Real question is why Stefanson and ministers put reputations on line for Sio Silica
Opinion
As remarkable as ethics commissioner Jeffrey Schnoor's report into the Sio Silica scandal is — and remarkable is a good word for it — it was unable to answer a fundamental question.
Why would a former premier and two senior former cabinet ministers put their personal and professional reputations at risk to issue a licence for a questionable silica mining proposal in the days after they were defeated in the 2023 election?
The fact that Schnoor could not fully explain 'why' is not a criticism of his report.
MIKAELA MACKENZIE / FREE PRESS FILES
Former Manitoba premier Heather Stefanson, left, with former finance minister Cliff Cullen, were found guilty of breaching ethics law by ethics commissioner Jeffrey Schnoor's report into the Sio Silica scandal.
MIKAELA MACKENZIE / FREE PRESS FILES
Former Manitoba premier Heather Stefanson, left, with former finance minister Cliff Cullen, were found guilty of breaching ethics law by ethics commissioner Jeffrey Schnoor's report into the Sio Silica scandal.
History shows that politicians caught engaging in ethical transgressions rarely face anything stiffer than a good tongue-lashing. In finding former premier Heather Stefanson, former deputy premier Cliff Cullen and former economic development minister Jeff Wharton guilty of breaching ethics law — and recommending fines for each politician — Schnoor has flipped that script in dramatic fashion.
In the days following the October 2023 election, Schnoor found that Stefanson, Cullen and Wharton went to extraordinary lengths to issue an environmental licence to Sio Silica, an Alberta-based company that wanted to mine silica sand in Vivian, just east of Winnipeg. The project involved unproven technology, and had triggered significant concern among environmental lobbies and area residents.
These efforts took place during the so-called 'caretaker' period, in which an outgoing government is prohibited from making any government decision before a new government takes over. Schnoor was resolute that Stefanson, Cullen and Wharton made a variety of attempts to ram through a licence during the caretaker period.
The report detailed how, working together and apart, the Tory trio tried to bully two other cabinet ministers into issuing a licence. They also tried to influence bureaucrats into licensing the mine without a ministerial directive.
All of these efforts were unsuccessful as a licence was not issued and the new government headed by Premier Wab Kinew quickly declared that he would say 'no to Sio.'
Stefanson argued in her submissions to Schnoor that because no licence was issued during the caretaker period, there was no breach of ethics law. Schnoor's report says the breach was committed in the effort to issue a licence in the days following the election loss.
'The caretaker convention stands at the very core of our democracy,' Schnoor wrote in a release accompanying his report.
'The legitimacy of a government depends on the support of the electorate, expressed in elections. A government that loses an election has lost the confidence of the people and has lost the legitimacy to do anything beyond maintaining the status quo until the new government can take office. The exercise of power by an outgoing government to make significant decisions except in the most exceptional circumstances is a serious affront to our democratic institutions and to voters.'
The price for this affront to democracy may seem, at first blush, to be insignificant. The ethics commissioner recommended Stefanson be fined $18,000 for her role. Cullen faces a $12,000 fine and Wharton, the only one of the three who still has a seat in the Manitoba legislature, faces at $10,000 fine.
RUTH BONNEVILLE / FREE PRESS FILES
Former Manitoba premier Heather Stefanson, left, and former economic development minister Jeff Wharton, pictured in 2022.
RUTH BONNEVILLE / FREE PRESS FILES
Former Manitoba premier Heather Stefanson, left, and former economic development minister Jeff Wharton, pictured in 2022.
Stefanson was fined the most because she was the head of the PC government at the time and thus, 'has a higher leadership responsibility that she failed to meet,' Schnoor wrote.
Wharton, on the other hand, got the smallest fine in part because he was the only one of the Tory trio who offered to apologize for his role in this scandal.
All of which brings us back to the pressing question of 'why' these three veteran politicians would engage in such clearly unethical behaviour.
Schnoor made it clear he did not find evidence that any of the three Tories acted for personal benefit. If there was no effort to line their own pockets, then what?
One might imagine that this was just a simple matter of them trying to help political friends in the private sector. When you dig into Sio Silica's network, you quickly find it has a strong Tory flavour.
Tuesdays
A weekly look at politics close to home and around the world.
The Tory trio said they continued to pursue a licence because they believed the project had enormous economic value and that it could become a major part of the PC party's economic legacy from the seven years it was in government.
Not one of those explanations comes even remotely close to addressing why they did what they did. Unfortunately, now that Schnoor's work is done, it appears we may never know the real motivations at work.
The bigger concern for the current iteration of the PC party is that this scandal may evolve into a millstone with some staying power.
Consider that the fines recommended by Schnoor have to be confirmed by a vote in the legislature. That means new Tory Leader Obby Khan and his 19 MLAs will have to vote for the fines — and thereby acknowledge that what the trio did was wrong — or vote against and suffer endless taunts by the Kinew government.
It appears one way or the other, Sio Silica will be a political gift for the NDP that will keep on giving for years to come.
dan.lett@freepress.mb.ca
Dan LettColumnist
Dan Lett is a columnist for the Free Press, providing opinion and commentary on politics in Winnipeg and beyond. Born and raised in Toronto, Dan joined the Free Press in 1986. Read more about Dan.
Dan's columns are built on facts and reactions, but offer his personal views through arguments and analysis. The Free Press' editing team reviews Dan's columns before they are posted online or published in print — part of the our tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates.
Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber.
Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
3 hours ago
- CBC
Dead woman's police statement not admissible in trial of alleged serial rapist
The evidence of a Calgary woman who told police she'd been kidnapped, drugged and sexually assaulted by an alleged serial rapist can not be considered at his trial because she died in tragic circumstances and can't be cross-examined. Richard Mantha is on trial, facing 20 charges related to allegations he sexually assaulted seven women, most of whom were vulnerable sex-trade workers at the time. One of those women, whom CBC News is calling LM in order to comply with a publication ban, died in a tragic accident in December. CBC News is not publishing details of her death because they would identify the woman, whose identity remains protected by a publication ban. On Friday, Justice Judith Shriar ruled the alleged victim's statement to police is not admissible because of concerns over its reliability. LM told police she'd spoken with other women on the street about the case. Because of her death, defence lawyer Justin Dean wouldn't get the chance to question her about the unsworn statement. Last month, prosecutor Dominique Mathurin played a video-taped statement LM gave to police, who were investigating Mantha at the time. In the video, LM told Staff Sgt. Shelby Stewart that, in April 2022, she was dumped on the side of the road after escaping an RV inside a quonset hut east of the city. 'The second girl' She was picked up by an RCMP officer who told LM that she was "the second girl that happened to" in the last week. The officer did not take the woman to a detachment for a statement. Instead, he dropped her off at a CTrain station in Calgary. About a year later, Mantha was being investigated by Calgary police and, in the course of that investigation, Stewart learned of LM's interaction with the RCMP. LM told Stewart that a man, whom the Crown alleges was Mantha, picked her up and offered her a ride to a CTrain station. It was raining and LM said yes. The man gave LM a Sprite, which she told police caused her to black out. LM fought off attacker LM told the officer that she woke up in an RV naked, except for her bra. She said she fought the man off and threatened to stab him. LM said she found her knife and demanded he drive her back to where he'd picked her up. As they left the RV, LM said she realized the vehicle was inside a quonset. Court has already heard evidence that Mantha was living in an RV inside a quonset on a property east of the city near Langdon. Once on the road, LM said the man shoved her out of the truck and left her on the side of the road. When asked to point out the location of the quonset on a map, LM identified Mantha's rental property as the place she'd been taken. The case is back for trial continuation in July.
CBC
3 hours ago
- CBC
Crown stays cold case murder charges after identifying 'insurmountable' issue with evidence
A Calgary man accused of killing two people nearly 30 years ago saw his murder charges dropped on Friday due to what the Crown described as "a significant issue with the evidence." Stuart Douglass MacGregor, 55, was facing two counts of first-degree murder for the killings of Barry Christian Buchart, 26, and Trevor Thomas Deakins, 25, who were fatally shot in 1994. Defence lawyers Rebecca Snukal and Michael Bates have been in pre-trial hearings dealing with the admissibility of certain evidence leading up to the trial which was set to take place in November. On Friday, Snukal confirmed she'd received a letter from the Crown announcing the charges had been stayed. "Our client has always maintained his innocence in relation to these charges and is extremely relieved and grateful to return home to his family," wrote Snukal and Bates in a brief statement. Snukal confirmed Stuart will be released from custody later today after being held at the Calgary Remand Centre since his arrest in 2023. Evidence issue 'insurmountable' A spokesperson for the Alberta Crown Prosecution Service also issued a statement, saying that prosecutors continually assess their cases to "ensure all aspects of the evidence are carefully considered at every stage of a prosecution." "During the prosecution, the Crown prosecutor encountered a significant issue with the evidence," reads the statement. "The Crown prosecutor thoroughly explored all paths to trial so the allegations could be determined on the merits, however, the evidentiary issue was ultimately determined to be insurmountable." On July 11, 1994, two men broke into a home in Calgary's southeast, where Buchart and Deakins were killed. Both victims were shot point-blank. The investigation into the killings went cold for decades before police reopened the investigation in 2019. Using genetic genealogical investigative techniques, police were able to track down family members of the suspects, which ultimately led them to arrest two men. Leonard Brian Cochrane was charged in 2020. MacGregor was arrested and charged in 2023, the same year a Calgary judge convicted Cochrane of murder. Cochrane is currently serving a life sentence.
CTV News
3 hours ago
- CTV News
School patrollers celebrated at end of year event
Thousands of AMA school patrollers gathered at Rundle Park on Friday to celebrate another year of keeping students safe on the roads. CTV News Edmonton's Amanda Anderson was there.
