Hong Kong judges doubt government to blame for lack of slavery law after sex offence case
Hong Kong's top judges have cast doubt on whether the government should be blamed for the lack of bespoke legislation penalising forced labour after a domestic helper failed to substantiate her complaint of sexual exploitation by her employer in two separate trials.
The Court of Final Appeal on Wednesday also suggested the Filipino worker's legal challenge would be unable to compel the authorities to enact specific laws targeting slavery even if she won the present case.
The helper, identified as CB, was behind
an initially successful bid for a judicial review that police failed to properly investigate her complaint against her employer, an elderly doctor from Britain, due to the absence of specific legislation against forced labour.
She claimed the doctor had repeatedly molested her and asked her to perform a series of sexual acts against her will over an eight-month span between September 2018 and April 2019.
But the Court of First Instance's ruling in 2022 was partially overturned by the Court of Appeal last year, with three judges of the appellate court finding insufficient basis to hold that the enactment of a bespoke offence was 'the only effective solution' to what the helper described as a systemic failure.
A renewed investigation conducted pursuant to the lower court's order reached the same conclusion that the helper was not a victim of forced labour.
The doctor, identified as Z, was initially jailed for 2½ years on two counts of indecent assault, before the decision was quashed on appeal and the defendant acquitted on all charges in the retrial. The worker also lost a subsequent civil claim against him.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South China Morning Post
10 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
Hongkongers warned not to download mobile game ‘promoting secessionist agenda'
Hong Kong police have warned residents against downloading a mobile game application advocating Hong Kong and Taiwanese independence or risk breaking national security laws. The force also said on Tuesday that action had been taken under the Beijing-imposed national security law to allow police to require the relevant electronic platforms to remove access to the game Reversed Front: Bonfire, which was developed by ESC Taiwan and released in April. Individuals who downloaded the app could be considered in possession of a seditious publication, contravening domestic security legislation, the Safeguarding National Security Ordinance, police said. It added that those who provided money or financial assistance to the game's developer, including making in-app purchases, with the intent to fund it acts of secession or subversion of state power, also risk committing an offence under the national security law. 'Reversed Front: Bonfire was released under the guise of a game with the aim of promoting secessionist agendas such as 'Taiwan independence' and 'Hong Kong independence', advocating armed revolution and the overthrow of the fundamental system of the People's Republic of China [PRC] established by the constitution of the People's Republic of China,' national security police said. 'It also has an intention to provoke hatred towards the central authorities and the government of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region.' Police added that anyone or any organisation that knowingly published the application, including sharing or recommending it online, would also risk contravening offences of inciting secession and subversion under the national security law, as well as seditious intention offences in the Safeguarding National Security Ordinance.
South China Morning Post
11 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
Hong Kong court convicts couple of child cruelty, murdering newborn son
A Hong Kong court has convicted a couple of murdering their newborn son after rejecting their assertions that the infant's head trauma and rib fractures could have been inflicted by his brother out of jealousy. A High Court jury comprising three men and four women returned a unanimous verdict on Tuesday to convict Imran Hossain, 32, and his wife Farzana Akter, 29, of murdering their seven-week-old baby, Iyman Hossain, in 2019. The unemployed couple was also found guilty of child cruelty for breaching their duty of care to the deceased. The trial heard the boy died in hospital six days after he became unresponsive and displayed abnormal eye movement in the family's subdivided flat in Sham Shui Po on August 24, 2019. Prosecutors said the defendants, both Hong Kong residents, failed to call emergency services that morning and only took the baby to hospital at least 90 minutes after he lost consciousness. The court heard the deceased was growing healthily in his last medical check-up at a clinic on August 8, 2019, but stopped gaining weight and displayed poor growth before he was admitted to hospital. An initial medical examination diagnosed Iyman with multiple thigh and rib fractures, with the child's right first rib found broken to a level of severity typically seen in a car crash or a fall from a great height. He was also found with bruises on his cheeks and forehead, scratches over a nostril and bloodstains on his nasal bridge.
South China Morning Post
16 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
Hong Kong warns residents about Los Angeles unrest as Trump deploys National Guard
Hong Kong authorities have urged residents to remain vigilant and prioritise safety when travelling to the United States due to ongoing immigration-related protests in Los Angeles. Some Hongkongers living in California's largest city criticised US President Donald Trump's decision to deploy the National Guard, stating that it would likely escalate the situation further. The US Immigration and Customs Enforcement's operation against illegal immigrants in Los Angeles on Friday triggered days of demonstrations by local residents, leading to clashes with law enforcement officers. Trump, who has made illegal immigration a prime focus of his presidency, ordered some 2,000 National Guard to Los Angeles during the weekend over the objections of Newsom and the city's mayor, Karen Bass, who have accused him of manufacturing a crisis. Late Monday, the US Pentagon ordered 700 members of the US Marine Corps to Los Angeles and an additional 2,000 National Guard members to quell the unrest. The extra contingent doubles the number of National Guard troops to more than 4,000. The Hong Kong government urged residents to attend to personal safety in light of protests across the country. 'The government reminds Hong Kong residents who are planning to travel to the United States, or are already there, to stay aware of the local situation, increase their vigilance, prioritise their safety, avoid crowded areas, and pay close attention to local announcements regarding the latest developments,' a spokesman said on Monday. 'Hesitant' Hongkongers worry Trump has shattered dreams of studying in US The Security Bureau's website was updated with the warning, saying protests had 'occurred across multiple cities including Los Angeles' since early June, resulting in 'violent clashes and injuries'. The government also reminded Hong Kong residents in the United States who required help to call a 24-hour hotline at (852) 1868, or reach out to the Immigration Department with its mobile app, among other means. Some Angeles-based Hongkongers defended the need for the protests. A 50-year-old university professor, who only gave his surname, Lam, said the scale of the social unrest was not even close to the Black Lives Matter movement of 2020 or the Rodney King protests of 1992, sparked by a court acquitting four police officers accused of beating an unarmed black man. 'The protests are very localised,' Lam said. 'A little fire with one or two [self-driving] Waymo cars set on fire.' Lam said protesters were expressing their anger at what Trump and the immigration authorities were doing. 'Many of them live with undocumented immigrants and have done so for years. They stand by them with compassion because they want to protect their neighbours and friends who have lived peacefully in the community for years,' he said. Protesters gather with signs and flags near a federal building in Santa Ana, California, following reports of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) raids on June 9, 2025. Photo: AFP Lam said he and some of his US-born colleagues had started to bring along their identity documents to avoid being mistakenly arrested. 'Even for us, because we do not look like a regular 'white person', we have started to carry a federal ID on top of our driving licence to show that we're actually citizens,' he said. 'There have been a lot of mistaken arrests; we just want to be safe.' A 29-year-old college lecturer from Hong Kong, surnamed Li, joined the protests as well as the rapid response networks to help defend immigrant workers against raids. 'While the mainstream media is demonising the protesters as 'violent rioters' defending 'criminals', what I saw instead were local community members looking to defend their families, friends and other communities from state violence,' Li said. He said he had seen rubber bullets and tear gas being fired amid the clashes. 'I do not feel safe with the federal government overriding state authority to deploy the National Guard in Los Angeles, which further exacerbates the state-sanctioned violence that is already heightening,' he said. Law, a 52-year-old Hongkonger who has lived in Los Angeles since 1991, expressed reservations about the deployment of the National Guard. 'I think it's borderline unconstitutional,' said Law, who works in marketing and lives in Santa Monica. 'The only consequence I can see with the arrival of the National Guard is that there may be an escalation, which is the opposite of the intention.'
