‘There Is No Place for Us' Review: Trapped in a Shadow Realm
When we first encounter Celeste Walker, she is paying weekly rent for a room at a shabby extended-stay motel in a run-down part of Atlanta. Eight months earlier, the single mother of three had returned from working at a warehouse to find her home destroyed by an arsonist, a man she once dated. With the house unlivable, she stopped paying rent and eventually received an eviction notice from the landlord, lowering her credit rating and hampering her ability to rent elsewhere. She and her children then went through a series of temporary living arrangements, including her car. She also discovered she had cancer and was forced to cut back on her working hours for treatment. Finally, she found a room she could afford at a place frequently visited by county health inspectors, but full of people facing problems like hers. According to the Atlanta school system, that made her and her children officially 'homeless,' since they had no place to call their own.
Grab a Copy
There Is No Place for Us: Working and Homeless in America
By Brian Goldstone
Crown
We may earn a commission when you buy products through the links on our site.
Buy Book
Amazon Barnes & Noble Books a Million Bookshop
Celeste—not her real name—heads one of five Atlanta families portrayed in Brian Goldstone's poignant 'There Is No Place for Us: Working and Homeless in America.' Over a three-year period starting in 2019, Mr. Goldstone, a journalist, immersed himself in their lives and interviewed dozens of social workers, landlords, attorneys, activists, public officials and others involved with them. His ethnography seeks to rebut the view that the homeless are people who suffer from afflictions such as substance abuse or mental illness and live on the streets or in shelters. A far larger group, he contends, work regularly, sometimes at more than one job, but cannot afford stable accommodations and move—or are forced to move—repeatedly.
It is difficult not to feel sorry for these families. Through in-depth and often heart-rending accounts, Mr. Goldstone shows why they lack stable housing and face difficulties in acquiring it. But his ideas about how to help them turn out to be superficial and unpersuasive.
Although alcohol, drugs and mental illness caused some of their problems, the women who are the central figures in each family seem to live, according to Mr. Goldstone's account, under a cloud of misfortunes and bad choices such as car accidents, illnesses, broken appliances, unexpected pregnancies, abusive spouses, Covid-19, cancelled leases and lost jobs. Government assistance, social workers and community activists make little difference in their lives (other than by raising hopes before dashing them). Still, they persist, going from low-paying job to low-paying job, finding shelter where they can (including with friends and relatives) and caring for their children as well as possible.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Fox News
21 minutes ago
- Fox News
The Will Cain Show - Monday, June 9
All times eastern Kelsey Grammer's Historic Battles for America Kelsey Grammer's Historic Battles for America Kelsey Grammer's Historic Battles for America FOX News Radio Live Channel Coverage
CBS News
23 minutes ago
- CBS News
Ross Township woman ready to move after months of sky-high electric bills
A woman in Ross Township said she is ready to move after paying hundreds of dollars in electric bills for months. Jaden Hunzeker lives alone with her cat at Alder Ridge in Ross Township. She is in a one-bedroom apartment, but her electric bills tell a different story. "I was getting bills that were $400 a month for electric," she said. "Looking at the charges like $200 for a DLC charge, your supply is also around $200. I was like that doesn't make sense. I actually thought I was paying for someone else's." She said Duquesne Light told her that's not the case and checked her meter, saying everything looked good. But the high bills kept pouring in last fall and through the winter and the spring. "They offered me to do the budgeting plan," she said. "I do the budgeting plan, but my outstanding balance was still skyrocketing high every month." February's bill showed $203 worth of Duquesne Light charges and $207 supply charges for a total of $410. It also showed a current monthly usage of 2,149 total kilowatt-hours. While Duquesne Light does not have a publicly available average kWh usage for a one-bedroom apartment, the United States Power Outage map says an average bill in Pittsburgh for a one-bedroom apartment is around $121.41 per month, with an average consumption of 690 kWh. Hunzeker's numbers are three times higher. For comparison, she talked to friends who live nearby. "Who are in an over 5,000-square-foot house paying $120 electric a month," she said. KDKA Investigates reached out to Duquesne Light, and it recommended the budget building for customers concerned about high bills. But Hunzeker is already using that. Duquesne Light added that an average customer living in an all-electric place could use more than 200 percent more electricity compared to a customer who uses non-electric heating. "That can be half a paycheck just going to electric," Hunzeker said. "I've called them numerous, numerous times and asked to speak to higher-ups as much as I could to try to figure this out, and I just keep getting rejected." "What options has this left you with?" KDKA's Meghan Schiller asked. "Debt," Hunzeker said. "Neighbors picking up part-time jobs just to afford the electric if they don't want to do the budget." KDKA dropped into the leasing office at Alder Ridge to ask if it's an infrastructure issue, with potentially older buildings, windows and heating and air conditioning, but did not hear back on Monday.
CBS News
an hour ago
- CBS News
Baltimore harbor fuel spill cleanup on track after initial estimate ballooned to 5,000 gallons, mayor says
The diesel sheen remains visible on the water in Harbor East, where 5,000 gallons of fuel spilled on June 4, as estimates surged past initial reports of the amount of diesel in the water. You can still see the diesel sheen on the water in Harbor East where 5,000 gallons of fuel spilled last week as estimates surged past initial reports of the amount of diesel in the water. CBS News Baltimore Bigger than initial estimates At first, authorities thought 200 gallons of fuel had spilled. That quickly grew to 2,000 gallons, then to 5,000 gallons. The latest eye-catching estimate was contained in a single sentence in the third paragraph of a joint news release from Baltimore Mayor Brandon Scott and Maryland Gov. Wes Moore on Friday night. "As part of their ongoing cooperation, Johns Hopkins reported an update that approximately 5,000 gallons of diesel fuel are believed to have leaked," the joint statement read. "There continue to be no impacts to drinking water or air quality in the area." Mayor Scott's response At City Hall on Monday, WJZ Investigator Mike Hellgren asked Mayor Brandon Scott about ongoing remediation efforts and whether he was confident about the 5,000-gallon estimate. "What we've heard from Hopkins is they are very confident that that is the amount," Scott said. "We obviously as a city cannot be the folks; we're not going to take the responsibility for saying how much because we didn't spill it." The ballooning amount of fuel that made its way into the Harbor came as a shock to some in Harbor East. "How could they not have known that in the first place if the truck had a certain amount of capacity?" asked Maryland resident Eric Smith. "We know that numbers are going to change, and they will be adjusted, but at least give us—best case scenario, it was this, the worst case scenario, it will be this." WJZ saw on Monday more protective barriers in the water and crews monitoring the area. The response is scaled down as the spill transitions from an emergency to remediation, the city said. Streets have all reopened, and water taxi service is back to normal. How did the fuel spill happen? The spill began on the Johns Hopkins Hospital campus on Fayette Street near Broadway when a contractor overfilled emergency generators. That diesel fuel washed through the storm drains to the Baltimore Harbor. Johns Hopkins has promised to pay to clean it up. "As I spoke to [Baltimore Fire] Chief Wallace last night, he felt very confident we were in the place where we needed to be, being able to open up some of the roads and things like that," Mayor Scott said. "The team has done a great job. We'll just continue to monitor as we move forward and make the adjustments necessary. But as of right now, the remediation of this has gone as smoothly as possible," Mayor Scott said. Ryan Workman, from Taylor Oil Company of Brooklyn Park, told WJZ that backup generators can have 10,000-gallon tanks. Environmental impact Dr. Scott Knoche, with Morgan State University, studies the economic impact on the environment from fuel spills. He also directs the Patuxent Environmental & Aquatic Research Laboratory. "It's nice to have a responsible party already identified and one that is committing to the process," Knoche said. "Those longer-term impacts can take months or years, or in some cases longer than that, to fully understand." WJZ cameras spotted many turtles in the canal along Lancaster Street, which has been cleared of pools of fuel. WJZ cameras spotted many turtles in the canal along Lancaster Street, which has been cleared of pools of fuel. CBS News Baltimore That diesel fuel was easy to spot because of its red dye. "The greater the magnitude, the more of the fuel in the water—all else equal—you're going to have greater chances of injuries, but that being said, the response appears to have been fairly quick," Knoche said. "I'm encouraged by the rapid response. Again, no one wants to see anything like this happen, and I'm sure there will be lessons learned to prevent the next one from occurring, and that's important, too." The Waterfront Partnership still expects the Harbor Splash public swimming event for June 21 to continue. The Maryland Department of the Environment is now leading the remediation efforts at the scene.
