Penfolds' new wine is controversial and boasts a super-sized price tag. What's the fuss about?
At $3500 a bottle, Penfolds-Jaboulet La Grange is sure to be a bloody fine wine.
What should we make of the latest crazily priced Penfolds wine, the French-Australian shiraz, Penfolds-Jaboulet La Grange? Is it just marketing?
―A.C., Wangaratta, VIC
Wine has long had one foot in the luxury business. First Growth Bordeaux, Château d'Yquem and grand cru Burgundy have been luxury wines for centuries. Now California, Tuscany, Champagne and dozens of other regions have luxury wines because there are more prosperous people in the world who want to drink them. Penfolds' owner, Treasury Wine Estates, is committed to joining the global luxury goods business.
The controversial wine is a 50/50 blend of Penfolds Grange with one of the most exalted French wines, Paul Jaboulet's Hermitage La Chapelle, which is also a syrah (shiraz). Both parts are 2021 vintage and the price is $3500 for one bottle. To some collectors, it doesn't matter that they could buy a bottle of each and blend them in their kitchen for a lot less money ($1800).
International blending of wine isn't rare. Jacob's Creek bottles and Coolabah casks had Chilean wine in them last century when – it's hard to believe now – we had a shortage of grapes.
Up until the early 20th century, it was common, in Bordeaux, to blend wine from other parts of France to bolster its red in bad years. Château Palmer revived this recently with its Historical XIXth Century Wine, which blends Rhône Valley syrah with Bordeaux cabernet and merlot.
Penfolds also makes special bottlings that blend South Australia wines with those from California and Bordeaux.
'Collectors could buy a bottle of each and blend them in their kitchen for a lot less money ($1800).'
At the end of the day, the Penfolds-Jaboulet La Grange is sure to be a bloody fine wine. Indeed, all of the Pennies wines with the super-sized price tags that I've tasted over the years are excellent and very age-worthy, so they satisfy the collector/speculator buyer as well as the wine-loving drinker.
It's not for me – it's not aimed at anyone on a wine-writer's budget – but I don't have a complaint about the fact that it exists, as some critics evidently do.
Psst! If anyone out there has a bottle of the La Grange, I'd love to try it.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Herald Sun
38 minutes ago
- Herald Sun
Andrew Forrest calls for end to Russian fuel imports
Don't miss out on the headlines from Victoria. Followed categories will be added to My News. 'Australian mums and dads should not be funding Putin's war machine,' Dr Forrest told the Herald Sun after it was revealed the Kremlin had received $1.85bn in taxes from crude oil exports that have, via Indian refineries, ended up in Australian fuel tanks since 2023. Calls have grown for Australia and other Western nations to close a loophole that allows third-party nations such as India, Turkey and China to refine Russian crude feedstock into petroleum and legally export it as a 'substantially transformed' product. Dr Forrest, recently named one of Time Magazine's 100 most influential people, said 'we need comprehensive reform of sanctions law to effectively police Russian fossil fuel imports.' 'The fossil fuel economy will always create dependencies on tyrants. The geostrategic need for green fuel independence is now.' Through his Minderoo Foundation, Dr Forrest has provided $20m in emergency aid to Ukraine for those impacted by the war and committed another $765m to post-conflict rebuilding, focusing on green energy and digital infrastructure. The Australian Federation of Ukrainian Organisations, a peak body for the diaspora, is also calling on major fuel retailers, including BP and Ampol, to prohibit imports from foreign refineries that use Russian crude, in particular the Jamnagar Refinery in India which has exported much of the estimated $3.7bn in fuel to Australia that contains Russian feedstock which generates taxes for autocrat Vladimir Putin. AFUO wants the Albanese government to close the sanctions loophole, mandate transparency on the crude origin of fuel and pursue international co-operation on the issue. The group's chair, Kateryna Argyrou, has also called for consumer labelling to certify 'clean fuel' standards for motorists and other users to provide confidence their purchases are not helping fund Putin's invasion. An Essential Research survey commissioned by AFUO found 60 per cent of Australians back comprehensive import bans on products made from Russian oil and 60 per cent also want petrol retailers to voluntarily commit to only using refineries that refuse Russian crude.
Perth Now
an hour ago
- Perth Now
EU warning for Australia on China
China is showing 'worrying signs' of deeper alignment with Russia's anti-West agenda, the EU's top diplomat in Australia has warned. The caution has come as Chinese President Xi Jinping and his Russian counterpart Vladimir Putin continue to step up co-operation against a backdrop of the raging war in Ukraine and simmering tensions in the Indo-Pacific. Ambassador Gabriele Visentin said on Wednesday what happens in Australia's neck of the woods is 'completely intertwined' with what happens in Europe. Ambassador Gabriele Visentin says China is showing 'worrying signs' of deeper alignment with Russia's anti-West agenda. NewsWire / Martin Ollman Credit: News Corp Australia 'I cannot possibly comment on the choice that the Australian government has on its defence policies,' the EU's envoy told the National Press Club. 'What I can say is that there is … a clear link between the Chinese and the Russian visions of what the new international rules-based order should be. 'We have seen maybe some worrying signs of military scaling up of China.' Deputy Prime Minister Richard Marles said last week said China's rapidly growing nuclear arsenal is driving 'security anxiety' in Australia. As of mid-2024, China's operational nuclear warheads exceeded 600, according to the US Department of Defence. That was nearly triple what the country was estimated to have in 2020. US Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth also earlier this month warned of an 'imminent' threat from China, saying Beijing could invade the democratically self-governing island of Taiwan as early as 2027. Such a move would deal a major blow to global supply of semiconductors – crucial components in modern tech – and massively disrupt vital trade routes. 'Let me be clear, any attempt by Communist China to conquer Taiwan by force would result in devastating consequences for the Indo-Pacific and the world,' Mr Hegseth told the Shangri La Dialogue. 'There's no reason to sugar-coat it. The threat China poses is real and it could be imminent. 'We hope not but certainly could be.' Mr Hegseth also called on Australia to boost defence spending in a meeting with Mr Marles, who holds the defence portfolio, on the sidelines of the conference. Asked how the EU might intervene in the event of a significant escalation in the Indo-Pacific, Mr Visentin was hesitant to outline any measures but said Europe had a 'vital interest' in keeping the region 'free'. 'I definitely think that the two theatres are completely intertwined,' he said. 'Forty per cent of the global trade towards the EU comes from the Indo-Pacific. 'Therefore, we do have a vital interest that the Indo-Pacific remains free and open. 'It's a matter of our wealth and our prosperity. 'So, of course we have to be aware of what a disruption of the status quo would mean for us as well.' The bloc deployed warships to the Red Sea in early 2024 to protect cargo ships from attacks by Islamist militants in Yemen emboldened by the conflict in Gaza. Mr Visentin also expanded on EU Commission President Ursula von der Leyen's comments last month saying she wanted a deeper 'strategic partnership' with Australia. 'It's not a military alliance,' he said. 'It's a partnership for co-operation on defence issues, including industrial things.' He added 'there is no scope for an understanding in terms of transfer of troops or mutual help and mutual assistance', unlike NATO, which guarantees blanket mutual defence if a member state is attacked.
Sydney Morning Herald
an hour ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
‘Betrayal': NSW to cut battery subsidies as federal scheme kicks in
The NSW government will end its incentive to install a home solar battery from July in favour of an enhanced Commonwealth scheme, and use the savings to encourage households to allow their stored energy to be remotely accessed by the grid. Since last November, NSW consumers have been able to access a rebate of up to $2600 (depending on the size of the battery) to attach storage to their rooftop solar systems. The scheme resulted in 11,400 battery installations across the state in six months. The program will conclude at the end of this month, while the Australian government's $2.3 billion Cheaper Home Batteries Program is set to start on July 1. The federal rebate, announced before the election, will reduce the cost of a battery by about 30 per cent, making it about double the size of the state scheme. Heidi Lee Douglas, chief executive of consumer advocacy group Solar Citizens, said the NSW government had betrayed solar households with its decision and put its legislated net zero targets further out of reach. The NSW Net Zero Commission has warned that NSW would not reach its emissions reduction targets from 2030 to 2050. 'This surprise decision is a blow to solar home owners planning to buy a home battery in coming months, and a betrayal of the prime minister and Federal Minister for Climate and Energy Chris Bowen's assurance that the federal Cheaper Home Batteries program can be 'stacked' with state initiatives,' Douglas said. 'This bizarre decision puts the timely closure of the Eraring coal-fired power plant at risk. A key justification for extending the life of the plant was the lack of energy storage. The Commonwealth stepped in by boosting battery rebates further and now the NSW government is making that transition harder.' The NSW government said the money would remain within its Peak Demand Reduction Scheme, a program designed to reduce electricity demand during peak periods. The government would redirect the funds to double the payments to encourage solar households to sign up to a virtual power plant (VPP) – a group of solar-powered batteries linked by software, which are owned by households and small businesses that have consented for excess stored power to be sold to the grid. Industry support
