Court upholds racketeering convictions of ex-Ohio House speaker and lobbyist in $60M bribery scheme
COLUMBUS, Ohio (AP) — A federal appeals court upheld the racketeering convictions of former Ohio House Speaker Larry Householder and an ex-lobbyist on Tuesday in a $60 million bribery scandal described as the largest corruption scheme in state history.
The unanimous ruling by a three-judge panel of the Sixth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals in Cincinnati represented a win for the Department of Justice, which had secured the convictions in March 2023 after a yearslong investigation. Householder, a Republican, was sentenced to 20 years in prison, and lobbyist and former Ohio Republican Party chair Matt Borges was sentenced to five years in prison.
Acting U.S. Attorney Kelly A. Norris said the appeals panel's unanimous decision 'affirmed the strength of the government's evidence, the correctness of the jury instructions, and the fairness of the proceeding.'
Householder was convicted of masterminding a $60 million bribery scheme funded by Akron-based FirstEnergy Corp. to elect allies, secure power, pass a $1 billion bailout of two of its affiliated nuclear plants and then defend the bill, known as House Bill 6, from a repeal effort.
Prosecutors had described Borges' primary role in the scheme as working to thwart a ballot campaign aimed at repealing the tainted legislation. Specifically, he was accused of paying $15,000 to someone who was helping spearhead the effort in order to get inside information. The referendum ultimately failed to make the ballot.
Scott Pullins, a long-time legal and personal adviser to Householder, called it a 'sad and disappointing day' for both men and their families and supporters, and 'even a sadder day for constitutional free speech and the rule of law.'
He said in a Substack post that Householder "raised undisclosed, unlimited donations for a 501c4 organization that supported him and his political allies' — just as speakers before and after him have done. 'But the federal government singled only Mr. Householder out for prosecution.'
Householder has a couple long shot legal options remaining: He could ask for a review by the full Sixth Circuit, or seek what's known as certiorari in the U.S. Supreme Court, hoping for consideration by the nation's highest bench. Both types of requests are rarely granted.
A message seeking comment was left for Householder's criminal defense attorney.
Householder's appeal failed on all six claims he brought in hopes of a reprieve. He alleged erroneous jury instructions, insufficient and inadmissible evidence, violations of his right to counsel, judicial bias and that his sentence was unreasonable for the circumstances.
The 65-year-old Householder argued that the government was wrong in describing what he had engaged in as a bribery scheme. Instead, he cast the money that flowed from FirstEnergy into a network of secret dark money accounts that he controlled as legal campaign contributions. Federal prosecutors charged that the money was given to Householder in exchange for the passage of House Bill 6, providing the necessary quid pro quo to make his conduct illegal.
Householder had also faulted U.S. District Judge Timothy Black in his appeal, asserting that he failed to properly instruct the jury that an agreement is necessary to prove bribery and that Householder needed to have agreed he would take action 'on a specific and focused question or matter' at the time that agreement was struck.
The judicial panel said all of his claims failed.
Borges' appeal hinged on three technical points of law. All failed, as well, though he could also ask for review by the full appellate court or the U.S. Supreme Court.
However, Circuit Judge Amul Thapar wrote in a concurring opinion that each of Borges' contentions 'raises tricky and unresolved issues in honest services fraud jurisprudence.'
'And here, Borges has a good argument his conduct fell within a murky middle: perhaps objectionable, but not clearly illegal,' he wrote. 'Until the Supreme Court revises its caselaw, however, we must follow its precedent.'
Dennis Belli, Borges' attorney, noted a part of Thapar's concurrence that said "(t)he Tinkerbell strategy — clap if you believe he's guilty — doesn't cut it when we think about criminal convictions.'
''Tinkerbell strategy' aptly describes the prosecution's use of an alleged violation of a misdemeanor statute in the Ohio Elections Code to obtain a felony racketeering conviction of Borges in federal court,' Belli said, noting that his client denies that the statute even applies to his conduct. 'I will be studying the 64-page ruling closely and thoughtfully, and will advise my client regarding his options going forward.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
UPI
18 minutes ago
- UPI
Newark mayor sues N.J. DA over being arrested last month
Newark Mayor Ras Baraka has filed a lawsuit against New Jersey District Attorney Alina Habba over his arrest last month. Photo by Justin Lane/UPI | License Photo June 4 (UPI) -- The Democratic mayor of Newark, Ras Baraka, has sued the Republican U.S. district attorney of New Jersey over his arrest last month outside of a prison being transformed into a detention facility to hold migrants arrested in the Trump administration's immigration crackdown. The lawsuit, announced Tuesday, accuses District Attorney Alina Habba and Special Agent in Charge Ricky Patel of the Newark Division of Homeland Security Investigations of violating Baraka's rights by arresting him without cause, initiating a malicious prosecution and committing defamation. "They abused their power to violently arrest me at Delaney Hall despite being invited inside," Baraka said in a statement Tuesday. "No one is above the law." Baraka was arrested on May 9 outside Delaney Hall, a Newark prison owned by GEO Group, which in February signed a contract with Immigration and Customs Enforcement to house migrants at the 1,000-bed center for 15 years. Habba accused Baraka of trespassing at the facility and claimed he was arrested after allegedly "ignored multiple warnings from Homeland Security Investigations to remove himself from the ICE detention center. "He has willingly chosen to disregard the law," she said on X following Baraka's arrest. "That will not stand in this state." Habba -- formerly a lawyer for President Donald Trump, who appointed her to her current position in New Jersey -- announced last month she was dropping the charges against Baraka "for the sake of moving forward." According to the lawsuit, Baraka was at the prison at the invitation of Rep. LaMonica McIver, one of three Democratic New Jersey House representatives visiting Delaney Hall that day to inspect it. Baraka arrived at Delaney Hall at about 1:42 p.m. EDT and spoke with members of the public protesting the Trump administration's immigration policies. At 1:50 p.m. a GEO Group guard invited Baraka to enter the inner gate of Delaney Hall, which the mayor did. He waited there for about 40 minutes, apparently for the Democratic lawmakers inside the facility. According to the lawsuit, Patel confronted Baraka at 2:33 p.m., and told him to leave. Baraka argued he was invited in by the guard, which Patel disputed, the court documents state. Minutes later, the members of Congress exited the facility after witnessing the confrontation between the two and informed Patel that they had wanted Baraka there. "After the members of Congress conveyed their thoughts, Defendant Patel threatened to arrest the Mayor," the lawsuit states. "In response, the Mayor said: 'I'm leaving now.'" Baraka was arrested by about 20 DHS agents, some masked, about 5 minutes after he left the GEO Group property, according to the filing. "Egged on by Defendant Patel, who ordered the DHS agents to 'take him down' (meaning violently tackle the Mayor of Newark) the agents pushed, shoved and assaulted the Mayor's security team and members of Congress before violently pulling Mayor Baraka's arms and arresting him without probable cause," the lawsuit states. "The DHS agents handcuffed the Mayor behind his back in an effort to effect maximum humiliation for what Defendant Habba's office later admitted was an alleged 'petty offense.'" The lawsuit, which is seeking compensatory and punitive damages, also accuses Habba of having a political agenda to forward Trump's immigration policies and to help Republicans in the state. When Habba told the court she was ending the prosecution of Baraka, federal Judge Andre Espinosa admonished the district attorney. "The hasty arrest of Newark Mayor Ras Baraka, followed swiftly by the dismissal of the trespassing charges a mere 13 days later, suggests a worrisome misstep by your office," Espinosa said. "An arrest, particularly of a public figure, is not a preliminary investigative tool. It is a severe action, carrying significant reputational and personal consequences, and it should only be undertaken after a thorough, dispassionate evaluation of credible evidence." On Monday, after learning of Baraka's intention to sue her, Habba retorted: "My advice to the mayor -- feel free to join me in prioritizing violent crime and public safety. Far better use of time for the great citizens of New Jersey." Habba later last month filed charges of assaulting law enforcement against McIver in connection with Baraka's arrest. Baraka has voiced solidarity with McIver, and McIver described the charges against her as "purely political."
The Hill
27 minutes ago
- The Hill
South Korea has endured 6 months of political turmoil. What can we expect in Lee's presidency?
SEOUL, South Korea (AP) — Images from the election of South Korea's new president, liberal Lee Jae-myung, are everything you'd expect to see in one of the world's most vibrant democracies. Peaceful. Orderly. And, because this is South Korea, compulsively eye-catching, with crowds singing raucously along to blaring K-pop, dancers bouncing in closely choreographed sequences, and color-coordinated outfits for the two front-runners and their supporters — blue for Lee, who was inaugurated Wednesday for a single, five-year term, red for the distant runner-up, conservative Kim Moon Soo. What the pictures don't capture is the absolute turmoil of the past six months, making Tuesday one of the strangest — and, possibly, most momentous — election days since the country emerged in the late 1980s from decades of dictatorship. Since Dec. 3, South Koreans have watched, stunned, as an extraordinary sequence of events unfolded: Then-South Korean President Yoon Suk Yeol declared martial law, a first since the dictatorship. In response, lawmakers, leaping fences and jostling with heavily armed soldiers, elbowed their way into a besieged parliament to vote the declaration down. Yoon was then impeached and removed from office and now, just two months after his fall, another president has taken office. Here is a look at Lee's victory, the startling events that set up the election, and the challenges Lee faces to heal a nation split along a host of political and social fault lines. They are, in a way, older than the nation. The Korean Peninsula was initially divided into a Soviet-backed north and U.S.-backed south after World War II. The states formalized the division in 1948, and the 1950-53 Korean War made it permanent, dividing the rivals along the Demilitarized Zone, one of the most heavily armed borders in the world. But the tensions go beyond geography. During the long fight for democracy during South Korea's dictatorships, several fractures arose that persist today: the contentions between liberals and conservatives, but also gaps between rich and poor, old and young and men and women. Since the end of dictatorship, over and over the country has seen its democracy tested. By its own leaders. By its antagonistic neighbor to the north. By each new generation's reaction to a tumultuous history of forced geographic division, war, dictatorship, and one of the most breakneck economic turnarounds in world history. Preceding Tuesday's election, thousands of protesters took to the streets, both supporting the deposed Yoon and denouncing him. 'Above all, the president must bring unity among a divided and confused public, which was caused by the martial law declaration,' Park Soo Hyun, a 22-year-old student, said Wednesday. Lee's party has a majority in parliament that will presumably allow the new president a freer hand in pushing through liberal legislation, including more funding for welfare programs and policies to address high living costs, joblessness and corruption. Typically, liberals like Lee have been more wary of South Korea's traditional allies, the United States and Japan, than conservatives. They have also often looked for reconciliation with North Korea. The United States sees South Korea as a crucial buttress against China and Russia and North Korea's growing nuclear capabilitie s. The South hosts nearly 30,000 U.S. troops. Lee, however, will have to find a way to keep his liberal base happy while managing the relationship with U.S. President Donald Trump, who has threatened Seoul with tariffs and has generally been lukewarm about the importance of the alliance. Lee has also been dogged by a raft of corruption cases, and it's not yet clear how much of a drag those will be on his presidency. 'I will make sure there is no more military coup d'état, in which the power entrusted by the people would never be used to intimidate people,' Lee said in his victory speech early Wednesday morning, referring to the martial law decree. Experts say it's a little of both. The last half-year has worsened already raw divisions, even as it highlighted the underlying strength of a rough-and-tumble democratic process. 'Fierce ideological divisions still infuse politics, which could impede South Korea's chances to grow into a truly mature democracy,' Duyeon Kim, a visiting professor at Yonsei University in Seoul, wrote recently for the Council on Foreign Relations. But Tuesday's vote and Wednesday's inauguration signaled a return to a more normal democracy. And even the crisis itself showed the resiliency of South Korea's institutions. A crowd helped lawmakers get past troops and into parliament to overturn the martial law decree. The soldiers who carried out Yoon's orders did so without enthusiasm and didn't use force against the people, John Delury, a Korea expert and visiting professor at John Cabot University, said Tuesday. Korean democracy is in the people's hands, he said, not any one person's, even the new president's. Lee 'enters office with a strong mandate. But he is not the savior of democracy,' said Delury. 'Korean people saved it themselves. Now they are entrusting him not to do any more damage to it for the next five years.'
San Francisco Chronicle
28 minutes ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
Pakistani troops kill 14 militants in raid in northwest region near Afghanistan
ISLAMABAD (AP) — Pakistan's security forces raided a militant hideout and killed 14 insurgents during a shootout in the country's northwest, the military said Wednesday. The overnight raid was conducted on the reported presence of Pakistani Taliban belonging to an Indian proxy in North Waziristan, a district in northwestern Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province, the military said in a statement. Pakistan's military said sanitization operations are being conducted to eliminate Pakistani Taliban groups it says are sponsored by India. Pakistani authorities often accuse India of backing outlawed Baloch Liberation Army and Pakistani Taliban groups that commit violence in Pakistan. The accusations have intensified since May in the wake of heightened tensions between the nuclear-armed nations. There has been a cross-border escalation between the countries over the disputed Himalayan region of Kashmir, which is divided between the two but sought in its entirety by each. The Pakistani Taliban, which calls itself Tehrik-e-Taliban Pakistan, or TTP, has been emboldened since its allies, the Afghan Taliban, returned to power in 2021. Many TTP leaders and fighters have taken sanctuary in Afghanistan.
