Prosecution rests case against Monroe County woman charged in fatal Swan Boat Club crash
Prosecutors rested their case Wednesday morning against a Monroe County woman accused of crashing her SUV into Swan Boat Club last year, killing two young siblings and injuring others attending a child's birthday party.
Twenty-seven witness testified since Monday, when the trial began for Marshella Chidester, 67, who is charged in the deaths of Zayn Phillips, 4, and his sister, Alanah Phillips, 8 and injuring others, some severely, in the April 20 crash.
The boat club is in Newport, about 30 miles south of Detroit.
Chidester is charged with two counts of second-degree murder, two counts of operating while intoxicated causing death and five counts of operating while intoxicated causing serious injury.
Her defense is expected to argue that a medical condition contributed to the crash, saying Chidester has seizures and neuropathy.
Prosecutors wrapped up their case after calling six witnesses Wednesday, including 14-year-old Edward Smothers, who suffered a broken leg and needed surgery and crutches. He testified that he attended the party with his aunt, Mariah Dodds, who gave emotional testimony in court Tuesday.
Roe Mundy, the phlebotomist who took Chidester's lab tests at the hospital just over three hours after the crash that day, also testified. Jurors saw video Tuesday from a Monroe County deputy's body-worn camera showing the test kit and blood draw at the hospital.
Under cross-examination, defense attorney Bill Colovos questioned why there was no doctor's name on a specific piece of paperwork. On redirect, Assistant Prosecutor Kenneth Laurain asked Mundy if she ever worked in a hospital not under the authority of a physician, to which she answered "no." She testified that she was not sure who the physician was in the emergency room that day because she was called down to the department to draw the blood and when she leaves, there is still paperwork being filled out.
The other remaining witnesses focused on Chidester's blood samples handled by the Michigan State Police crime lab in Lansing.
Tabitha Faust, a forensic scientist at the lab, testified the case "had a rush" and the samples were hand-delivered to prepare for alcohol testing right away. During her testimony, it was stated that Chidester's blood alcohol level was 0.18, with the legal limit being 0.08.
Law enforcement officials previously said Chidester had a blood alcohol level of 0.18, more than twice the legal limit to be considered legally drunk in Michigan, at the time of the crash. The charges read in court Monday accused her of being impaired by a combination of alcohol and Gabapentin, an anticonvulsant and nerve pain medication.
Colovos asked Faust: "Your testing is only as good as the subject matter delivered to you, correct?" To which, she answered "correct."
Samantha Beauchamp, a supervisor in the toxicology unit at the lab, testified that Chidester's blood sample contained 0.13 micrograms per milliliter of Gabapentin.
Contact Christina Hall: chall@freepress.com. Follow her on Twitter: @challreporter.
Support local journalism. Subscribe to the Free Press.
Submit a letter to the editor at freep.com/letters.
This article originally appeared on Detroit Free Press: Prosecution rests case against woman in fatal Swan Boat Club crash
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBS News
15 hours ago
- CBS News
Livonia police officer shoots armed man who was "behaving erratically"
Police in Livonia, Michigan, say an officer shot a man who they say was acting erratically and pointed a gun at the officer Friday afternoon. Authorities received a call at about 2:10 p.m. about a 31-year-old Livonia man with a gun near Middlebelt and Five Mile roads. The caller told police that the man was acting erratically. Responding officers made contact with the man, who pointed the gun at an officer. Livonia police say the officer fired his weapon, striking the man. He was taken to the hospital for treatment. His current condition is unknown. Police say the officer was not injured. Michigan State Police is investigating the shooting.
Yahoo
18 hours ago
- Yahoo
Oakland Co. sheriff's deputies found loaded weapons at high school graduation in Pontiac
Oakland County sheriff's deputies found multiple fully loaded weapons at a high school graduation in Pontiac on June 3 and believe suspects could have carried out a mass shooting at the event, Oakland County Sheriff Michael Bouchard said in a news conference Friday, June 6. Deputies "probably prevented a mass shooting," Bouchard said and are still searching for one suspect, Jamarion Hardiman, 20, of Pontiac. Deputies found multiple weapons around the United Wholesale Mortgage sports complex on South Boulevard where the Arts and Technology Academy of Pontiac graduation was being held. Sheriff's deputies were originally called out after reports of a brawl breaking out, but were told by an individual at the event that rumors of Snapchat threats about a possible shooting were circulating, according to Bouchard. As deputies started to investigate the individuals involved in the fight, they learned they had been seen placing packages under cars at the sports complex's parking lot, and found that those packages were weapons. The weapons found include what Bouchard described as an AR-style pistol and a Glock semi-automatic handgun. Both were loaded with 40-round magazines, Bouchard said. The guns were not registered. "Just those two weapons without changing magazines had 80 rounds of potential firepower shooting into a graduation," Bouchard said. "You can only imagine the outcome of that." One suspect, a 19-year-old Bouchard did not name, is in custody. Another, Hardiman, is still wanted. Neither were graduating students, but had ongoing disputes with others in the school community. Contact Lily Altavena: laltavena@ This article originally appeared on Detroit Free Press: Fully loaded weapons found at high school graduation in Pontiac
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
Witness in Jessica Bedford murder case: After gunshots I heard him say 'Die b----'
The Brief Local mother Jessica Bedford was last seen on Mother's Day of 2020 by her daughter. Police believe Keyvonte Clark fatally shot her in Detroit and moved the body before disposing of it. On Thursday at Clark's prelim, an ex-girlfriend took the stand with disturbing testimony. DETROIT (FOX 2) - Jessica Bedford was reported missing back in May of 2020. Now investigators says she was murdered. The suspect, Keyvonte Clark was in court Thursday and we want to warn you that the details are disturbing. The backstory Clark, 31, is accused of killing Bedford, a local mother whose last contact with her daughter was on Mother's Day of 2020 when she went missing. Bedford was 34. Prosecutors say Clark shot and killed Bedford at a home in the 12000 block of Cloverlawn Street in Detroit. He allegedly moved her body to another location, and it has not been recovered. Today the court heard testimony from Clark's former girlfriend. Prosecutor: "What do you hear him saying to Dre?" "That he was about to kill Jessica," said Clark's witness testified she thought she was pregnant with Clark's child and she and Jessica had been at Clark's home – when Clark's friend sexually assaulted her. She says she later told Clark over the phone about the sexual assault – evidently Clark blamed Jessica for allowing it to happen."I can hear him yelling, saying 'You let him come in here and rape my baby mama,'" the witness "What did you hear Jessica saying?" "She sounded confused," the witness said. "I believe I heard her say – 'What are you talking about?'"The testimony was graphic – the witness saying she didn't come forward because she was scared of Clark. The judge ordered the witness's voice be altered because there have been threats. Prosecutor: "What do you hear?" "Gunshots," she said. Prosecutor: "What do you hear Keyvonte saying?" "I hear him say that he just killed Jessica over and over," the witness said. "After I heard the gunshots on the phone I heard Dre say 'Die b---h.'"Prosecutor: "Did you ever see Jessica again? "No," she said. The witness testified Clark came and got her, drove her back to his home in Detroit – where a red couch had been removed from the living room. "It was being burned in the backyard," the witness said. Prosecutor: "What was the conversation?" "That Jessica's body was in the basement," she said. Prosecutor: "And did they talk about getting rid of the body?" "Yes," the ex-girlfriend said. The witness testifying Clark's dogs were in the basement – chewing on the body. Related: Detroit cold case - man accused of murdering woman reported missing in 2020 Prosecutor: "What did he say they were going to do?" "Burn it," she said. Jessica Bedford's body was never found and Michigan State Police arrested Clark in April of this year – nearly five years after her mother reported her missing. Clark's ex-girlfriend sais she was sworn to secrecy. Prosecutor: "What did he tell you?" "That I better not say anything," she said. The preliminary exam will continue in August. The Source Information for this story was taken from Thursday's preliminary exam and previous reports.
