logo
As activists mobilize against drilling, oil and gas operators sour on Colorado

As activists mobilize against drilling, oil and gas operators sour on Colorado

Yahoo10-02-2025

An oil pump jack is pictured in the middle of a traffic circle at a new residential development in Weld County on June 24, 2020. (Andy Bosselman for Colorado Newsline)
This story originally appeared at Capital & Main.
A decision by Colorado state regulators to put two multiwell oil and gas proposals on hold showcased the growing influence of Denver-area antidrilling groups that have organized over the last decade in the face of large fossil fuel developments proposed on the outskirts of their suburban neighborhoods.
Colorado's Energy and Carbon Management Commission in November rejected a controversial request by Extraction Oil & Gas Inc. to build a 26-well oil operation, known as the Draco pad, in fossil fuel friendly Weld County and use it as a platform to drill under the town of Erie, which has fought to keep its land free from gas and oil extraction.
In early January, the five-member body also denied for now an application by a smaller operator to construct a 20-well pad about 45 minutes to the southeast. The so-called Secret Stash project would have been drilled on a former bombing range that's also slated for scores of additional wells.
If constructed, both developments would have been less than a mile from the fast-growing suburbs that ring the state's capital. The decisions to block the drilling for now marked a milestone for community organizations that have lobbied the state's oil and gas agency for years to move drilling operations farther away from their homes.
'I would suggest that before any of these are permitted that the commission and other agencies do a bit more homework and do some simple math,' Randy Willard, a 36-year resident of nearby Aurora, testified at the Jan. 8 hearing on the Secret Stash pad.
'They will see that the impact of Secret Stash does not stand alone and in fact adds to the impacts of the area considerably,' added Willard, who is among scores of members of Save the Aurora Reservoir, a neighborhood nonprofit group created to fight multiwell pads proposed within several miles of homes.
SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX
Both developments put on hold by state regulators underscored the challenges energy companies face in tapping lucrative shale deposits miles below the sprawling neighborhoods along the Front Range. As drilling moved ever closer to communities, state legislators enacted a unique law in 2019 that required the energy commission to prioritize health, safety and the environment over industry profits.
Capital & Main reached out to Civitas Resources Inc., the parent company of Extraction Oil & Gas, for a response. The company did not respond.
Extensive new rules outlined in a state Senate bill also required energy companies to provide officials with more information about how hydrocarbon extraction projects affect traffic, air emissions and water use. This additional data gives regulators more sway over how and when pads are constructed.
As written, Senate Bill 19-181 also gave greater authority to municipalities over oil and gas operations within their boundaries and required that community groups be allowed additional opportunities to influence the process.
The dramatic shift in Colorado's fossil fuel regulatory environment, and the subsequent power it's given residents, is affecting the market value of oil and gas companies and causing operators to question the economics of doing business in the state, industry analysts said.
Civitas Resources Inc., the parent company of Extraction, whose Draco pad the commission placed on hold in November, is exploring the sale of extensive assets it holds in the region's Denver-Julesburg basin, according to a Jan. 15 report in Bloomberg News. The holdings reportedly include the Lowry Ranch Comprehensive Area Project, a 166-well project that led to the creation of Save the Aurora Reservoir.
'A potential sale would remove the market/investor stigma associated with Colorado, which is weighing on the valuation,' Gabriele Sorbara, an analyst at Siebert Williams Shank & Co. LLC, told Reuters. 'Investors do not want to touch Colorado-focused E&Ps,' or exploration and production companies.
The reasons Colorado's energy commission gave for placing the Secret Stash and Draco multiwell projects on hold varied. On the Secret Stash pad application, state regulators asked the operator to clarify how many times it planned to drill on the pad and how many truck trips and air emissions would result from drilling on the site.
'It's not clear what is being proposed,' Commissioner John Messner said. Multiple trips to drill on the site 'also means additional truck trips, which means additional emissions, which means additional impacts.'
The company proposing the Secret Stash development, GMT Exploration Co. LLC, told the commission it wanted to start with several wells to determine the hydrocarbon production potential in the area.
Colorado regulators approve oil and gas drilling plan on state land east of Aurora
'Initially it will likely be two to six wells,' Maxwell Blair, the privately held company's regulatory manager, told the commission before it denied the project. 'It's not totally clear whether all 20 will be developed at this point.'
The commission asked that GMT rework its application to better specify air, water and other effects it expected to result from operations it planned at the site.
GMT did not respond to Capital & Main's request for comment.
In Erie, the state's energy commission ordered Extraction Oil & Gas Inc. to consider constructing the Draco pad on an alternate site within the picturesque town. That parcel, already home to 29 wells, two landfills and a Superfund site, would give the town authority to regulate operations that affect its residents, commissioners said.
'To me this application is very challenging,' Commissioner Brett Ackerman said at a Nov. 15 online hearing about the original site in Weld County, next door to the town of Erie. 'On one hand, it includes many best-in-class practices we often encourage, and on the other hand, there are multijurisdictional issues.'
Commissioners voted unanimously to put the plan on hold after an eight-hour hearing on the proposal spread over two days. The hearing included testimony from Erie residents who already have oil and gas wells in their backyards or feet from their homes or children's schools.
The commissioners required Extraction to conduct a 'full alternative location analysis' of a site known as Redtail Ranch, a highly contaminated area that was once envisioned as a master-planned community.
Residents' reactions to the commission's ruling were mixed. There was little celebration, as the decision would merely move the effects of the industrial operation to the doorstep of other neighborhoods. And the well bores would still be drilled under communities that already have scores of existing wells — including some that need to be plugged and abandoned.
'We will prepare to vigorously oppose [the alternative site] should they make an actual effort to pursue that,' said Christiaan van Woudenberg, a resident who can see the Redtail Ranch site from his back deck. 'Until then we are in the shock phase wondering, 'Do we have to do this again, to fight for our health and safety and the ability to spend time outdoors?''
When the existing wells were drilled and fracked — a process in which sand and water are injected down a well to release oil and gas trapped in shale miles beneath the surface — on the ranch in 2017, the noise from diesel generators kept van Woudenberg awake for months. The disruption dysregulated his nervous system and forced his neighbors to put 2-inch plastic foam pads in their windows, he said.
Extraction said in its drilling application to regulators that the Redtail Ranch location was among several alternatives for the pad that were deemed unfeasible 'due to local regulations.'
The company said it chose the 20-acre site in Weld County in part because electricity is available to power drilling and fracking equipment, allowing it to forgo diesel generators. Commissioners applauded the plan, citing the fact it would cut down on toxic emissions and noise.
Even so, the five-member body expressed concerns about the pad's location on the outskirts of a planned 3,100-home community, with homes priced between $500,000 and $1.5 million.
The drilling site would be within 2,000 feet of at least 70 residences, a park, walking trails and a school. To reach minerals under the town of Erie, Extraction asked to drill some of the longest horizontal bores ever proposed in Colorado that would run contiguous to existing wells. Residents and town officials expressed fear about the potential for interaction between older wells and the newer bores.
The Draco pad is proving to be a test case for what happens when local oil and gas rules are misaligned. Extraction proposed drilling in Weld County, which requires only a 500-foot setback — less than a length of two football fields — between wells and homes. The town of Erie meanwhile mandates 2,000 feet between the two. The issue is further complicated because Erie is bifurcated by Weld and Boulder counties. The latter enacted a moratorium on drilling in the 2010s. Yet the wells would extend underground from the Draco pad into Boulder County.
But the county, like the town of Erie, has no jurisdiction over the application because the pad on which the wells would be drilled is located next door in Weld, the state's largest oil and gas county. The jurisdictional confusion triggered by the geographic location of the Draco pad was evident throughout the two-day online hearing on Extraction's proposal.
'From a land-use perspective, this is a good location,' Jason Maxey, then-director of Weld County's energy department, said during the November hearing. He said the county determined the application complied with its code requirements and approved it in February 2024. Four alternate locations were considered, he said, and the proposed site chosen was the one that best mitigated effects on residents.
Extraction echoed Maxey's comments that none of the alternative parcels were viable. This is particularly true of the Redtail Ranch alternative, company representatives said, even though it's farther from homes and industrial activities that already exist on the site.
'We thought it would be highly unlikely the town of Erie would approve an oil and gas location zoned heavy industrial 2,005 feet away from a residential development to the south,' Jeff Annable, Extraction's manager of well and location permitting, said at the November hearing
Indeed, the Redtail Ranch location is beset by challenges. Existing oil and gas operations there racked up the highest number of complaints in the state, most from nearby communities. The acreage would need to be rezoned from agricultural/residential to industrial. And questions remain about the presence of water and whether toxic contaminants already on the site were adequately cleaned up.
David Frank, Erie's environmental services department director, told Capital & Main he met with Extraction in early January to discuss the process for submitting an application to drill on the Redtail Ranch site. The firm would also need to meet with the planning department to begin the rezoning process, Frank said.
It is unclear if rezoning must be completed before the company could request that the Erie Town Council approve an oil and gas permit for the site, he said. Additional analysis is also necessary to determine if the location is more protective of residents, he said.
'The purpose of the alternative location analysis is not to find the most convenient, or easily permitted location,' Frank said. 'The fact that the mineral estate they are pursuing is largely in Boulder County, and portions of it under the town of Erie, perhaps those are the local governments that should be granted siting authority.'
The Erie Town Council rejected an application from Stratus Companies to build homes on the Redtail Ranch site in June, citing existing industrial activities that include a landfill shuttered in 2020, a 1960s-era waste disposal site so toxic that it required a cleanup overseen by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, an operating landfill and two active oil and gas pads. One council member called the property 'spectacularly contaminated.'
Oil and gas operations on the site over the last seven years also drew hundreds of complaints from nearby communities. Van Woudenberg, the Erie resident who lives across the street from the site, created a website to educate people how to file reports about health effects, noise, light and traffic they observed at fossil fuel sites. He then mobilized residents by putting door hangers on homes.
The action resulted in about 905 noise, odor, light and air quality complaints to be filed against Crestone Peak Resources LLC, which operates two pads on the Redtail Ranch site, documents show. The company is a subsidiary of Civitas Resources Inc., as is Extraction Oil & Gas Inc., the firm that submitted the Draco pad proposal.
Residents of 26 neighborhoods that would be affected by Extraction's proposal to drill under their homes held a community picnic a few days after the commission's Nov. 15 decision and recommitted to opposing the project, no matter its location.
'There's a growing engagement, an excitement, passion and breadth of experiences and backgrounds behind this movement,' Erie resident Sami Carroll, who created the Flatiron Meadows Oil & Gas Monitoring Group in early 2024 to oppose the Draco pad, told Capital & Main.
'I had a woman tell me we've changed the face of activism in Erie — this has become bigger and more impactful in so many ways,' Carroll added.
Copyright 2025 Capital & Main
SUPPORT: YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Trump's 'big beautiful' spending bill could make it harder to claim this low-income tax credit
Trump's 'big beautiful' spending bill could make it harder to claim this low-income tax credit

CNBC

time42 minutes ago

  • CNBC

Trump's 'big beautiful' spending bill could make it harder to claim this low-income tax credit

As Senate Republicans debate President Donald Trump's "big beautiful bill", a lesser-known provision from the House-approved package could make it harder to claim a low-income tax credit. If enacted as written, the House measure in the "One Big Beautiful Bill Act" would require precertification of each qualifying child for filers claiming the so-called earned income tax credit, or EITC, starting in 2028. Under current law, taxpayers claim the EITC on their tax return — including Schedule EIC for qualifying children. The provision aims to "avoid duplicative and other erroneous claims," according to the bill's text. But policy experts say the new rules would burden eligible filers, who may forgo the EITC as a result. The measure could also delay tax refunds for those filers, particularly amid IRS cutbacks, experts say. More from Personal Finance:Job market is 'trash' right now, career coach says — here's whyWhat a 'revenge tax' in Trump's spending bill could mean for investorsWhat Trump's plan to slash Pell Grant to lowest level in a decade means for you "You're going to flood the IRS with all these [EITC] documents," said Janet Holtzblatt, a senior fellow at the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center. "It's just not clear how they're going to process all this information." Holtzblatt, who has pushed to simplify the EITC for decades, wrote a critique of the proposed precertification last week. "This is not a new idea, but was previously considered, studied and rejected for very good reasons," Greg Leiserson, a senior fellow at the Tax Law Center at New York University Law, wrote about the proposal in late May. Studies during the George W. Bush administration found an EITC precertification process reduced EITC claims for eligible filers, Leiserson wrote. During the study, precertification also yielded a lower return on investment compared to existing EITC enforcement, such as audits, he wrote. One of the key benefits of the EITC is the tax break is "refundable," meaning you can still claim the credit and get a refund with zero taxes owed. That's valuable for lower earners who don't have a tax bill, experts say. To qualify, you need "earned income," or wages from work. The income phase-outs depend on your "qualifying children," based on four IRS tests. "Eligibility is complicated," and residency requirements for qualifying children often cause errors, said Holtzblatt with the Tax Policy Center. For 2025, the tax break is worth up to $8,046 for eligible families. You can claim the maximum EITC with adjusted gross income up to $61,555 for single filers and $68,675 for married couples filing jointly. These phase-outs apply to families with three or more children. As of December 2024, about 23 million workers received the EITC for tax year 2022, according to the IRS. But 1 in 5 eligible taxpayers don't claim the tax break, the agency estimates. Nine Democratic Senators last week voiced concerns about the House-approved EITC changes in a letter to Senate Majority Leader John Thune, R-S.D., and House Speaker Mike Johnson, R-La. If enacted, the updates would "further complicate the EITC's existing challenges and make it more difficult to claim," the lawmakers wrote. Higher earners are more likely to face an audit, but EITC claimants have a 5.5 times higher audit rate than the rest of U.S. filers, partly due to improper payments, according to the Bipartisan Policy Center. The proposed EITC change, among other House provisions, still need Senate approval, and it's unclear how the measure could change. However, under the reconciliation process, Senate Republicans only need a simple majority to advance the bill.

What to know about Chicago Sports Network, the TV home of the White Sox, Bulls and Blackhawks
What to know about Chicago Sports Network, the TV home of the White Sox, Bulls and Blackhawks

Chicago Tribune

timean hour ago

  • Chicago Tribune

What to know about Chicago Sports Network, the TV home of the White Sox, Bulls and Blackhawks

Starting Oct. 1, the Blackhawks, Bulls and White Sox have a new TV home — but some in Chicago won't be able to see it. Here's what to know about Chicago Sports Network. Chicago Sports Network — a joint venture among the three teams and Nashville, Tenn.-based Standard Media — is supplanting NBC Sports Chicago, the 20-year-old regional sports network whose broadcast rights expired after the Sox season ended. NBC Sports Chicago, founded as Comcast SportsNet in 2004, was a partnership between cable giant Comcast and the Cubs, Sox, Hawks and Bulls. A ratings and revenue winner for most of its run, it covered Cubs and Sox World Series championships, three Hawks Stanley Cups and several Bulls playoff appearances. But the Cubs broke off to form the Marquee Sports Network in 2020, and regional sports networks, long the cash cow of pay TV, have struggled financially in recent years as cord-cutting takes its toll on the cable bundle. Enter CHSN. Eight months after launching, Chicago Sports Network finally hit the airwaves on Comcast on June 6 — but for a price. CHSN is now on the higher-priced Ultimate tier as part of an inaugural carriage agreement with the cable giant. Viewers can find it on Channel 200, where NBC Sports Chicago resided until pulling the plug last fall. For Comcast customers on the lower-priced basic plan, Channel 200 already bears a message that CHSN requires a subscription upgrade to watch. The Ultimate tier costs an additional $20 per month, on top of the $20.25 regional sports network fee Comcast charges Chicago-area subscribers each month. Comcast has been issuing a monthly $8.85 credit to partially offset that fee during the ongoing negotiations with CHSN. For basic subscribers who don't upgrade, the $8.85 credit will become a permanent adjustment, bringing the regional sports fee down to $11.40 per month. In the wake of the deal, CHSN abruptly pulled the plug on June 9 on local TV affiliates in Chicago, Rockford, Peoria, and Fort Wayne and South Bend, Indiana. That leaves an untold number of fans who may have purchased an indoor antenna, a new receiver or even clambered up onto a roof to hook up an outdoor antenna, with a bunch of wires and a blank TV screen. About 15% of the 3.46 million homes in the Chicago market watch TV using an antenna, according to Nielsen. Going live on Comcast may have already given CHSN a ratings boost. Sources said the first primetime audience for the White Sox-Royals game was up 66% over the previous week's Sox-Orioles broadcast, which was prior to Comcast joining the pay-TV lineup. The 24/7 regional sports network will air for DirecTV subscribers across a five-state footprint that includes Illinois, Iowa and portions of Indiana, Wisconsin and Michigan. 'We have always prided ourselves on being a sports leader and intend to remain at the forefront,' Rob Thun, chief content officer for DirecTV, said in a news release. CHSN will be included in the 125-plus-channel Choice Package on DirecTV, which costs $74.99 per month. DirecTV has about 300,000 subscribers in the Chicago area. DirecTV subscribers can find CHSN on Channel 665, and for U-verse it's Channels 1741 (HD)/741 (SD) — the same ones NBCSCH had. The network is moving forward with its direct-to-consumer streaming service, bypassing the pay-TV middleman to reach blacked-out viewers. The app, which launches Nov. 15, will offer live access to CHSN, including all Bulls, Blackhawks and White Sox games, as well as other programming. The cost is $19.99 per month for one team's games or $29.99 for all three, plus the nightly primetime sports talk shows. The service will enable subscribers to stream the regional sports network directly on web browsers, mobile devices and in the coming weeks, connected TV platforms. Another option: FuboTV, which struck a deal with Chicago Sports Network on Oct. 25 ahead of the Bulls' second regular-season game. Fubo, a leading national streaming service that focuses on live sports content, will include CHSN for subscribers in the Chicago market as part of its base Pro plan, which costs $79.99 per month, with a $20 discount off the first month, the company said. Just like with NBC Sports Chicago, there is a CHSN and a CHSN+ to accommodate for those instances. For DirecTV users, it will be Channel 665 for CHSN and 665-1 for CHSNP. Astound also lists two channels each for HD and SD: CHSN HD Channel 685 and CHSNPLS HD Channel 576, and then CHSN SD Channel 370 and CHSNPLS SD Channel 371. All the over-the-air deals also include two channels to handle the overflow. CHSN finished an atrium studio at the United Center where fans will be able to interact with the live Hawks and Bulls game broadcasts. A studio for Sox games at Guaranteed Rate Field is also in the works for next season, Coyle said. The Bulls and Hawks will share a studio in the United Center's east atrium in the space previously used by Stadium for shows such as 'The Rally.' 'That's a new model that really I haven't done before,' analyst Kendall Gill said of the Bulls show he'll be a part of, 'but I'm excited to see what it's like. … Maybe a celebrity with local ties, or if (Bears quarterback) Caleb Williams perhaps came to the game, maybe he sits in the third seat for a segment or two, things like that. 'So you get a different perspective from people from different sports.' Chuck Garfien and Ozzie Guillén are back as the studio team for CHSN, complete with a new set in left field from the newly rebranded Rate Field. Steve Stone and John Schriffen will be back in the broadcast booth. Because who wouldn't want to see what the Sox have in store as an encore for the worst season ever. Sign up for our White Sox Insider newsletterCHSN will air 69 regular-season games; any updates to the TV schedule will post on Veteran NHL announcer Rick Ball and analyst Darren Pang will handle the Hawks telecasts. For pregame and postgame shows, Pat Boyle, a Chicago sportscaster for two decades, will be joined by analyst Tony Granato, a former NHL player and coach, and studio contributor and backup analyst Caley Chelios, daughter of Hawks legend Chris Chelios. CHSN will air all 82 regular-season games — as well as the five preseason ones, which began Oct. 8 in Cleveland. Only five games in the 2024-25 season will air nationally: Nov. 7 at home against the Minnesota Timberwolves, Nov. 23 at home against the Memphis Grizzlies and April 6 at the Charlotte Hornets will be broadcast on NBA TV, and Nov. 20 matchup at the Milwaukee Bucks and Jan. 17 at the Hornets will be broadcast on ESPN. Adam Amin and Stacey King will call Bulls games for CHSN. The pregame, halftime and postgame shows will include host Jason Goff, Gill and sideline reporter and insider K.C. Johnson, a former Bulls beat reporter for the Tribune. Former Bull Will Perdue, who served as a studio analyst for NBCSCH, won't resume that role for CHSN. 'Bulls Countdown Live' will air before every regular-season game and 'Bulls Postgame Live' immediately following each game. Sign up for our Tribune Sports newsletter

Detroit-area's Dunham Hills Golf Club to undergo revision by world-class designer
Detroit-area's Dunham Hills Golf Club to undergo revision by world-class designer

USA Today

time2 hours ago

  • USA Today

Detroit-area's Dunham Hills Golf Club to undergo revision by world-class designer

Detroit-area's Dunham Hills Golf Club to undergo revision by world-class designer Golf fans in metro Detroit, get excited: A world-class name in golf course architecture is bringing his talents to southeast Michigan. Mike DeVries, based in Traverse City and best known in these parts for crafting Kingsley Club and Greywalls at Marquette Golf Club, is the designer tabbed for a project at Dunham Hills in Hartland, Michigan. The redesigned course, if all the money is raised, will be rebranded as Proving Ground Golf Club, a nod to Detroit's historic automotive industry (the new logo is a sports car with a flag in the back seat). It could open by 2027. The property was purchased in December 2024 by a group of investors who are "passionate, like-minded golfers," including Michigan Golf Hall of Famer Brian Cairns. DeVries' new routing was revealed May 31 after more than a year of planning. Proving Ground wants to offer something different, something rarely seen in golf clubs in America. The club will offer public play, but its grand vision will be modeled after clubs in the United Kingdom, where a robust annual season pass membership base takes a block of play in part to lower fees and hopefully take better care of the golf course. There will still be plenty of tee times available for the public. It's a setup used by the acclaimed Belvedere in Charlevoix, Michigan. "The plan was simple, start with great land and a top-tier architect," the club said in a statement. "With Dunham Hills and Mike DeVries we found both." "From scouting and acquiring the property, walking the land with Mike, and watching his sketches evolve into a world-class design, this journey has been nothing short of extraordinary. Mike's vision is now taking shape, and we couldn't be more excited about what's ahead." Dunham Hills is a tree-lined routing with up-and-back holes, allowing shorter walks between greens and tees, with plenty of movement in the land — a nod to its name. DeVries' style is to let the natural property determine the golf, and he has a good canvas to work with at the par-71, 6,758-yard course opened in 1967. Dunham Hills remains open for public play this season. DeVries' reimagined layout and routing is set at 6,859 yards from the tips playing as a par-70 layout. It has two par-5s and three par 3s on the front nine, including a short 137-yard sixth hole, and takes out the back-to-back par 5s on Nos. 12-13 and instead has a par-5 14th. "Really, when you start to look at a piece of property, I respond to what's inherently there," he recently told Michigan Golf Journal. "Asking, how do we build good, fun golf that's engaging for every level of player for that property, and not just try to drop a template in there, or this idea or that idea, and try to reproduce it. 'For me, it's sculpture with a 20,000-pound piece of equipment. To me, that's all part of the creative process and figuring out the right puzzle and how we solve that.' DeVries, now known worldwide for his course designs, has three other Michigan layouts to his name besides Kingsley (2001) and Greywalls (2005), each in west Michigan and well-regarded by golfers: Pilgrim's Run (Pierson), Diamond Springs (Hamilton) and the Mines (just outside Grand Rapids). Proving Ground would be the second high-end, newly constructed public 18-hole golf course in southeast Michigan, after a two-decade period without one. The Cardinal at St. John's opened in 2024. Marlowe Alter is an assistant sports editor at the Detroit Free Press and spraying golf aficionado. You can reach him by email: malter@

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store