Sukkwan Island review – a survival drama takes an ill-advised left-turn
As writer-director, Vladimir de Fontenay has taken the central novella Sukkwan Island from David Vann's autobiographical short-fiction collection from 2009, detached it from the surrounding complex constellation of stories related to this main piece and presents it here as a standalone drama of father-son bonding.
The resulting film begins as something forthright and heartfelt; it looks as if it's going to be a liberatingly scary wilderness adventure out there in the real world away from cellphones, social media etc. But with its strenuous yet subdued performances and weirdly cramped and gloomy narrative, it leads us finally into a blind alley: a twist-reveal which I found fundamentally unsatisfying.
Swann Arlaud (the lawyer from Justine Triet's Anatomy Of A Fall) is Tom, a guy who is unhappily separated from Elizabeth (Tuppence Middleton) due to his own now bitterly regretted infidelity. Above all, he misses their now teenage son Roy – played by Woody Norman, the tousle-haired kid from Mike Mills's C'mon C'mon from 2021.
He pleads with Elizabeth to let him take Roy away with him for a stay in a lakeside cabin he has rented on remote Sukkwan Island (in Alaska in the original, now in the Norwegian Fjords) – he promises a glorious time of hunting, fishing and emotional reconnection.
Taking pity on her ex-partner's wretchedness and loneliness, Elizabeth agrees and so does Roy who is initially excited by this extraordinary prospect and by finally getting to know his smart, witty down-to-earth dad on this magically beautiful island. But then he is increasingly alarmed by his father's mood swings and by how obviously unprepared he is to live in this very dangerous place. What have they got themselves into?
Well, the answer to that question appears to recede continually, just out of reach, as the story proceeds. Apparently catastrophic things happen: a bear attacks their cabin while they are out, gobbling their food and damaging their vital two-way radio. Tom grimly shows Roy the firearms he has brought with him, including a revolver – inevitably bringing to mind Chekhov's time-honoured dictum about what happens to a gun produced in Act One. At one stage, Tom falls down a steep incline with weird suddenness and at another stage, Roy passes out, lost in the freezing snow. Yet there appears to be not much in the way of credible, physical consequence to any of this, despite Roy's own increasingly miserable need to return home. And a character called Anna (Finnish star Alma Pöysti) from the mainland is continuously on call with her hydroplane to deliver supplies and help.
Cinematographer Amine Berrada certainly makes the film look lovely, and the performers themselves do their best, but the story feels numb and blank and the ending is unconvincing, raising questions which are not addressed by the final explanatory titles before the closing credits. A frustrating, dislocated experience.
Sukkwan Island is screening at the Sundance film festival and is seeking distribution
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Daily Mirror
Giovanna Fletcher admits 'it's hard leaving' as husband Tom pleads 'can you not'
Giovanna Fletcher and her husband Tom have been married for nearly a decade and have three children together, but the couple have admitted that making time for each other can be difficult Giovanna Fletcher admits "it's always hard" moving on from a production as husband Tom Fletcher pleaded with her not to go away again. Giovanna, 40, is known as the host of the host of the Happy Mum, Happy Baby podcast as well as her novels. She was also crowned Queen on the Jungle on the 20th series of I'm a Celeb. Alongside her life as a celebrated podcaster and author, Giovanna juggles family life with three youngsters, Buzz, 11, Buddy, 9, and seven year old Max, pairing with McFly's frontman Tom Fletcher. Her notable theatre work has seen her light up the West End in shows like 2:22: A Ghost Story and Everybody's Talking About Jamie, coming off a recent tour as the lead in The Girl on the Train. In a chat with Heat magazine about returning to the stage, Giovanna admitted: "Absolutely. It's always hard leaving a show, especially one you love." Tom, the 39-year-old McFly sensation, quipped: "I've only just got her back home. Can you not send her back off on tour, please." Not one to sit idle, Giovanna has matched her bustling agenda with that of her spouse Tom, who is gearing up for an electrifying Busted vs McFly Tour of his own. He's no stranger to penmanship either, having authored books himself, and now he's venturing into the dramatic arts world. Tom has been working diligently, composing lyrics and music for Paddington The Musical, while also adapting his children's book series, The Dinosaur that Pooped, for the stage with The Dinosaur that Pooped A Rock Show. The power couple recently carved out some time for a "rare" evening at The Great Gatsby's press night, with Giovanna commenting on their action-packed lives: "We're very busy". Tom echoed the sentiment, the former Strictly Come Dancing star remarked: "We won't get many nights like this." Childhood sweethearts Tom and Giovanna first crossed paths at the Sylvia Young Theatre School and later sealed their love with a 2012 wedding. Tom's heartfelt wedding speech, where he expressed gratitude to his wife and bandmates, became an internet sensation. Giovanna recently shared insights into the challenges of balancing demanding careers during a podcast, sympathising with a listener's marital difficulties. She confessed: "That's really hard isn't it. I can relate, I feel with Tom if we can manage to watch something together and our feet touch, that's a win." She continued: "I also think being aware that you're so busy that you're juggling, that you're drifting is really really important, because then you can do something about it. I think not being aware of it is the difficult place to be." Furthermore, Giovanna passionately advised against comparing one's relationship to others. She stated: "I think it's so easy to look at other couples out there, whether that's your mates, or online and go 'oh my gosh they've got it sorted'. It's all b******s, total total rubbish."
The Sun
a day ago
- The Sun
Win a copy of The Treasures by Harriet Evans in this week's Fabulous book competition
HARRIET Evans is our go-to author for sweeping cross-generational stories with a family home at the centre – and this first in a trilogy definitely doesn't disappoint. When Alice's golden childhood in the 1950s comes to an abrupt end, she flees to NYC, where she is soon joined by English boy Tom, who's running away from his own past. 1 10 lucky Fabulous readers will win a copy of this new novel in this week's book competition. To win a copy, enter using the form below by 11:59pm on June 21, 2025. For full terms and conditions, click here.
Daily Mirror
a day ago
- Daily Mirror
Tom Jones' late wife's last advice to him as he prepared to lose love of life
Sir Tom Jones was married to his wife Melinda "Linda" Trenchard for 59 years before she died in 2016, and the legendary singer has opened up on her tragic advice to him Sir Tom Jones has opened up about the heart-wrenching final words from his late wife before she succumbed to cancer. The iconic singer was by Melinda "Linda" Trenchard's side during her last days after a life together that spanned 59 years, from their marriage in 1957 until her death in 2016. Celebrating his 85th birthday, Sir Tom recounted the profound advice Linda gave him. Speaking on BBC 's Sounds of the 60s with Tony Blackburn, he shared: "When my wife knew that she had terminal cancer, I was with her for the last 10 days in hospital in the room with her. "She said, 'Look I gotta leave, but you don't fall with me. I'm going down, I know, there's nothing I can do about it but don't you do that.'". He continued to reveal how his beloved Linda urged him to persevere and how those words not only helped him through his grief but also guide him when advising young artists today. "She told me, 'Don't you fall with me, you've got to keep going, you've got to get on stage. You've still got songs to sing and think of me when you do it'." Tom reflected on the levity Linda brought to his life, underlining the importance of laughter and remembrance. He went on to express how Linda's memory gave him the fortitude to carry on with his career despite considering retirement in the wake of her passing, reports Wales Online. "She loved jokes and I used to make her laugh a lot so. Now, she gives me strength as when she passed away I thought I was gonna crumble." Noting the challenge of managing emotions while performing, Sir Tom disclosed how close he came to ending his singing career due to overwhelming emotion: "I almost packed it in. I didn't think I could sing anymore because you can't get too emotional sing when you sing because your voice won't come out." Sir Tom Jones has shared some sage advice for aspiring vocalists, saying, "This is what I say to singers now, you take the emotion and then you work it into the song, get it through, but don't get too involved with it because then you'll cry and you won't be able to sing." Celebrating a milestone, the legendary singer announced on his Instagram: "I'm celebrating my 85th birthday this Saturday! and am thrilled to be sharing a very special concert performance - 'Live on Soundstage 2017' for the first time on my YouTube channel." In addition to joining Tony Blackburn on the BBC, Sir Tom is set to feature in a BBC Arts programme called In My Own Words, as reported by GB News. Reflecting on the opportunity, the iconic Sex Bomb singer expressed: "Taking the time to look back at some of the extraordinary things that have happened in my life for In My Own Words has been really enjoyable and thought-provoking. "Some of the archive I'd not seen before, and watching snippets of those past times, places, styles, and struggles brought home how lucky I am. "Being able to spend the day in the first house I ever owned brought back so many memories... I hope everyone enjoys watching it as much as I did making it!".
