
Letters: The Government should think twice before giving away general tax cuts
If New Zealand has a bad record for work safety, why is the coalition Government deliberately diluting health and safety enforcement?
Our work fatality and injury rate from poor health and safety compliance is considerably worse than that of Australia or Europe.
Yet the Government is going ahead with the Act-inspired dismantling of Worksafe's ability to enforce and prosecute offenders. Instead, Worksafe will be more advisory, which means power shifts to employers whether to comply or not.
The road-cone hotline is just a populist smokescreen.
The Cabinet Paper says WorkSafe will become a more 'supportive regulator', which really means it will be more toothless. This is going to mean less compliance with work safety requirements, not more or better. Cutting corners on health and safety requirements is an easy way to cut costs.
It is estimated that our poor work safety costs the economy upwards of $5 billion a year. Why would you actively seek to make it worse? This ideological cultural war against regulations and standards is getting ridiculous.
Jeff Hayward, Auckland.
A quick solution
The speed limit on State Highway 5 around Hawke's Bay returned to 100km/h last week after it had been lowered to 80km/h in 2022.
This and every other speed reduction had no factual basis. Most of us saw it as a socialist control. National, on the other hand, look at things quite differently. They continue to seek out progress in any and all things.
Those I have spoken to since SH5 reclaimed its 100km/h limit say that they now drive it far safely, because they can watch the road ahead, not their speedometer for fear of a pointless speeding ticket way below what the road is designed to cope with.
John Ford, Taradale.
Give us the facts
Paul Goldsmith is on a mission to make facts, not opinion, predominant in public media. His own Minister of Finance, Nicola Willis, and Minister of Health Simeon Brown recently claimed a 7% increase in health funding in Budget 2025, claiming it beat both inflation and immigration.
If that claim is analysed, a significant part of the 7% was to compensate for holiday back pay. It's misleading to make the ordinary punter believe there is actually 7% more to pay for more doctors, nurses and specialists, all desperately needed.
Goldsmith has egg on his face for besmirching the media for precisely what his ministers are culpable of. An austere Budget embellished by smoke and mirrors. Will Willis and Brown deny this?
Steve Russell, Hillcrest.
Settlers emboldened
United States President Donald Trump has emboldened the Zionist settler movement's takeover plans in Gaza.
Our Government's complacency makes all New Zealanders complicit in the ethnic cleansing by the Israeli Government.
Some people still try to dismiss the Israeli Government's current campaign of terror and propaganda as 'anti-Semitism'.
It's time Winston Peters sent the Israeli ambassador home.
Pauline Doyle, Napier
Slaughter will continue
Many Israelis will have had relatives murdered during Hitler's Holocaust. They will have seen footage of them being herded to their death, seemingly with little or no resistance.
So when Hamas murdered over 1000 innocent Israelis, it is understandable that Israel vowed never to allow history to repeat itself. Hamas is dedicated to the annihilation of Israel. Tragic as the situation in Gaza is, the blame rests fairly and squarely with Hamas and, unless and until they guarantee to lay down their arms, the slaughter will continue.
Ray Gilbert, Pāpāmoa Beach.
A country of courage
I agree wholeheartedly with Glen Stanton and Ruth Coombes' letters (May 31) regarding the silence of our Government on the genocide in Gaza.
Palestine should be recognised as a sovereign nation.
The actions Israel and the US are perpetuating should be called out by our Government.
I feel ashamed of my country, that we don't have the courage to stand and be counted. We used to be a country that had courage. We will be judged by history.
Diane Brown, Northcote.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


NZ Herald
4 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Bodies of two Israeli-American hostages retrieved from Gaza
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu says the bodies of two Israeli-Americans killed in Hamas' October 7, 2023, attack and held in Gaza have been returned to Israel. 'In a special operation by the [security agency] and the [military] in the Gaza Strip, the bodies of two of our hostages held
![Choose Clean Water - Latest News [Page 1]](/_next/image?url=http%3A%2F%2Fimg.scoop.co.nz%2Fstories%2Fimages%2F1908%2Fscoop_image.jpg&w=3840&q=100)
![Choose Clean Water - Latest News [Page 1]](/_next/image?url=https%3A%2F%2Fstatic-mobile-files.s3.eu-central-1.amazonaws.com%2Fscoop.png&w=48&q=75)
Scoop
4 hours ago
- Scoop
Choose Clean Water - Latest News [Page 1]
Changes To Fish & Game Continue Coalition's Handover Of Power To Polluters Choose Clean Water spokesperson Tom Kay says the changes announced today are clearly designed to remove Fish & Game's ability to advocate for the health of rivers. More >> 'Don't Be Fooled': Govt's Freshwater Reforms Means More Pollution In Your Water & Commercial Control Of Public Resources Friday, 30 May 2025, 7:30 pm | Choose Clean Water Choose Clean Water says it's important for the public to make submissions on the changes (these can be made until 27 July 2025) but it's just as important for the public to contact MPs and Ministers directly to voice their opposition. More >> National Direction Changes Expected To Advance Dangerous ACT Ideology At Expense Of The Health Of NZers And Environment Monday, 26 May 2025, 3:04 pm | Choose Clean Water Choose Clean Water says the cabinet paper's prioritising of 'the enjoyment of private property rights' in public policy is straight out of an extreme libertarian ideology and becomes incoherent and dangerous when applied to communities' needs ... More >> Farm Model Weakness Proves Strength Of Input Controls To Save Rivers Wednesday, 11 August 2021, 4:57 pm | Choose Clean Water Freshwater campaigners say the independent review of farm modelling tool, 'Overseer', released today has found profound weaknesses with the tool and in doing so has proved the strength of Government and regional councils turning to greater control of inputs ... More >> Government Must Stand Strong On Freshwater Reform For All New Zealanders Wednesday, 14 July 2021, 1:52 pm | Choose Clean Water Campaigners say the Government must stand strong against pressure from some in the agricultural sector to weaken freshwater reforms, following the release today of the Government's consultation document on freshwater farm plans and fencing rules. ... More >> Wairarapa Water Ltd.'s Bad Science And Poor Process A Warning Bell For All Monday, 21 December 2020, 1:31 pm | Choose Clean Water Freshwater campaigners say Wairarapa iwi Rangitāne o Wairarapa statement released today highlighting their concerns around Wairarapa Water Ltd's 'rushed time frames and incorrect information' is an important warning bell for the public and politicians. ... More >> Fish & Game Endangers Its Vital Public Role By Moving Closer To Federated Farmers Friday, 27 November 2020, 3:49 pm | Choose Clean Water Freshwater Campaigners Say The NZ Fish And Game Council Is Endangering Its Vital Public Role In The Protection Of Rivers And Lakes If It Moves Closer To Federated Farmers, Following Today's Announcement On The Two Organisations' Intention To ... More >> Water Campaigners Welcome Greens' Focus On Nitrogen Pollution Saturday, 12 September 2020, 12:16 pm | Choose Clean Water Water campaigners are welcoming the Greens' focus on nitrogen pollution in the party's 'Farming for the future' policy released today. 'Excessive nitrogen in our waterways is impacting the health of people, rivers and lakes, and wildlife ... More >> Water Storage Should Not Be Prioritised Over Waste & Drinking Water Infrastructure Thursday, 11 June 2020, 5:03 pm | Choose Clean Water The Government should be putting public health first in its post-Covid spending, freshwater campaigners say, prioritising waste and drinking water infrastructure over water storage Campaigners from Choose Clean Water were disappointed to learn ... More >> Crucial Policy Missing From Government's Water Announcement, Say Campaigners Thursday, 28 May 2020, 12:16 pm | Choose Clean Water Freshwater campaigners are frustrated the Government has delayed a crucial decision on nitrogen pollution for a further 12 months until after the election. 'We have urged the Government many times to put in place clear and unequivocal limits for ... More >> Strong Water Rules Essential As New Report Shows Most NZ Rivers Polluted Thursday, 16 April 2020, 12:39 pm | Choose Clean Water A government report released today shows most New Zealand rivers are polluted, highlighting why strong water rules are urgently needed, say freshwater campaigners. The report shows most of our waterways are under stress and many are severely impacted. In our ... More >> Industry Lobbyists And Politicians – Don't Exploit Covid-19 Crisis To Push Long-held Agendas Monday, 23 March 2020, 11:18 am | Choose Clean Water It is irresponsible and dishonest for agricultural industry lobbyists and opportunistic politicians to exploit the Covid-19 crisis for their unrelated political agendas, say freshwater campaign group Choose Clean Water. Federated Farmers have called for ... More >> 'Don't Fail Us On Water, PM': Togs, Towels And A Serious Message At Parliament Today Monday, 2 March 2020, 7:38 am | Choose Clean Water A group of young freshwater campaigners are getting their togs on, grabbing a towel and heading to parliament at rush hour this morning with a message to Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern; 'Don't fail us on water.' The group, from the student-established ... More >> 'Strong Water Rules Now': Campaigners Remind PM Of Clean River Promises Outside Parliament Today Tuesday, 11 February 2020, 6:59 am | Choose Clean Water Freshwater campaigners will be outside parliament today with large banners reminding the Prime Minister of her party's 2017 pre-election promises to clean up the country's rivers. The group from Choose Clean Water, a student-established campaign to strengthen ... More >> Stats NZ shows urban & rural NZers agree on water pollution Wednesday, 2 October 2019, 3:00 pm | Choose Clean Water Results of the General Social Survey highlighted today by Stats NZ today show that urban and rural New Zealanders agree on freshwater pollution, say freshwater campaigners. 'Information on the General Social Survey 2018 released today by Stats NZ today ... More >> Freshwater policy holds potential if Gov resists pressure Thursday, 5 September 2019, 11:03 am | Choose Clean Water Freshwater campaigners welcome the release of Action for healthy waterways policy discussion documents today saying they hold great potential to deliver on the Government's election promise. However, it is clear there is intense pressure from dairy lobbyists ... More >> Dairy-led water accords do nothing to stop intensification Monday, 2 September 2019, 4:22 pm | Choose Clean Water Dairy industry-led water accords have done nothing to stop intensification over the last decades, which has led to the decline of the health of the country's rivers and lakes, say freshwater campaigners. And there is no commitment from dairy leaders ... More >> An 'action plan' with no action and a fatal flaw Tuesday, 5 June 2018, 4:20 pm | Choose Clean Water An 'action plan' with no action and a fatal flaw: Why agricultural leaders continue to fail New Zealand's rivers and their industry For immediate use 4pm Tuesday, 5 June 2018 Choose Clean Water NZ The Good Farming Practice: Action Plan for Water ... More >>


Scoop
4 hours ago
- Scoop
Changes To Fish & Game Continue Coalition's Handover Of Power To Polluters
Changes announced to Fish & Game this morning are another move in the Coalition Government's handover of power to intensive farming and other polluting commercial interests, and will result in the further degradation of our rivers and freshwater, say freshwater campaigners. Choose Clean Water spokesperson Tom Kay says the changes announced today are clearly designed to remove Fish & Game's ability to advocate for the health of rivers. 'Fish & Game has used its statutory purpose as a strong advocate for the health of rivers across New Zealand, and as such has helped protect numerous rivers from pollution and degradation.' 'There are some things about the system that do need fixing, but this is not only about that—this is the Coalition Govt taking advantage of an opportunity to reduce Fish & Game's influence over polluters." 'When environmental groups, local community groups, or iwi can't afford to legally challenge a damaging activity or poorly made decision, Fish & Game is often there to ensure waterways are protected—working on behalf of their members to protect habitat for fish. But this Government is trying to stop that.' The Coalition has stated that Fish & Game's advocacy functions will be 'revised' so regional Fish & Game Councils will only be able to take court action in relation to advocacy if explicitly approved by the New Zealand Fish & Game Council or the Minister and within a new restricted advocacy policy. This morning's press release from Minister for Hunting and Fishing James Meager on the changes states they will restrict the organisation's ability to undertake court proceedings and require 'Fish & Game councils to better consider the interests of other stakeholders such as farmers and the aviation sector in decision-making'. 'It's telling that the Government has said specifically that it wants Fish & Game to better consider farming interests. Why not public health interests? Why not the interests of future generations? Why not the myriad of other commercial interests that operate in our communities? This demonstrates that this decision is another example of the Government enabling more pollution in rivers, lakes, and drinking water sources, and the handing of more power over our water to polluting commercial interests like intensive farming.' 'We know how detrimental the influence of Ministers can be over the statutory purposes of agencies like the Department of Conservation to protect our environment, for example. This is another case of Ministers being given the power to step in and stop actions that would protect our environment.' Fish & Game led the processes to secure many Water Conservation Orders—similar to National Parks—for our rivers, protecting them for anglers and the public alike to enjoy. In 2002 they launched a large campaign against 'Dirty Dairying' and the conversion of land into intensive agriculture, particularly in the South Island. More recently, Fish & Game took up a legal challenge against ongoing extreme pollution of Southland's waterways where dairy interests were wrongly claiming 'there is no evidence of diffuse discharges from farming activities, either individually or cumulatively, causing adverse effects, including significant adverse effects on aquatic life'. 'Proponents of damaging, intensive agriculture and other major polluters are all over this Government's decisions. This decision stinks of undue influence.'