'When do we stop picking him?': Aussies' Test dilemma
Humbled Australia believe Marnus Labuschagne still has a "big future" but have failed to guarantee his spot following two years of underwhelming performances.
A day after captain Pat Cummins acknowledged Australia will undergo a "reset" following another top-order capitulation, coach Andrew McDonald addressed the team's batting woes.
Having not lost an ICC final since 2010, Australia were upstaged by Temba Bavuma's fighting South Africans at Lord's, with a five-wicket defeat crushing their hopes of defending the World Test Championship title they won in 2023.
In the second innings, only plucky knocks from star quick Mitchell Starc and wicketkeeper Alex Carey saved the No.1-ranked team from utter embarrassment.
Promoted from No.3 to open in a Test for the first time, struggling Labuschagne got starts, but ultimately only made 17 and 22 to extend his century drought to almost 24 months.
In the recently completed two-year WTC window, Labuschagne averaged just 27.82.
"He's a big part of the future of the team," McDonald said.
"Anyone that averages (46.19) in Test cricket at that age (30) is important.
"We've got older players there that are closer to the end than the start.
"If he can get his game in good order for the next four or five years, he can underpin that batting order, but at the moment, he'd be disappointed with the returns.
"We're confident that he could return to his best, hence why we keep picking him, and it's at what point do we stop picking him?
"There's no harder worker than Marnus, and now it's really just about the returns."
Labuschagne's opening partner, 38-year-old Usman Khawaja, was again exposed against express pace after falling to Proteas spearhead Kagiso Rabada for 0 and 7.
Khawaja made a career-best 232 on slow pitches in Sri Lanka earlier this year, but his recent history against quality fast bowlers is a concern.
"He gives us stability at his best at the top and, and we like to look at our players at their best," McDonald said of Khawaja.
"A couple of failures here, and people then start to talk about, 'Maybe it's the end, maybe it's the end'.
"I don't see an end date with the way he's training."
Cameron Green, who batted at No.3 in his first Test since March 2024 after recovering from back surgery, was also troubled by Rabada and was out for 4 and 0.
Green, 26, was the only member of the Australian XI in his 20s in this Test.
But after suffering a compound dislocation of his right little finger at Lord's, star No.4 Steve Smith is almost no chance to play in at least the first Test against the West Indies.
Smith will travel to Caribbean, but will be required to keep his finger in a splint for up to eight weeks.
The wound should heal in two weeks, and he could play sooner than initially thought if he can tolerate wearing a splint while batting.
Teenage tyro Sam Konstas, who announced himself last Boxing Day, is set to be given an opportunity as opener for Australia's first tour of the Caribbean in 10 years.
If Smith can't play, Konstas could slot back in to open with Usman Khawaja.
"He'll be right in the window," McDonald said of Konstas.
"He was a big discussion leading into this Test match.
"We need to bed down that opening combination. We've had a bit of musical chairs there, so now might be the time."
Josh Inglis, who scored a century on debut against Sri Lanka earlier this year, is also in the squad and could be given a chance to add to his two Tests.
This AAP article was made possible by support from Amazon Prime Video, which broadcast the World Test Championship final.
Humbled Australia believe Marnus Labuschagne still has a "big future" but have failed to guarantee his spot following two years of underwhelming performances.
A day after captain Pat Cummins acknowledged Australia will undergo a "reset" following another top-order capitulation, coach Andrew McDonald addressed the team's batting woes.
Having not lost an ICC final since 2010, Australia were upstaged by Temba Bavuma's fighting South Africans at Lord's, with a five-wicket defeat crushing their hopes of defending the World Test Championship title they won in 2023.
In the second innings, only plucky knocks from star quick Mitchell Starc and wicketkeeper Alex Carey saved the No.1-ranked team from utter embarrassment.
Promoted from No.3 to open in a Test for the first time, struggling Labuschagne got starts, but ultimately only made 17 and 22 to extend his century drought to almost 24 months.
In the recently completed two-year WTC window, Labuschagne averaged just 27.82.
"He's a big part of the future of the team," McDonald said.
"Anyone that averages (46.19) in Test cricket at that age (30) is important.
"We've got older players there that are closer to the end than the start.
"If he can get his game in good order for the next four or five years, he can underpin that batting order, but at the moment, he'd be disappointed with the returns.
"We're confident that he could return to his best, hence why we keep picking him, and it's at what point do we stop picking him?
"There's no harder worker than Marnus, and now it's really just about the returns."
Labuschagne's opening partner, 38-year-old Usman Khawaja, was again exposed against express pace after falling to Proteas spearhead Kagiso Rabada for 0 and 7.
Khawaja made a career-best 232 on slow pitches in Sri Lanka earlier this year, but his recent history against quality fast bowlers is a concern.
"He gives us stability at his best at the top and, and we like to look at our players at their best," McDonald said of Khawaja.
"A couple of failures here, and people then start to talk about, 'Maybe it's the end, maybe it's the end'.
"I don't see an end date with the way he's training."
Cameron Green, who batted at No.3 in his first Test since March 2024 after recovering from back surgery, was also troubled by Rabada and was out for 4 and 0.
Green, 26, was the only member of the Australian XI in his 20s in this Test.
But after suffering a compound dislocation of his right little finger at Lord's, star No.4 Steve Smith is almost no chance to play in at least the first Test against the West Indies.
Smith will travel to Caribbean, but will be required to keep his finger in a splint for up to eight weeks.
The wound should heal in two weeks, and he could play sooner than initially thought if he can tolerate wearing a splint while batting.
Teenage tyro Sam Konstas, who announced himself last Boxing Day, is set to be given an opportunity as opener for Australia's first tour of the Caribbean in 10 years.
If Smith can't play, Konstas could slot back in to open with Usman Khawaja.
"He'll be right in the window," McDonald said of Konstas.
"He was a big discussion leading into this Test match.
"We need to bed down that opening combination. We've had a bit of musical chairs there, so now might be the time."
Josh Inglis, who scored a century on debut against Sri Lanka earlier this year, is also in the squad and could be given a chance to add to his two Tests.
This AAP article was made possible by support from Amazon Prime Video, which broadcast the World Test Championship final.
Humbled Australia believe Marnus Labuschagne still has a "big future" but have failed to guarantee his spot following two years of underwhelming performances.
A day after captain Pat Cummins acknowledged Australia will undergo a "reset" following another top-order capitulation, coach Andrew McDonald addressed the team's batting woes.
Having not lost an ICC final since 2010, Australia were upstaged by Temba Bavuma's fighting South Africans at Lord's, with a five-wicket defeat crushing their hopes of defending the World Test Championship title they won in 2023.
In the second innings, only plucky knocks from star quick Mitchell Starc and wicketkeeper Alex Carey saved the No.1-ranked team from utter embarrassment.
Promoted from No.3 to open in a Test for the first time, struggling Labuschagne got starts, but ultimately only made 17 and 22 to extend his century drought to almost 24 months.
In the recently completed two-year WTC window, Labuschagne averaged just 27.82.
"He's a big part of the future of the team," McDonald said.
"Anyone that averages (46.19) in Test cricket at that age (30) is important.
"We've got older players there that are closer to the end than the start.
"If he can get his game in good order for the next four or five years, he can underpin that batting order, but at the moment, he'd be disappointed with the returns.
"We're confident that he could return to his best, hence why we keep picking him, and it's at what point do we stop picking him?
"There's no harder worker than Marnus, and now it's really just about the returns."
Labuschagne's opening partner, 38-year-old Usman Khawaja, was again exposed against express pace after falling to Proteas spearhead Kagiso Rabada for 0 and 7.
Khawaja made a career-best 232 on slow pitches in Sri Lanka earlier this year, but his recent history against quality fast bowlers is a concern.
"He gives us stability at his best at the top and, and we like to look at our players at their best," McDonald said of Khawaja.
"A couple of failures here, and people then start to talk about, 'Maybe it's the end, maybe it's the end'.
"I don't see an end date with the way he's training."
Cameron Green, who batted at No.3 in his first Test since March 2024 after recovering from back surgery, was also troubled by Rabada and was out for 4 and 0.
Green, 26, was the only member of the Australian XI in his 20s in this Test.
But after suffering a compound dislocation of his right little finger at Lord's, star No.4 Steve Smith is almost no chance to play in at least the first Test against the West Indies.
Smith will travel to Caribbean, but will be required to keep his finger in a splint for up to eight weeks.
The wound should heal in two weeks, and he could play sooner than initially thought if he can tolerate wearing a splint while batting.
Teenage tyro Sam Konstas, who announced himself last Boxing Day, is set to be given an opportunity as opener for Australia's first tour of the Caribbean in 10 years.
If Smith can't play, Konstas could slot back in to open with Usman Khawaja.
"He'll be right in the window," McDonald said of Konstas.
"He was a big discussion leading into this Test match.
"We need to bed down that opening combination. We've had a bit of musical chairs there, so now might be the time."
Josh Inglis, who scored a century on debut against Sri Lanka earlier this year, is also in the squad and could be given a chance to add to his two Tests.
This AAP article was made possible by support from Amazon Prime Video, which broadcast the World Test Championship final.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
West Australian
an hour ago
- West Australian
GEORGIE PARKER: Labuschagne, Khawaja face axe as Australian selectors weigh changes to Test squad
Australia's loss to South Africa in the World Test Championship final might be exactly what we needed - both on the pitch and back in the selection room. The match was a different result than we all expected, but it exposed truths about our selection decisions (or delusions), our understanding of what a win can mean beyond the scoreboard, and the growing divide between sport and the people it's meant to belong to. Here are my three takeaways from the final: 1. Are our selectors scared, or do we not have depth? Once again, our top order was caught out under pressure. Even taking in to account the tougher conditions Australia had with the bat compared to South Africa, if we're as good as we think we are, we needed to be better. Australia's batting looked predictable, flat, and inflexible with no resilience. The same names keep getting picked - why? Out of loyalty, perhaps? Maybe the next in line aren't up to scratch just yet? Or maybe the selectors are keeping their blinkers on with what the future of this team looks like? Marnus Labuschagne is hanging on by a thread, Cam Green was underdone and Usman Khwaja, is banging on the door of retirement. It feels as though they're trying to put square pegs in round holes in the top order, forcing something to fit that's not quite right. We've got away with it for some time with either our world best bowling attack or individual performances with the bat, but we can't keep relying on that with a home Ashes summer looming. A longer term vision and looking at how a game was played out rather than just the result is needed. The West Indies tour couldn't come fast enough. 2. We underestimated what this win means to South Africa In Australia, a world championship win is big, but expected. In South Africa, it's something else entirely. It's rare but it also has another layer beyond the trophy we don't quite understand. This win isn't just about cricket. It's about pride. It's about belonging. It's about a country still healing from its past, and sport being one of the few things powerful enough to bring people together, even for a moment. South Africa's history with sport is complex. Once used as a symbol of division, sport is now one of the most visible ways for the country to show unity — across race, class, and language. For millions, seeing that team lift the trophy was deeply emotional. It wasn't just a game — it was a national moment. It's something we often miss when watching from afar. The weight of what a victory like this can do for a country like South Africa is immense. Temba Bavuma has gone from being called a 'quota captain' to captaining his team to a World Championship, against the best team in the world. 'For us as country here's an opportunity for us… as divided as we are at times, to forget all of that, rejoice in this moment and just be one' his said. So as flat as I am about Australia losing, a win for South Africa is a victory for something greater than the sport. 3. We're putting more and more sport behind paywalls - a nd that's a problem Maybe you didn't even watch the final. And if you didn't, chances are it's because it was locked behind Amazon Prime. This is the national cricket team playing in a world final - and it wasn't on free-to-air TV. It's becoming a pattern. The AFL's 'Super Saturday' is only available on Fox Footy or Kayo. So, if you're not paying on a Saturday, you're not watching on a Saturday. Yes, broadcasting deals fund the game. But sport is supposed to be for everyone. It's how people connect - across generations, backgrounds, and suburbs. When we move these moments behind paywalls, we chip away at what makes them special. We're not just losing casual viewers - we're losing future fans. Young kids who might have fallen in love with cricket or footy simply don't see it anymore. The diehards will always watch, but diehards aren't the ones that grow the game.
Sydney Morning Herald
4 hours ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Twenty-nine reasons to expect a different Sam Konstas as he nears a Test recall
London: As Australia's players and staff took a moment to spend time with their families on the Lord's outfield following the end of the World Test Championship final, Sam Konstas spent most of his time hanging out with their kids. It was a moment that underlined how at 19, Konstas is a generation gap behind the rest of an ageing team, the oldest member of which - Usman Khawaja - is twice his age. But it is by another number - 29 - that Konstas may be entitled to remind the world how assiduously he has worked since the end of the Australian season, to return to the kind of batting that got him into contention to play for the national team in the first place. After his high-profile flame out at the SCG against Scott Boland in a February Sheffield Shield match, and before his departure with the Australian Test squad for London and the Caribbean, Konstas had no fewer than 29 net sessions with his batting coach Tahmid Islam in Sydney. At each and every one of those sessions, Konstas avoided the ramp or scoop shots that he used to such outlandish effect against Jasprit Bumrah on Boxing Day at the MCG, when Australia chose him as a 'circuit-breaker' against India. That modus operandi is an important part of Konstas' story. Against Bumrah, Australia had looked all at sea over the first three Tests of the series, and after the retirement of David Warner lacked a player willing to take the attack to him. Perth debutant Nathan McSweeney has struggled under that spotlight, but so too had the established Usman Khawaja and Marnus Labuschagne. Konstas had no such baggage, and surprised even those closest to him with the gusto with which he went after Bumrah on the biggest stage. Those shots, and the ones he attempted in the next three innings in Melbourne and Sydney, brought a range of critiques from Australia and abroad. Some of them were of the unkind variety that seems unavoidable in the era of the engagement-friendly hot take.
The Age
4 hours ago
- The Age
Twenty-nine reasons to expect a different Sam Konstas as he nears a Test recall
London: As Australia's players and staff took a moment to spend time with their families on the Lord's outfield following the end of the World Test Championship final, Sam Konstas spent most of his time hanging out with their kids. It was a moment that underlined how at 19, Konstas is a generation gap behind the rest of an ageing team, the oldest member of which - Usman Khawaja - is twice his age. But it is by another number - 29 - that Konstas may be entitled to remind the world how assiduously he has worked since the end of the Australian season, to return to the kind of batting that got him into contention to play for the national team in the first place. After his high-profile flame out at the SCG against Scott Boland in a February Sheffield Shield match, and before his departure with the Australian Test squad for London and the Caribbean, Konstas had no fewer than 29 net sessions with his batting coach Tahmid Islam in Sydney. At each and every one of those sessions, Konstas avoided the ramp or scoop shots that he used to such outlandish effect against Jasprit Bumrah on Boxing Day at the MCG, when Australia chose him as a 'circuit-breaker' against India. That modus operandi is an important part of Konstas' story. Against Bumrah, Australia had looked all at sea over the first three Tests of the series, and after the retirement of David Warner lacked a player willing to take the attack to him. Perth debutant Nathan McSweeney has struggled under that spotlight, but so too had the established Usman Khawaja and Marnus Labuschagne. Konstas had no such baggage, and surprised even those closest to him with the gusto with which he went after Bumrah on the biggest stage. Those shots, and the ones he attempted in the next three innings in Melbourne and Sydney, brought a range of critiques from Australia and abroad. Some of them were of the unkind variety that seems unavoidable in the era of the engagement-friendly hot take.
