‘Another Aussie': Even Schmidt can't ignore elephant in Lions room
There is certainly precedence for picking players who originate from Australia, New Zealand and South Africa – former Crusaders winger Sean Maitland, Dylan Hartley and Matt Stevens, a Junior Springbok, all made the initial selection.
There has been a long history of players from the SANZAAR countries finding their way into the Home Nations' Test teams: in that sense this Lions tour is nothing different, and the 'nothing to see here' argument put forward in some quarters in the northern hemisphere holds water.
There is no doubt, either, that all the SANZAAR Lions have displayed a level of personal commitment and passion for their adopted countries.
But this is really a numbers game, and the volume of SANZAAR players in this year's squad is atypical.
In fact, it might never be repeated because World Rugby changed the eligibility laws at the end of 2020 to extend the residential qualification period from three years to five years.
It was a significant rule change advertised at the time to uphold the 'integrity and sanctity' of the international game, but it came too late to affect this Lions squad.
The second question of whether it matters is an emotive one. Lions icon Willie McBride raised his head above the parapet a few months ago and said he was 'bothered' by the presence of eight players who were not born in either Britain or Ireland.
McBride was subsequently labelled by some as an old man shouting at the clouds, but not so fast. This week, recently retired England halfback Danny Care voiced the same sentiment.
'Whatever I say here, you're going to get stick. You open yourself up to it,' he told the BBC Rugby Union Weekly podcast.
'It doesn't sit that well with me that some of these… both your starting wingers are going to be lads that never, ever once in their childhood or even their mid-20s ever dreamt of wearing a red Lions jersey.'
Loading
In other words, it does matter, and it matters to British and Irish players – this is not simply a topic being beaten up by the venomous Australian media to unsettle the tourists.
Schmidt, of course, has to be careful on the subject. As Ireland coach he benefited from the services of both Bundee Aki, a New Zealander of Samoan heritage, and CJ Stander, a South African, in a famous win against the All Blacks in 2018. And, as he said earlier in the week, he coached Bealham as well.
It would be hypocritical of him to use the SANZAAR players as a stick to beat the Lions with.
But for the rest of us, there is the nagging question of why the Lions have been permitted to turn SANZAAR players against the Wallabies in a series that is ultimately designed to test the quality of the rugby that is being played within the respective borders of the Australia and the British and Irish Isles?
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
7NEWS
2 hours ago
- 7NEWS
Aussies show class to South African hero Aiden Markram despite falling short in WTC final
South Africa have beaten Australia by five ix wickets to claim the World Test Championship at Lord's on Saturday. Needing eight wickets to claim a miracle win, the Aussies started Day 4 brightly with two wickets in the opening session, but opening batter Aiden Markram (136) led the Proteas to victory. Aussie skipper Pat Cummins struck early to remove opposing captain Temba Bavuma in a major early boost. Mitchell Starc clean bowled Tristan Stubbs to leave the South Africans at 4-241, still 41 short of victory. But Markram was rock solid and looked on track to hit the winning runs until he picked out Travis Head and mid-wicket with just six runs required. Recognising the magnitude of Markram's innings, every single Australian on the field went up to the batter to congratulate him on the match-winning knock in a classy move. He received a standing ovation from the Lord's crowd as he left the field. David Bedingham (20 not out) and Kyle Verreynne (seven not out) were there at the end with the latter hiting the winning runs, but Markram was the hero for South Africa. The turnaround for the Proteas has been remarkable. This defining moment comes less than 18 months after they sent a heavily depleted squad to New Zealand so their stars could stay home and play in the country's T20 league instead. South Africa were predictably thrashed 2-0 by the Black Caps, but then went on to complete eight wins in a row to claim an unexpected Test title. It was Australia's first loss in a world final since England beat them to claim the 2010 T20 title. Since then, Australia have won two ODI World Cups (2015, 2023), a T20 trophy (2021), and the 2023 WTC decider against India at The Oval. Their record in global finals goes to 8-4, dating back to the first ODI World Cup back in 1975. Australia have been the cause of much of South Africa's pain, beating them in ODI World Cup semi-finals in 1999, 2007 and 2023. South Africa's run chase was the second-highest successful pursuit in fourth-innings in a Test at Lord's, equal with England's 282 against New Zealand back in 2004. In a final that exceeded the hype, South Africa boldly took it up to the Australians from the moment Bavuma decided to bowl first after winning the toss. Beau Webster (72) and Steve Smith (66) carried Australia on the first day, rolled for 212 after Proteas spearhead Kagiso Rabada fired with 5-51 in his first Test since receiving a one-man ban for testing positive to cocaine. But Australia's pace artillery struck back in typical fashion, running through the Proteas for only 138 thanks to Pat Cummins' 6-28. During one of his greatest spells, the star quick became the eighth Australian take 300 Test wickets, joining teammates Nathan Lyon and Mitchell Starc. But the first-innings lead of 74 quickly seemed like nowhere near enough when Australia suffered a collapse of 5-29 in just 45 minutes late on day two. Starc (58 not out) and Alex Carey (43) steered them out of dire trouble, but batting became significantly easier at the start of day three to give South Africa's batters confidence they could complete the chase. Smith in doubt for West Indies series Star batter Steve Smith has avoided surgery after suffering a 'gruesome' compound dislocation of his finger at Lord's. In a major blow for Australia's immediate and long-term prospects, Smith hurt his right little finger in a crucial moment of the World Test Championship final on Friday. The 36-year-old left hospital to return to the team hotel on Friday night and was back at Lord's on Saturday watching on. His finger was washed and disinfected at hospital, later placed in a splint. The wound should heal in two weeks, and he will be able to play if he can tolerate wearing a splint while batting. Smith will be required to keep his finger in a splint for up to eight weeks. Australia's first Test against the West Indies begins in Barbados on June 25, followed by matches in Grenada and Jamaica. One of the greatest red-ball batters of all time, Smith's possible absence will be a major blow after scoring four centuries from his past six Tests in a stunning late-career resurgence. But Smith's misfortune could give out-of-form teammate Marnus Labuschagne a reprieve. The 30-year-old Labuschagne averaged less than 30 in this WTC cycle over the past two years, with his last century coming back in July 2023. A long-term No.3, Labuschagne moved up to open for the first time in his Test career for this match. But the promotion failed to snap him out of his lean spell, making 17 and 22. Teenage tyro Sam Konstas, who announced himself last Boxing Day, is set to be given an opportunity as opener for Australia's first tour of the Caribbean in 10 years. If Smith can't play, Konstas could slot back in to open with Usman Khawaja, while Labuschagne would likely drop down to No.3. But even Khawaja, who turns 39 this year, is under pressure to keep his Test career going after scores of 0 and 7 in this Test. Wearing a helmet while standing closer in slips than normal, former Australia captain Smith put down a regulation chance off Mitchell Starc that would have dismissed Proteas captain Temba Bavuma for only two. Smith immediately left the field in immense pain after spilling the catch that would have put Australia in the box seat to claim back-to-back WTC titles. Instead, Bavuma combined with Aiden Markram for an unbeaten 143-run stand to put South Africa in reach of a famous victory by stumps on day three.
The Age
2 hours ago
- The Age
After decades of heartbreak, South Africa clinch historic victory over Australia in world Test final
London: Australia have lost their World Test Championship title to South Africa after the Proteas pulled off a nervy fourth innings chase at Lord's, to end decades of trauma in big finals. Aiden Markram (136) guided his side to within just six runs of victory with a magnificent century before he was finally caught by Travis Head off Josh Hazlewood, but the damage was already done. Just minutes after the crowd stood to applaud Markram as he left the field, keeper-batsman Kyle Verreynne hit Mitchell Starc through the covers to clinch a remarkable five-wicket victory after Pat Cummins' men made the Proteas sweat by keeping runs tight and taking the wickets of Temba Bavuma and Tristan Stubbs. Australian desperation was underlined by how Cummins burned through all his team's three DRS referrals in the space of about an hour as he tried to gamble for wickets. They also appealed for a catch at short leg off Travis Head's boot, but replays showed the ball had hit the ground first. Even Verreynne would have been sent on his way late, caught behind attempting to ramp Starc. It was ultimately a decisive triumph for the South Africans, who claimed their first win in a major global tournament final after years of near misses, most recently at last year's Twenty20 World Cup in the Caribbean. All up, their heartbreak in knockout games at the biggest tournaments – the men's 50-over world cup, the Twenty20 world cup, and the men's Champions Trophy – spanned two quarter-finals, 12 semi-finals and one final. 'Years in the waiting… [against] the biggest opposition, in Australia, they've given us so much heartache over the years, but now the exclamation mark of an ICC event,' said former Proteas skipper Shaun Pollock in commentary after the winning runs were struck. 'They'll be singing, they'll be dancing on the streets of South Africa.' But this win was their eighth Test match victory in as many games. Steve Smith could only watch the final stages from the team balcony in the members' pavilion after suffering a compound dislocation of his right little finger after trying to take a catch on the third day.
Sydney Morning Herald
2 hours ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
After decades of heartbreak, South Africa clinch historic victory over Australia in world Test final
London: Australia have lost their World Test Championship title to South Africa after the Proteas pulled off a nervy fourth innings chase at Lord's, to end decades of trauma in big finals. Aiden Markram (136) guided his side to within just six runs of victory with a magnificent century before he was finally caught by Travis Head off Josh Hazlewood, but the damage was already done. Just minutes after the crowd stood to applaud Markram as he left the field, keeper-batsman Kyle Verreynne hit Mitchell Starc through the covers to clinch a remarkable five-wicket victory after Pat Cummins' men made the Proteas sweat by keeping runs tight and taking the wickets of Temba Bavuma and Tristan Stubbs. Australian desperation was underlined by how Cummins burned through all his team's three DRS referrals in the space of about an hour as he tried to gamble for wickets. They also appealed for a catch at short leg off Travis Head's boot, but replays showed the ball had hit the ground first. Even Verreynne would have been sent on his way late, caught behind attempting to ramp Starc. It was ultimately a decisive triumph for the South Africans, who claimed their first win in a major global tournament final after years of near misses, most recently at last year's Twenty20 World Cup in the Caribbean. All up, their heartbreak in knockout games at the biggest tournaments – the men's 50-over world cup, the Twenty20 world cup, and the men's Champions Trophy – spanned two quarter-finals, 12 semi-finals and one final. 'Years in the waiting… the biggest opposition in Australia, they've given us so much heartache over the years, but now the exclamation mark of an ICC event,' said former Proteas skipper Shaun Pollock in commentary after the winning runs were struck. 'They'll be singing, they'll be dancing on the streets of South Africa.' But this win was their eighth Test match victory in as many games. Steve Smith could only watch the final stages from the team balcony in the members' pavilion after suffering a compound dislocation of his right little finger after trying to take a catch on the third day.
