Germany's new leadership may be having second thoughts about supporting Netanyahu's war
When Germany and Israel established diplomatic relations six decades ago, protesters gathered outside the ceremony in Jerusalem waving signs demanding 'a German-free Israel'.
A photograph from the stiff occasion shows ambassador Rolf Pauls extending his credentials to an unsmiling president Zalman Shazar while Golda Meir and other Israeli ministers glare at the official, fateful document.
It was just 20 years after the end of the second World War and the wounds of the Holocaust were still fresh. Later, the ambassador's son Christian Pauls, himself a former ambassador to Ireland, remembered the occasion as 'terribly intense for both sides'.
In keeping with that gloomy, intense tradition, German officials conceded on Monday that there was 'no celebratory mood' in Berlin when German president Frank-Walter Steinmeier received his Israeli counterpart Yitzhak Herzog.
READ MORE
Amid warm words to mark six decades of bilateral relations, described by Steinmeier as a 'gift', four public protests took place. At one outside the chancellery, organised by Amnesty International, demonstrators held up signs reading: 'Germany and Israel: no partnership for genocide' and 'No weapons for war crimes in Gaza'.
The protests reflect international pressure building on Binyamin Netanyahu's government to end its two-month humanitarian aid blockade on Gaza. In a joint press conference, Steinmeier urged Israel to allow aid into Gaza 'not sometime – now'.
Herzog insisted Israel was meeting humanitarian law and urged the international community to study plans for a 'new mechanism which will enable the distribution of aid directly to the people of Gaza' – cutting out the Palestinian militant group Hamas.
'If all mediators, the USA and all those in dialogue with Hamas make it very clear – 'open the door and leave the hostages behind' – then the reality on the ground will change immediately,' Herzog told German state television.
The deteriorating situation in Gaza has forced new German chancellor Friedrich Merz to learn at light speed the meaning of Middle East realpolitik.
[
Tensions rising in Germany amid criticism of Israeli government
Opens in new window
]
Merz was a staunch pro-Israeli voice in opposition but, hours after his swearing-in as chancellor last Tuesday, conceded that the Israeli approach in Gaza was a 'source of great concern'. Israel had a right to defend itself, he added, but 'must also remain a country that meets humanitarian obligations'.
Before a private meeting with Herzog, Merz said German-Israeli ties had, for 60 years, 'been a symbol of reconciliation and the unique responsibility of our country toward Israel'.
'The existence of Israel and its security are anchored in the essence of our existence,' he added.
Preparing the ground for Merz's visit to Israel was a priority during the inaugural weekend visit of new German foreign minister Johann Wadephul.
The 62-year-old said Berlin was 'open' to US-backed proposals for a new humanitarian organisation to bring aid to Gaza. Apart from that, though, there was much continuity in his remarks. He warned the current conflict could not be 'resolved permanently by military means' and doubted 'whether all of Israel's strategic goals can be achieved in this way'.
There was an echo of the previous German government, too, in his call for the return of the remaining Israeli hostages and warnings against expulsion of the two million Palestinians from Gaza or permanent Israeli occupation of Gaza.
Despite that, clear pro-Israel sentiment remains strong among the ruling CDU Bundestag party. Its foreign policy expert Jürgen Hardt argued on Monday that Berlin and other capitals 'would do well to listen to Israel and, behind closed doors, form its own opinion on this situation analysis'.
Amid the subdued 60th anniversary, a mutinous mood is growing in sections of the German media. The centre-left Süddeutsche Zeitung led the way on Monday, arguing that the new Merz government found itself 'at a crossroads'.
'A credible commitment to international law and its institutions cannot be reconciled,' it argued in an editorial, 'with unconditional support of this government of Israel, which has right-wing extremists in its ranks who want to drive people out of their homeland'.
For some German Middle East analysts the most visible difference in Germany's approach to Israel isn't between the old and new administrations – but between the CDU in opposition and in office.
'As the siege of Gaza reaches new levels, Merz is now in power and responsible for everything,' said Dr Peter Lintl of Berlin's SWP think tank. 'It's particularly difficult for Steinmeier: to express thanks for the reconciliation of the last 60 years then address the hard approach of Israel in Gaza – how to balance that?'
Before he left Berlin for Jerusalem, a visibly uncomfortable Steinmeier addressed the elephant in the corner of the German-Israeli relationship as it turns 60: an International Criminal Court arrest warrant issued against Netanyahu last year for alleged war crimes.
As opposition leader, Merz said he would, once in power, extend an invitation to the Israeli prime minister. After a week in office, the Merz invitation has dropped out of sight and Steinmeier said he hoped it stayed that way.
'I assume and hope that both sides are smart enough,' he said, 'to ensure that a decision never has to be taken on whether to enforce an international arrest warrant against an Israeli prime minister in Germany.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
3 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Iran fires fresh missiles amid ongoing Israeli airstrikes
Iran launched a second round of missiles against Israel late on Saturday as Israel's military kept up attacks in Iran following earlier strikes which targeted nuclear and military sites. They also killed key leaders in the country's governing theocracy. Israel said hundreds of airstrikes over the past two days killed nine senior scientists and experts involved in Iran's nuclear programme, in addition to several top generals. Iran's UN ambassador said 78 people were killed and more than 320 wounded. People inspect the ruins of a house that was struck by a missile fired from Iran (AP/Daniel Rolider) The US and Iran had been scheduled to hold their sixth round of indirect talks over Iran's nuclear programme on Sunday in Oman, but Oman's foreign minister said the meeting was cancelled after Israel's strikes. First responders were looking for survivors and clearing the remnants of a missile which fell on a neighbourhood outside Tel Aviv early on Sunday morning. Responders used a drone to look for survivors in areas that were too hard to access. Some people were fleeing the area with their belongings in suitcases. People take shelter during sirens warning of incoming fire in Tel Aviv (AP/Baz Ratner) The Israeli military said early on Sunday it had targeted Iran's Defence Ministry headquarters in Tehran as well as sites it alleged were associated with Iran's nuclear programme around Tehran. It alleged the sites were 'related to the Iranian regime's nuclear weapons project'. US intelligence agencies and the International Atomic Energy Agency have repeatedly said Iran was not pursuing a nuclear weapon before Israel unleashed its campaign of airstrikes on Friday. Three drones were launched toward a base housing US forces in Iraq following Israel's strikes on Iran, a US military official and a second US official said on Saturday. Both spoke on condition of anonymity because they were not authorised to speak publicly. The drones were shot down, the officials said. No group claimed responsibility for the attack on Ain al-Asad air base in western Iraq. Flames rise from an oil storage facility after it appeared to have been hit by an Israeli strike in Tehran, Iran (AP/Vahid Salemi) A network of powerful Iran-backed militias in Iraq has remained mostly quiet amid the escalating Israel-Iran conflict. In the past, the militias had periodically attacked US bases in Iraq and Syria in retaliation for Washington's support for Israel in its war against the Iran-allied Hamas militant group in Gaza. Also on Saturday, for the second day, supporters of armed factions in Iraq demonstrated in central Baghdad to denounce the Israeli bombing of Iran. The protesters did not attempt to breach the heavily fortified Green Zone where the US Embassy is located.
Irish Daily Mirror
10 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
WW3 fears amid calls for de-escalation of Middle East conflict
Israel has issued a grave warning to Tehran, saying it will "burn" after retaliatory strikes killed three civilians near Tel Aviv. "The Iranian dictator is taking the citizens of Iran hostage," Israel Katz said. "It is bringing about a reality in which they, and especially Tehran's residents, will pay a heavy price for the flagrant harm inflicted upon Israel's citizens," he continued. "If Khamenei continues to fire missiles at the Israeli home front, Tehran will burn." Iran has also issued a warning to western nations this morning, including the UK, France and US, that it will strike military bases and ships if it continues to support Israel. Iran's state-owned Mehr News Agency issued the grave warning, saying: "Any country that participates in repelling Iran's attacks on Israel will be subject to Iranian forces targeting all regional bases of the complicit government, including military bases in the Persian Gulf countries and ships and naval vessels in the Persian Gulf and the Red Sea." It comes as Foreign Secretary David Lammy said he is 'alarmed' by the strikes overnight and is expected to spend the day in crisis talks with counterparts across the Middle East and elsewhere. Israel is continuing air strikes on Iran after an initial attack killed six nuclear scientists and top Iranian commanders. Iran's U.N. ambassador said 78 people were killed and more than 320 wounded by IDF strikes overnight on Saturday with at least five top ranking Revolutionary Guard figures perishing. For live updates, follow our blog below... Protesters have taken part in anti-Israel and anti-US demonstrations in Tehran, Iran. On Saturday, marchers gathered at Enghelab Square after walking from Azadi and Imam Hussein Squares, chanting slogans such as "Revenge, revenge," and calling for stronger retaliation against Israel. Demonstrators held Iranian flags and carried posters of Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei. Three drones were launched toward a base housing U.S. forces in Iraq following Israel's strikes on Iran, a US military official and a second US official said on Saturday. Both spoke on condition of anonymity because they were not authorised to speak publicly. The drones were shot down, the officials said. No group claimed responsibility for the attack on Ain al-Asad air base in western Iraq. Iran state TV claimed that "heavy and destructive" attacks against Israel are expected within the coming hours. Meanwhile, the Israeli military continues to strike several targets across Iran. Emmanuel Macron spoke by phone with Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian on Saturday, the French President's office said. Macron called "for the utmost restraint to avoid escalation," the statement said, and urged his Iranian counterpart to return to the negotiation table quickly: "The Iranian nuclear issue … must be solved through negotiation." He also demanded the immediate release of two French nationals, Cécile Kohler and Jacques Paris, held hostage by the Iranian regime for over three years, Macron's office said. Today, Macron also spoke on the phone with Donald Trump about the situation in the Middle-East. The PM added: "We do have long-standing concerns about the nuclear programme Iran has. "We do recognize Israel's right to self defence, but I'm absolutely clear that this needs to de-escalate. There is a huge risk of escalation for the region. More widely in terms of conflict, you can see the impact already on the economy and oil prices. "And of course, all of this is linked to what's going on in Gaza. So you can see why my strong position is this needs to de-escalate, and that is the primary focus of the discussions that I've been having and will continue to be." Mr Starmer also refused to say whether the UK had been given advanced notice of Israel's strike. Speaking to reporters, the Prime Minister said: "I will always make the right decisions for the UK and our allies. "We are moving assets to the region, including jets, and that is for contingency support in the region. I will be clear-eyed in relation to our duties and obligations and my duties as Prime Minister of the United Kingdom." Pressed on whether the assets in the region would be involved in defending Israel, the PM told reporters he would not "get into operational issues". Keir Starmer revealed tonight extra British military assets, including fighter jets, will be deployed to the Middle East as fears grow over an all-out war in the region. The Prime Minister described the assets as "contingency support" and it is understood aircraft began deployment preparations on Friday. The UK already has jets in the region as part of its Operation Shader contribution. The PM also urged the Iranian regime and Benjamin Netanyahu's Israeli government to de-escalate and pull back from the brink as he flew to the G7 in Canada. You can read more here. Trump described the regional situation as "very alarming," Ushakov said, but acknowledged the "effectiveness" of Israel's strikes on targets in Iran. The leaders did not rule out a possible return to negotiations on the Iranian nuclear program, according to Ushakov. Vladimir Putin and Donald Trump held a 50-minute phone call on Saturday to discuss the escalating situation in the Middle East and Ukraine peace talks, the Russian President's aide Yuri Ushakov said. During the conversation, Putin briefed Trump on his recent talks with the leaders of Iran and Israel and reiterated Russia's proposal to seek mutually acceptable solutions on the Iranian nuclear issue. "The dangerous escalation of the situation in the Middle East was naturally at the centre of the exchange of opinions," Ushakov told journalists following the conversation between Putin and Trump . Trump described the regional situation as "very alarming" and neither leader ruled out a possible return to negotiations on the Iranian nuclear program, according to Ushakov. According to Ushakov, Putin told Trump about the implementation of the agreements during peace talks in Istanbul between Russian and Ukrainian delegations, including the exchange of prisoners of war. This image shows destroyed buildings following Iranian military attacks in Rishon LeZion, Israel. Croatia's consul in Israel and his wife were lightly injured when Iran launched missile strikes on Tel Aviv, Croatia's Foreign Minister Gordan Grlic Radman has said. He wrote on X: "I am shaken by the news that our consul and his wife were injured in the attack on Tel Aviv. The building they live in was hit. "I spoke with them and, fortunately, their injuries are minor and they are not in any life-threatening condition." An Israeli drone has struck a refinery in Iran's South Pars gas field on Saturday, semiofficial Iranian news agencies reported. If confirmed, it would mark the first Israeli attack on Iran's oil and natural gas industry. Israel did not immediately acknowledge the attack. Such sites do have air defense systems around them, which Israel has been targeting since Friday. The Fars and Tasnim news agencies reported the strike, saying it happened in Phase 14 of the field. Iran shares the gas field, which stretches across the Persian Gulf, with Qatar. Oman's foreign minister says planned talks between Iran and the United States over Tehran's rapidly advancing nuclear programme "will not now take place" after Israel's strikes targeting the Islamic Republic. Badr al-Busaidi made the announcement on social media on Saturday. It comes after Iran's foreign minister said any talks would be 'unjustifiable' amid the ongoing attacks. Oman has been mediating the talks. "The Iran US talks scheduled to be held in Muscat this Sunday will not now take place," al-Busaidi wrote. "But diplomacy and dialogue remain the only pathway to lasting peace." A sixth round was due to happen in Muscat, Oman's capital, before the Israeli strikes began Friday. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has issued new threats to Iran, while saying his country's military was destroying Tehran's ability to manufacture ballistic missiles. "We will hit every site and every target of the Ayatollahs' regime and what they have felt so far is nothing compared with what they will be handed in the coming days," Netanyahu said in a video message. Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov, in a phone call with his Iranian counterpart Abbas Araghchi, reaffirmed Moscow's readiness to help resolve issues surrounding Iran's nuclear programme and to assist in de-escalating tensions between Iran and Israel. The Russian Foreign Ministry said the conversation, initiated by the Iranian side, followed a call Friday between Presidents Vladimir Putin and Masoud Pezeshkian. The ministry said Russia reiterated its condemnation of Israel's military actions against Iran, calling them a violation of the UN charter and international law. This image shows Iranian Red Crescent volunteers working in a Tehran neighbourhood hit by a reported Israeli strike. Talks that were due to take place between the US and Iran tomorrow have been cancelled, a spokesperson for Iran's Ministry of Foreign Affairs has said. The two nations were set to meet in Muscat, Oman, for a sixth round of talks over Tehran's nuclear program - but the meeting will no longer go ahead following Israel's attack on Iran yesterday. Iranian state media Mehr News reported that Esmaeil Baghaei said: "The United States has supported the Zionist regime's aggression, including the targeting of Iran's peaceful nuclear facilities. "Participating in talks with a party that is the principal supporter and accomplice of the aggressor is fundamentally meaningless." The US hasn't officially confirmed or denied the reports. Donald Trump will be monitoring the situation between Israel and Iran and developments across the Middle East all day, a White House official told NBC News. Later today, the US President will attend a military parade in Washington DC to celebrate the army's 250th anniversary. Israeli warplanes hit more than 400 targets across Iran in the past 24 hours as part of Operation "Rising Lion," including dozens of missile sites and air defense systems in Tehran, the military said. Separately, it said over 20 senior Iranian commanders were eliminated, including top intelligence and missile officials. Israeli army spokesperson Effie Defrin said the road to Tehran was now "open," calling the strikes the deepest ever carried out by the Israeli Air Force. The Grand Egyptian Museum will open later this year because of the Israeli-Iranian escalation, authorities said on Saturday. The mega-project near the famed Giza Pyramids was sent to open on July 3. However, the Tourism and Antiquities Ministry said the opening was moved to the fourth quarter of 2025, without giving a date and citing ongoing regional developments. The museum has been under construction for about two decades. Some sections have been open since 2022 for limited tours. However, its overall opening has been repeatedly delayed for a number of reasons, including because of the coronavirus pandemic. The Prime Minister spoke to the Crown Prince of Saudi Arabia, Mohammed bin Salman, on Saturday afternoon, and Foreign Secretary David Lammy was expected to spend the day in talks with counterparts across the Middle East and elsewhere. A Downing Street spokesperson said Sir Keir and the Crown Prince spoke on Saturday afternoon. According to a read-out of the conversation issued by Number 10, 'they discussed the gravely concerning situation in the Middle East and agreed on the need to de-escalate'. 'The Prime Minister updated on his conversations with partners so far, and reiterated that the UK is poised to work closely with its allies in the coming days to support a diplomatic resolution.' At least 23 Palestinians have been killed in Gaza, according to medics, most of them near an aid distribution site. Staff at al Awda and al Aqsa hospitals in central Gaza said at least 15 people were killed as they tried to approach the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation aid centre near the Netzarim corridor. They said the rest were killed in separate attacks across the territory. Sir Keir Starmer and the Crown Prince of Saudi Arabia Mohammed bin Salman have "agreed on the need to de-escalate" the conflict between Iran and Israel, Downing Street has said. The two leaders spoke on Saturday afternoon, according to a read-out issued by Number 10. A Downing Street spokesperson said: "They discussed the gravely concerning situation in the Middle East and agreed on the need to de-escalate. "The Prime Minister updated on his conversations with partners so far, and reiterated that the UK is poised to work closely with its allies in the coming days to support a diplomatic resolution." A phone alert from Israel's Home Front Command has warned f incoming rocket and missile fire. James Eden who is stranded in Jerusalem during a wave of Iranian missile attacks has described the city as a "ghost town" and said he feels "abandoned" by the Foreign Office. Mr Eden, 72, from Newcastle-upon-Tyne, flew to Israel on Monday for a short pilgrimage to visit Christian sites he first saw two decades ago. Israel has given its first report of wounded soldiers since Iran retaliated last night. The military said seven were lightly wounded in central Israel, though they wouldn't say exactly where. They were taken to hospital briefly, they added, before being sent home. No further details were given. Footage shared by an affiliate of Iran's state TV showed a fire after an Israeli strike at Zagros Khodro, a former car manufacturing plant in Borujerd. The state-run IRNA news agency also reported an Israeli strike on Saturday around Abadan in Iran's southwestern Khuzestan province. Other strikes appeared to be happening in Kermanshah near a military barracks. The Israeli military says seven soldiers were lightly wounded on Friday night in an Iranian missile strike in central Israel. It says they were briefly hospitalized and sent home. This is the first report of military casualties in the operation. It gave no further details on where the soldiers were located. David Lammy has said he is 'alarmed' by the strikes in the Middle East overnight. In a post on X, the Foreign Secretary said: 'Alarmed by further strikes in the Middle East overnight, with reports of fatalities and injuries in Israel. 'We must urgently de-escalate & prevent any further harm to civilians. Following the Prime Minister's call with PM Netanyahu, I spoke to Iranian FM Araghchi to urge calm.' Alarmed by further strikes in the Middle East overnight, with reports of fatalities and injuries in Israel. We must urgently de-escalate & prevent any further harm to civilians. Following the Prime Minister's call with PM Netanyahu, I spoke to Iranian FM Araghchi to urge calm. David Lammy is expected to spend the day in talks with counterparts across the Middle East after Iran launched retaliatory attacks against Israel overnight. The Foreign Secretary will be briefed by officials on Saturday and will speak to figures in the Middle East and elsewhere. It comes after conversations with representatives from Iran, Jordan and Saudi Arabia as well as European foreign ministers on Friday. The Esfahan and Natanz nuclear sites in Iran have been significantly damaged in strikes, according to reports from the Reuters news agency. The Israeli official tells Reuters that over 150 targets in Iran have been attacked. Most drones and missiles that have been launched towards Israel have been intercepted, the official says. They also said the nuclear facilities in Esfahan and Natanz have been "significantly damaged" and that i will take weeks for the damage to be fixed. New pictures from the Fars news agency also show smoke rising in Tabriz, northern Iran, after an earlier strike was reported there this morning.
Irish Times
15 hours ago
- Irish Times
Taoiseach says UN being ‘eroded', calls for world powers to de-escalate Iran-Israel conflict
World powers must use their influence with Israel and Iran to bring about a return to a rules-based international order where dialogue and diplomacy are used to resolve disputes, the Taoiseach has said. Speaking to reporters in Cork on Saturday, Micheál Martin said Israel's attack on Iran's nuclear programme and Iran's retaliatory missile attack on Tel Aviv are worrying developments that only add to the trauma experienced by civilians across the Middle East, 'It is deeply concerning that we have so much conflict in the Middle East. It is dangerous in terms of its impact on civilian populations in the first instance. We see the horrors of Gaza – Syria is coming out of the embers of a horrible civil war,' he said. 'A war that's been planned for a decade' - why Israel has attacked Iran and what happens next Listen | 21:11 Mr Martin said Iran should have engaged proactively years ago about its nuclear programme and set about dismantling it. It is important that the West continues its engagement with Iran even though the current situation could 'make that very difficult', he said. READ MORE 'There has to be a return to a rules-based international order. At the moment, it is receding before our very eyes. It is being eroded; the United Nations (UN) is being eroded and that is a matter of deep concern to us,' he said. 'We want to see a peaceful resolution to the conflict. We believe in dialogue, and we believe in diplomacy, so we would say, to the world powers in particular, to use their influence and stop the hostilities to bring about a ceasefire in Gaza and the release of all hostages.' Mr Martin said a failure to de-escalate the tensions between Israel and Iran would have serious consequences. He said the International Atomic Energy Agency had previouslywarned of the consequences that would arise if Iran did not engage fully with the agency on its nuclear programme. He said the agency also said the bombing of nuclear installations is hugely concerning. Mr Martin was speaking to reporters while attending a ceremony at Cork Airport to officially name the main airport artery Rory Gallagher Avenue in honour of the Cork guitarist.
