logo
Opinion - When it comes to deportations, why are the media hiding the ball?

Opinion - When it comes to deportations, why are the media hiding the ball?

Yahoo24-03-2025

Few things are so unhelpful as the journalist who buries the lede.
There has been a lot of that lately, especially insofar as the Trump administration's immigration crackdown is concerned.
Take, for example, the case of the Georgetown University researcher arrested in Virginia last week over his alleged ties to terrorism. Badar Khan Suri reportedly spread Hamas propaganda online while having 'close connections to a known or suspected terrorist, who is a senior advisor to Hamas,' according to the Department of Homeland Security.
This is pretty serious stuff, which is why the coverage has been so maddening. In most reports, the allegations against Suri are buried so deep as to be next to the dinosaur bones.
'Trump is seeking to deport another academic who is legally in the country, lawsuit says,' reported Politico on March 19. The subhead adds, 'Badar Khan Suri, a fellow at Georgetown, says he is being punished because of the suspected views of his wife, a U.S. citizen with Palestinian heritage.'
The Associated Press ran the same story, but with the headline, 'Government cannot deport Georgetown scholar until court rules, judge orders.' The subhead adds, 'A federal judge has ordered immigration officials not to deport a Georgetown scholar that the government detained until the court has had a chance to rule.'
NBC News published the headline, 'Georgetown University graduate student detained by immigration authorities,' with a subhead that reads, 'A lawyer for Badar Khan Suri, who was teaching on a student visa, said Thursday that he is grateful for the support he has received since his arrest.'
These are just a few headlines and news blurbs plucked at random, but they represent the overall coverage. We are immediately provided with the who, what, where and even when — but not with the why. That's an omission so glaring as to be intentional.
It is possible — but unlikely — for a journalist to forget outright one of the five Ws of lede writing. But the entire newsroom? And for the issue to be spread out over multiple organizations? The word 'unlikely' is getting a workout this week.
Now, regarding Suri's arrest, there are some pertinent details you ought to know. First, he is in the U.S. on a temporary visa. He is an Indian national and married to Mapheze Saleh, a Gaza-born U.S. resident. Saleh is the daughter of Ahmed Yousef, who has served as a senior political adviser for Hamas (although he claims he no longer holds this position).
To recap: A guest in the U.S., who is the son-in-law of a (possibly) former Hamas official, has been arrested and detained on allegations that he promotes agitprop for a designated terrorist organization. Whether the charges hold up is one thing, but these are indisputably the federal government's allegations against Suri.
Yet, were you to read Politico's original scoop on the matter, you couldn't find DHS's justification for the arrest until the ninth paragraph, and that's only after the reader is told the foreign national 'has no criminal record' and merely '[opposes] U.S. foreign policy toward Israel,' or so says his lawyer.
The Associated Press does only slightly better, mentioning the Hamas propaganda in the opening paragraph but failing to note Suri's connection to Hamas leadership. The Associated Press eventually revealed this connection, but only in passing and only to suggest there's no there there. And maybe there isn't, but when this familial connection represents half of DHS's argument against Suri, why save that information for the 10th paragraph, and why note it only in passing?
By glossing over this latter detail and focusing solely on the 'propaganda' angle, the Associated Press has effectively reframed the story as a free speech issue exclusively, rather than one that also concerns alleged national security issues.
For NBC News, it took 11 paragraphs before readers learned of the allegations against Suri.
The coverage has been every bit as befuddling and exasperating as the initial coverage of the arrest of Mahmoud Khalil, the 30-year-old Columbia student and legal permanent resident whom ICE arrested and detained over his alleged support for Hamas. If you recall the early coverage of his arrest, there was plenty in terms of human interest — everything from details of Khalil's marriage to his campus activities. But there was precious little about why the federal government detained him.
It took me multiple articles and independent research to understand DHS's position — not because the federal government lacked an explanation, but because few media outlets bothered to publish it.
There's a robust and worthwhile debate to be had about these arrests. Some conservatives have expressed discomfort over the legality of such actions. However, it will be impossible to have the discussion if the media continue to hide the ball on the why of these arrests, ignoring or downplaying the behaviors and factors federal authorities cite as legal justification.
We can't have the debate if we have only partial information.
Becket Adams is a writer in Washington and program director for the National Journalism Center.
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

L.A. immigration protests intensify and Israel intercepts Gaza aid ship: Morning Rundown
L.A. immigration protests intensify and Israel intercepts Gaza aid ship: Morning Rundown

Yahoo

time16 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

L.A. immigration protests intensify and Israel intercepts Gaza aid ship: Morning Rundown

California Gov. Gavin Newsom threatens to sue the Trump administration. Israel intercepts a Gaza-bound aid ship with Greta Thunberg aboard. And residents of a San Diego neighborhood say they live in fear after a fiery jet crash. Here's what to know today. California Gov. Gavin Newsom said he plans to sue the Trump administration over its deployment of the National Guard in Los Angeles as protests in the city intensified over the weekend. President Donald Trump's order required the Defense Department to coordinate with Newsom before he sent in the National Guard, Newsom said, adding that the administration failed to do so. 'There's a protocol; there's a process,' Newsom told correspondent Jacob Soboroff yesterday in an interview on MSNBC. 'He didn't care about that. And the worst part? He completely lied.' Newsom noted that Trump had said on social media that everything was safe because after he had sent the guard — except the guard had not been deployed at the time. This is Morning Rundown, a weekday newsletter to start your day. Sign up here to get it in your inbox. Newsom also mentioned that he and Trump spoke by phone on Friday, but Trump didn't express concern about his ability to manage the growing protests or the prospect of federalizing National Guard troops. Newsom also dared for Trump's 'border czar' Tom Homan to 'arrest me.' On Saturday, Homan threatened to arrest anyone who obstructs the immigration effort, including city and state leaders. 'He knows where to find me,' Newsom said of Homan. 'That kind of bloviating is exhausting. So, Tom, arrest me. Let's go.' Newsom and Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass have intensely criticized Trump's decision to authorize the deployment of at least 2,000 National Guard troops in response to the protests. As of Sunday, around 300 National Guard members were in the city. U.S. Northern Command said on Sunday that 500 Marines were on standby and ready to provide backup to National Guard troops if needed. Protests around the Southern California city escalated over the weekend, with tensions rising between demonstrators and authorities yesterday in downtown. At one point, both sides of the 101 Freeway were shut down after protesters streamed onto the roadway. Video showed police launching flash-bangs to disperse protesters, as well as tear gas and less-lethal projectiles. By the end of the night, an unlawful assembly declaration had been expanded to include all of downtown. Authorities said at least 56 people had been arrested, including 29 on Saturday and at least 17 when the 101 Freeway was shut down. Read the full story here. A travel ban on 12 countries, including Afghanistan, Iran and Libya, took effect at 12:01 a.m. ET, less than a week after President Donald Trump announced the ban over national security concerns. Another seven countries, including Cuba and Venezuela are under partial restrictions. Several top Defense Department jobs are still unfilled after a series of missteps have shaken confidence in Secretary Pete Hegseth's leadership. Israel's Foreign Minister said the British-flagged yacht Madleen was 'safely making its way to the shores of Israel' and that passengers will 'return to their home countries' after it was boarded by Israeli forces. The vessel carrying Greta Thunberg and other activists was attempting to break Israel's naval blockade to deliver aid to Gaza. Israel had previously vowed to stop the vessel. Madleen was carrying a symbolic shipment of humanitarian aid to Gaza, where Israel's 11-week blockade has heightened fears of starvation. Meanwhile, the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation announced yesterday the opening of three distribution centers today. Read the full story here. 'Maybe Happy Ending' dominated the 2025 Tonys with six awards, including best musical and co-star Darren Criss bringing home the trophy for best leading actor in a musical. This year's show also saw Nicole Scherzinger win best actress in a musical for her debut Broadway role in 'Sunset Boulevard,' while Sarah Snook won for best leading actress in a play for 'The Picture of Dorian Gray' (and bringing her closer to an EGOT) and Cole Escola won best lead actor in a play for 'Oh, Mary!' 'Wicked' star Cynthia Erivo hosted the night, charming audiences with a warning that she would 'sing off' winners if their acceptance speeches ran beyond the 90-second window and a nod to 'Dreamgirls' as she bid everyone farewell. And let's not forget the 'Hamilton' medley, performed by the hit show's original cast. See more highlights from the night, plus a full list of winners. The Oklahoma City Thunder dominated the Indiana Pacers in Game 2 of the NBA Finals, winning 123-107 and tying the series, thanks to the same blueprint that led the Pacers to a Game 1 win. Frenzied social media claims about ivermectin's supposed 'miraculous' abilities has some clamoring for over-the-counter access to the drug, but a lack of FDA guidance has some pharmacists worried. At least two people were killed by falling trees in Mississippi and Georgia as severe storms rolled through the South. Carlos Alcaraz produced one of the greatest comebacks in French Open history to win the men's title for a second straight year. A jet crashed into a military housing neighborhood in San Diego. But with so much going on nationally, it seemed like a blip in the news cycle. I wanted to know how the survivors were recovering after experiencing such stark terror. They were asleep — their babies tucked in nearby — when smoke and fire penetrated their bedrooms in the early morning hours of May 22. They had to flee while jet fuel snaked down the street, igniting every car in its path. Panicked neighbors outside screamed to find their children. Two weeks later, their fear endures. The Navy families still live below an active flight path about 2 miles from an airport. That means about every 30 minutes, an aircraft roars above and brings them back to the morning fire roused them out of bed. 'It terrifies me knowing that we have planes coming over here all day, all the time,' one of the survivors said. 'It's a lot to be reminded of every single day.' — Melissa Chan, national reporter Sales are skyrocketing on Amazon for this anti-frizz hair product from Amika. Our team scoured through reviews to help you decide if it's worth adding to your cart. Plus, your loofah is also probably nastier than you realize. Consider one of these dermatologist-approved alternatives instead. Sign up to The Selection newsletter for hands-on product reviews, expert shopping tips and a look at the best deals and sales each week. Thanks for reading today's Morning Rundown. Today's newsletter was curated for you by Elizabeth Robinson. If you're a fan, please send a link to your family and friends. They can sign up here. This article was originally published on

IAEA chief says information obtained by Iran 'seem to refer' to Israeli nuclear research site
IAEA chief says information obtained by Iran 'seem to refer' to Israeli nuclear research site

Yahoo

time16 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

IAEA chief says information obtained by Iran 'seem to refer' to Israeli nuclear research site

VIENNA (AP) — The head of the International Atomic Energy Agency said Monday that the information Iran claimed it seized regarding Israel's nuclear program 'seems to refer' to the country's Soreq Nuclear Research Center, the first acknowledgment outside of Tehran of the theft. The office of Israel's prime minister had no immediate response on the remarks by IAEA Director General Rafael Mariano Grossi, who spoke during a news conference in Vienna. The alleged theft comes at a time of renewed tensions over Iran's nuclear program, which enriches uranium a short, technical step away from weapons-grade levels and looks poised to reject a U.S. proposal over a possible deal on its atomic program. 'We have seen some reports in the press. We haven't had any official communication about this," Grossi told reporters. "In any case, this seems to refer to Soreq, which is a research facility which we inspect by the way. We don't inspect other strategic parts of the program, but this part of the program we do inspect." He did not elaborate on where he received his information, though the IAEA maintains a confidential reporting system for nations to report security incidents involving their nuclear programs. Soreq, located 20 kilometers (12 miles) south of Tel Aviv, is a national laboratory for nuclear science established in Israel in 1958, engaged in nuclear science, radiation safety and applied physics. The IAEA has so-called 'item-specific safeguards agreements' with Israel, Pakistan and India, all countries that are not party to the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons. Under Israel's agreement, the IAEA monitors Soreq but has no access to Israel's nuclear facility at Dimona, believed to provide the fuel for Israel's undeclared nuclear weapons program. Over the weekend Iranian state television and later the country's intelligence minister claimed without offering evidence that Tehran seized an 'important treasury' of information regarding Israel's nuclear program. Israel, whose undeclared atomic weapons program makes it the only country in the Mideast with nuclear bombs, has not acknowledged any such Iranian operation targeting it — though there have been arrests of Israelis allegedly spying for Tehran amid the Israel-Hamas war in the Gaza Strip. Iranian Intelligence Minister Esmail Khatib claimed thousands of pages of documents had been obtained which would be made public soon. Among them were documents related to the U.S., Europe and other countries which, he claimed, had been obtained through 'infiltration' and 'access to the sources.' He did not elaborate on the methods used. However, Khatib, a Shiite cleric, was sanctioned by the U.S. Treasury in 2022 over directing 'cyber espionage and ransomware attacks in support of Iran's political goals.' For Iran, the claim may be designed to show the public that the theocracy was able to respond to a 2018 Israeli operation that spirited out what Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu described as a 'half ton' of documents related to Iran's program. That Israeli announcement came just before President Donald Trump in his first term unilaterally withdrew America from Iran's 2015 nuclear deal with world powers, which greatly limited its program in exchange for the lifting of economic sanctions. This week, Western nations are expect to go before the IAEA's Board of Governors with a proposal to find Iran in noncompliance with the United Nations' nuclear watchdog. It could be the first time in decades — and likely would kick the issue to the U.N. Security Council. That could see one of the Western countries involved in the 2015 nuclear deal invoke the so-called 'snapback' of U.N. sanctions on the Islamic Republic. The authority to restore those sanctions by the complaint of any member of the original 2015 nuclear deal expires in October — putting the West on a clock to exert pressure on Tehran over its program before losing that power. ___ Associated Press writer Jon Gambrell in Dubai, United Arab Emirates, contributed to this report. ___ The Associated Press receives support for nuclear security coverage from the Carnegie Corporation of New York and Outrider Foundation. The AP is solely responsible for all content. ___ Additional AP coverage of the nuclear landscape:

‘Piracy': World reacts to Israel's seizure of Gaza-bound aid vessel Madleen
‘Piracy': World reacts to Israel's seizure of Gaza-bound aid vessel Madleen

Yahoo

time16 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

‘Piracy': World reacts to Israel's seizure of Gaza-bound aid vessel Madleen

Israel has intercepted a Gaza-bound aid ship, preventing the 12 activists on board, including Swedish climate campaigner Greta Thunberg, from reaching the blockaded Palestinian territory. Israeli forces 'forcibly intercepted' the Madleen in international waters overnight about 100 nautical miles (185km) from Gaza, the Freedom Flotilla Coalition NGO said in a statement on Monday. Al Jazeera lost contact with the vessel at 7:00 GMT. Apart from Thunberg, those taken into custody by Israel are Palestinian French Member of the European Parliament Rima Hassan, Baptiste Andre, Pascal Maurieras, Yanis Mhamdi and Reva Viard from France; Thiago Avila from Brazil; Suayb Ordu from Turkiye; Sergio Toribio from Spain; Marco van Rennes from the Netherlands; Yasemin Acar from Germany; and Omar Faiad, a journalist with Al Jazeera Mubasher, also from France. Israel has detained the crew for 'interrogation'. Here's how the world has reacted: The interception of the Madleen is a 'flagrant violation of international law', Hamas said in a statement, calling for the activists on board to be released and saying it holds Israel 'fully accountable for their safety'. 'Israel has no legal authority to restrict access to Palestine since such is within the exclusive right of the Palestinian people,' said the rights organisation Al-Haq, which is based in Ramallah in the occupied West Bank. 'The assault on this flotilla, since it happened in international waters, is considered a form of piracy under international law,' said Esmaeil Baqaei, a spokesman for Iran's Ministry of Foreign Affairs. Israel's interception of the Madleen is a 'clear violation of international law' that 'once again demonstrates that Israel is acting as a terror state', Turkiye's Ministry of Foreign Affairs said in a statement. President Emmanuel Macron 'has asked that our six French nationals be allowed to return to France as soon as possible,' said the Elysee Palace in a press release. 'We have asked to be able to exercise our consular protection over them' and to 'visit them', Minister for Europe and Foreign Affairs Jean-Noel Barrot added. Spain has summoned Dan Poraz, charge d'affaires at the Israeli embassy in Madrid, reported the Spanish newspaper El Pais and Al Jazeera Arabic, quoting a source at Spain's Ministry of Foreign Affairs. The Jewish Council of Australia has expressed 'grave concerns for the activists on board the Gaza Freedom Flotilla' and called 'on the Australian government to urgently intervene to secure the immediate release of the vessel and safety of the crew'. 'We strongly condemn the cowardly and illegal Israeli attack on the Madleen as it approached Gaza with desperately needed humanitarian supplies,' the Council on American-Islamic Relations said. 'We applaud Greta Thunberg and the other activists of the Madleen who bravely risked their safety and freedom to help the starving people of Gaza.' Israel's seizure of the Madleen 'outside Israeli territorial waters' is a 'blatant violation of international law', said The Left, the European Parliament faction that Hassan belongs to. 'The arrest of the crew members and the confiscation of aid intended for a population in immediate humanitarian distress is unacceptable and is clearly part of a wider strategy to starve and massacre Palestinians in Gaza while hiding Israeli war crimes from the world.' 'Madleen must be released immediately,' United Nations Special Rapporteur on the Occupied Palestinian Territory Francesca Albanese said. 'Breaking the siege is a legal duty for states and a moral imperative for all of us. Every Mediterranean port should send boats with aid, solidarity and humanity to Gaza. They shall sail together – united, they will be unstoppable.' 'As the occupying power (as recognised by the ICJ [International Court of Justice]), Israel has a legal obligation to ensure civilians in Gaza have sufficient food and medicine. They should have let Madleen deliver its humanitarian supplies to Gaza,' said Agnes Callamard, secretary-general of Amnesty International, asserting that Israel's interception of the Madleen 'violates international law'.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store