US arbitrator orders Zia Chishti to pay $9.1mn to TRG International
In a big blow to former TRG Pakistan CEO Zia Chishti, a US arbitrator has ordered him to pay $9.1 million (Rs2.5 billion) to TRG International, Business Recorder learnt on Tuesday.
The arbitration was regarding the legality of share pledges of TRG Pakistan that were central to Zia Chishti's borrowing Rs2.5 billion from JS Bank to buy additional shares of TRG Pakistan. TRG had alleged that it was part of a plan by him and the JS Group to illegally take over TRG Pakistan as a first step towards taking control of TRG's international assets.
TRG Pakistan shared the development in a notice to the Pakistan Stock Exchange (PSX) on Tuesday.
'The company has been informed by its affiliate The Resource Group International Limited ('TRGIL') that a final award has been issued by a US arbitrator in respect of the arbitration initiated by TRGIL against Mr Chishti challenging the pledging by Mr Chishti of company shares owned by him.
'On January 27, 2025, the arbitrator had issued a partial final award which ruled, inter alia, that shares pledged by Mr Chishti, primarily to JS Bank as security for a loan, were in breach of contractual obligations of Mr Chishti.
'On April 22, 2025, the arbitrator issued a final award that, in addition to the remedies contained in the partial final award dated January 27, 2025, ordered Mr Chishti to pay TRGIL a sum of US$ 9.1 million,' the notice read.
Zia Chishti 'resigns as CEO, director at TRG Pakistan'
TRG contended that Chishti was not allowed to pledge the shares given his contractual undertakings, and had asked the arbitrator to order him to remove the pledge.
In January 2025, the US arbitrator ruled in favour of TRG, and declared that Chishti had breached his contractual obligations by making the pledge. The court then ordered him to remove the pledge.
In April 2025, the arbitrator has ordered Chishti to pay $9.1 million (or PKR 2.5 billion) to TRG.
As questions are raised about the ability of former TRG Pakistan CEO to pay such a significant amount to TRG, the fate of Rs2.5 billion loan from JS Bank to Chishti remains unclear.
In recent filings with the Sindh High Court, JS Bank has declared the loan to be in default.
TRG has had stay orders in place from the Sindh High Court since 2023 preventing the exercise of security on the loan.
Zia Chishti, The Telegraph settle libel suit over reporting of ex-employee's 'grooming' allegations
It is unclear whether the loan continues to be carried on JS Bank's books given the default and the stay orders on collateral.
During the most recent quarter ended March 31, 2025, JS Bank reported profit before tax of Rs2.7 billion, which could get wiped out with a write-off of this loan
Market analysts have questioned the nature of the loan made in 2022, as it represented a huge exposure for JS Bank for a loan made to a single person. The loan was renewed in November 2024 despite the stay orders on the share pledge security were in place, only to be in default two months later.
In the bourse notice on Tuesday, TRG Pakistan also shared that it had received copies of certified orders regarding the adjudication of Writ Petitions 3383 and 3395 of 2025 filed in the Lahore High Court and 693 of 2025 filed in the Islamabad High Court by Zia Chishti.
SHC restrains Zia Chishti, wife from transferring shares of TRG Pakistan: notice
In both writ petitions, Chishti had sought to suspend ad-interim orders of the Civil Judge in Lahore and Islamabad dated December 2, 2024, December 10, 2024, and February 11, 2025, respectively, that restrained the company in respect of its board elections.
'On April 8, 2025 the Honorable Islamabad High Court judge was pleased to dismiss Writ Petition 693 of 2025 and on April 11, 2025, the Honorable Lahore High Court judge was pleased to dismiss Writ Petitions 3383 and 3395 of 2025,' the notice read.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
an hour ago
- Express Tribune
Govt slaps Rs415b taxes to raise Rs2.2tr
Listen to article The government on Tuesday proposed over Rs415 billion worth of new tax measures to extract an additional Rs2.2 trillion from the sluggish economy by taxing digital earnings, online services, solar panels, and cars used by the middle class. It also proposed drastic reductions in import taxes to open the economy to foreign competition. The Finance Bill 2025-26, kept secret from the media by cancelling the press briefing, shows the government favouring a 19th-century-style economy by giving some relief on property purchases while taxing 21st-century digital platforms. The bill also proposes banning economic transactions of ineligible persons, including the purchase of property, cars, and investments in securities where assets don't match the purchase. Despite promoting green energy, the government has imposed an 18% sales tax on imported solar panels, raised sales tax on 850cc cars from 12.5% to 18%, and introduced a Rs2.5 per litre carbon levy. A new levy has also been imposed on conventional cars to subsidise electric vehicles. Through the finance bill, the government also amended various non-tax laws and introduced two new ones: the Digital Presence Proceeds Act, 2025, and the New Energy Vehicles Adoption Levy Act, 2025. A senior tax official said the government proposed over Rs415 billion in tax measures: Rs292 billion from Federal Board of Revenue (FBR)-related steps, Rs111 billion by imposing a Rs2.5 per litre carbon levy on petrol, diesel, and furnace oil, and Rs9 billion from the levy on conventional cars. These are part of the plan to collect Rs2.2 trillion in additional taxes to hit the Rs14.13 trillion revenue target for FY26. The petroleum and carbon levy target is set at Rs1.47 trillion. Going after the youth In a highly unusual move, the government aims to collect Rs64 billion by taxing digital and online platforms and courier services. The move appears to protect non-taxpaying retail businesses. Digitally delivered services are defined as those delivered via the internet or electronic networks with minimal or no human input. These include music, video and audio streaming, cloud services, software, telemedicine, e-learning, online banking, architectural design, research and consultancy, digital accounting, and other online facilities. E-commerce is defined as buying or selling goods and services over computer networks via websites, apps, or platforms that allow digital ordering, including via phones, tablets, or automated systems. A new law introduces a Digital Presence Proceeds Tax. It applies to all foreign vendors with a significant digital presence in Pakistan and will charge a 5% tax on proceeds from digitally ordered goods and services, whether delivered digitally or physically. These vendors must provide client-wise information for any local or foreign vendors whose advertisements are relayed in Pakistan. Banks must deduct a 5% tax. For local platforms, a 1% tax will be charged if the supply amount is up to Rs10,000, 2% if up to Rs25,000, and 0.25% if above Rs25,000. Cash on delivery by courier services is now taxed: 0.25% on electronics, 2% on clothing, and 1% on other goods. Online marketplaces allowing unregistered vendors to sell will be fined Rs1 million if those vendors are not registered under the Sales Tax Act or Income Tax Ordinance. Banks, payment gateways, or couriers failing to deduct or pay the tax under Section 160 will be fined 100% of the tax involved. The debt servicing surcharge, currently capped at 10% of electricity costs, will be relaxed to help retire Rs1.3 trillion in circular debt. Income tax There was confusion over the withholding tax on cash withdrawals. The finance minister announced a rise from 0.6% to 1%, but Deputy PM Ishaq Dar later set it at 0.8%. Withholding tax on service provision (excluding IT services) rises from 4% to 6%. Non-specified services are taxed at 15%, and sportsmen now pay 15%, up from 10%. Tax on profit on debt will rise from 15% to 20%. Dividend tax goes up to 25%, and 15% on mutual fund dividends. For the first time, a 5% tax will apply to pensioners with annual pensions of Rs10 million or more. Some relief is given to lower and upper-middle-income salaried groups. The tax rate for incomes up to Rs1.2 million is cut from 5% to 2.5%. It was originally proposed at 1%, but the rate was raised due to a 10% salary increase for government employees. For annual incomes up to Rs2.2 million, the rate drops from 15% to 11%. For Rs3.2 million earners, the rate is reduced from 25% to 23%. There's no relief for those earning over Rs4.1 million. However, the top slab surcharge has been reduced from 10% to 9% to curb "brain drain". Super tax for individuals earning Rs200-500 million is reduced by 0.5 percentage points. Tax exemption on electricity bills in former FATA areas continues for another year. A flat 4% fair market value tax applies on rental income from commercial properties. Buyers from unregistered vendors will be penalised: 10% of purchase-related expenses will be disallowed. If payment is received in cash for a single invoice exceeding Rs200,000, 50% of purchase-related expenses will be disallowed. All entities in a group must derive income under the Normal Tax Regime to claim group relief. The income tax exemption for Special Economic Zones (SEZs) and Special Technology Zones (STZs) developers and entities is limited to 2035 or ten years from the start of exemption, whichever is earlier. Real estate Advance tax on property sale or transfer is raised: from 3% to 4.5% for properties worth Rs50 million, from 3% to 5% for Rs100 million, and from 4% to 5.5% for properties over Rs100 million. Purchase tax rates are reduced: from 3% to 1.5%, from 3.5% to 2%, and from 4% to 2.5%, depending on property value. Economic transactions by ineligible persons are banned if the purchase exceeds 130% of their declared total assets. Custom duty The government proposes new tariff slabs of 5%, 10%, and 15%, replacing the existing 3%, 11%, and 16% slabs. The zero-duty slab expands from 2,201 to 3,117 tariff lines. Duty is proposed on 479 tariff lines that were previously exempt. Additional customs duties of 2% on slabs of 0%, 5%, and 10% (covering 4,383 lines) are abolished. Additional duties on 518 lines under the 15% slab are cut from 4% to 2%. Duties on 2,166 lines under the 20% slab drop from 6% to 4%. On 468 lines under slabs above 20%, the rate is cut from 7% to 6%. Regulatory duties are removed on some goods, and reduced for 595 PCT codes. The maximum regulatory duty rate falls from 90% to 50%. Sales tax An 18% sales tax based on market price has been imposed on imported pet food (including food for dogs and cats) in retail packaging, as well as on imported coffee, chocolates, and cereal bars in retail packaging. The government has introduced a 10% sales tax on the supply and import of plant and machinery by industrial units located in the erstwhile FATA/PATA regions. An 18% sales tax has been imposed on the import and supply of solar panels, whether or not assembled in modules or made up into panels. These were previously exempt from sales tax. The government has increased the sales tax on small cars from 12.5% to 18%. The current reduced rate of 10% on local supplies of vermicelli and sheer malls has also been raised to 18%. The government has doubled the sales tax rate to 2% on sales made through e-commerce and online marketplaces. The tax will be collected by banks, financial institutions, exchange companies, and payment gateways for digital payments, while couriers will handle tax collection for cash-on-delivery transactions.
Business Recorder
3 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Budget FY2025-26: Pakistan govt proposes ‘Carbon Levy' on petrol, diesel
Pakistan government imposed a new tax on the sale of petrol, diesel and furnace oil namely 'Carbon Levy' at Rs2.5 per litre to be collected in upcoming fiscal year 2025-26 that will be raised to Rs5 per litre in the financial year 2026-27, according to budget documents on Tuesday. The new tax will be collected apparently with effect from July 1, 2025 in addition to the existing expensive petroleum development levy (PDL) at Rs78 per litre on petrol and Rs77 per litre on diesel, making the petroleum products further costlier. Budget 2025-26: Pakistan targets 4.2% growth as Aurangzeb presents proposals 'for a competitive economy' While announcing the budget for 23025-26, Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb also announced to collect Petroleum Levy on the sale of furnace oil (FO) at the rate to be notified by Federal Government from time to time. While speaking at the National Assembly's floor, Aurangzeb said that the Carbon Levy was being imposed to discourage more use of fossil fuel and to mobilise resources for climate change and green energy programmes. Topline Securities commented 'in line with commitment to IMF, the government has imposed PDL on furnace oil; however, the rate is not disclosed yet'. Recent reports suggest the government would also surge PDL on the petroleum products to Rs100 per litre in the upcoming fiscal year (FY26) in line with s new agreements with International Monetary Fund (IMF) under the ongoing 37-month long $7 billion Extended Fund Facility (EFF). Key highlights of Pakistan budget for 2025-26 To recall, the diesel is being sold at Rs254.64 per litre and petrol at Rs253.63 per litre in Pakistan with effect from June 1. 2025. The government revises the petroleum products prices twice a month in line with global oil pricing trends.
Express Tribune
4 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Excess power capacity
Listen to article Pakistan's power sector is mired in a tragic paradox, with citizens enduring relentless load-shedding and unaffordable bills. The nation pays Rs2.5 to Rs2.8 trillion annually to power plants that don't generate a single unit of electricity. This astronomical sum — equivalent to roughly 3% of GDP — epitomises a system where financial engineering trumps public interest, burdening consumers with costs for "capacity" that remains perpetually idle. The roots of this scandal lie in flawed power purchase agreements (PPAs) signed with independent power producers (IPPs). These contracts guarantee fixed "capacity payments" regardless of actual electricity generation, transferring all operational and market risks to the public. As Pakistan's installed capacity grew to over 46,000 MW — driven significantly by over 2,800 MW added through net metering — the utilisation of existing plants plummeted. Thermal power, though still dominant at 55.7% of the mix, remains underused in the winter due to transmission constraints and seasonal demand fluctuations — winter demand is about 12,000 MW, compared to summer demand of about 30,000 MW. Substandard transmission lines have been blamed for the failure to bring several new cost-effective plants online, notably Port Qasim, China Power and Lucky Electric. Instead, the government continues to rely on older, less efficient plants, resulting in a double whammy of unnecessary capacity payments and increased pollution. Capacity payments accounted for about 71% of the power purchase price last year and are projected to rise by one-third this year. The guaranteed payments are also a sorry example of 'socialism for the rich and capitalism for the poor', which is at the core of most of Pakistan's economic failings. Annual capacity payments exceed Pakistan's healthcare budget sixfold, and IPPs often inflate costs without fear of reprisal due to the sweetheart deals they were granted by every government over the past three decades. Meanwhile, millions of citizens are struggling to pay their inflated power bills. While some PPAs have been terminated, the government still has much work to do to rectify the situation, including grid modernisation and continuing to encourage a shift to renewables and locally-sourced fuels. It is also worth noting that in most countries, revenue from capacity payments is reinvested into infrastructure and other efficiency improvements instead of being rerouted to shareholders. Here, IPPs and distributors both have the gall to demand government intervention to improve infrastructure for which they are already receiving 'free money'. An egregious recent example saw one distributor, in response to criticism of its loadshedding policy, actually suggest that the government take over loss-making feeders while letting it reap all the profits. That such a suggestion could seriously be made is in itself a reflection of the power imbalance in the power sector.
