Ireland U-turns to oppose EU pharma reforms after intense lobbying
Ireland has pivoted to oppose contentious
European Union
reforms aimed at broadening access to new drugs and medicines, following a blitz of lobbying from big
pharmaceutical
companies over recent months.
The proposed reforms would cut back a current eight-year window pharma companies have to exclusively sell new drugs they produce, before cheaper generic competitors enter the market.
Taoiseach
Micheál Martin
, Ministers and senior civil servants have all been on the receiving end of a significant push from the pharma sector, to get Ireland to adopt a pro-industry position in the EU debate.
Irish health officials had been keen on the reforms improving access to new drugs. Allowing generic drugmakers into the market earlier would potentially result in cheaper prices for the
Health Service Executive
when buying medicines for public patients.
READ MORE
Speaking on Thursday, Minister for Enterprise
Peter Burke
confirmed the
Government
had shifted its stance. It now 'accepted' companies should retain the current eight years of market dominance over new drugs they developed, he said.
This means Ireland has joined Denmark, Germany, Italy, Sweden and several other EU countries who support the pharma industry's position, heading into a vote in Brussels in the coming weeks.
A compromise that would encourage companies to conduct more clinical trials in EU states, to earn back one lost year of protection from generic rivals, is the other option on the table in the vote.
The original idea was to allow companies win back extra years of 'protection' over their research and data from clinical trials if they rolled out new drugs across the EU more quickly.
[
US tariffs on pharmaceuticals risk shortages of lower-cost generic drugs
Opens in new window
]
Pharmaceutical firms staunchly oppose the proposals, which they claimed would make companies less likely to develop new medicines in Europe.
Several pharma giants based in Ireland, such as
Pfizer
,
Eli Lilly
,
Novo Nordisk
and
Johnson & Johnson
(J&J), stepped up pressure on the Government to back the industry line, new logs of lobbying disclosures show.
Much of the lobbying focused on getting the ear of Mr Martin and
Department of the Taoiseach
secretary general John Callinan.
Oliver O'Connor, head of the
Irish Pharmaceutical Healthcare Association
(IPHA), argued that there were alternative ways to improve access to new medicines, in recent correspondence to several departments.
The industry group chief wrote to Mr Martin directly, calling for the Government to take account of the major role the pharma sector played in Europe's economy, lobbying disclosures show.
A lobbyist from J&J raised the matter with
Robert Watt
,
Department of Health
secretary general, on the margins of a think tank event in Dublin earlier this year. The pharma firm followed up in writing afterwards, making the case for 'protecting' the existing system.
When the new Government was formed both Minister for Health
Jennifer Carroll MacNeill
and Mr Burke got letters of congratulations from the head of J&J's Irish operations, Michaela Hagenhofer.
The US pharma company asked that support for companies' intellectual property rights 'be reflected' in Ireland's position at the European level, according to filings disclosing the lobbying.
Danish pharma giant
Novo Nordisk
, which makes the blockbuster weight-loss drug
Ozempic
, also made representations. The head of Novo Nordisk's Irish operation, Nina Therese Hovland, lobbied Minister for Finance
Paschal Donohoe
at a dinner hosted by consulting firm
EY
.
United States
president
Donald Trump
's threat of coming trade
tariffs
on pharmaceutical imports has put pressure on the Government to signal it supports the sector, which is a major employer and corporate tax contributor.
Mr Martin met a delegation representing the Irish and European pharma industry in Government Buildings in mid-April. Lobbying logs show the meeting discussed trade tariffs and the EU reforms.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
37 minutes ago
- Irish Times
‘It is our Christmas': Eid celebrations in Tallaght a mix of faith and fun
At the National Basketball Arena in the Dublin suburb of Tallaght, it was a mix of quiet holiness and children's laughter. Men and women bowed and prayed fervently in one part of the venue while children played everywhere else. That was a precursor to when the praying ended and a fleet of bouncy castles sprouted, seemingly out of nowhere, like mushrooms in a field following a hot August night. About 4,000 people attended Eid al-Adha, with food stalls positioned inside and out. The aroma of barbecued meat filled the air and flavoured the day. Eid marks the end of Ramadan fasting and is one of the two great festivals in the Muslim calendar. 'It is our Christmas ,' said Mohamed Nasr from Egypt, who works in tech and has been in Ireland for five years. He was at the arena because of the dispute at the Islamic Cultural Centre (ICCI) in Dublin's Clonskeagh which has resulted in its closure. The dispute has arisen out of the alleged unlawful appointment of new directors to the centre's operating company, the Al Maktoum Foundation CLG. READ MORE Nasr lives near the ICCI. 'I'm listening to both sides,' he said, noting that the next High Court hearing involving the centre will be in late June. Regardless of the closure, he says 'people have to celebrate, they have to enjoy themselves'. Eid at the arena was hosted by the South Dublin Islamic Centre, which was set up in 2020. Eid celebrations also took place at Croke Park on Friday. It was Ahmed Elsayed's first Eid at the arena. Normally, he would celebrate it at the ICCI. Elsayed, who also works in tech, said the Tallaght venue was 'the place to be on a nice day'. Outside the arena, a man registered his displeasure that such an event was taking place there. He had a camera phone in one hand and the leash of his calmer German Shepherd in the other. He made unfounded claims about St Patrick's Day now being called Green Day, along with other anti-immigration rhetoric.
Irish Times
40 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Leaving Cert student diary: ‘I'm proof there's an alternative to incredibly stressful exams'
I'm only young, so it's fair to say I don't follow the ins and outs of education policy. But I do hear, from my friends and on the news, about how incredibly stressful the Leaving Cert is and how it needs to be reformed. I and the other 4,512 students sitting the Leaving Cert Applied [LCA] are living proof that there is a different way. The LCA means students like me, who prefer practical and vocational approaches, are not left behind. I know Ireland is trailing other European countries in terms of offering this vocational option, although the numbers sitting the LCA are growing every year. The LCA offers entry routes to college too. I am hoping to get into a post-Leaving Cert course: nursing studies at Moate ETB [education and training board]. It gives us a foundation in nursing, includes practical experience and a work placement, and is also linked to a general nursing course at TUS [Technological University of the Shannon]. READ MORE Over the past few years, I decided to learn sign language. I'm not doing it as an examined subject, but I felt that it would be a really useful skill for a nurse to have, as it means I can communicate with more people. I'm not fluent, but I can hold a basic conversation and I hope to improve. As for the exams? It's a case of so far, so good. I appreciated the layout of the papers and they haven't been as difficult as I expected. English and communications was probably my best so far, as a lot of the topics I studied appeared. Hotel catering and tourism, however, was probably the most challenging, although still achievable. In this subject, we learn about restaurants, tourist sites and we work on menus for parties and for people with food allergies and intolerances, such as coeliac disease. LCA students have already done a lot of projects and continuous assessment throughout the year, so that relieves the pressure of a single, high-stakes exam. [ Leaving Cert and Junior Cycle: Record 140,000 to sit State exams Opens in new window ] I can't believe the end is in sight, as I finish up on Tuesday with an exam on construction and graphics. I'll miss my classmates in school. There's only been eight of us in the entire LCA programme, so we became tight-knit. I currently commute for over an hour every day to and from school. This is because we moved a few years ago but I wanted to stay in the same school. I wish there was better public transport, particularly for rural areas, as there's currently only two buses a day. It's safe to say that I won't miss this commute. – Amy Cox is a Leaving Cert Applied student at Athlone Community College
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Unions to meet with Wellman examiner to discuss possible sale
Unions representing about 200 of the 217 staff at the Wellman recycling plant in Mullagh, Co Cavan will meet with examiner Kieran Wallace of Interpath Advisory on Monday as part of an effort to find a buyer for the facility and prevent job losses. The unions say the plant has considerable untapped potential and safeguarding it and its workforce should be a particular priority for government given its environment significance. Its parent company, Indorama Ventures, says it has lost 'double-digit millions across 2023 and 2024' and needs to be financially restructured. Mr Wallace, of Interpath Advisory was appointed interim examiner on Tuesday. Having opened in 1973 under American ownership, the facility in Mullagh was taken over by Thai based Indorama Ventures in 2011. At one point it employed more than 500 people and the unions claim it has been run down by its current owners. READ MORE The factory recycles plastic bottles and other waste and is capable of producing polyester fibres and other products including car components. Union representatives briefed local TDs on what they believe is the potential of the plant on Thursday evening and hope to persuade the examiner to allow them speak with prospective buyers. A meeting with management is also scheduled for next Wednesday. 'I think the hope would be that Government would take a particular interest is saving the plant given the context of Ireland's recycling policies,' said Michael O'Brien of Unite. 'The examinership did not come as a huge surprise to the people working at Wellman but they are not fatalistic about the situation at all and they want to be involved in the process to find a buyer because they believe they can help highlight its potential.' Indorama, which operates a large network of facilities internationally has cited high energy costs and competition from China and other regions. It has said its board believes the plant 'does have a potential future'. It says, however, that some jobs may be lost during the examinership process and there is concern among the three unions with members there, Siptu and Connect as well as Unite, that the terms offered may fall short of previous voluntary packages. Siptu's Alan Clark said he is optimistic a buyer can be found to take the operation over as a going concern. 'It's a very versatile facility and we certainly believe there is the potential for it to continue.' Despite the number of jobs at the site having reduced over time, Wellman remains a major employer in Cavan and important to the local economy.
