Google Earth helps man win planning battle over garden decking
Google Earth helps man win planning battle over garden decking
Gareth Leek won the planning case after obtaining images from Google Earth showing the decking had been in his garden for more than four years unchallenged
A photograph showing the completed decking at the house in Pontypool, Torfaen
(Image: Local Democracy Reporting Service )
A homeowner has been embroiled in a legal row with his local council over the size of his garden decking which was half a centimetre too high.
Gareth William Leek, from Pontypool, finally won permission to retain his garden decking this month after he was contacted by the council and informed he should have submitted a planning application for the size of the smart decking in his back garden – years after he'd built it.
Mr Leek told the council he was unaware the decking required any formal permission from the local authority when he built it in 2017 and he discovered when he looked further into the matter that the decking wasn't even a centimetre over the threshold for a planning application to have to be submitted. For our free daily briefing on the biggest issues facing the nation sign up to the Wales Matters newsletter here.
Mr Leek won the planning case after obtaining images from Google Earth showing the decking had been in his garden for more than four years unchallenged meaning he should legally be allowed to keep it.
He also forwarded a letter to the council which was signed by his neighbour who was supportive of Mr Leek keeping the decking as it was and agreed Mr Leek had had the decking in place in the garden since at least 2019.
Article continues below
A planning hearing heard Mr Leek had retrospectively applied for a certificate of lawful development.
The decking is 4.84m wide and 3.82m long and is 0.83cm from ground level meaning it was just over half a centimetre over the height that requires planning approval.
Planning officer Simon Pritchard acknowledged the evidence presented by Mr Leek, which included a Google Earth aerial image from June 2018.
Article continues below
The application indicated the decking was finished in October 2017 and the neighbour confirmed its presence since at least 2019 when they arrived next-door at St Augustine Road.
Mr Pritchard said that the council had no contrary evidence or reason to doubt that the decking had not been "substantially completed for less than four years".
Mr Pritchard's report confirmed that the application is now immune from enforcement action, deemed lawful, and the department has issued the certificate.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
9 hours ago
- BBC News
Pontypool homeowner uses Google Earth to win decking planning row
A homeowner has used Google Earth to keep decking he built in his garden after a planning permission dispute with a council. Gareth William Leek, from Pontypool, Torfaen, had been told a planning application was required for his decking years after it was built because it was about 50cm (20in) too far off the ground. Decking more than 30cm (12in) requires planning permission, but local authorities must take action within four years for most developments. A planning officer concluded there was no reason to doubt the decking had not been "substantially completed" for less than four years and Mr Leek's certificate of lawful development was granted. The application stated the decking had been completed in October 2017 and a statement from a neighbour supported Mr Leek's claim it had been built since at least 2019, when they moved to St Augustine Road in Griffithstown, Pontypool. As part of his evidence, Mr Leek also dug out old photographs dating back to August 2017, when the raised wooden platform was constructed. The council planning department said the 4.84m wide, and 3.82m long, light grey composite decking was 83cm from the ground level, meaning it is just over half a metre over the height that requires planning approval, which is 30cm. Planning officer Simon Pritchard said the council accepted the evidence put forward by Mr Leek which included a Google Earth aerial photograph from June Pritchard said the council did not have any evidence itself, or from anyone else, to contradict the information provided.
Wales Online
11 hours ago
- Wales Online
Aqua Park protesters to take their fight to the Senedd
Aqua Park protesters to take their fight to the Senedd 'The views of 7,000 people who have signed a petition against the Aqua Park are being blatantly ignored' Cosmeston Country Park is set to be the new location of an inflatable water park (Image: Mark Lewis ) Opposition to a planned inflatable water park at a nature reserve in south Wales is intensifying, with campaigners set to take their fight to the Senedd this week. The controversial Cardiff Bay Aqua Park is due to relocate to the eastern lake at Cosmeston Lakes Country Park, near Penarth, with a launch scheduled for Friday, July 5. The trial attraction, which will run for eight weeks over the summer, has sparked fierce backlash from local residents, environmentalists and conservation groups who argue it poses a threat to both public safety and sensitive wildlife habitats. Cosmeston Country Park spans over 100 acres and is home to a range of rare species, including the critically endangered water vole. It was designated a Local Nature Reserve in 2013 due to its rich biodiversity and is considered one of the Vale of Glamorgan's most tranquil and ecologically significant areas. A demonstration is planned outside the Senedd in Cardiff Bay at 3pm on Wednesday, June 25, just ten days before the attraction's scheduled opening. Organisers from the Save Cosmeston and the Vale campaign, part of the broader Vale Action Group, say they are now exploring legal options to halt the development. Local councillors approved the temporary trial despite a petition opposing the project that gathered over 7,000 signatures. Article continues below The Vale of Glamorgan Council has previously defended the decision, stating there is a "local appetite" for the Aqua Park and describing it as a potential "great addition" to the park's summer offerings. Yet protesters disagreed, arguing that the installation will disrupt Sites of Special Scientific Interest (SSSIs) within the park and raise serious safety concerns. Swimming has long been banned in the lakes due to their industrial past as a quarry. On June 14, over 500 people, including families with children formed a human chain around the lake in a symbolic act of protest. Organisers say this was a powerful display of community opposition that transcends local boundaries. Protesters gathered around the lake against the proposals (Image: Mark Lewis ) For our free daily briefing on the biggest issues facing the nation, sign up to the Wales Matters newsletter here Saar Lenaerts, spokesperson for Save Cosmeston and the Vale, emphasised that the group is not fundamentally against the concept of an aqua park but believes Cosmeston is the wrong location. "We continue to passionately believe Cosmeston Lakes Country Park isn't the right place for this attraction. We are not against the Aqua Park in principle but its location. There are far more suitable and less dangerous places for it to be situated," Saar said. "Swimming has been banned in Cosmeston lakes for years due to its past industrial use as a quarry. We simply cannot understand what has changed to suddenly to make it safe. We truly believe people's lives will be at risk." Saar also criticised the adequacy of ecological and water safety testing, which she claims was conducted by the company itself under the supervision of Natural Resources Wales. The campaign alleges the process lacked transparency and proper public consultation. "Some people have accused us of being NIMBYS, of being selfish and not thinking of young people, even maliciousness. This is simply untrue." she added. "Many of the protesters do not live in on Cosmeston's doorstep and the views of 7,000 people who have signed a petition against the Aqua Park are being blatantly ignored. The Vale of Glamorgan's responses have been divisive, dismissive, and derogatory." Protestors have cited the diverse wildlife that inhabit the lake (Image: Taite Johnson ) The protest group says it has received pro bono legal guidance and is considering legal action as a last resort. A Crowdfunder campaign to support their efforts has received significant backing. "I would encourage as many people as possible to join us outside the Senedd 3pm Wednesday to make some noise and voice our presence to Members of the Senedd who will be sitting in a plenary session that afternoon." The Aqua Park was previously located in Cardiff Bay, but its operators were forced to find a new venue after concerns were raised over water quality. If the trial at Cosmeston proves successful, the company may seek to extend its licence beyond the summer. Meanwhile, environmental groups and campaigners continue to call for a re-evaluation of the decision, arguing that short-term entertainment should not come at the expense of long-term environmental protection. Connor James, founder of Aqua Park Cardiff, said the company was "thrilled" to bring the attention to Cosmeston in partnership with the council. In early June he said: "We're thrilled to bring Aqua Park Cardiff to Cosmeston Lakes by partnering with The Vale of Glamorgan Council. 'The Country Park is a fantastic venue for our exciting watersport experience, perfect for supervised adventure and family fun. With an exciting new course of obstacles, we can't wait to welcome visitors to our incredible new home. 'We are also really excited to be playing our part in giving people and families much-needed access to active outdoor experience, in a controlled and supervised environment to help boost their physical and mental well-being.' Vale of Glamorgan councillor Bronwen Brooks - the deputy leader and cabinet member for sustainable places - also previously defended the decision: "The Aqua Park will be another great addition to the already fantastic offer at Cosmeston Country Park as the Council continues to promote sustainable tourism and leisure activities in the area. "Consultation with residents through the council's placemaking work has shown there is appetite locally - particularly among young people - for more varied leisure activities, and the re-introduction of water-based activities at Cosmeston will help us to ensure that our Country Parks are for everyone. Article continues below "Trying new things is at the heart of what we do as an ambitious council, and this pilot could also enable further income opportunities for our Country Parks – especially in supporting the re-wilding and conservation work already underway at Cosmeston."
BBC News
11 hours ago
- BBC News
Hinckley school's fears over mouldy and 'unsafe' classrooms
Officials at a school in Hinckley have claimed they were denied funding to deal with leaky and mouldy classrooms. Battling Brook Primary School said it can no longer use two of its teaching rooms because they are "unsafe".The Local Democracy Reporting Service (LDRS) said the school had applied for government funding to replace the affected mobile classrooms but had its bid rejected for reasons "outside of its control".The Department for Education (DfE) has urged the school to apply for a grant from its Urgent Capital Support fund. The school said the mobile units, which are more than 10-years-old, have rotten flooring, leaking ceilings and mould on the walls. The LDRS said the rejection of the school's bid for funds followed a recent government announcement that 22 other local education settings would receive a share of a £45.2m pot to carry out "urgent" safety and safeguarding works. The school told the LDRS the unusable classrooms were having wider impacts on its pupils.A school spokesperson said the issue has resulted in a "reduction in space for intervention groups including nurture sessions, small group work, breakfast club provision and music lessons".The spokesperson said the issues were impacting the "integrity of the whole block" and concerns over "water ingress" have meant the electricity has had to be "turned off". In winter this means heating cannot be run in them so "the areas of the school which border these classrooms are extremely cold". The school believes missing information in a report commissioned by the school, and for the government, meant it scored below the threshold needed for the funding to be offered. It added the report was completed too close to the government's deadline for them to request it be changed. It is appealing the refusal of its funding bid, with the government saying it can expect an outcome in August. A DfE spokesperson said it was providing long-term maintenance funding nationally through to 2034-35, rising to almost £3bn per year to improve the condition of schools and said nearly £20bn was available through its School Rebuilding DfT spokesperson said unsuccessful applicants should also consider applying for the government's Urgent Capital Support MP Dr Luke Evans has asked early education minister Stephen Morgan to meet him to discuss the matter and try to get funding to solve the issues before the new school year starts in September.
