Chipman double-homicide case delayed again as defence waits for disclosure of evidence
A case against a Chipman man charged with two counts of first-degree murder has been delayed for a third time because of a substantial amount of evidence that has yet to be shared with the defence.
Dates for a preliminary hearing were scheduled to be set on Monday, but defence lawyer Carley Parish said by telephone that she still hadn't received disclosure of evidence from the Crown.
Mark Elley was arrested in January and charged in the deaths of Robert Waugh, 47, and Victoria King, 23, both of the Fredericton area, whose bodies were discovered in a burnt-out SUV in Chipman in November.
Chipman RCMP responded Nov. 25 at around 8 a.m. to a report of two people inside a burning vehicle off Midland Road, about 60 kilometres northeast of Fredericton.
When officers arrived, they located the bodies of a man and woman inside a white Chevrolet Equinox "that had been consumed by fire."
After Elley's arrest in January, Cpl. Hans Ouellette, spokesperson for the New Brunswick RCMP, wouldn't say whether the accused and victims were known to each other, or whether the accused is known to police, citing the court case and continuing investigation.
He also didn't say at the time whether the victims were killed by the fire.
On Monday, Crown prosecutor Jennifer Cooper said there is "substantial disclosure" in the case, which takes a lot of time and effort to review.
She said there are 300 documents alone, "not pages but documents."
Cooper said the disclosure of evidence is "a very serious matter" and it's important that the vetting be done properly. She said in response to questions by Judge Lyne Raymond that it's unrealistic that the disclosure would be ready by the end of the week.
Raymond set the matter over until March 24, at which time the Crown is expected to give an indication of when that disclosure will be ready.
The setting of preliminary hearing dates were also delayed on Feb. 10 and Feb. 24, again because the defence didn't have the disclosure of evidence.
Parish also raised the issue that her client was arrested in January and still hasn't had a bail hearing.
Elley appeared in court on Monday by telephone and remains in custody.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
19 minutes ago
- CTV News
RCMP charge man, seize fentanyl and meth in central Alberta
An RCMP patch is seen on the shoulder of an assistant commissioner, in Surrey, B.C., on Friday, April 28, 2023. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Darryl Dyck RCMP have charged a 22-year-old central Alberta man with drug trafficking. The Wetaskiwin RCMP Crime Reduction Unit was patrolling when they saw a known male offender driving a Hyundai Venue on Tuesday. Officers stopped him after finding that he did not have a driver's licence. Mounties found about 27 grams of fentanyl and approximately 53 grams of methamphetamine as well as other items consistent with drug trafficking in the vehicle. RCMP charged a 22-year-old Mackwacis man with possession for the purpose of trafficking and possession of proceeds of crime. The man is to appear in Wetaskiwin court on Thursday. Another individual who was in the vehicle has two charges pending for possession for the purpose of trafficking.
Calgary Herald
an hour ago
- Calgary Herald
Edmonton police officer who repeatedly struck arrestee with baton found not guilty
An Edmonton police officer caught on video hitting a man with his baton has been acquitted of assault. Article content Jurors on Wednesday returned to the courtroom after nine hours of deliberation and found Const. Alexander Doduk not guilty of two counts of assault for his arrest of construction worker Justin LaFrance near the Edmonton courthouse on a snowy morning in 2019. Article content Article content Article content LaFrance claimed Doduk attacked him as he tried to talk to a man suspected of breaking a window, while Doduk said LaFrance resisted arrest, including by grabbing at his duty belt. Article content Article content The chaotic arrest — during which Doduk hit and punched LaFrance before striking him repeatedly with his baton — was captured on security cameras at the nearby Royal Alberta Museum. The cameras did not record sound, leading to competing claims from Crown and defence about what LaFrance and Doduk said before and during the arrest. Article content As a rule, jurors do not explain how they arrived at their verdict, but the outcome indicates they believed the Crown failed to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Doduk used excessive force. Article content Jurors did not hear other details about Doduk's career — including his role in the death of Steven Nguyen, an unarmed man who died after Doduk shot him four times in 2021. The shooting was investigated by the Alberta Serious Incident Response Team (ASIRT), which concluded there were grounds to believe Doduk committed a 'culpable homicide.' The Alberta Crown Prosecution Service, however, declined to proceed with charges, saying it could not prove Doduk's actions were 'unreasonable' under the Criminal Code's police use-of-force provisions. Article content Article content Article content The arrest at the centre of Doduk's trial happened Nov. 26, 2019. LaFrance was part of a crew renovating a building across the street from the Edmonton courthouse and told court he heard glass break during his morning site check. He walked out onto 97 Street, flagged down a passerby and asked if he had seen someone break a window. The passerby pointed to a man in dark clothing on the opposite street corner by the museum, LaFrance testified. Article content Article content LaFrance said he waved to Doduk as the officer drove by in his cruiser, and crossed 97 Street diagonally after Doduk flashed his lights to control traffic. He said he caught up with the alleged vandal and calmly asked him to stop until police arrived. Article content Doduk described a different scene. Driving by on his way to the courthouse, Doduk claimed he heard LaFrance screaming threats at the vandalism suspect, then saw him cross the busy road during rush hour. Doduk said he parked his cruiser and went after the two men, worried they would come to blows.
National Post
2 hours ago
- National Post
B.C. judge says man's ‘relatively modest' child porn collection doesn't merit jail time
A B.C. man who admitted to police he was aroused by child pornography found in his home but later denied sexual interest in children, will serve his sentence at home, partly due to the 'relatively modest size' of his stash — six images. Article content Such was the ruling from provincial court Judge Andrew Tam in Kelowna, who handed down a conditional sentence of two years less a day to Mark Keenan in a decision published this week. Article content Article content 'Although there is no strict mathematical relationship between the size of the collection and the length (or indeed type) of sentence, the size of a collection has often been held to be an aggravating factor, ' Tam wrote. Article content Article content 'It stands to reason, then, that a modest collection, while not a mitigating factor, could nevertheless distinguish it from other cases.' Article content Keenan, 54, pleaded guilty to one count each of possession of child pornography and distribution of the same, offences for which he was first arrested in September 2018 after someone alerted the National Centre for Missing and Exploited Children (NCMEC) about his account. Article content The RCMP obtained a search warrant and found the six images meeting the definition of child pornography on one of his devices. Article content Forensic investigations also uncovered communication between Keenan and other users, mostly adults but including one who identified as a 15-year-old boy, in which he discussed sexual activities with children and the exchange of images. Article content Article content Keenan insisted at his sentencing hearing in March that he had 'no sexual interest in children' and that he happened upon the images while searching for beach and sunset photos. Article content Article content So appalled at the sight of child pornography, Keenan, in both a statement to police upon his arrest and again at his hearing, maintained he found the images in September 2017 and was using them to run his own 'undercover sting' to catch pedophiles on Tumblr so he could get them banned. Article content Tam rejected the idea the offences were carried out 'for the public good' and noted Keenan, in his statement to police, provided 'the most damning evidence.' Article content When asked by officers if he was aroused by the images he replied, 'I mean, in a way, it's hard not to be.' Article content He first pointed to the messages, in which Keenan offered 'extensive and detailed' insight into his sexual interests with children. The judge called the exchanges 'unnecessarily graphic' for someone only trying to snag a predator and questioned why they went on long after ample evidence had been acquired.
