Woman pleads guilty to child cruelty in connection to sexual abuse case
A 59-year-old woman has pleaded guilty to child cruelty in connection with sexual abuse, which was perpetrated by her partner on their daughter, over a 13-year period.
She entered the plea to two breaches of the 1908 Children Act at Castlebar Circuit Criminal Court.
The offences took place at a house in the west in 1995 and 2000.
The victim's father is serving an 18-year jail sentence, after pleading guilty to charges including indecent assault, sexual assault and rape, on dates between 1988 and 2001, starting when she was just three years old.
The court heard the abuse perpetrated "was prolific in its frequency" and took place in several rooms in the family home.
The State argued that, based on the knowledge the accused had about the abuse, she had failed in her duty to protect her daughter. This meant the victim had been exposed to sexual abuse on an almost daily basis.
The woman pleaded guilty to two counts of cruelty to a child, on a full facts basis, when the case came before Judge Sinéad McMullan today.
Inspector Thomasina McHugh outlined a timeline of the abuse, telling the court that the victim believed her mother was aware of what was going on, when she was eight years old.
She detailed how the victim remembered her mother returning home one evening, while her father was abusing her on a couch in the sitting room.
Abuse became 'rougher', court told
He was said to have been startled by the accused's unexpected arrival, which was followed by an argument.
The court heard that the victim presented to hospital on several occasions between 1995 and 2000 and that the abuse became "rougher" as she grew older.
Her parents were interviewed after a friend witnessed a sexual assault in September 1998 but no charges were brought.
In early 2001, the victim told a neighbour that she was being abused by her father. On hearing this, her mother told her that if the complaint proceeded, the family would be broken up and her siblings would be taken into care. As a result, the victim withdrew her complaint.
In her statement to gardaí, the victim outlined how she had attempted to tell her mother about the abuse.
"She didn't believe me, when I was brave enough to say he was abusing me", she said.
The abuser has been convicted of the sexual abuse of several other children.
During the course of the investigations into the abuse perpetrated by the man, his wife refused to make a statement when requested by gardaí.
When she was initially arrested in 2019, she denied that she was aware of the abuse but subsequently conceded she had been told of the crimes by the victim's friend and the neighbour.
Judge McMullan acceded to a request by Des Dockery SC, for the accused, that legal aid be extended to cover a psychologist's report on his client. A probation and welfare report will also be completed.
The woman has been remanded on continuing bail and will be sentenced at a later date.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Journal
an hour ago
- The Journal
Tourist ‘ate' passport biometric data and attacked airport official, court hears
A TOURIST TORE out and devoured the biometric data page of his passport after assaulting a Dublin Airport official verifying his identity, a court was told. Palestinian national Hasan Alshaer, 27, with no stated address, was charged with assaulting a customs official at Terminal 1 and an offence under the Immigration Act for failing to produce a passport or document establishing his identity. He appeared at Dublin District Court today following his arrest at 5pm on Tuesday. Court Garda Sergeant Niall Murphy told Judge John King that the allegation was Mr Alshaer presented to an immigration control officer. 'He tried to run away from her taking his passport with him; when she chased after him, judge, it is alleged he struck at her, causing her to fall, he tore out a page of the travel document he was carrying and then ate the page with the biometric data on it.' The sergeant contended that the accused was a flight risk and objected to his bail. Defence barrister Paddy Flynn said his client had money and could stay in a hotel. Mr Flynn said the accused came to Ireland as a tourist and gardaí had his Palestinian passport. Advertisement The sergeant countered that the passport was 'no use' because it cannot be verified properly now. The defence said the man had a second Greek passport, but the State contended that compounded his problem because gardai could not verify who he was. The defence said Mr Alsher had lived in Germany and Greece for five years. Judge King said, 'There is a serious problem here. He arrives in this country, sees immigration, runs, and then tears a page out of his passport, and this page has his biometric data on it, it is alleged. That is a huge problem for him'. Mr Flynn said he was instructed that the man had a residential permit. However, the judge suggested a fingerprint check with Interpol could assist but noted that it could take some time. Sergeant Murphy said that would not be resolved that day, and it was unlikely that the State would now accept any documentary evidence provided by the accused. He added that he did not present a visa or any authority to enter the country on top of allegedly destroying the travel document he initially presented to customs officers. Mr Alsher, who has yet to enter a plea, listened to the proceedings with the aid of an interpreter and remained silent during the hearing, He postponed his bail application. Judge King remanded him in custody to appear again on Friday.
Irish Examiner
an hour ago
- Irish Examiner
MV Matthew crew 'terrified' amid chaos of cocaine trafficking operation, court hears
Crates of cocaine, loaded under cover of night from an armed boat by some crew members while others aboard the MV Matthew were plied with alcohol 'as a distraction' began a descent into chaos which would ultimately lead to their arrest. 'Terrified' and 'alone at sea', the crew said they were then compelled to comply with the major drug trafficking operation directed from Dubai that resulted in Ireland's largest ever cocaine seizure off the Cork coast in September, 2023. Fear permeated the bulk cargo ship, the accused said, with some crew saying they were promised bonuses to 'keep their mouths shut' when they questioned the legality of the cargo. They were told it was 'spare parts' but many of the sailors admitted that they suspected it was illegal contraband — most likely drugs or weapons. Eight men have pleaded guilty to their involvement in a drug smuggling plot in which 2.25 tonnes of cocaine — the largest seizure in the history of the State — was found on the Panamanian registered MV Matthew, a 190-metre-long, 32-metre-wide bulk cargo ship off the Cork coast. All arrested aboard the MV Matthew said they flew to Dubai for interviews before flying on to South America to begin their job. All bar one — Cumali Ozgen — had significant experience at sea and many had multiple maritime qualifications. In mitigation, the men were described as people in difficult circumstances who provided diligently for their families, some of whom suffered ill health. But they were 'expendable' and the 'bottom of the food chain' for the organised crime group running the drug trafficking operation, the Special Criminal Court heard in mitigation. Those directing the operations from Dubai remained thousands of miles away from the ship and 'kept their hands clean'. Military personnel secured the MV Matthew and escorted it into Cork Harbour in September, 2023, after the suspected drugs were found on board in what turned out to be Ireland's largest ever cocaine seizure. File picture: PA Although Mr Ozgen may have been the 'eyes and ears' of those directing the operation from Dubai, there was no suggestion he had an organising role, defence barrister Brendan Grehan SC said. Mr Ozgen had accepted that he loaded three crates with drugs on the MV Matthew and was involved in moving the drugs by hand. He also admitted playing a part in helping to burn the drugs, getting paint thinner to try to intensify the flames, after the ship was stormed by elite army rangers in September 2023, bringing the criminal operation to a sudden and dramatic end. He admitted that he believed he would get a bonus of some 50,000 to 100,000 — euros or dollars. He had a prestigious cabin on the boat, although initially claimed he was a 'cleaner' which 'didn't make sense,' Mr Grehan said. Unlike anyone else on the boat, he had no seafaring experience, although he was described as an 'ordinary seaman'. His role to some extent was tending to the cargo aboard — the drugs, Mr Grehan said. He had no previous convictions and appears to have worked in a series of menial jobs in the past. 'I think it's well established that we're in a hierarchy for those involved in this kind of drug smuggling operation,' Mr Grehan said. He added: The owners or stakeholders keep their hands clean and very far away from any possible exposure. And the people on board were being directed by a company in Dubai and people offboard throughout the operation, he said. These voices from off the boat directed the crew not to comply with directions from the Irish naval ship, despite warning shots being fired. They also directed them to burn the drugs and get rid of all phones, he said. One 'caring' message told the crew that the organisers were not interested in 'one dollar out of this' and they did not want anyone going to jail, telling them to 'head to Sierra Leone'. 'Perhaps it is not surprising that people felt obliged to comply with the wishes of people in that organisation,' he said, given the power of the organised crime gang that appeared to be involved. 'Mr Cumali Ozgen asked me to apologise to the people of the court and to the people of Ireland. 'He got involved in a misguided attempt to get money to assist his family, particularly his son [who suffered a brain tumour and required surgery]. He regrets every day how stupid he was to get involved in this matter. He wanted to make money but finds himself getting no money, no financial reward and facing a lengthy custodial sentence. Harold Estoesta was a recently qualified 2nd Officer. He was assigned a communication role on the boat, perhaps because of his strong command of English, his barrister Michael Hourigan SC said. He was not happy about this but had to take orders, he said. He said he was told the boat had to take on a cargo of spare parts. Fears about possible contraband He was directed to assist on the night the cargo was brought aboard, but some of the other crew were to be given as much alcohol as possible. When he saw armed men on the boat unloading the cargo he became extremely concerned that they were loading contraband — drugs or weapons. But he was then 'terrified' and 'alone at sea' so felt he must comply. He was told that everyone would get bonuses, when he raised concerns that the cargo was not spare parts. 'Ships can be very dangerous places and countless sailors go missing every year,' his barrister, Mr Hourigan said. 'He made certain choices but I ask you to contextualise, fear was present on his part. 'Essentially, he was threatened on the boat,' he said. Mr Estoesta was of good character with no previous convictions. At 31, he was accomplished, having been a government scholar in the Philippines. The captain, Iranians Soheil Jelveh, 51, was highly qualified and had no previous links to organsied crime, barrister Keivon Sotoodeh said. His wife has cancer and his daughter, 22, is studying in Istanbul. His son is 20. He has been the family's sole breadwinner, he said. Two Ukrainians who had escaped to Romania after Russia invaded their country, were also arrested from the MV Matthew. Vitaliy Vlasoi, who turned 33 on Tuesday, was brought up by his mother, a kindergarten teacher, and studied at the maritime college in Odessa before beginning his professional life as a sailor. Seafaring was in his blood, the court heard, with multiple generations of his family working on boats. He married in 2019 and has a five-year-old daughter. His young family and his mother moved to Ireland since his arrest. His wife works 50 hours a week in a shop to support the family, travelling 1.5 hours by bus to get there. Not being there for his family weighs heavily on his mind, the court heard. His mother cried in court as she watched her son in the accused's box. Mykhailo Gavryk, 32, also from Odessa who fled to Romania when Russia invaded Ukraine, had been of good character, described as proactive, hard-working, creative and a good leader in references supplied to the court by educational institutions. He was the only man and the only breadwinner in his family, his barrister, Paul O'Higgins said. He has donated money to the Ukrainian army and a letter of thanks for this was supplied to the court. He handed over the pin to his phone to gardaí and used his own name on messaging apps on the boat. His knowledge and responsibility for the operation was 'at the bottom of the pile', and the least of all those aboard the MV Matthew, Mr O'Higgins said. The MV Matthew being escorted into Cork Harbour in September, 2023, after the suspected drugs were found on board in what turned out to be Ireland's largest ever cocaine seizure. File picture: PA Saied Hassani, 40, has a wife and six-year-old daughter in Iran, the Special Criminal Court heard. He has worked at sea almost consistently since graduating from maritime college, which he started in 2005. He has been away so much for work that he missed all of his daughter's birthdays. He has two sisters who need medical care — one is in a wheelchair and one has cancer — and he has worked to provide for his wider family since his father died. 'There is nothing in his records to suggest he has done anything like this before,' his barrister Mark Lynam SC said. He even thanked the criminals in Dubai 'for this opportunity' when he got the job, thinking it would help his family, Mr Lynam said. He had the lowest responsibility for the operation of all the officers on board, Mr Lynam said. Although he was found with €20,000 cash when the MV Matthew was seized, this was given to him by the captain before he was airlifted off the boat, he said. He had succumbed to the temptation not out of greed or for better lifestyle — but to support family, some of whom are sick, Mr Lynam said. Detective Sergeant Keith Halley, who led the historic drug bust, said that the operation was directed from Dubai but also had Iranian involvement. A transnational organised crime group with "immense capabilities, unlimited resources and a global reach," directed the MV Matthew drug smuggling operation from a cell in Dubai before it was stormed off the Cork coast. A cell structure within the organised crime group which manned the operation was evident, so if one cell was compromised, the overall damage would be limited, Det Supt Halley told the Special Criminal Court at the men's sentencing hearing on Tuesday. The MV Matthew, owned by a Dubai-based company, repeatedly tried to evade the Irish navy before it was boarded by Ireland's elite army ranger wing via helicopter in rough seas in September 2023 off the Cork coast. Ukrainians Mykhailo Gavryk, and Vitaliy Vlasoi, both 32; Iranians Soheil Jelveh, 51, and Saeid Hassani, 39; Filipino Harold Estoesta, 31, and Dutch national Cumali Ozgen, 49, all pleaded guilty to possession of cocaine for sale or supply on board the MV Mathew between 24 and 26 September 2023. Ukrainian national Vitaliy Lapa, aged 62, with an address at Rudenka, Repina Str in Berdyansk, and Jamie Harbron, aged 31, of South Avenue, Billingham in the UK, pleaded guilty to attempting to possess cocaine for sale or supply between 21 and 25 September 2023. Justice Melanie Grealy has set sentencing for all eight men on July 4.
Sunday World
6 hours ago
- Sunday World
Dylan McCarthy's mum says world has been ‘destroyed' by son's death in ‘mob attack'
Marita McCarthy told the court her son went out to celebrate the birth of his nephew and came back in a coffin. The mother of a young man who died after he was assaulted during a melee outside a Kildare pub while celebrating the birth of his nephew nearly three years ago has said her world has been 'turned upside down' by the 'senseless attack' on her first-born child and only son. In an emotional victim impact statement, Marita McCarthy said the Cranberries song 'Dreams' came out when her son Dylan was born in 1993, but now she cries when she hears it because her son's dreams were 'snuffed' out by the fatal assault. The money she had saved for her son's wedding had gone towards his funeral instead, Ms McCarthy said. Ms McCarthy told the court her son went out to celebrate the birth of his nephew and came back in a coffin. She said her world has been turned upside down by the 'senseless and unprovoked mob attack on my family'. Her husband Eamonn, who was with Dylan on the night, and who was himself assaulted during the incident, said he had to discharge himself from hospital to attend his son's funeral. Sean Kavanagh (26). Pic Collins Courts Dylan's sister, Orla McCarthy, said she had asked her brother to be her newborn son's godfather just hours before he was killed. The statements were read out at a sentencing hearing on Tuesday afternoon for Calvin Dunne (25) and Sean Kavanagh (27). Dunne was acquitted of murder but convicted of Dylan McCarthy's manslaughter by a Central Criminal Court jury following a trial earlier this year. He was also found guilty of a charge of violent disorder. Two weeks into the trial, Dunne's co-accused, Kavanagh, with an address at St Mary's Lane, Church Avenue, Monasterevin, pleaded guilty to a charge of assault causing harm to Eamonn McCarthy. A charge of violent disorder was taken into consideration. After a defence application, Ms Justice Biggs then directed the jury to find Kavanagh not guilty of the murder of Dylan McCarthy, a charge he had denied. It was the State's case that Mr McCarthy (29) died following an incident in which he received punches and a kick to the head from Dunne while he was attempting to get up off the ground. Two eyewitnesses told the jury that Dylan McCarthy was kicked in the head, with one describing the noise as 'a loud thud' that was 'like kicking a football', while the other said it sounded 'like a car door' shutting. Dunne contended, however, that he was acting in self-defence, that Mr McCarthy was himself 'involved in violence' on the night and that he did not kick the deceased in the head. Mr McCarthy's cause of death was a traumatic head injury and spinal injury caused by blunt force trauma. Calvin Dunne (24). Photo: Collins Courts State pathologist Dr Heidi Okkers told the jury it was not possible to determine whether a punch or kick caused the fatal injury that led to Mr McCarthy's death. In his impact statement, which was read to the court by his wife, Eamonn McCarthy said his previous life disappeared on the night of August 21, 2022 and he had lost his 'son and best friend'. 'I'm a broken man. The future is bleak.' He said following the assault he was on a liquid diet for 12 weeks and now has five plates and permanent nerve damage on the right side of his face. Eamonn McCarthy said his last memory of his son 'gurgling' and of his 'eyes rolling back in his head' will haunt him for the rest of his life. Mr McCarthy said his son was 'not a fighter' and everyone who knew Dylan knew he never hit or fought with anyone. He said he hasn't been inside a pub since the night his son was killed because he has anxiety around crowds. He said his life has become very isolated and he doesn't want to leave the house. Mr McCarthy said he felt like he had 'let my son down when he needed me most'. 'I have never regretted anything so much as entering the Bellyard pub,' he said. Mr McCarthy said Dylan had told him that night that he was going to propose to his girlfriend Aoife in the coming months. Marita McCarthy told the court today: 'I have no wedding to look forward to. The money I had been saving for their wedding went towards a funeral. Dylan's mother said her son was hit and kicked to death before those responsible 'calmly walked away'. She said they did not stick around to see what they did to Dylan and had left her husband with life-long, life-altering injuries. Dylan McCarthy News in 90 June 4th 'My world is destroyed, devastated, changed beyond belief every day,' she said. 'Instead of picking a 30th birthday present I was picking a headstone. Every day is like Groundhog Day, wishing it wasn't true.' She said her son died 'on a footpath outside a pub' as her husband watched his eyes 'rolling into his head and his last gasps'. In her victim impact statement, Dylan's girlfriend Aoife Talty said she met him after her 22nd birthday and they fell 'instantly in love with each other'. She said Dylan was 'kind, fun gentle and caring'. He never liked to be the centre of attention she said, but people were drawn to him and his 'infectious laugh'. Ms Talty said Dylan always made her feel 'loved and happy' and she was looking forward to spending their lives together. The trial heard that on the night of the fatal assault in August 2022, a row broke out after a drink was spilled and the group were ejected from the premises. Dunne told gardai that when a group of people came out of the pub and a fight broke out, he saw his former co-accused Sean Kavanagh fighting with Dylan and Eamonn McCarthy. Dunne said that at one point, Dylan McCarthy went to hit Kavanagh from behind, so Dunne grabbed Dylan McCarthy by the wrist. He told gardaí Dylan McCarthy turned to punch him, so Dunne hit him in the 'chin or jaw' area, causing him to fall. Dunne said he then 'lightly kicked' Dylan to what he believed was 'the chest area'. The defendant told gardaí that Dylan and Eamonn McCarthy were being 'extremely violent'. 'Everything I did was to stop them attacking Sean, I didn't drill him or kick him viciously,' Dunne said. Dunne, of Abbey View, Monasterevin, Co Kildare, had pleaded not guilty to the murder of Mr McCarthy on or about August 22nd, 2022. He had also pleaded not guilty to violent disorder on August 21st, 2022, at Dublin Road, Monasterevin. Kavanagh told gardaí he looked into the pub after hearing shouting and saw staff being assaulted. He said he tried to help remove the group causing the disturbance. He said the fight spilled out onto the street at which point members of this group started to punch and assault him as he attempted to remove them. Kavanagh said a man in his 50s put him in a headlock, causing him to feel 'extremely fearful' for his safety. After he got out of the headlock, he said punches were exchanged and he struck the man in self-defence. The jury heard Eamonn McCarthy sustained a fractured jaw and required surgery and five plates to treat his injuries. He also sustained a broken nose and a hairline fracture around one of his eye sockets. He waited until after Dylan's funeral had taken place to have the operation. At today's sentencing hearing, Detective Garda James Young told prosecution counsel Seoirse Ó Dúnlaing SC that neither Dunne nor Kavanagh have any previous convictions. Mr Ó Dúnlaing said the DPP placed the manslaughter offence in the mid-range of offending attracting a headline sentence of between four and ten years. Michael Lynn SC, for Kavanagh, handed in a letter of apology that his client had written to the McCarthy family. Mr Lynn said the defendant was 24 at the time of the incident. Kavanagh pleaded guilty to the Section 3 assault, he said, and has accepted his responsibility. Mr Lynn said it was clear everything on the night happened in a very, very short space of time and Kavanagh 'deeply regrets what happened' and 'what he did'. Mr Lynn described Kavanagh as 'hardworking' person and a 'good friend' who was spoken of very highly by a very wide range of members of the community from different backgrounds. He said Kavanagh is a decorated sportsman and had represented Ireland in basketball. He said his client has used his sporting talent to contribute to his local club in terms of underage training and involvement with various teams. John Fitzgerald SC, representing Dunne, said nothing he said on behalf of his client was seeking to mitigate or get around the fact the McCarthy family have been given a life sentence. The lawyer asked the court to consider the matter in the wider context and take into account the effects it will have in the future. He said the probation report assessed Dunne as being of low risk of re-offending. Ms Justice Caroline Biggs said she needed time to digest and consider everything she had heard and adjourned the matter to June 30 for finalisation.
