Guernsey 'floating voters' want education and housing prioritised
With under a week to go until Guernsey's general election, we spoke to some literal floating voters swimming at Havelet Bay to find out their priorities ahead of the poll. Members of the Bluetits swimming group said they wanted to see education and housing prioritised in the next assembly. Yvonne Elliot said she did not believe education had "improved anything" in the last term. Janine Le Cras agreed: "They've made a complete mess of education."
During the last term, the Committee for Education, Sport and Culture (ESC) managed to get States approval for its plans for three secondary schools and a seperate post-16 campus. However, it came under fire for a decision to temporarily move the Sixth Form Centre to La Mare De Carteret High School. ESC has also faced criticism from politicians after poor results in GCSE maths. Despite this, a number of the island's schools have received positive Ofsted reports in recent months, following heavily critical inspections of St Sampson's High School and Les Voies this term.
After a swim at Havelet Bay and before a bean jar - a popular local dish - on land Janine said: "I used to work in education, in IT. "It really worries me the way the private colleges appear to be marginalised and demonised, as they're doing a lot for the community."One of the last decisions made by this States was to ensure private colleges received States funding in future after an attempt by ESC to withdraw their grant. Politicians agreed to replace the lump sum with a per-student grant system - so, if the colleges take fewer in the future, they would receive less money.Ms Le Cras said: "If you can't afford to send your child to the colleges, I think the opportunities are limited and, quite frankly, scary."
After swimming to a bobber in the bay, Linda Falla said her top election issue was housing. She said: "We can't get enough people to work here and we need people to come in, in specialised jobs."We need housing for young people to stop them leaving the island, because they're our future."Housing the island's young people was also top priority for Yvonne, alongside Janine, who said: "I have two children - one is living in the UK because of her work, one is living here; he lives with me in a wing of my house, which, thankfully, is a self-contained flat. "I have no idea how he'd find somewhere to live, as he wouldn't be able to afford it."There's no affordable renting, there's no affordable buying for local. You have to be in a really high-paying job to be able to afford to buy a house, and that needs to change or we are going to lose our heritage."According to the latest States figures the average cost of a local market property was £580,412, while, to rent, its £2,068 a month.
Post-swim, in the warm at Fishy Tales, the conversation moved from election priorities to the election itself, as frustration built at the island's electoral system."I'm feeling confused, there's a awful lot to choose from," commented Janine. The 2025 poll will be the second time the election has been fought on a fully island-wide basis after a referendum in 2018, which resulted in the current system of 38 deputies being elected in an island-wide constituency. There was agreement by the swimmers that the system made it harder to decide who to vote for.Linda has been looking through her copy of an almost 300 page manifesto booklet: "It's very difficult, there's too many to choose from. "Like most people, I am going through, crossing off the ones I know I won't vote for. I have a big 'maybe' list and a short definite list."Ms Le Cras expressed some cynicism at the entire process: "An awful lot are singing from the same hymn sheet, and I'm not sure they believe what they're saying, just what they think people want to hear. "It makes choosing candidates very difficult. I'm wading my way through the manifestos at the moment, crossing out the definite ones, yes, by a few. "I don't think I'll be using all of my votes, as I frankly don't think some candidates are suitable."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
3 hours ago
- The Independent
Three union leaders included in King's Birthday Honours
Three trade union leaders have been included in the King's Birthday Honours for services to areas including education and green jobs. Dave Ward, long-serving general secretary of the Communication Workers Union (CWU) is made a CBE for services to trade unions, and Dr Patrick Roach, who recently retired as general secretary of the NASUWT teachers' union is made a CBE for services to education. Sue Ferns, deputy general secretary of the civil service union Prospect, is made an OBE for services to green jobs and workplace transition. Mr Ward has been general secretary of the CWU for a decade, leading the union through the privatisation of Royal Mail and recent sale of the postal giant to Czech billionaire Daniel Kretinsky. He started work as a messenger boy at Tooting delivery office in south London before becoming a union rep, holding several positions before succeeding Billy Hayes as general secretary in 2015. He is married with four children, supports Chelsea and is a keen blues guitarist. He told the PA news agency: 'The New Deal for Workers campaign was founded and led by the CWU. 'At a time when society has never been more unequal the trade union movement pushing Labour to turn this campaign into a new Employment Rights Bill could not have been more important. 'This honour is recognition of our union's work in this area and for the way we stand up for postal, telecom, financial services and tech workers across the UK. 'I joined the GPO as a telegram boy in 1976 and it is a privilege to now be the general secretary of a union that campaigns for our members in and out of the workplace. 'We now need employers and the Government to go even further in rebalancing workplaces and society. We will continue to lead this.' Dr Roach stepped down as NASUWT general secretary in April after five years. The son of Jamaican immigrant parents, he grew up in Walsall, West Midlands, in the 1970s, and has described how he faced racism at school on a daily basis. He is married with two children. He was a teacher of politics and sociology in further education and was a researcher and lecturer in education, social policy and equalities in higher education. He later joined NASUWT and headed the union's education and equalities work before becoming assistant general secretary and then deputy general secretary. He has served in a number of voluntary roles as a school governor and in supporting the provision of supplementary education for African Caribbean children. Dr Roach became head of the union in 2020 at the start of the first national lockdown, leading union members in uncharted territory as schools and colleges, teachers and headteachers adapted to one of the most challenging post-war periods in education. As head of the TUC's anti-racism taskforce, Dr Roach was instrumental in leading Britain's trade union movement in challenging racism and injustice at work. He told the PA news agency: 'I am humbled and incredibly proud to be granted this honour. 'It has been my privilege to have been afforded the opportunity to devote my career to education and in the service of NASUWT members, teachers and headteachers, whose commitment, work and dedication every day continues to inspire, shape lives and make a world of difference.' Sue Ferns, who has also been a member of the TUC General Council since 2005, grew up in Sheffield, South Yorkshire, and was the first member of her family to go to university, studying industrial relations at Salford University. After graduating in 1982, she started working for the TUC's economics department. She joined Prospect in 1993, becoming head of research in 2002, director of communications and research in 2013, and senior deputy general secretary in 2018. She has campaigned on issues including the gender pensions gap, workers' rights in the science, engineering and energy sectors, and clean energy. She has taken part in several government taskforces and working groups, particularly on clean energy jobs and workforce skills. She told the PA news agency: 'I am privileged to have spent my career in the trade union movement, determined to make a positive difference to the lives of working people. 'I'd like to thank the countless colleagues, trade union representatives and members within our movement, whose commitment to improving the lives of others has been an inspiration throughout my career.'
Daily Mail
6 hours ago
- Daily Mail
School fees blow as judges reject challenge to Labour tax - even though they say it's discriminatory
Private school families lost their challenge to Labour 's tax on fees yesterday – but judges still branded the measure 'discriminatory'. The judgment by the High Court said the 20 per cent VAT would have a 'disproportionately prejudicial effect' on pupils with special needs. However, it also ruled Parliament still had the right to impose such a decision. Yesterday, the Boarding Schools Association said it was a 'sad day' for vulnerable pupils, adding: 'There are no winners here.' At least one of the claimants now plans to appeal. Paul Conrathe, solicitor at SinclairsLaw which represented a group of special educational needs parents, Education Not Discrimination, said 'the Government should hang its head in shame'. There was anger over the Government's insistence during the case that the tax would benefit state schools. This week it suggested that the money will now pay for housing. VAT on school fees was introduced on January 1, having been pledged in Labour's manifesto. The claim against it was brought by three groups of families and some private schools. They aimed to have the tax declared 'incompatible' with human rights laws. Yesterday's judgment, by Dame Victoria Sharp, Lord Justice Newey and Mr Justice Chamberlain, agreed that the tax was 'discriminatory' against pupils with special educational needs. It also interfered with their right to an education under the European Convention on Human Rights, they said. 'If the imposition of VAT makes the fees unaffordable, there is a significant risk that the state school to which they transfer will not provide adequately for their needs,' they added. 'The measure will have a disproportionately prejudicial effect on them.' However, they concluded Parliament had a 'broad margin of discretion in deciding how to balance the interests of those adversely affected against the interests of others who may gain from public provision funded by the money it will raise'. Many parents of special educational needs children pay fees because private schools offer better pastoral care. The Government said the court had confirmed its legislation was 'compatible with its human rights obligations'.
Times
6 hours ago
- Times
How Angela Rayner's unlikely rapport with the King is paying off
With a hand lifted up to shield his mouth from the watching camera crews, the King leant across to whisper to Angela Rayner. Leaning in to hear what was being said, a broad smile spread across the face of the deputy prime minister. We may never know what was said, unless it is disclosed by the 45-year-old Labour firebrand in her memoirs. However, the meeting at Dumfries House in Scotland was enough to show the world that there is an understanding between the pair. On the face of it, it is an unlikely friendship but one that is no less genuine as a result. The Times understands that Rayner has also held meetings with the King and the Prince of Wales that, while not secret, took place away from the cameras. Rayner's role as housing minister coincides not only with the King's personal concerns but also with those of his son. In April Rayner held a private meeting with Prince William at Windsor Castle. The details, again, are likely to remain private, but it is understood that the pair discussed William's Homewards project, his five-year campaign to make homelessness 'rare, brief and unrepeated'. This week Rayner announced that the government would be decriminalising rough sleeping by scrapping the 200-year-old Vagrancy Act from spring next year. It is a move that will be wholeheartedly supported by William, who has spoken of the need to remove the stigma around homelessness. Having slept rough on the streets of London in 2009 to raise awareness of the issue, the Prince of Wales hopes to eradicate the need for anyone to spend even a single night on the streets. This all comes back to Rayner, who has often spoken of her deep respect for the monarchy, and a commitment to Queen (now King) and country. As housing, communities and local government secretary, Rayner is responsible for overseeing Labour's pledge to build 1.5 million homes by 2029, creating a dozen new towns in the process. There are certainly those in the palace who wish her well. Her charm appears to have disarmed the King while she also appears to be thrilled to get to know him behind the scenes. They could barely come from more different worlds. She had a difficult childhood and was pregnant at 16 with her first child. In a recent interview with The Times, she was asked about a photograph in which Charles appears to be feigning shock in a comical response to one of her jokes. The Prince of Wales is committed to ending homelessness She declined to divulge what she had said to elicit such a response, saying: 'That's got to be private. But he's got a really good sense of humour. I know it sounds strange coming from me, but he's incredibly easy to get along with.' Royal sources point out that the King has many strong friendships across the political spectrum, but the pictures of Rayner in her bovver boots having a giggle with Charles is not one of his more obvious alliances. He laughs at her jokes, she listens intently to his thoughts and there's even a little good-natured mickey-taking, which most Britons would acknowledge as one of the signs of a fond friendship. 'Golly, what amazing trousers!' Charles said when Rayner turned up to a meeting in a bright green pair. Rayner's brief comes into contact with one of the King's great passions: that of creating affordable housing centred around sustainable themes and practical but aesthetically pleasing designs. Rayner and Charles were seen laughing together like old friends as she visited the Ayrshire headquarters of the King's Foundation. While weighty subjects were discussed, it was clear the pair felt relaxed in each other's company, the King chuckling away at Rayner's jokes and vice versa. Behind the scenes, as well as in front of the cameras, sources say they get on well. While monarchs and future kings are more likely to spend their time with the prime minister than their deputy, Rayner's role has set her apart. When the King invited Sir Keir Starmer to see a housing project he had inspired in Nansledan, Cornwall, in February, he extended the invitation to Rayner. In an unprecedented royal engagement, the trio were seen walking around the development, which is being built as a 540-acre extension to the seaside town of Newquay. While Starmer appeared slightly awkward, Rayner and the King chatted more freely. The pair in Newquay in February ALASTAIR GRANT/GETTY It will not have been lost on Charles's aides that Rayner's policies as housing minister will seek to address problems so often highlighted by senior members of the royal family, such as homelessness and affordable housing. Charles would prefer new houses to be aesthetically pleasing and believes that good design and community should be at the heart of any housing project. Rayner has also joined the King and other members of the royal family at Blenheim Palace and Westminster Abbey. That she has no time for Andrew (she allegedly once referred to him as a 'nonce') clearly will not stand against her. According to the book Get In by the journalists Patrick Maguire and Gabriel Pogrund, which tells the story of the Labour Party under Starmer's leadership, Rayner is reported to have told her office: 'I'm not going to vote to keep that nonce on … I can't go back to my constituency and say, 'Yeah, I support that'.' The book reported an aide saying: 'She was very actively reaching out to the palace, the upper echelons of the civil service and said she thought this [Andrew] was a huge problem, and that the government needed to address this, and that she would offer cross-party support to make sure it happened.' While she has been critical of Prince Andrew privately, she has defended the broader monarchy publicly. After the royal family was criticised in 2017 by Emma Dent Coad, then Labour MP for Kensington, she gave a television interview in which she said: 'They are a fantastic export. People love them across the world, and they contribute to everything that's British, and I don't have a problem with the royal family.' In turn, the palace appears to have welcomed Rayner with open arms. This month Rayner was invited on to a panel with Kristina Murrin, chief executive of the King's Foundation. When Charles arrived at the SXSW festival in east London this month, he was greeted by Rayner, Sir Sadiq Khan, the mayor of London, and Eva Omaghomi, the King's former diversity tsar who chairs the festival's advisory council, among others. Earlier, Rayner had spoken at the festival about sustainable communities. It is a subject close to the King's heart and now, it seems, so is the deputy prime minister.
