Sukkwan Island review – a survival drama takes an ill-advised left-turn
As writer-director, Vladimir de Fontenay has taken the central novella Sukkwan Island from David Vann's autobiographical short-fiction collection from 2009, detached it from the surrounding complex constellation of stories related to this main piece and presents it here as a standalone drama of father-son bonding.
The resulting film begins as something forthright and heartfelt; it looks as if it's going to be a liberatingly scary wilderness adventure out there in the real world away from cellphones, social media etc. But with its strenuous yet subdued performances and weirdly cramped and gloomy narrative, it leads us finally into a blind alley: a twist-reveal which I found fundamentally unsatisfying.
Swann Arlaud (the lawyer from Justine Triet's Anatomy Of A Fall) is Tom, a guy who is unhappily separated from Elizabeth (Tuppence Middleton) due to his own now bitterly regretted infidelity. Above all, he misses their now teenage son Roy – played by Woody Norman, the tousle-haired kid from Mike Mills's C'mon C'mon from 2021.
He pleads with Elizabeth to let him take Roy away with him for a stay in a lakeside cabin he has rented on remote Sukkwan Island (in Alaska in the original, now in the Norwegian Fjords) – he promises a glorious time of hunting, fishing and emotional reconnection.
Taking pity on her ex-partner's wretchedness and loneliness, Elizabeth agrees and so does Roy who is initially excited by this extraordinary prospect and by finally getting to know his smart, witty down-to-earth dad on this magically beautiful island. But then he is increasingly alarmed by his father's mood swings and by how obviously unprepared he is to live in this very dangerous place. What have they got themselves into?
Well, the answer to that question appears to recede continually, just out of reach, as the story proceeds. Apparently catastrophic things happen: a bear attacks their cabin while they are out, gobbling their food and damaging their vital two-way radio. Tom grimly shows Roy the firearms he has brought with him, including a revolver – inevitably bringing to mind Chekhov's time-honoured dictum about what happens to a gun produced in Act One. At one stage, Tom falls down a steep incline with weird suddenness and at another stage, Roy passes out, lost in the freezing snow. Yet there appears to be not much in the way of credible, physical consequence to any of this, despite Roy's own increasingly miserable need to return home. And a character called Anna (Finnish star Alma Pöysti) from the mainland is continuously on call with her hydroplane to deliver supplies and help.
Cinematographer Amine Berrada certainly makes the film look lovely, and the performers themselves do their best, but the story feels numb and blank and the ending is unconvincing, raising questions which are not addressed by the final explanatory titles before the closing credits. A frustrating, dislocated experience.
Sukkwan Island is screening at the Sundance film festival and is seeking distribution
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Record
2 hours ago
- Daily Record
Prestwick podcaster joins billionaire Sir Tom Hunter in his estate for exclusive in-depth conversation
David McIntosh Jr. and his production team visited Blair Estate, HQ of The Hunter Foundation, last month. Scotland's first home‑grown billionaire, Sir Tom Hunter, sat down with Prestwick podcaster David McIntosh Jr. for a wide-ranging podcast recorded inside 900-year-old Blair Estate. The episode is a full‑circle moment for host David McIntosh Jr. who first met the Ayrshire billionaire 15 years ago when he visited Prestwick Academy to deliver an assembly on aspiration and resilience. David, 26, described this talk as his "sliding-door moment". He said: "Sir Tom walked into my school gym in bright‑white Nikes and rewired what I believed was possible for a kid from Ayrshire. Sir Tom changed the trajectory of my life that day." Born in New Cumnock in 1961, Sir Tom founded the Sports Division and sold it for £290 million in 1998. Subsequently, he and his wife established The Hunter Foundation to channel his wealth towards philanthropic causes, donating over £150 million to various initiatives. David grew up on a council estate, and meeting Sir Tom at the age of 11 he realised that "an idea could outrun any postcode". Three years ago David started his podcast "Origin Story," which was a side-hustle with 1,900 downloads when Sir Tom joined him on Zoom. David said: "He left me with a line I've quoted ever since - 'It's better to ask forgiveness than seek permission.' Last month I put it back to him." David and his production team, consisting of Howie Gardner, Samraj Singh and Andres McNeill, visited Blair Estate, HQ of The Hunter Foundation, earlier last month to record a new episode for the podcast. He said: "Being invited to his castle to interview him felt surreal. It is proof that geography is not destiny and postcode is not potential. "We set our cameras in his private office: deep-green panelling, crackling fire, windows onto sweeping parkland. "In that room we spoke about vans of trainers, scaling Sports Division to £250m exit, cashing out at 37, losing millions in 2008, why Scotland needs political reform and if Sir Tom would run for first minister and appoint a DOGE. "I asked deeply personal questions as well, if money makes him happy, about his hardest career decision and the inexpensive items he values." David believes that this conversation "closed the loop". He said: "A kid who once received free school meals and clothing grants recorded in a castle office with the man who lit the fuse. "This is a significant chapter in my origin story." The full interview will be available on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and YouTube.
Scottish Sun
4 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Race Across The World left out HUGE part of winner's life as fans ask ‘why wouldn't they mention that?'
HORSING AROUND Race Across The World left out HUGE part of winner's life as fans ask 'why wouldn't they mention that?' Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) IT was a tense sprint to the finish line in last night's finale of Race Across The World. But fans were baffled that a huge part of the winner's life had been left out of the series. Sign up for the Entertainment newsletter Sign up 5 It was a tense sprint to the finish line in last night's finale of Race Across The World Credit: PA 5 Mother and son duo Caroline and Tom were thrilled to win Credit: PA 5 But fans were baffled as to why a part of Caroline's life had been cut from the show Credit: BBC The final episode followed the pairs travelling from Goa, India, to the southernmost tip of India, Kanniyakumari, 1000km away. But after a 51-day cross-continent race, it was mother and son duo Caroline and Tom who took home the £20,000 prize. The pair, who were leading the race from its fifth episode earlier this month, beat brothers Melvyn and Brian, sisters Elizabeth and Letitia and young couple Fin and Sioned to the finish point. And it was an emotional moment for the duo, as they opened the all-important guest book on their arrival. Celebrating their win, Caroline broke down in tears telling her son: 'We must never doubt ourselves, ever, ever, ever again.' On-screen Caroline has spoken about giving up her career to become a mum and how the show has given her the chance to do something for herself. But what hasn't aired on the BBC show is that Caroline is a successful eventer. In her everyday life, the Race Across the World winner has a number of achievements under her belt when it comes to horse riding. Just before she joined the show, she won the 2024 British Eventing BE80 grassroots league when riding 14-year-old horse Really. Caroline has had Really for almost a year now, according to British Eventing. Secrets of BBC competition show exposed in one-off special episode after fans slammed 'fake' scenes Since Race Across the World came to an end, she has returned to eventing and has continued to be successful This season, Caroline topped the British Eventing's BE90 March/April OBP League. In May, she told The Horse and Hound: "It's lovely to be back and I'm looking forward to the championship. "Eventing has got a little bit of the challenge of Race Across the World because you have to be prepared, fit, determined and have an aim in mind." Fans questioned on social media why this was never aired in the show and one said: "Horseandhound magazine has an article about Caroline. "A successful eventer for years, and Tom who Caroline had when she was 40. "Have lost trust in this programme and the phoney sob stories. Such a shame." Another added: "Why wouldn't they mention this on the show!" A third explained: "I'm not dismissing her feelings about her role in life, but her whole I'm just a stay at home mum who has never done anything in my life attitude rubs a bit thin when you take her sporting career into account. "She's not just an amateur, she has been doing it for 25 years + (i.e. all the time she was running a house)." Another added: "I don't like how Caroline is making out that she is just some poor housewife who has never had a life when actually she is a very successful eventer." "She is making out that she hasn't done anything for herself since getting married, this is simply not true," explained another. While one poster said: "I think that's more of an age thing, and your children getting older. "My Mum kept going on about having lost her purpose and confidence when I went to uni even though she had a very successful career." But another disagreed: "Caroline is successful in Eventing (horse sport) which, to me, makes her sob story seem a little disingenuous and designed to counter their obvious privilege. "They definitely have grown over the course of the series and become more likeable, I don't think the producers really needed to work as hard on it as they might have thought." Caroline also told the publication that her experience with horses helped her on the TV show and added: "Horsey people are generally quite grounded and extremely tough. "You can put up with being dirty and grubby and you just get on with it, and that really helped because dignity goes out the window very, very quickly. "You don't mind getting your hands dirty in both senses of the word. "And I was quite fit, which was probably the biggest help for me in the long run." 5 Caroline and Tom became closer during the race and were thrilled to win Credit: PA 5 Tom was able to see his mum as a human being with her own needs and desires during the show Credit: BBC Race Across The World is available to stream on BBC iPlayer.
Wales Online
6 hours ago
- Wales Online
Winners of Race Across The World 2025 crowned
Winners of Race Across The World 2025 crowned Housewife Caroline, 60, and 21-year-old Tom became the first mother-and-son team to win Mother and son duo Caroline and Tom were crowned the winners of the fifth series of Race Across the World. (Image: BBC/Studio Lambert ) Mother and son Caroline and Tom have won series five of BBC One's Race Across The World. Housewife Caroline, 60, and 21-year-old Tom became the first mother-and-son team to win after reaching the final checkpoint in Kanniyakumari, the southernmost tip of mainland India, to claim their £20,000 prize. Four teams in the 14,100km (8,761-mile) race successfully crossed Asia, the world's largest continent, to make it to the finish line. During Wednesday's episode, Caroline and Tom had to find Vattakottai Fort where the final sign-in book was waiting. After turning the page to discover they were the first team to make it to the landmark they hugged, overcome with emotion. Writing their names in the book, Tom said: "That's a really good feeling, I'm lost for words, I can't believe it. Article continues below "Fifty-one days racing through countries I never thought I'd go to. "I never thought we'd come this far, I never thought we'd achieve so much and I've never been prouder of my mum – she got me through it." Sisters Elizabeth and Letitia came second, just 19 minutes behind the winners, with teenage couple Fin and Sioned third. Brothers Brian and Melvyn arrived in fourth place, three hours and five minutes behind Caroline and Tom. The winning pair began the last leg in the lead, six hours and 54 minutes ahead of Elizabeth and Letitia. They started from the seventh checkpoint, Panaji in Goa with just over 1,000km (600 miles) to traverse across the southern Indian states to reach the finish line. Reflecting on their win, Tom said the race was "the best experience of my life". Caroline said: "We've learnt so much, we've enjoyed it and to actually win it as well as to have the experience is the best thing that could have happened to us." The contestants traversed areas of China, Nepal and India, covering more than 14,000km over 51 days. Article continues below The teams will reunite for a special episode airing at 9pm on Wednesday June 18 on BBC One where they will reflect on the race and the impact it has had on their lives. All eight episodes of Race Across The World are available to watch on BBC iPlayer.
