2FA Codes And More
The latest Katz malware version can steal most everything. Infostealers are the new black. When it comes to hacking fashion, malware that steals user credentials has been in vogue for a while now. We've seen the evidence in the 19 billion compromised passwords that are already available online, or the 94 billion browser cookies published to the Dark Web and Telegram channels. Microsoft has been spearheading the fight against the credential-stealing criminals, leading the recent global takedown of large parts of the Lumma Stealer network infrastructure, for example. Yet, the danger still persists; in fact, it is evolving. New research has revealed that a notorious threat to Windows users has emerged in the form of a new variant that can steal most anything and everything. Here's what you need to know about Katz. There is nothing particularly unusual about the way that the Katz Stealer malware is distributed. Victims are targeted through the usual cybercriminal methods, including phishing emails, malicious advertisements, dangerous search results, and dodgy downloads. Once installed, however, Katz looks to see if you are using Google Chrome, Microsoft Edge or the Brave web browser and goes into what is known as headless mode. This is pretty much as it sounds, a browser with no visible interface, running 'headless' in the background but with the body able to render pages and interact with the web as normal. Katz can also bypass Google's app-bound encryption protections for Chrome, according to security researchers, which would aid in the credential-stealing payload. And it's the payload that has us shaking our collective heads in disbelief. A May 23 analysis of the latest Katz Stealer malware, by the Nextron threat research team, has revealed the true extent of this steal-everything threat to Windows users. According to the full analysis, which I would recommend you go and read, after you finish here, of course, the range of Katz when it comes to data that can be stolen is, well, extensive. As well as the usual mitigation advice for consumers to deploy two-factor authentication and passkeys on all accounts where available, apply all operating system and browser security updates as soon as possible and be alert to all the usual phishing tricks, the Nextron threat research team recommended the following for enterprise users: Nextron also suggested watching out for the scanning of Windows registry keys and files associated with popular browsers and wallet applications, as this is indicative of Katz Stealer activity. As Sergeant Phil Esterhaus used to say, if you know you know, 'be careful out there.'
Forbes
42 minutes ago
- Forbes
Google Issues New $1 Trillion Threat Security Advisory
Google issues new scam threats advisory. dpa/picture alliance via Getty Images Whether it's the FBI warning about smartphone attacks leveraging fears of deportation in the U.S. foreign student population, recommendations to use a secret code as AI-powered phishing campaigns evolve, instant takeover attacks targeting Meta and PayPal users, or confirmed threats aimed at compromising your Gmail account, there is no escaping the cyber-scammers. Indeed, the Global Anti-Scam Alliance, whose advisory board includes the head of scam prevention at Amazon, Microsoft's director of fraud and abuse risk, and the vice president of security solutions with Mastercard, found that more than $1 trillion was lost globally to such fraud in 2024. But do not despair, despite the Federal Trade Commission warning of a 25% year-on-year increase in losses, Google is fighting back. Here's what you need to know. There can be no doubt that online scams, of all flavors, are not only increasing in volume, but they are also evolving. We've seen evidence of this in the increasing availability and cost-effectiveness of employing AI to empower such threat campaigns. No longer the sole stomping ground of solo actors and chancers looking to make a few bucks here and there, the scams threat landscape is now dominated by organized international groups operating at scale. The boundary between online and physical, offline fraud is blurring. Hybrid campaigns are a reality, combining phone calls with internet calls to action. The Global Anti-Scam Alliance State of Scams Report, published in November 2024, revealed the true cost of such crimes: $1.03 trillion globally in just 12 months. A March 2025 report from the Federal Trade Commission showed that U.S. consumers alone had lost $12.5 billion last year, up 25% from 2023. And that GASA report also found that only 4% of victims worldwide reported being able to recover their losses. Something has to be done, and Google's Trust and Safety teams, responsible for tracking and fighting scams of all kinds, are determined that they are the people to help do it. 'Scammers are more effective and act without fear of punishment when people are uninformed about fraud and scam tactics,' Karen Courington, Google's vice president of consumer trusted experiences, trust & safety, said. In addition to tracking and defending against scams, Google's dedicated teams also aim to inform consumers by analyzing threats and sharing their observations, along with mitigation advice. The May 27 Google fraud and scams advisory, does just that, describing the most pressing of recent attack trends that have been identified. These are broken down into five separate scams, each complete with mitigating best practice recommendations, as follows: Customer support scams, often displaying fake phone numbers while pretending to be legitimate help services, are evolving and exploiting victims through a combination of social engineering and web vulnerabilities, Google warned. Along with the protection offered by Gemini Nano on-device to identify dangerous sites and scams, Google advised users should 'seek out official support channels directly, avoid unsolicited contacts or pop-ups and always verify phone numbers for authenticity." Malicious advertising scams, often employing the use of lures including free or cracked productivity software and games, have also evolved. 'Scammers are setting their sights on more sophisticated users,' Courington said, 'those with valuable assets like crypto wallets or individuals with significant online influence.' Google uses AI and human reviews to combat the threat and block ad accounts involved in such activity. Only download software from official sources, beware of too good to be true offers, and pay particular attention browser warnings when they appear, Google said. Google's teams have seen an increase in fake travel websites as the summer vacations get closer, usually luring victims with cheap prices and unbelievable experiences. Again, these will likely impersonate well-known brands, hotels, and agencies. Google advised users to use its tools such as 'about this result' to verify website authenticity. 'Avoid payment methods such as wire transfers or direct bank deposits,' Courington said, 'especially if requested via email or phone.' The old chestnut of package tracking scams has not vanished, more's the pity. 'These scams often trick users into paying additional fees that real delivery services would never request,' Courington explained. Google has seen these scammers employing a tactic whereby the websites and messages used are changed dynamically, based on when the link is sent to the victim. Scam detection in Google Messages has been deployed as one level of protection by Google, but Courington also recommended users should verify the status of any expected package with the shipping company or seller rather than by a link from an unknown source. And finally, there's also no escaping the road toll scams that continue to appear. 'A toll road scam involves scammers sending fraudulent text messages claiming that you owe unpaid toll fees,' Courington warned. Thankfully, these are not always the most realistic of threats, with Google analysts seeing users spammed by toll road fee claims in states that don't even have any toll roads. The best mitigating advice remains stopping to pause, count to ten, and ask yourself if the claim is a plausible one. If it is, then confirm it directly with the toll operator rather than via a link in a message.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Trump tariffs live updates: Trump says China 'violated' trade agreement with US; tariffs face legal limbo
President Donald Trump lashed out at China on Friday morning on Truth Social, saying China had "violated" its trade deal with the US. "China was in big trouble two weeks ago" due to the high tariffs set by the US, he said. Trump said he made a quick deal with China — which he accused them of breaking. "The bad news is that China, perhaps not surprisingly to some, HAS TOTALLY VIOLATED ITS AGREEMENT WITH US. So much for being Mr. NICE GUY!" Trump wrote. US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent told Fox News on Thursday that trade talks between the US and China are "a bit stalled," saying a call between President Trump and China's Xi Jinping may be needed The escalation comes as the US-China detente — reached earlier this month, when each country eased sky-high tariffs on the other — looks more fragile amid both trade-related and other tensions. Meanwhile, Trump's most sweeping tariffs have entered a period of legal uncertainty. A federal appeals court allowed the tariffs to temporarily stay in effect, a day after the US Court of International Trade blocked their implementation, deeming the method used to enact them "unlawful." That means Trump's tariff agenda remains intact, if in flux, in the latest twist in the unfolding legal saga. Late Wednesday, the trade court voted to block many of Trump's tariffs, including the flat-rate "reciprocal" tariffs aimed at US trade partners, as well as key China-focused duties. The US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, which oversees the International Trade Court, granted the Trump administration's request for a temporary administrative stay. This gives the court time to review legal arguments and filings. The administration must submit its briefings by June 9, after which the court will determine the next steps. The White House had vowed Thursday to take its appeal to the Supreme Court if necessary. Administration officials also hinted that court rulings would not be the final say for a president who has based much of his economic agenda on enacting the tariffs. Yahoo Finance's Ben Werschkul has an overview of the other maneuvers Trump could pursue. Amid the legal chaos, US trade negotiations have apparently continued in earnest this week with India and the EU. Here are the latest updates as the policy reverberates around the world. Bloomberg News reports: Read more here. The temporary trade deal that led to the US and China pausing steep tariffs is showing signs of fraying. In a post on Truth Social on Friday, President Trump made it clear who he thinks is to blame. "I made a FAST DEAL with China in order to save them from what I thought was going to be a very bad situation, and I didn't want to see that happen," Trump said. "Because of this deal, everything quickly stabilized and China got back to business as usual. Everybody was happy! That is the good news!!! "The bad news," he continued, "is that China, perhaps not surprisingly to some, HAS TOTALLY VIOLATED ITS AGREEMENT WITH US." "So much for being Mr. NICE GUY!" Reuters reports: Read more here. Yahoo Finance's senior reporter Hamza Shaban reports on Nvidia (NVDA) and Trump tariffs: Read more here. Apple (AAPL) iPhone sales and its rivals are expected to take a significant hit due to President Trump's tariffs. Bloomberg News reports: Read more here. With US-China trade talks stalling, tensions may rise further as Trump steps up arms sales to China's rival, Taiwan. Bloomberg News reports: Read more here. Some of China's biggest tech companies have started to switch development of their artificial intelligence to homegrown chips as opposed to using semiconductors from America, due to the US export controls — which has led to a dwindling stockpile of Nvidia (NVDA) processors. The FT reports: Read more here. A federal appeals court has temporarily reinstated President Trump's global tariffs by pausing a lower court ruling that had blocked them. The decision, which came sooner than expected, means the tariffs will remain in effect for now. The US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, which oversees the International Trade Court, granted the Trump administration's request for a temporary administrative stay. This gives the court time to review legal arguments and filings. The administration must submit its briefings by June 9, after which the court will determine the next steps. As Yahoo Finance legal reporter Alexis Keenan noted, Trump has broad authority to impose tariffs through various legal channels, including Sections 232 and 301. The administration had chosen to justify the tariffs under an emergency act, citing concerns such as immigration and drug trafficking — an argument the lower court rejected. Legal experts say it's unclear how the appeals court will ultimately rule, as another court might interpret the emergency authority in a different way. Analysts are raising concerns about how a new court ruling against President Trump's tariffs could force the U.S. government to raise the debt ceiling. Reuters reports: Read more here. Tensions between the US and China are rising again after the Trump administration announced it would revoke Chinese student visas, restrict chip design software, and try to block Huawei from selling advanced AI chips globally. Per Bloomberg, China's Foreign Ministry called the crackdown on student visas "discriminatory" on Thursday but did not move to immediately retaliate, signaling it was trying to avoid the kind of rapid escalation that brought tariffs to triple-digit levels. Still, the divide shows that the two countries are far from resolving their issues — chiefly tech competition — and coming to a trade agreement. Trump has yet to speak with Chinese leader Xi Jinping in his second term, despite hints a few weeks ago after top officials met in Geneva that a call was imminent. Read more here. A top official said that Taiwan will continue to seek a trade deal with the US despite the trade court's ruling on Wednesday that at least temporarily paused many of President Trump's tariffs. The Manhattan-based court ruled that many of Trump's wide-ranging tariffs, including the 10% "reciprocal" tariffs, were unlawful in a decision that the administration is expected to appeal. Taiwan is pushing for tariffs lower than the 10% base rate, Bloomberg reports: Read more here. Tariff uncertainty may be the primary thing standing in the way of lower interest rates, the Federal Reserve's Austan Goolsbee suggested on Thursday. Bloomberg reports: Read more here. Bloomberg reports: Reuters reports: Read more here. Such a move could add another wrinkle to US trade negotiations with the EU. Reuters reports: Read more here. Shares in HP Inc. (HPQ) fell by 8% on Thursday in premarket trading after the company's profit outlook missed estimates and it cut the annual earnings forecast, citing a weaker economy and continuing costs from US tariffs on goods from China. Bloomberg News reports: Read more here. Bloomberg News reports: Read more here. Markets may be celebrating the latest turn in the tariffs saga, but the US trade court's block isn't definitive — and that means there's still cause for concern, some analysts say. Reuters reports: Read more here. President Trump's tariff plans appear to be hanging by a thread after the US Court of international Trade deemed them "unlawful." However, his other big priority, a tax and spending bill, could help advance his tariff plans, if it ever gets off the ground. Reuters reports: Read more here. Bloomberg News reports: Read more here. Bloomberg News reports: Read more here. The temporary trade deal that led to the US and China pausing steep tariffs is showing signs of fraying. In a post on Truth Social on Friday, President Trump made it clear who he thinks is to blame. "I made a FAST DEAL with China in order to save them from what I thought was going to be a very bad situation, and I didn't want to see that happen," Trump said. "Because of this deal, everything quickly stabilized and China got back to business as usual. Everybody was happy! That is the good news!!! "The bad news," he continued, "is that China, perhaps not surprisingly to some, HAS TOTALLY VIOLATED ITS AGREEMENT WITH US." "So much for being Mr. NICE GUY!" Reuters reports: Read more here. Yahoo Finance's senior reporter Hamza Shaban reports on Nvidia (NVDA) and Trump tariffs: Read more here. Apple (AAPL) iPhone sales and its rivals are expected to take a significant hit due to President Trump's tariffs. Bloomberg News reports: Read more here. With US-China trade talks stalling, tensions may rise further as Trump steps up arms sales to China's rival, Taiwan. Bloomberg News reports: Read more here. Some of China's biggest tech companies have started to switch development of their artificial intelligence to homegrown chips as opposed to using semiconductors from America, due to the US export controls — which has led to a dwindling stockpile of Nvidia (NVDA) processors. The FT reports: Read more here. A federal appeals court has temporarily reinstated President Trump's global tariffs by pausing a lower court ruling that had blocked them. The decision, which came sooner than expected, means the tariffs will remain in effect for now. The US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, which oversees the International Trade Court, granted the Trump administration's request for a temporary administrative stay. This gives the court time to review legal arguments and filings. The administration must submit its briefings by June 9, after which the court will determine the next steps. As Yahoo Finance legal reporter Alexis Keenan noted, Trump has broad authority to impose tariffs through various legal channels, including Sections 232 and 301. The administration had chosen to justify the tariffs under an emergency act, citing concerns such as immigration and drug trafficking — an argument the lower court rejected. Legal experts say it's unclear how the appeals court will ultimately rule, as another court might interpret the emergency authority in a different way. Analysts are raising concerns about how a new court ruling against President Trump's tariffs could force the U.S. government to raise the debt ceiling. Reuters reports: Read more here. Tensions between the US and China are rising again after the Trump administration announced it would revoke Chinese student visas, restrict chip design software, and try to block Huawei from selling advanced AI chips globally. Per Bloomberg, China's Foreign Ministry called the crackdown on student visas "discriminatory" on Thursday but did not move to immediately retaliate, signaling it was trying to avoid the kind of rapid escalation that brought tariffs to triple-digit levels. Still, the divide shows that the two countries are far from resolving their issues — chiefly tech competition — and coming to a trade agreement. Trump has yet to speak with Chinese leader Xi Jinping in his second term, despite hints a few weeks ago after top officials met in Geneva that a call was imminent. Read more here. A top official said that Taiwan will continue to seek a trade deal with the US despite the trade court's ruling on Wednesday that at least temporarily paused many of President Trump's tariffs. The Manhattan-based court ruled that many of Trump's wide-ranging tariffs, including the 10% "reciprocal" tariffs, were unlawful in a decision that the administration is expected to appeal. Taiwan is pushing for tariffs lower than the 10% base rate, Bloomberg reports: Read more here. Tariff uncertainty may be the primary thing standing in the way of lower interest rates, the Federal Reserve's Austan Goolsbee suggested on Thursday. Bloomberg reports: Read more here. Bloomberg reports: Reuters reports: Read more here. Such a move could add another wrinkle to US trade negotiations with the EU. Reuters reports: Read more here. Shares in HP Inc. (HPQ) fell by 8% on Thursday in premarket trading after the company's profit outlook missed estimates and it cut the annual earnings forecast, citing a weaker economy and continuing costs from US tariffs on goods from China. Bloomberg News reports: Read more here. Bloomberg News reports: Read more here. Markets may be celebrating the latest turn in the tariffs saga, but the US trade court's block isn't definitive — and that means there's still cause for concern, some analysts say. Reuters reports: Read more here. President Trump's tariff plans appear to be hanging by a thread after the US Court of international Trade deemed them "unlawful." However, his other big priority, a tax and spending bill, could help advance his tariff plans, if it ever gets off the ground. Reuters reports: Read more here. Bloomberg News reports: Read more here. Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
