Sukkwan Island review – a survival drama takes an ill-advised left-turn
As writer-director, Vladimir de Fontenay has taken the central novella Sukkwan Island from David Vann's autobiographical short-fiction collection from 2009, detached it from the surrounding complex constellation of stories related to this main piece and presents it here as a standalone drama of father-son bonding.
The resulting film begins as something forthright and heartfelt; it looks as if it's going to be a liberatingly scary wilderness adventure out there in the real world away from cellphones, social media etc. But with its strenuous yet subdued performances and weirdly cramped and gloomy narrative, it leads us finally into a blind alley: a twist-reveal which I found fundamentally unsatisfying.
Swann Arlaud (the lawyer from Justine Triet's Anatomy Of A Fall) is Tom, a guy who is unhappily separated from Elizabeth (Tuppence Middleton) due to his own now bitterly regretted infidelity. Above all, he misses their now teenage son Roy – played by Woody Norman, the tousle-haired kid from Mike Mills's C'mon C'mon from 2021.
He pleads with Elizabeth to let him take Roy away with him for a stay in a lakeside cabin he has rented on remote Sukkwan Island (in Alaska in the original, now in the Norwegian Fjords) – he promises a glorious time of hunting, fishing and emotional reconnection.
Taking pity on her ex-partner's wretchedness and loneliness, Elizabeth agrees and so does Roy who is initially excited by this extraordinary prospect and by finally getting to know his smart, witty down-to-earth dad on this magically beautiful island. But then he is increasingly alarmed by his father's mood swings and by how obviously unprepared he is to live in this very dangerous place. What have they got themselves into?
Well, the answer to that question appears to recede continually, just out of reach, as the story proceeds. Apparently catastrophic things happen: a bear attacks their cabin while they are out, gobbling their food and damaging their vital two-way radio. Tom grimly shows Roy the firearms he has brought with him, including a revolver – inevitably bringing to mind Chekhov's time-honoured dictum about what happens to a gun produced in Act One. At one stage, Tom falls down a steep incline with weird suddenness and at another stage, Roy passes out, lost in the freezing snow. Yet there appears to be not much in the way of credible, physical consequence to any of this, despite Roy's own increasingly miserable need to return home. And a character called Anna (Finnish star Alma Pöysti) from the mainland is continuously on call with her hydroplane to deliver supplies and help.
Cinematographer Amine Berrada certainly makes the film look lovely, and the performers themselves do their best, but the story feels numb and blank and the ending is unconvincing, raising questions which are not addressed by the final explanatory titles before the closing credits. A frustrating, dislocated experience.
Sukkwan Island is screening at the Sundance film festival and is seeking distribution
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Record
an hour ago
- Daily Record
Tom Jones 'nearly fainted' while recording iconic song
Sir Tom Jones sang the theme tune to the 1965 James Bond film Thunderball, but the iconic singer has now admitted that he 'almost fainted' while belting out the song Sir Tom Jones has shared a dramatic moment from his illustrious career, revealing that he "almost fainted" while belting out the theme tune to the James Bond film Thunderball. The legendary singer, 85, was brought in at the eleventh hour to perform a song that would incorporate the film's title. This decision came after an initial track by Shirley Bassey, and subsequently Dionne Warwick, was scrapped by the film's producers for being too long for the opening sequence. The iconic Johnny Cash submitted a song for the film, but his effort was similarly rejected. In the end, composer John Barry and lyricist Don Black decided to enlist the Welsh superstar Tom for the task. Known for his deep baritone sound, Tom admits the song's final high note was a struggle. The strenuous effort nearly caused him to lose consciousness inside the recording studio, reports Wales Online. During an interview on BBC Radio 2's Sound of the 60s with Tony Blackburn, Sir Tom recounted the experience: "John Barry who wrote the music and Don Black did the lyrics, so John Barry said, 'Hold the note as long as you can because the music is going to go on longer than that, so don't try to hold it until the end. So just hold it as long as you can and then forget it.' I forgot to take a big enough breath." Sir Tom then recounted that the correct lyrics should have been "he strikes like thunder" before taking a deep breath to sing "ball". He added: "But I didn't, so I hit ball and I'm going, and I'm going, and I close my eyes and I go a little flat towards the end there, you'll hear it just at the end, tapering off, because I couldn't hold it any longer. "When I opened my eyes, the room was spinning, so I had to grab hold of the booth I was in to steady myself. I almost went down." The recount of Sir Tom's experience in the studio was confirmed by the songwriter when speaking to Far Out magazine; Don described how Tom "got a head rush" whilst singing the final note. He revealed: "With 'Thunderball' the first thing I did was look it up in the dictionary. So I scratched my head and used it as a code word, you know, 'He strikes like thunderball'. "The thing I remember most is Tom Jones' recording of the song in which he fainted on the last note. He got a head rush or something. The Bond songs I describe as the lure of the forbidden. It should have the whiff of a boudoir about it" Hailing from Treforest near Pontypridd, Tom was chosen to perform the James Bond theme tune barely a year following his chart-topping debut with 'It's Not Unusual'. Nonetheless, the Bond theme 'Thunderball' reached only number 35 in the UK Top 40. Tom has enjoyed an illustrious career boasting 36 UK Top 40 hits as well as 19 US Top 40 entries. His contributions to music were honoured with a knighthood in the year 2006. Regrettably for Tom, his rendition of 'Thunderball' was ranked as the fourth-worst James Bond theme by Classic FM in 2022, with Madonna's 'Die Another Day' taking the unfortunate title of the worst. The publication labelled it "a curiously joyless effort". Meanwhile, Shirley Bassey's 1971 classic Diamonds are Forever clinched the top spot as the best. The iconic Welsh songstress also lent her voice to the themes for Goldfinger in 1964 and Moonraker in 1979.
Wales Online
an hour ago
- Wales Online
Tom Jones says he 'nearly' fainted singing this one iconic song
Tom Jones says he 'nearly' fainted singing this one iconic song Sir Tom Jones was recruited to sing an iconic theme song just over a year after hitting the top of the charts with It's Not Unusual, but he almost had an unfortunate incident in the recording booth Sir Tom Jones almost "passed out" while singing one iconic song (Image: GETTY ) Sir Tom Jones revealed he 'almost fainted' when performing the theme tune to James Bond's Thunderball. The 85-year-old crooner was recruited last minute to record a song that featured the film's title. It came after an earlier track recorded by Shirley Bassey, and latterly Dionne Warwick, was rejected by movie executives as it was too long for the film's opening sequence. Legendary country musician Johnny Cash reportedly submitted his own song for consideration, which was also turned down. Instead, composer John Barry teamed up with lyricist Don Black and recruited Welsh icon Tom for the song. Known for his low baritone sound, Tom admits he struggled with the final note of the song however. It led to a moment where he almost passed out in the recording booth. Speaking on BBC Radio 2's Sound of the 60s with Tony Blackburn, Tom explained: 'John Barry who wrote the music and Don Black did the lyrics, so John Barry said, 'Hold the note as long as you can because the music is going to go on longer than that, so don't try to hold it until the end. So just hold it as long as you can and then forget it.' I forgot to take a big enough breath.' Tom was recruited to record Thunderball at the last minute (Image: GETTY ) Article continues below Sir Tom then explained that he should have sung 'he strikes like thunder' and then took a large breath in before singing 'ball'. He continued: 'But I didn't, so I hit ball and I'm going, and I'm going, and I close my eyes and I go a little flat towards the end there, you'll hear it just at the end, tapering off, because I couldn't hold it any longer. 'When I opened my eyes, the room was spinning, so I had to grab hold of the booth I was in to steady myself. I almost went down.' The singer's version of events in the recording studio was echoed by the songwriter. Speaking to Far Out magazine, Don explained Tom 'got a head rush' singing the final note. He said: 'With 'Thunderball' the first thing I did was look it up in the dictionary. So I scratched my head and used it as a code word, you know, 'He strikes like thunderball'. Tom Jones has had 36 UK Top 40s (Image: Daily Post Wales ) 'The thing I remember most is Tom Jones' recording of the song in which he fainted on the last note. He got a head rush or something. The Bond songs I describe as the lure of the forbidden. It should have the whiff of a boudoir about it' Tom, from Treforest near Pontypridd, was recruited to sing the James Bond theme just a year after his break-out song It's Not Unusual hit number one in the UK charts. The theme song however only reached number 35 in the Top 40. The singer has scored 36 UK Top 40 hits during his career as well as 19 in the USA. He was given a knighthood for services to music in 2006. Unfortunately for Tom, Thunderball was named as the fourth-worst James Bond theme by Classic FM in 2022, with Madonna's Die Another Day chosen as the worst. The publication described it as a "a curiously joyless effort". Article continues below Shirley Bassey's 1971 hit Diamonds are Forever was named as the best. The legendary Welsh singer also recorded the theme songs for Goldfinger in 1964 and Moonraker in 1979.
Daily Mirror
12 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Love Island fans forced to do double-take as 'past winner returns'
Love Island viewers were surprised to see a 'familiar face' when tuning in to the twelfth season of the ITV dating show for the premiere tonight, which saw couples pair up with a twist Love Island fans were surprised during the launch episode of the new series after one Islander's entrance sparked déjà vu, convincing viewers that a former winner had made a shock return. As the boys were introduced in Monday night's premiere, viewers couldn't help but compare new arrival Harry Cooksley to Love Island: All Stars winner Tom Clare. The resemblance was so striking that one fan tweeted: "Is the first one not pink jacket Tom?" Another gasped: "HARRY'S TOM'S DOUBLE!!" Others became suspicious that the wool was being pulled over their eyes by the former cast member, with one suggesting: "Tom really thinks he can trick us by re-entering the villa under 'Harry'. This has Casey's idea written all over it." Someone else agreed, adding: "Tom sneaked in and thought we wouldn't notice." However, the man in question is in fact Harry, a 30-year-old from Guildford who is the oldest member of the original 2025 cast. While he might look like Tom's long-lost twin, he is actually a newcomer to the villa. In the real world, Harry splits his time between playing football for Farnham Town, working in gold trading, and picking up modelling gigs on the side. He even boasts a surprising claim to fame involving England star Declan Rice. Before going on the ITV show, he revealed: "When Declan Rice does a shoot, any body close-ups will actually be me. You'll never see my face, but you'll see my shoulder or chest, that kind of thing." Harry was selected by motivational speaker Sophie Lee, who has been advocating for burn victims ever since she nearly lost her life during a terrible fire-breathing accident in 2019. She was performing in Chicago when an air conditioning unit blew a fireball back into her face and she had to be rushed to the hospital after being in so much pain that she blacked out. Speaking about that difficult time, Sophie shared: "I couldn't breathe by yourself, I couldn't eat, I couldn't really see, it was scary." However, she has also told "I refuse to let [the accident] define me." Meanwhile Tom Clare, who won the All Stars edition earlier this year alongside girlfriend Molly Smith, is now back in pre-season training with his club Macclesfield. He is also still very much in love with Molly. The couple recently returned from a romantic break in the Maldives, where they enjoyed a private dinner under the stars and some much-needed downtime. Although fans have been speculating that a proposal is on the cards, Tom told The Mirror that he is in no rush. He said: "I want to spend the rest of my life with Molly, but there's no pressure in our time or anyone else's." The pair continue to support each other through their respective careers, with Molly often cheering Tom on at his matches, while Tom pops by her photoshoots. "We kind of make the effort," she said, with Tom adding that they're "very similar" and just "banter with one another".
