Murder victim 'speaks' beyond the grave in AI generated video at sentencing
The family of an Arizona man killed in a road rage incident nearly four years ago brought him back last week as an AI-generated image to face the man responsible for his killing give an impact statement to the judge.
The video message created by Christopher Pelkey's sister that used his likeness and voice during the May 1 sentencing was the first time the technology was used in an Arizona court at a sentencing, according to records.
Pelkey was killed in November 2021 by Gabriel Paul Horcasitas, who was ultimately convicted of manslaughter charges. The AI-generated Pelkey spoke to Horcasitas in court and sought forgiveness.
"In another life, we probably could have been friends," the avatar said in the video. "I believe in forgiveness and in God who forgives. I always have and I still do."
MORE: Bill would criminalize 'extremely harmful' online 'deepfakes'
Stacey Wales, Pelkey's sister, told ABC affiliate KNXV that the slain victim's friends and family "agreed this capture was a true representation of the spirit and soul of how Chris would have thought about his own sentencing as a murder victim."
Wales said she wrote the script for the video and noted that her brother was a forgiving, God-fearing man.
Dozens of other family members also provided victim impact statements and expressed anger over Horcasitas' actions.
Prosecutors asked the judge for Horcasitas to be sentenced to nine and a half years in prison, but Judge Todd Lang ultimately issued a 10 and a half year sentence. Lang said he was moved by the AI-generated video.
"I loved that AI, thank you for that. As angry as you are, as justifiably angry as the family is, I heard the forgiveness," the judge said during the sentencing. "I feel that that was genuine."
Horcasitas's attorney, Jason Lamm, told ABC News that he was not given advanced notice about the video. He argued in court that Pelkey was the one who instigated the road rage incident and what the judge heard was a "kinder, more gentle" version of Pelkey.
"I appreciate the fact that victims have the right to address the court, and this was a cathartic endeavor for Stacey Wells, but this was cringe," Lamm told ABC News.
He said he has filed a notice of appeal for his client and that the use of the AI-generated video will likely be one of the points of contention.
MORE: EU launches global sting operation against AI-generated child sexual abuse material
"This will be a bellwether case not just for Arizona but also courts around the country to rule on the use of AI in victim impact statements," Lamm said.
Arizona Supreme Court Chief Justice Ann Timmer provided a statement to KNXV about the use of AI in court cases.
"AI has the potential to create great efficiencies in the justice system and may assist those unschooled in the law to better present their positions. For that reason, we are excited about AI's potential. But AI can also hinder or even upend justice if inappropriately used," she said in her statement.
"A measured approach is best. Along those lines, the court has formed an AI committee to examine AI use and make recommendations for how best to use it. At bottom, those who use AI—including courts—are responsible for its accuracy," she added.
Murder victim 'speaks' beyond the grave in AI generated video at sentencing originally appeared on abcnews.go.com
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Georgia Couple Arrested for Allegedly Leaving 3-Year-Old Child Alone in Shed 'Without Running Water or Electricity': Reports
A three-year-old boy, Bjorn Turner, was allegedly left unsupervised in a filthy shed without running water or electricity for weeks On June 2, Sarah Pombert, 34, and Joseph Turner, 35, were arrested on charges of child cruelty, per Fox 5 Atlanta They are currently being held in Douglas County Jail, facing felony charges for allegedly causing "cruel or excessive mental or physical pain"A Georgia couple has been arrested for second-degree child cruelty after being accused of keeping a three-year-old child alone in a backyard shed for weeks. On June 2, Sarah Pombert, 34, and Joseph Turner, 35, were arrested for allegedly leaving three-year-old Bjorn Turner 'unsupervised, unbathed and unclothed' in a backyard shed in Douglasville from May 1 to May 22, ABC News, Fox 5 Atlanta and the Miami Herald reported. An arrest warrant filed on May 29 by the Douglas County Sheriff's Office stated that the accused 'kept a dirty living space in a shed without running water or electricity, and left the child unsupervised, unbathed, and unclothed with criminal negligence," according to the outlets. Officials have not disclosed the child's connection to Pombert and Turner, nor have they shared how they became aware of the child being left in the space, ABC News and the Miami Herald reported. A neighbor, Matthew Govoni, alleged that the couple had lived at the home for over a decade and the shed recently 'burned down during Memorial Day weekend,' ABC News reported, citing Atlanta ABC affiliate WSB. He also allegedly told the outlet that he was 'not surprised' to hear about the child's treatment and living conditions, considering 'the lifestyle [the family] live.' "I'm saddened for them and the child, but I mean, for the child, I hope they can get to a place where they can be helped," Govoni told WSB, per ABC News. Pombert and Turner are currently being held at the Douglas County Jail. The couple faces felony charges for allegedly causing "cruel or excessive mental or physical pain" to a child, according to Douglas County jail records obtained by Fox 5 Atlanta. Want to keep up with the latest crime coverage? Sign up for for breaking crime news, ongoing trial coverage and details of intriguing unsolved cases. As of Friday, June 6, no defense attorney was listed for Pombert or Turner, ABC News reported, citing court records. PEOPLE has reached out to the Douglas County Sheriff's Office for comment. Read the original article on People
Forbes
2 hours ago
- Forbes
FBI Warns iPhone And Android Messaging App Users Not To Click
As the onslaught, and that's what it is, of cyberattacks targeting smartphone users continues, the Federal Bureau of Investigation has some drastic, yet practical advice: do not click on these messages. Here's what the FBI says that iPhone and Android users must do to stay protected against the cybercriminal hackers carrying out these attacks. It feels like the threat from criminal hackers has never been greater, at least if the number of cybersecurity advisories, law enforcement warnings, and critical alerts from some of the best threat intelligence analysts in the business is anything to go by. From Windows users being urged not to open malicious LNK files and ransomware attacks that are skyrocketing. But it's smartphone users who are once again on the sharp end of many of these evolving threat campaigns. Android users have watched as their contacts are turned into hackers, and iPhone users are now advised to have a special code ready to repel malicious callers. The FBI has not been shy of coming forward with warnings itself: a public service cybersecurity advisory concerning an ongoing malicious texting campaign impersonating officials in U.S. federal and government roles, another regarding smartphone attacks against lawful foreigners in the U.S., and even postings to social media platforms such as X warning members of the public about attackers using AI-generated messages. One thing that many of these threats have in common is the use of smartphone messaging to execute their attacks. SMS phishing, known as smishing by some, and voice message phishing which can be referred to as vishing by the same people who seem to hate the English language, are often employed and often driven by AI tools in the background. Yet, no matter how advanced the attack might seem. No matter how sophisticated it all appears, what with AI being involved and brand or officialdom impersonation involved. They nearly all rely on the same tactic to infect the user, to get the victim to download malware or hand over login credentials. Yes, you've guessed it: a malicious link. Which is where the blunt but accurate FBI warning enters the security equation: Do not click. 'Don't click on anything in an unsolicited email or text message. Look up the company's phone number on your own (don't use the one a potential scammer is providing), and call the company to ask if the request is legitimate,' the FBI said.
Yahoo
6 hours ago
- Yahoo
Warren urges Department of Education IG to investigate DOGE access to student loan data
Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., is requesting the Department of Education's Office of Inspector General review the Department of Government Efficiency's alleged "infiltration" of the agency's internal federal student loan database. "The full extent of DOGE's role and influence at ED remains unknown," Warren wrote in a letter first obtained by ABC News. "This lack of clarity is not only frustrating for borrowers but also dangerous for the future of an agency that handles an extensive student loan portfolio and a range of federal aid programs for higher education," she added. The internal federal student aid (FSA) systems handle the $1.6 trillion student loan portfolio for more than 40 million borrowers. It's unclear whether DOGE has made any changes to student loan data. MORE: Elizabeth Warren launches campaign to investigate Department of Education closure: 'I will fight it with everything I've got' "The Department is refusing to tell Americans who's digging through their personal data and if their data is safe," Warren wrote in a statement to ABC News. "I'm pushing for an independent investigation into what the Department of Education is hiding from us." The OIG office is the statutory, independent entity within the department responsible for identifying fraud, waste, abuse, and criminal activity involving department funds, programs, and operations, according to its website. Warren and a group of Democratic senators, including Sens. Tammy Duckworth, D-Ill., Ben Ray Lujan, D-N.M., Ed Markey, D-Mass., Jeff Merkley, D-Ore., Tina Smith, D-Minn., Chris Van Hollen, D-Md., Richard Blumenthal, D-Conn., Cory Booker, D-N.J., and Ron Wyden, D-Ore., accuse the Department of Education of refusing to comply with her monthslong congressional investigation into what, if any, records have been accessed by DOGE employees that could be sensitive. "[The Education Department] further refused to disclose any information about the scope of DOGE's access to sensitive student borrower data, including whether or not DOGE was granted access to the National Student Loan Data System or any other database that holds sensitive federal student loan borrower data," they wrote in the letter to Department of Education Acting Inspector General René L. Rocque. Billionaire Elon Musk and the DOGE team gained access to several federal agencies earlier this year. The team was tasked to slash federal spending and help dismantle the education department. At a House Appropriations Committee hearing on the department's fiscal year 2026 budget last month, Education Secretary Linda McMahon said the DOGE employees working at the department had the same access any of the agency's employees would be granted. MORE: Secretary McMahon wants Harvard to 'come back to the table' to negotiate with Trump admin McMahon has also said that DOGE was conducting a 'solid audit' of the agency and she appreciates their work to help identify waste, fraud and abuse. The news comes ahead of Warren's first ever meeting with McMahon. Warren sent McMahon dozens of questions ahead of the meeting as she hopes to discuss student loan repayment and forbearances, access to student aid and debt relief, among other topics. However, in February, Warren opened an investigation into DOGE's influence at the agency. The department's responses to her investigation did not indicate how a DOGE employee who previously had "read-only access" to files had those privileges "revoked," whether this employee has 'retained access' to any other internal databases, and what actions the agency has done to ensure that sensitive information would not be 'released or misused," according to Warren's letter to the inspector general. In its responses, the department said it couldn't answer the senator's questions due to 'ongoing litigations,' the letter added. "These responses failed to diminish our concerns about borrowers' privacy and whether the Department may have violated the law or the federal government's procedures in handling this data," senators wrote in the letter. ABC News reached out to the Education Department and the White House about DOGE's access to borrower data but did not receive a reply before this story was published. In April, Warren launched her "Save Our Schools" campaign in opposition to President Donald Trump's and McMahon's efforts to dismantle the department. The senator has previously investigated the firing of FSA employees and how a reduction in staff at the agency could have "dire consequences" for borrowers. "ED should immediately restore all fired [Federal Student Aid] employees responsible for reviewing student aid complaints and refrain from taking any measures to deter the submission of complaints," Warren and a group of Democratic senators wrote in a letter to McMahon in March. Recently, congressional Democrats insisted McMahon cooperate with a separate inspector general review of the administration's plan to shutter the smallest Cabinet-level agency. A group of lawmakers on the Education and Workforce, Oversight, Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs, and Appropriations committees in the House and Senate sent the secretary a letter requesting she comply with the federal watchdog. "The OIG must be allowed to do its job," they wrote. "We urge the Department to immediately meet its obligation under the law to fully comply with the OIG's review. "Congress and the public need to understand the full extent and impact of the Administration's actions on the Department and the students, families, and educational communities it may no longer be able to serve," they added. McMahon's "final mission" as the 13th education secretary is to abolish the department, but the administration's first steps to diminish the agency was denied in a federal appeals court loss last week. The Department of Education has since filed an appeal with the Supreme Court. Warren urges Department of Education IG to investigate DOGE access to student loan data originally appeared on
