US judge skeptical of Trump's 'gender ideology' arts grants restrictions
March 27 (Reuters) - A federal judge appeared open on Thursday to blocking President Donald Trump's administration from requiring arts organizations to certify they will not promote "gender ideology" to obtain grant funding from the National Endowment for the Arts.
Senior U.S. District Judge William Smith during a hearing in Providence, Rhode Island, questioned how such a policy could be reconciled with federal law, "which prohibits requiring grant recipients from engaging in essentially government propaganda."
The NEA first adopted that criterion last month to implement an executive order the Republican president signed upon returning to office on January 20 that directed the government to recognize only two sexes - male and female - and required agencies to ensure grant funds do not promote "gender ideology."
Several arts and theater groups represented by the American Civil Liberties Union sued, opens new tab, saying the policy would force them to self-censor to obtain funding and alter the scope of artistic projects that involve transgender characters or LGBTQ actors.
After the lawsuit was filed, the NEA withdrew its certification requirement pending further review, with plans to issue a new policy by April 30.
Assistant U.S. Attorney Kevin Bolan argued that decision meant the request for an injunction sought by the Rhode Island Latino Arts, the National Queer Theater, the Theater Offensive and the Theatre Communications Group was moot.
"The circumstances have changed," Bolan said.
But Smith told Bolan the agency's decision to voluntarily end the policy appeared manipulative and designed so the government could argue the request for an injunction was moot when it was likely the NEA would just re-adopt the same requirement.
"I really do struggle to see how the agency could not do exactly what it has already done under the plain terms of the executive order without violating the executive order," said Smith, an appointee of Republican President George W. Bush.
The judge said such a requirement appeared to contradict the agency's governing statute, the National Foundation on the Arts and the Humanities Act of 1965, which requires grants to be issued based on artistic merit and excellence, without regard to particular viewpoints.
Vera Eidelman, a lawyer with the ACLU, said the policy was clearly a viewpoint-based eligibility bar that ran afoul of not just that statute but also the U.S. Constitution's First Amendment's free speech protections.
She said by law, the NEA had been barred from directing, supervising or controlling a funded organization's policies or personnel in order to further its mission of fostering "the material conditions for releasing this creative talent."
"All of these restrictions were meant to prevent the NEA from becoming essentially a government propaganda machine, allowing political control of culture," she said.
Smith promised to rule by April 4, citing a looming deadline three days later for arts organizations to submit applications for grant funding for the 2026 fiscal year.
While he did not promise an injunction, he said one would help get the plaintiffs "out of this Hobson's choice they have to make about whether to submit a proposal they want to submit versus the proposal they think they might have to submit."
The case is Rhode Island Latino Arts v. National Endowment for the Arts, U.S. District Court for the District of Rhode Island, No. 1:25-cv-00079.
For the plaintiffs: Vera Eidelman and Scarlet Kim of the American Civil Liberties Union Foundation.
For the government: Kevin Bolan of the U.S. Attorney's Office for the District of Rhode Island
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NBC News
25 minutes ago
- NBC News
National Park Service closes D.C.'s historic Dupont Circle Park during WorldPride
The National Park Service and U.S. Park Police on Thursday evening closed Dupont Circle Park, widely known as the heart of Washington,'s LGBTQ neighborhood, ahead of the final weekend of WorldPride, an international Pride celebration being held in the nation's capital this year. This year's parade route was not set to go through Dupont Circle, but the park has traditionally hosted unofficial celebrations after Pride events. It was home to some of D.C.'s earliest Pride celebrations in the 1970s as well as major protests during both the LGBTQ rights and Civil Rights Movements. The park service said in a letter Wednesday that the park would be closed from 6 p.m. Thursday until 6 p.m. Sunday. The letter said the U.S. Park Police had determined that the closure is necessary to 'secure the park, deter potential violence, reduce the risk of destructive acts and decrease the need for extensive law enforcement presences.' Capital Pride Alliance, which organizes D.C. Pride and is hosting this year's WorldPride celebration, said Friday that it is 'frustrated and disappointed' in the park service's decision to close Dupont Circle during WorldPride. 'This beloved landmark is central to the community that WorldPride intends to celebrate and honor,' Capital Pride Alliance said in a statement. 'It's much more than a park, for generations it's been a gathering place for DC's LGBTQ+ community, hosting first amendment assemblies and memorial services for those we lost to the AIDS epidemic and following tragic events like the Pulse nightclub shooting.' The organization added that the 'sudden move' was 'made overnight without consultation with the Capital Pride Alliance or other local officials,' and that no WorldPride activities were planned in Dupont Circle and thus no official events would be affected. The park's closure comes after weeks of back and forth between D.C. police and federal officials. D.C. Police Chief Pamela Smith requested a full closure of the park in April, and on Tuesday morning, the National Parks Service issued a statement that the park would be closed through the final weekend of WorldPride festivities due to the request from Smith and U.S. Park Police, NBC Washington reported. That same day, Smith rescinded the request after meeting with members of the community to talk about the significance of the park to the Pride celebration, according to NBC Washington, and Smith told two D.C. City Council members that the park would remain open for the weekend. Then, in a letter Wednesday, Major Frank Hilsher of the U.S. Park Police requested that 'anti-scale' fencing, which is designed to prevent people from climbing over it, be used to close the park. Hilsher's letter, which was included with the park service's letter, detailed a number of incidents that occurred in the park after formal Pride events over the years, including vandalism in 2023 that resulted in $175,000 in damage to the park's historic fountain. He added that open-source intelligence reporting has 'identified a local DJ advertising and selling tickets to an unpermitted gathering/party in Dupont Circle following World Pride events.' The event, Hilsher said, is not sanctioned by WorldPride and has not applied for a separate permit that would allow the park service to manage the event. 'This social media advertisement is stating that this is the same DJ and 'party' as the previous several years, which have resulted in the unsafe conditions and damages recounted above,' Hilsher said in the letter. Organizers of WorldPride estimated that as many as 3 million people could attend, though they also issued a warning to potential transgender attendees from outside of the U.S. to come at their own risk and consider travel advisories from some European countries. In just the first few weeks of his second administration, President Donald Trump issued several executive orders targeting trans people, including declaring that there are only two unchangeable sexes; prohibiting trans people from enlisting and serving in the military; barring trans girls and women from competing on female sports teams in federally-funded K-12 schools and colleges; and barring federal funding from going to hospitals that provide transition-related care to minors. As a result of Trump's executive order defining sex, federal officials have also scrubbed agency websites of any mention of transgender or intersex people. References to transgender and queer people were removed from the webpage for the Stonewall National Monument commemorating the site of the 1969 Stonewall Uprising, widely considered a turning point in the modern gay rights movement. A web page dedicated to Frank Kameny, an LGBTQ rights pioneer, was also erased from the National Park Service website this year. The National Park Service's webpage for Dupont Circle Park also now says that the park 'has served as the anchor of a neighborhood of diplomats, government officials, war commemorations, and the LGB community for over 200 years,' removing transgender and queer from the LGBTQ acronym. Earlier this week, the Navy confirmed to NBC News that it would rename the USNS Harvey Milk, a fleet replenishment oiler named for the LGBTQ rights activist, Navy veteran and first openly gay man elected to public office in California.
NBC News
an hour ago
- NBC News
Former federal inmate pardoned by Trump tapped as Bureau of Prisons deputy director
A former federal inmate who was pardoned by President Donald Trump in his first term for drug trafficking crimes more than two decades ago has been tapped as deputy director of the federal Bureau of Prisons, according to bureau spokesperson Kristie Breshears. Joshua J. Smith, a Tennessee businessman who founded an inmate advocacy and rehabilitation nonprofit foundation, the Fourth Purpose, will be second in command in the bureau. The BOP has never had a formerly incarcerated inmate work as an employee at any level, according to a senior bureau official. 'Josh brings to this role something our agency has never had before at this level, a perspective shaped by lived experience, proven innovation and national impact,' Director William K. Marshall III said in a memo to staff Thursday. 'His firsthand understanding of our facilities — of the tension, the risk and the importance of trust — makes him uniquely positioned to advocate for the resources and reforms front-line staff need to do their jobs safely and effectively,' added Marshall, a former prison commissioner in West Virginia whom Trump selected as BOP director in April. Smith declined to comment when reached by phone Thursday. Trump granted a full pardon to Smith, who had been convicted of conspiracy to possess drugs with intent to distribute. Indictments were filed in 1997 for marijuana- and cocaine-related charges, and the court docket shows he pleaded guilty. The court recommended he go to the Federal Correctional Institution Manchester in Kentucky and boot camp for a 60-month sentence. He was also set to have five years supervised release, substance abuse treatment and a $12,500 fine. The bureau, in recent years, has been roiled by accusations of cronyism and corruption, widespread staffing shortages, and violence and misconduc t in prisons. Its leadership must manage a massive $8 billion-plus budget, more than 143,000 federal inmates across 122 prisons, and a workforce of more than 35,000 as the Justice Department's largest employer. In deciding to pardon Smith, the White House said in 2021 that, after his release from prison in 2003, he 'dedicated his life to his faith and to his community,' founded Fourth Purpose and 'mentored incarcerated individuals and taught business classes to those in prison — including at the prison where he was incarcerated.' Smith's pardon request was supported by Tennessee Gov. Bill Lee, a Republican. According to his online biography, Smith said he was raised by a single mother in government housing, was convicted of 10 felonies by the time he was 16 and entered prison at 21. While in prison, he said, he learned about Christianity and God and was mentored by white-collar criminals. He said he started a multimillion-dollar company that hired ex-offenders before becoming more active in prison reform. 'Today is a day of redemption that I attribute to God's grace,' Smith said after he was pardoned, adding that 'there are a lot of Josh Smiths in prisons across our country, and I am going to help as many as possible find a new purpose.' Smith's pardon was one of 74 that Trump granted on his last day in office during his first term, when he also pardoned former chief strategist and longtime ally Steve Bannon, who was indicted on wire fraud and money laundering conspiracy charges, and hip-hop star Lil Wayne, who pleaded guilty to weapons charges.
NBC News
an hour ago
- NBC News
Tired in Tornado Alley
June 6, 2025, 2:00 PM EDT By Evan Bush and Chase Cain DAVENPORT, Iowa — The message at the Quad Cities National Weather Service, which keeps an eye on the flood-prone Mississippi River and the heart of Tornado Alley, is that everything is fine. Yes, two of the office's three top positions are vacant. No, the office doesn't have a hydrologist, despite its proximity to the mighty Mississippi, which flooded Davenport for 96 days in 2019. And, sure, the staff is down by about 42% from its typical 24 to 14, according to former employees familiar with the office. Those left are putting on a brave face. 'We feel good to meet the mission,' said Matt Friedlein, who is normally the office's science and operations officer but has been filling in as the acting meteorologist-in-charge. The mission here is crucial. This is tornado country, where the warnings that come from this office can be matters of life and death. On Tuesday, eight tornadoes roared through the region, downing trees, derailing rail cars and snapping utility poles. Like National Weather Service offices across the country, the Quad Cities office is dealing with deep cuts after the Trump administration laid off probationary workers. And while the Trump administration has claimed everything is OK — while also saying it will be refilling more than 100 NWS roles across the country — even some Republican members of Congress are sounding the alarm. 'We're fixing it,' said Rep. Mike Flood, R-Neb., who introduced bipartisan legislation Friday that would classify NWS employees as critical public safety workers and protect them from future cost-saving federal cuts. 'We're going to make them public safety. We're going to fund them.' Last week, before the administration acknowledged it planned to hire new staffers, NBC News joined a congressional tour — at the invitation of Rep. Eric Sorensen, D-Ill., Congress' only meteorologist and a critic of the administration — to see the effects of the Trump administration's cuts at the Quad Cities forecasting office for Iowa and Illinois. We found a dedicated but short-staffed office scraping by as best it could and politely avoiding a few of the most pointed questions. Were there plans to hire a new hydrologist? What would ideal staffing levels be? 'I'll have to refer you to public affairs,' Friedlein said. Ray Wolf, who retired from the Davenport office in 2023 but has kept in touch with his former colleagues, said that they were 'hanging in there' but that the nationwide cuts had left the system vulnerable to a failure. 'How long can they keep on before something invariably breaks down?' he said. 'If you keep stressing a system beyond its limits? Eventually, there's going to be an issue somewhere that's going to show up.' The National Weather Service is down about 560 employees since the Trump administration laid off workers and offered buyouts and early retirements to others, according to Sen. Maria Cantwell, D-Wash, who held a news conference Wednesday opposing the cuts. At least eight offices have stopped operating 24 hours a day. At least 10 of 122 NWS forecasting offices this year have halted or suspended the release of weather balloons that provide data to predict the weather; they simply didn't have the staff to manage. Real-time weather data collected and analyzed by the National Weather Service and its parent agency, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) — from balloons, radar, maritime buoys and satellites — forms the basis of almost all public and private weather forecasting. Meteorologists at forecasting offices are responsible for analyzing the modeling data and sending alerts to the public. Improvements to weather models are the result of applying the agencies' research. The agency has been spotlighted for cuts for months. Project 2025, a road map for conservatives ahead of the election, suggested dismantling many of NOAA's functions and privatizing that work, placing it under state control or sending it to other agencies. Staffing levels at the weather service have become a political pressure point — but even as the Trump administration approved hiring more than 100 additional staffers for critical roles, Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick insisted the agency had enough resources. NOAA and NWS are part of the Commerce Department. 'We are fully staffed with forecasters and scientists,' Lutnick said Wednesday at a Senate Appropriations Committee hearing. 'Under no circumstances am I going to let public safety or public forecasting be touched.' At a House Appropriations Committee hearing Thursday, Lutnick suggested that some regional centers within the National Weather Service could be consolidated and that more balloon launches could be automated. Now, members of Congress on both sides of the aisle are pushing for change as tornadoes tear across the Midwest, hurricane season ramps up and the peak of wildfire season out west nears. Sorensen, who worked for 22 years as a TV meteorologist, has signed on to co-sponsor Flood's bill, along with Reps. Frank Lucas, R-Okla., Jared Moskowitz, D-Fla., and Jimmy Panetta, D-Calif. Sorensen said he's concerned a mistake by a worn-down meteorologist will lead to unnecessary deaths. He compared the situation to a used car — once trusty and now headed for a lapse. 'It's not running the way that it was supposed to,' Sorensen said of the service. 'Meteorologists, we're human, you know. We will make mistakes, and I don't want to ever see us in a situation where funding or a lack of funding has now caused there to be a loss of life.' Some help is on the way. The administration recently approved the agency's hiring 126 new staffers, including meteorologists, hydrologists, physical scientists and electronics technicians, a measure CNN first reported Monday. 'A targeted number of permanent, mission-critical field positions will soon be advertised under an exception to the Department-wide hiring freeze to further stabilize frontline operations,' Erica Grow Cei, a meteorologist and spokesperson for the National Weather Service, said in a statement. The National Weather Service has also opened a period of reassignment for current staffers to relocate and fill more than 150 critical positions. More from NBC News Science under siege: Trump cuts threaten to undermine decades of research The best and brightest young scientists are looking beyond the U.S. as cuts hit home With fewer weather balloons due to government staffing cuts, forecasts may be less accurate The union that represents weather service employees says hiring is welcome news, but hardly enough. 'It's a Band-Aid,' said Tom Fahy, the legislative director for the National Weather Service Employees Organization. 'We're still doing triage. We're still plugging the holes and unnecessary vacancies across the country, and 126 [hirings] only starts to provide the healing we need across the country.' In addition to making weather service employees public safety employees, Flood's bill would require an assessment of the NWS workforce and prioritize hiring staffers who regularly launch weather balloons. The Quad Cities forecasting office has been able to keep up with weather balloon releases only because it has gotten help from visiting NWS staffers on temporary assignments. In Sorensen's district, forecasting dictates when farmers plant crops or apply pesticides, when riverfront businesses lay out sandbags to meet Mississippi floodwaters and how pilots approach Quad Cities International Airport. But forecasters earn their keep during this time of year, when the air occasionally becomes heavy, sirens howl and the sky darkens or even turns green. About two weeks ago, on May 20, funnel clouds reported near the Quad Cities airport forced travelers to take cover in the basement and federal air controllers to leave the glass tower that overlooks the landing strips. Schoolchildren at Geneseo Middle School nearby huddled against the wall with hands covering their heads for about 45 minutes, 'Midwest life,' Nathan Dwyer, 12, said of the well-rehearsed ritual, which is directed, in part, by meteorologists who analyze federal radar systems and then send off warnings that light up smartphones and provide the radar images you see headlining TV newscasts. The cuts to weather service staffing has left some in the community — including Nathan's mom — wondering whether they will continue to have the same level of safety and emergency information as in the past. 'I want to be confident that if there is severe weather heading my way that I'm informed,' said Megan Dwyer, a farmer near Moline, Illinois. 'I want senior meteorologists that are behind the scenes making sure that these models are being updated and accurately reflect what's happening.' On May 20, that's exactly what happened. Alex Gibbs, the lead meteorologist at the Quad Cities National Weather Service, fired off tornado warnings after he recognized a 'typical setup' for tornadic rotation on radar. 'I've been doing it for 15 years. It's like riding a bike, honestly,' he said. Much of what makes up a tornado warning comes from the specialized computer systems and decades of data that now power the weather models that can forecast extreme weather — but not all of it. Meteorologists like Gibbs remain a crucial piece of the system. Gibbs said he honed a 'gut' instinct for recognizing the patterns that develop into tornadoes when he was chasing storms in graduate school. In the end, nothing touched down, and the event was just a scare. On Tuesday, the region counted eight small twisters, which downed trees and derailed train cars. Some in the Quad Cities are concerned that there will be little margin in a major severe weather outbreak and that long hours will grind down the 14-person staff down over time, leaving the community vulnerable. Wolf, the retired Davenport meteorologist, said he's worried. As many as 12 employees used to simultaneously staff severe weather outbreaks, he said. The cuts leave fewer people for reinforcements, particularly if other forecasting offices are tied up in their own weather crises. 'When you have a staff of 14 and you need 10 people, now, all of a sudden, you're in a world of hurt,' Wolf said. 'If we have a big, severe weather event in the next week or two, I'm sure they will carry on and do a really good job with it as they have historically. The challenge comes when you're stressing the whole system time after time after time.' Brian Payne, the emergency manager for Scott County, Iowa, who works closely with the office, said that it was providing a similar level of service so far and that he hadn't noticed any issues. 'We rely very heavily on them,' Payne said, adding that he was concerned about staffing and change at the agency. 'They sound tired.' A former National Weather Service employee with knowledge of the situation in Davenport said the staff's professionalism and dedication were preventing worse outcomes. 'They all pitch in and work the hours and crazy shifts to get the job done,' said the former employee, who was concerned that speaking out would make the office a target. 'I just feel bad for the staff. There's a lot of weight on their shoulders.' Sorensen said employees fear retribution and are scared to speak out. 'These are my friends. These are my colleagues. I went to college 25 years ago with the meteorologist-in-charge here,' Sorensen said, referring to Friedlein. 'They're nervous that what they say may have a political ramification, and then somebody much like a bully back in high school will come and knock them down for no reason, right?' The concerns in the Quad Cities office reflect a challenging national staffing picture. The office is one of 35 of 122 forecasting offices without permanent meteorologists-in-charge to lead them, according to an agency list. As of last month, about 43% of forecasting offices had staffing vacancy rates above 20%, according to Fahy. At least six offices have vacancy rates high enough that they have shuttered overnight services, leaving the areas they service vulnerable to overnight surprises. Congressional Democrats from California, where offices in Sacramento and Hanford are closed overnight, have railed against the cuts, calling them the 'beginning of a public safety crisis with potentially catastrophic consequences.' In Florida, John Morales, a meteorologist for NBC South Florida, said that the quality of hurricane forecasts would be 'becoming degraded' because of staffing shortages and weather balloon cuts and that he couldn't be confident in them. Flood, the Nebraska Republican, said he found an office sapped of life when he visited with staffers in the agency's Omaha-area office as the federal government was offering early retirement. 'I could see it in their eyes. They were burnt-out. They were concerned. There were people there that, you know, have been there for 30 years that were taking the retirement buyout,' he said. When the office could no longer launch weather balloons, Flood said, his constituents took notice, and he felt compelled to intervene. 'This is not a partisan issue,' Flood said. 'People understand how valuable the National Weather Service is. And a lot of times people take them for granted because they've always been there.' Evan Bush Evan Bush is a science reporter for NBC News. Chase Cain Chase Cain is a meteorologist for NBC News.
