Gen Z is increasingly turning to ChatGPT for affordable on-demand therapy, but licensed therapists say there are dangers many aren't considering
Examples of people using ChatGPT for therapy have proliferated online, with some claiming that talking to a chatbot every day has helped them more than years of therapy. Licensed professionals say that while AI could be helpful in aiding work with a licensed therapist, there are countless pitfalls to using ChatGPT for therapy.
ChatGPT has turned into the perfect therapist for many people: It's an active 'listener' that digests private information. It appears to empathize with users, some would argue, as well as professionals can. Plus, it costs a fraction of the price compared to most human therapists. While many therapists will charge anywhere from up to $200—or even more—per one-hour session, you can have unlimited access to ChatGPT's most advanced models for $200 per month.
Yet, despite the positive anecdotes you can read online about using ChatGPT as a therapist, as well as the convenience of having a therapist that's accessible via almost any internet-enabled computer or phone at any time of day, therapists warn ChatGPT can't replace a licensed professional.
In a statement to Fortune, a spokesperson for ChatGPT-maker OpenAI said the LLM often suggests seeking professional advice to users who discuss topics like personal health. ChatGPT is a general-purpose technology that shouldn't serve as a substitute for professional advice, according to its terms of service, the spokesperson added.
On social media, anecdotes about the usefulness of AI therapy are plentiful. People report the algorithm is level-headed and provides soothing responses that are sensitive to the nuances of a person's private experiences.
In a viral post on Reddit, one user said ChatGPT has helped them 'more than 15 years of therapy.' The patient, whose identity could not be confirmed by Fortune, claimed that despite previous experience with inpatient and outpatient care, it was daily chats with OpenAI's LLM that best helped them address their mental health.
'I don't even know how to explain how much this has changed things for me. I feel seen. I feel supported. And I've made more progress in a few weeks than I did in literal years of traditional treatment,' the user wrote.
In a comment, another user got to the root of AI's advantages over traditional therapy: its convenience.
'I love ChatGPT as therapy. They don't project their problems onto me. They don't abuse their authority. They're open to talking to me at 11pm,' the user wrote.
Others on Reddit noted that even the most upgraded version of ChatGPT at $200 per month was a steal compared to the more than $200 per session for traditional therapy without insurance.
Alyssa Peterson, a licensed clinical social worker and CEO of MyWellBeing, said AI therapy has its drawbacks, but it may be helpful when used alongside traditional therapy. Using AI to help work on tools developed in therapy, such as battling negative self-talk, could be helpful for some, she said.
Using AI in conjunction with therapy can help a person diversify their approach to mental health, so they're not using the technology as their sole truth. Therein lies the rub: Relying too heavily on a chatbot in stressful situations could hurt people's ability to deal with problems on their own, Peterson said.
In acute cases of stress, being able to deal with and alleviate the problem without external help is healthy, Peterson added.
But AI can, in some cases, outperform licensed professionals with its compassionate responses, according to research from the University of Toronto Scarborough published in the journal Communications Psychology. Chatbots aren't affected by the 'compassion fatigue' that can hit even experienced professionals over time, the study claims. Despite its endurance, an AI chatbot may be unable to provide more than surface-level compassion, one of the study's co-authors noted.
AI responses also aren't always objective, licensed clinical social worker Malka Shaw told Fortune. Some users have developed emotional attachments to AI chatbots, which has raised concerns about safeguards, especially for underage users.
In the past, some AI algorithms have also provided misinformation or harmful information that reinforces stereotypes or hate. Shaw said because it's impossible to tell the biases that go into creating an LLM, it's potentially dangerous for impressionable users.
In Florida, the mother of 14-year-old Sewell Setzer sued Character.ai, an AI chatbot platform, for negligence, among other claims, after Setzer committed suicide following a conversation with a chatbot on the platform. Another lawsuit against Character.ai in Texas claimed a chatbot on the platform told a 17-year-old with autism to kill his parents.
A spokesperson for Character.ai declined to comment on pending litigation. The spokesperson said any chatbots labeled as 'psychologist,' 'therapist,' or 'doctor,' include language that warns users not to rely on the characters for any type of professional advice. The company has a separate version of its LLM for users under the age of 18, the spokesperson added, which includes protections to prevent discussions of self-harm and redirect users to helpful resources.
Another fear professionals have is that AI could be giving faulty diagnoses. Diagnosing mental health conditions is not an exact science; it is difficult to do, even for an AI, Shaw said. Many licensed professionals need to accrue years of experience to be able to accurately diagnose patients consistently, she told Fortune.
'It's very scary to use AI for diagnosis, because there's an art form and there's an intuition,' Shaw said. 'A robot can't have that same level of intuition.'
People have shifted away from googling their symptoms to using AI, said Vaile Wright, a licensed psychologist and senior director for the American Psychological Association's office of health care innovation. As demonstrated by the cases with Character.ai, the danger of disregarding common sense for the advice of technology is ever present, she said.
The APA wrote a letter to the Federal Trade Commission with concerns about companionship chatbots, especially in the case where a chatbot labels itself as a 'psychologist.' Representatives from the APA also met with two FTC commissioners in January to raise their concerns before they were fired by the Trump administration.
'They're not experts, and we know that generative AI has a tendency to conflate information and make things up when it doesn't know. So I think that, for us, is most certainly the number one concern,' Wright said.
While the options aren't yet available, it is possible that, in the future, AI could be used in a responsible way for therapy and even diagnoses, she said, especially for people who can't afford the high price tag of treatment. Still, such technology would need to be created or informed by licensed professionals.
'I do think that emerging technologies, if they are developed safely and responsibly and demonstrate that they're effective, could, I think, fill some of those gaps for individuals who just truly cannot afford therapy,' she said.
This story was originally featured on Fortune.com
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Associated Press
12 minutes ago
- Associated Press
Asian markets rise as US stock indexes near records amid easing trade tensions
Shares rose early Tuesday in Asia after U.S. stock indexes drifted closer to records, while oil prices extended gains. Beijing and Washington dialed back trade friction as the U.S. extended exemptions for tariffs on some Chinese goods, including solar manufacturing equipment, that U.S. industries rely on for their own production. The U.S. Trade Representative extended those exemptions, which were due to expire on May 31, by three months through Aug. 31. Still, China criticized the U.S. on Monday over moves it alleged harmed Chinese interests, including issuing AI chip export control guidelines, stopping the sale of chip design software to China, and planning to revoke Chinese student visas. Hong Kong's Hang Seng gained 1.1% to 23,417.39, while the Shanghai Composite index added 0.3% to 3,356.36. In Tokyo, the Nikkei 225 advanced 0.6% to 37,683.19. South Korean markets were closed for a snap presidential election triggered by the ouster of Yoon Suk Yeol, a conservative who now faces an explosive trial on rebellion charges over his short-lived imposition of martial law in December. Australia's S&P/ASX 200 was up 0.7% to 8,475.50. In Taiwan, the Taiex gained 1.4%. On Monday, U.S. stock indexes drifted closer to their records following a stellar May, Wall Street's best month since 2023. The S&P 500 rose 0.4% to 5,935.94 after erasing an early loss from the morning. The Dow Jones Industrial Average added 0.1% to 42,305.48. The Nasdaq composite climbed 0.7% to 19,242.61. Indexes had fallen close to 1% in the morning following some discouraging updates on U.S. manufacturing. President Donald Trump has been warning that U.S. businesses and households could feel some pain as he tries to use tariffs to bring more manufacturing jobs back to the country, and their on-and-off rollout has created lots of uncertainty. But stocks rallied back as the day progressed. Nvidia climbed 1.7%, and Meta Platforms rose 3.6%, for example. Oil prices have gained as attacks by Ukraine in Russia raise uncertainty about the flow of oil and gas around the world. Early Tuesday, U.S. benchmark crude oil was up 62 cents at $63.14 per barrel. Brent crude, the international standard, picked up 57 cents to $65.19 per barrel. Markets took in stride fresh salvos between the world's two largest economies, just a few weeks after the United States and China had agreed to pause many of their tariffs that had threatened to drag the economy into a recession. That followed President Donald Trump's accusation at the end of last week, where he said China was not living up to its end of the agreement that paused their tariffs against each other. Trump on Friday told Pennsylvania steelworkers he's doubling the tariff on steel imports to 50% to protect their industry, a dramatic increase that could further push up prices for a metal used to make housing, autos and other goods. That helped stocks of U.S. steelmakers climb. Nucor jumped 10.1%, and Steel Dynamics rallied 10.3%. On the losing side of Wall Street were automakers and other heavy users of steel and aluminum. Ford fell 3.9%, and General Motors reversed by 3.9%. Lyra Therapeutics soared nearly 311% for one of the market's biggest gains after reporting positive late-stage trial results of an implant to treat chronic sinus inflammation in some patients. In the bond market, Treasury yields rose as worries continue about how much debt the U.S. government will pile on due to plans to cut taxes and increase the deficit. The yield on the 10-year Treasury climbed to 4.44% from 4.41% late Friday and from just 4.01% roughly two months ago. That's a notable move for the bond market. Besides making it more expensive for U.S. households and businesses to borrow money, such increases in Treasury yields can deter investors from paying high prices for stocks and other investments. Yields had dipped briefly in the morning, before rallying back, following the updates on manufacturing, which suggested that effects of Trump's tariffs are taking root in the economy. A report from S&P Global on manufacturing came in better than expected, though uncertainty caused by tariffs has worries high about supplier delays and rising prices. Also early Tuesday, the dollar rose to 143.10 Japanese yen from 142.71 yen. The euro slipped to $1.1438 from $1.1443. ___ AP Business Writers Stan Choe and Matt Ott contributed.
CBS News
12 minutes ago
- CBS News
Why are car insurance rates up in Maryland?
Why are car insurance rates up in Maryland? Why are car insurance rates up in Maryland? Why are car insurance rates up in Maryland? One thing everyone is noticing these days is rising costs, and that includes your car insurance. Viewers have asked WJZ why their auto insurance rates are increasing in Maryland. WJZ Anchor Rick Ritter tracked down the answer for this segment of Question Everything. Why is car insurance so expensive? Rick Ritter sat down with Marie Grant, who is Maryland's insurance commissioner. Marie Grant: "Typically in urban environments, we do see higher rates of auto insurance based on experience on what happens to a car in a city. Grant: "What we're seeing here in Maryland and what consumers are feeling are, unfortunately, national trends that consumers in other states are feeling, as well." Data released this year from Insurify shows car insurance costs surged nationally by 15% in 2024. Maryland drivers pay the most for car insurance, according to the website. On average, Marylanders are paying more than $4,000 a year, which is a 53% increase from 2023. Grant: "Maryland, historically, has been in the top quarter of states for auto insurance rates, and that's due in part to the nature of our state." "We tend to drive a lot, with longer commuting distances and a lot of congestion on roads. With pretty heavy traffic and accident rates higher than other states, it all contributes." While congestion and traffic-related incidents play a role, high repair costs are also to blame. AAA A found that today's advanced technology in cars can cost twice as much to repair, and now the threat of tariffs could complicate things even more. Grant: "During the pandemic, costs went down, folks weren't driving as much, and there weren't as many accidents. As Marylanders got back on the road, as well as inflation, the cost of cars then increased." Rick Ritter: "With so much talk about the escalating trade war and the president's tariffs, will it help contribute to rising car insurance rates?" Grant: "Unfortunately, the answer is yes. We haven't seen evidence of that with current rate filings, but if you asked me a month ago without tariffs on the horizon, I would've said trends are looking positive." Climate and crime can be contributing factors to higher costs of insurance, as well. Maryland has seen stolen vehicle claims surge over the last few years, according to the National Insurance Crime Bureau. If you live in an area with more frequent severe weather, like flooding or wildfires, it can impact your premiums, too. What can Marylanders do to save? Grant says to shop around for several insurers. Most think two or three, but five to 10 is what's recommended. Search for discounts, like safety features or bundling policies, which can help keep costs down. Consider a telematics program that monitors how safe you're driving. Then can bring down rates for you, as well. When in doubt, the insurance commissioner's office lines are always open. The office receives dozens of calls daily from Marylanders inquiring about their rates. "I love hearing from Marylanders. Consumers should definitely reach out to us," Grant said. "Fresh eyes never hurt, so we do want to make sure we are asking tough questions of our insurers to make sure they are putting their best foot forward, and that's what we do." Car insurance adds to a budget From the escalating trade war to inflation, it feels like the cost of everything is going up these days. "It's horrible, from car insurance to groceries," a Baltimore resident said. "Everything feels so expensive," said Yaniv Ezra, an Uber driver and student in the city. "I'm a DoorDash and Uber Eats driver, and you can see that barely anyone is buying anything." The rising prices for utilities, food, and gas, mixed in with skyrocketing car insurance, make things tough. "It's very high," Ezra said. "I'm paying $200 a month now just because I moved to the city."
CBS News
16 minutes ago
- CBS News
San Francisco Marina District close to having new transitional-housing facility
A recovery housing facility proposed in San Francisco's Marina District is closer to moving one step closer to final approval. It's a part of the mayor's plans to open hundreds of new beds for homeless people struggling with addiction. Steve Adami spent two decades in and out of prison, struggling to escape a vicious cycle of drug addiction and crime. Looking at a California Corrections picture of himself, he reflected on how far he has come in his journey. "It's someone I don't recognize anymore. It was definitely somebody who needed a lot of help and support to get his life together, and that's what I got," said Adami. Tackling San Francisco's drug and homelessness crisis is now Adami's mission as executive director of The Salvation Army's The Way Out program. "Areas of the city have been overrun by public drug use, open-air drug markets and crime. I don't want that model in my neighborhood either. But that's not the model we're proposing at the Marina Inn," said Adami. The recovery housing facility, providing 68 beds at Octavia and Lombard Street in the Marina District, will be operated by The Salvation Army in partnership with the city's Department of Public Health. It's an abstinence-based, two-year transitional housing program for people who have already completed long-term drug treatment "This model program has not been the type of program San Francisco has used in the past," said Adami. Everyone is required to work, save money and get drug tested. "Sadly, many of the residents of this faculty will relapse. Statistics just show that's the case. When they do, they're now in our neighborhood," said San Francisco resident Maurice Fitzgerald, who lives in the Marina District. While many residents believe drug-free transitional housing can help clean up city streets and even help nearby businesses, others like Fitzgerald say they're concerned about relapses and participants who have criminal backgrounds. "We have concerns this will increase car break-ins and that desperate drug addicts will do whatever they need to do to find money to get their fix," said Fitzgerald. Adami and other city officials said sex offenders, arsonists, and people who have committed crimes against children won't be allowed. Garrett Collard is a resident at a similar recovery housing program. He said he would be back on the streets if it weren't for the Salvation Army's pilot program. "You're just right back where you started. You go six months and are clean, but if you have nowhere else to go or stay in another program or go to a sober living environment, you're back on the streets," said Collard. Adami points to participants like Collard and to recovering addicts like himself as reasons to support the city's Break the Cycle initiative, aiming to add hundreds of new treatment and recovery beds across the city. "The current administration and the Department of Public Health and Department of Homelessness are implementing new abstinence-based strategies because they're proven to be effective," said Adami. It's programs like this that are giving Adami hope others can follow in his footsteps too. The city has announced plans to open nearly 300 treatment and interim housing beds at five sites across the city by the end of summer. It's part of the mayor's Break the Cycle initiative to add 1,500 beds citywide for homeless people and those struggling with mental illness and addiction.
