logo
Push for new Florida bear hunt ignores real source of problems: Humans

Push for new Florida bear hunt ignores real source of problems: Humans

Yahoo13-03-2025

The population of the Florida black bear is about what it was a decade ago, yet there are calls for hunting them again. (Photo via FWC)
The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission is once again considering holding a bear hunt. To me, this is like saying, 'The captain of the Titanic in interested in sailing straight toward the nearest iceberg, because it went SO well last time.'
The last bear hunt was a decade ago. I was there, so trust me when I tell you it was a disaster for both the bears and the FWC. James Cameron didn't direct a movie about it, the way he did for the Titanic, but he could have.
The hunt was supposed to last a whole week. Instead, after hunters killed 304 bears in just two days, the wildlife commission's executive director shut it down early. Of that number, 36 lactating mama bears were slain, meaning there were probably some cubs left orphaned.
One critic of the hunt, Chuck O'Neal of Speak Up Wekiva, said it was as challenging as hunting dairy cows. The bears were that laid back and easy to target.
I am hopeful that this latest attempt to let people shoot at Florida's fairly rare bears can be blocked before a single gun is cocked. The wildlife commission is soliciting public opinion by holding an online hearing on the issue tonight (Thursday). The agency is also collecting feedback via email through BearComments@MyFWC.com.
A good question to ask them might be: 'Commissioners, how can you hold a hunt to kill bears when you can't even say for sure how many bears there are?'
That question is one that even bothers the pro-hunting folks.
Every day, about 900 new people move to Florida. Most of them have no idea we have bears here — or that the new home they just bought was built in what probably used to be bear habitat.
Then when a bear shows up to hang out on their porch, or swing in their hammock or chillax in their hot tub, they freak out and call 911 as if it's the bear that's the intruder.
Florida's bears are smaller than grizzlies, reaching a maximum of only 750 pounds (compared to more than 1,000 for their Western relatives). Their diet mostly consists of berries, acorns, and insects. That means they usually have no interest in gobbling up you or your little dog too.
They once roamed all over the state, but between hunting and rampant development of their habitat, their population dwindled to just a few hundred by the 1970s. That's when the state listed them as threatened.
There was talk of putting them on the federal endangered list too. But in 1992, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service said listing the Florida black bear was 'warranted but precluded' under the Endangered Species Act.
What that meant was that other species needed protection more urgently and the government simply didn't have enough dough to cover the bears too.
Six years later, though, the federal agency decided the bears did not need protecting after all. Agency officials said they were confident Florida's bears had a 'stable' future, thanks to the state's strict land management rules created by the 1985 Growth Management Act.
Those are the rules that developers persuaded then-Gov. Rick Scott and the Legislature to ditch in 2011. They dumped them in favor of our current system, which is based on approving development wherever developers want to build it, no matter what problems may result.
Meanwhile, the FWC took bears off the state's own imperiled wildlife list in 2012. The trouble started the following year.
With so many people moving into the bears' habitat, conflicts were bound to happen. Sure enough, bears made a series of violent attacks on humans between 2013 and 2015.
The bears were hungry and had wandered into areas where they found loose garbage can lids and the people who owned the cans. One Central Florida man, claiming he was 'the Bear Whisperer,' had even been feeding them by hand. At least, he did so until one of his neighbors was attacked.
Why were the bears rooting in garbage cans? It was the state's own fault.
In its infinite wisdom, the state Agriculture Department was letting people harvest unlimited amounts of saw palmetto berries from Florida's 37 state forests. The berry-pickers paid $10 for the right to collect an unlimited amount of berries. Then they would sell them to companies marketing them as a questionable cure for men's sexual problems.
No, I am not making that up. Erectile dysfunction led to ecosystem dysfunction.
Once the link between the berry collectors and the bear attacks became clear, the state halted the unlimited berry-picking in state forests. But by then, some members of the FWC had decided the best solution was to shoot a lot of bears for the first time in 21 years.
Tens of thousands of people wrote in to urge the commissioners not to do it. When I asked the commission's pro-hunting chairman, Tampa mall developer Richard Corbett, why the board was ignoring the public's wishes, he about chewed my head off.
'Those people don't know what they're talking about,' Corbett barked at me. 'Most of those people have never been in the woods. They think we're talking about teddy bears: 'Oh Lord, don't hurt my little teddy bear!' Well, these bears are dangerous.' (Amid the subsequent uproar over Corbett's rant, he resigned.)
Of course, the hunt showed which animal in Florida is the more dangerous one. Proposals for a follow-up hunt the next year were, pardon the pun, shot down.
Yet ever since then, we've continued killing the bears — sometimes via poaching but more commonly by hitting them with our cars. About 300 died on Florida's roadways last year.
Then came the December wildlife commission meeting.
The commissioners, meeting in Lakeland, had a lot to talk about — gopher tortoise management, manatee protection zones, stone crabs, and so forth. But before they got to that stuff, they had scheduled 'a 5-year update on implementation of the 2019 Florida Black Bear Management Plan.'
The update, delivered by a well-respected state bear expert named Mike Orlando, included, according to the agenda, 'an overview of bear management efforts and current research activities.' The subject of hunting was not on the agenda, but it came up anyway.
If you want, you can watch the meeting the way I did this week, on video from the Florida Channel. It's fascinating.
First comes Orlando's extensive and factual report on all that the scientists are doing, which includes his comment that they are not recommending any changes right now to what the commission is doing.
Then comes a long line of public commenters, some of whom say they believe it's time for another hunt and some of whom say no new hunt is needed or wanted. One speaker, Katrina Shadix of Bear Warriors United, told the commissioners the state's human population was the one that had exceeded its carrying capacity, not the bear population.
One thing both sides said, over and over, is that they'd like to see an updated, statewide population figure for the bears. Orlando said the scientists were working on it, but that such a number would not be ready until 2029.
As soon as the public commenters were done, Commission Chairman Rodney Barreto, a Coral Gables developer (do you see a trend here?), asked if any of the commissioners had anything to say. Commissioner Gary Lester, who works for the developer of mega-retirement mecca The Villages, was the first to pipe up.
'I'll be very succinct,' he said. 'I would like to see a proposal from staff for a bear hunt.'
That slippery sound you hear is the commission's skids being greased.
'For the FWC to even consider a hunt before these [population] studies are complete is outrageously irresponsible, dangerous and just plain WRONG!' Shadix told me via email.
One of the people I talked to about this was a former wildlife commissioner, Ronald 'Alligator Ron' Bergeron.
Bergeron got his nickname because he once tried to wrestle an alligator. It nearly drowned him before he punched it in the snout and made it turn loose of his hand.
Bergeron, who's also been a rodeo champ and a python hunter, is not a shy guy. He was on the wildlife commission in 2015, and he was the lone commissioner who voted against holding the last bear hunt.
He counseled his colleagues to slow down their unseemly rush to approve a hunt for a creature he first saw from his grandfather's airboat at age 5. Bears are an icon of the Florida wild and should be given respect, he contended.
'I believe that we need to evaluate, take our time a little bit here,' he told them. They ignored him.
A year later, his was the loudest voice calling for the commission not to repeat that debacle. That time, his colleagues listened to him.
When we talked this week, Bergeron introduced me to his daughter, Diamond, who is taking over his Bergeron Everglades Foundation. She was at the December wildlife commission meeting and noticed the same thing I did.
Before holding the hunt in 2015, the FWC's scientists estimated there were about 4,300 bears, but they were still counting at that point. The commission pushed ahead with the hunt anyway.
The most recent numbers from FWC's scientists are still an estimate, not a precise count. And the latest estimate, 10 years after that botched hunt, is that there are 4,050 bears. No gains, just a dip from a decade ago.
'I don't think they know how many bears there are in the state,' Diamond Bergeron said. 'I'm still trying to wrap my head around that.'
The key to allowing humans to hunt wild animals is sustainability, the former wildlife commissioner told me. If you don't know how many bears there are, how can you be sure we won't kill too many in a hunt? How can you guarantee this important species will remain a part of wild Florida?
Considering there have been no further incidents in which bears mauled people, as there were before the last hunt, what's supposed to be the goal of holding a new hunt?
That's why, Bergeron said, 'I don't think any different than I thought in 2015. I don't believe [a hunt] is necessary.'
And his daughter pointed out another figure, one that I had missed. In 2024, Orlando and his staff fielded the fewest number of human complaints about bears in the past five years, she said.
So, if there are fewer conflicts between humans and bears, and no recent attacks by bears, and fewer bears than there were 10 years ago, then what's the point of hunting them?
There are signs that this is part of a long game by a small group that's been planning for a long time to push the state into another hunt. And they fooled the voters on this last fall.
Last year, some of the same people who want a bear hunt pushed through a vote on a strange state constitutional amendment that said hunting and fishing are recognized as rights under the law.
The measure was sponsored by Sanford Sen. Jason Brodeur, who's such a friend to the environment that he won a 2021 award from the Florida Home Builders Association.
It seemed like a pointless exercise, because no one was calling for a ban on either hunting or fishing. But some people — I was one — opposed this amendment because it also said that hunting and fishing would become the 'preferred method' of wildlife management in Florida.
Hunting and fishing did not save the manatee or any other creature, including the bear. To give those practices preference in wildlife management seemed like an effort to tie the hands of scientists.
The measure passed anyway. Several of the folks who spoke in December in favor of a new bear hunt cited that constitutional amendment as a reason to hold a new hunt, contending the voters wanted one.
These claims are about as valid as those of Rep. Jason Shoaf, R-Shoot-em-up, who apparently saw a movie called 'Cocaine Bear' and believed it to be a documentary. He claimed last year that bears on drugs were wreaking havoc in Florida.
'We're talking about the ones that are on crack, and they break your door down, and they're standing in your living room growling and tearing your house apart,' Shoaf told a House committee considering an anti-bear bill he was pushing.
Florida's bears are, unlike some Florida politicians, drug-free. Yet Shoaf's dopey bill allowing poachers to claim they were standing their ground against drugged-up bears passed both houses and was signed into law.
Shoaf, by the way, has been calling for a new bear hunt since 2023.
'We really need a bear hunt,' he told the News Service of Florida two years ago. 'It's what we need here in North Florida. We're inundated. We've got way too many.'
I think we need to send Rep. Shoaf, Commissioner Lester, and several other folks to some remedial math courses. That way maybe they can understand that what we're 'inundated' with is humans, not bears. Our growing population is crowding the bears, not the other way around.
I'd also like to require them all to watch something — no, not the movie 'Titanic,' but another boating related entertainment. It's one of the earliest TV shows about Florida, which starred Dennis Weaver as an airboat-piloting game warden whose son had a pet bear.
It was called 'Gentle Ben.'
SUPPORT: YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Three hunters capture this huge invasive species in Everglades swamps
Three hunters capture this huge invasive species in Everglades swamps

Miami Herald

time2 hours ago

  • Miami Herald

Three hunters capture this huge invasive species in Everglades swamps

Three hunters captured a 16-foot-long, 105-pound python in the Everglades just as they were returning home after a night of searching for the enormous invasive snakes that have become a scourge in South Florida. Zach Hoffman, Jan Gianello, and Justice Sargood hunted the snake in the early morning hours of May 31 near Everglades City, in Collier County in the southwest of the state. Hoffman said they decided to check one last spot on the way home when they suddenly saw what looked like a shadow. They immediately jumped out of the truck and ran toward the snake that was between the road and the ditch. Sargood held the python by the head and began wrestling with it. 'Jan and I controlled the rest of the body so it wouldn't coil too tightly. Once we had control of the snake, we ethically removed it. Then we realized what we had just caught,' Hoffman told the Naples Daily News. Read more: Do you want to help protect the Everglades ecosystem and win up to $10,000? The trio has been hunting the monstrous snakes for three years, and as of last May, the largest they had caught measured 10 feet, 2 inches, he said. The three have captured more than 100 pythons. Another group of python hunters captured the longest Burmese python ever measured on July 10, 2023, in Big Cypress National Preserve in eastern Collier County. It measured 19 feet. Burmese pythons have a negative impact on native species. They are primarily found in and around the Everglades ecosystem in South Florida, where they feed on birds, mammals and other reptiles. These snakes were first found in the Everglades swamps in 1979 in Miami-Dade County and are believed to have been released or escaped from captivity. A breeding population was confirmed in the early 2000s, and the snake was recognized as an established invasive species. They are found in Broward, Palm Beach, and Monroe counties, and on the southwest coast of Florida. Since 2000, more than 23,000 Burmese pythons have been removed from Florida's natural habitat, according to data from the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission. Burmese pythons are aggressive predators that disrupt the food chain, affecting native birds, mammals, and reptiles. A single female can lay more than 100 eggs at a time, which accelerates their spread.

The Truth About the 'Titan' Sub Disaster: 'Baffling' Decisions, Their Final Moments and a 'Smoking Gun' (Exclusive)
The Truth About the 'Titan' Sub Disaster: 'Baffling' Decisions, Their Final Moments and a 'Smoking Gun' (Exclusive)

Yahoo

time7 hours ago

  • Yahoo

The Truth About the 'Titan' Sub Disaster: 'Baffling' Decisions, Their Final Moments and a 'Smoking Gun' (Exclusive)

Two years after the Titan tragedy killed five people, a clearer picture is emerging about what led to catastrophe and why no one averted it PEOPLE interviewed investigators as well as people who were close to the company behind the sub, some of whom are also featured in a new Netflix documentary 'It comes down to Stockton Rush. The decisions he made led to this. It was a cult of personality. If you went against him, you were likely to be out'Bonnie Carl remembers the text she received from a friend in June 2023: 'Have you seen? OceanGate's in the news.' Her heart sank. She suspected what had happened — and who had suffered for it: 'But I thought, 'Jesus Christ, I don't want to be right.' ' On June 18 the submersible Titan, built by Carl's former employer, the headline-grabbing exploration company OceanGate, went missing off the coast of Newfoundland, Canada, as it headed 12,500 ft. beneath the surface of the Atlantic Ocean to the wreck of the Titanic. The world was gripped by the search for the strange vessel and its five wealthy passengers and crew, counting down the hours before oxygen would run out some two miles deep in ink-black water. Then, four days after it disappeared, shredded pieces of the 22-ft. sub were found on the ocean floor near the century-old resting place of the doomed liner it had sought. Titan imploded under the crushing weight of the sea, killing all four passengers along with OceanGate cofounder Stockton Rush, 61, who was piloting the vehicle. 'When they found the wreckage, it gutted me. It still does,' says Carl, breaking down in tears. 'I'm angry. This shouldn't have happened.' The fact that it did, however, seems to surprise no one who was close to OceanGate or to its ambitious — some say domineering­ — leader. Now, two years after the tragedy, as the U.S. Coast Guard is preparing to release its final report this month after extensive investigation, a clearer picture is emerging of what led to Titan's terrifying final moments — and why no one averted catastrophe. The USCG inquiry, along with a new Netflix documentary, Titan: The OceanGate Disaster, and PEOPLE's interviews with former employees and confidants of Rush, describes a fatally flawed submersible design made worse by carelessness, a charismatic leader whose dreams blinded him to his faults and a company culture of fear that kept the dangers hidden from the public. 'It comes down to Stockton Rush. The decisions he made led to this,' says Mark Monroe, director of the Netflix doc. 'It was a cult of personality. If you went against him, you were likely to be out.' Rush believed 'the rules didn't apply [to him] ... and that there's value in breaking them,' says Monroe. But 'there are also rules of physics and engineering — and those apply to all of us.' Titan When Bonnie Carl was hired as OceanGate's bookkeeper in 2017, 'it was my dream job,' she recalls. A Seattle native, Carl was a CPA who had fallen in love with sea life and scuba diving four years earlier, and OceanGate offered her the chance to help with dives at its Everett, Wash., headquarters, and to learn to pilot a sub from the company's director of marine operations, David Lochridge. Lochridge, a former diver in the U.K. Royal Navy who had become an expert pilot specializing in sub rescues, fixated on the water as a boy visiting his grandparents on the Isle of Cumbrae off the coast of Scotland. Like Carl and many other OceanGate employees and investors, Lochridge was intrigued by Rush and his mission to make sea exploration more accessible with less expensive vessels. 'Stockton was a visionary who was trying to democratize the abyss,' says Fred Hagen, a developer who made two trips to the Titanic on Titan. 'That was a noble cause.' Born into wealth and an ancestral line that stretched to the nation's founding, Rush — with piercing blue eyes, thick silver hair and a square jaw — carried an air of the patrician set. He graduated from Princeton University with a degree in aerospace engineering, built and piloted his own plane and submersible, became a venture capitalist — and married the great-great-granddaughter of a couple who died on the Titanic. Rush started OceanGate in 2009 and later began working on a sub design made of carbon fiber, which is lighter and cheaper than the typical titanium or steel. Industry experts were skeptical the material could withstand extreme pressure. But Rush persisted, even after small-scale prototypes imploded. Some in the close-knit diving community believe he was certain that he'd make it work eventually—and make history too. ­'Stockton took risks and lived outside the box,' Hagen says. 'And he paid for it with his life.' Never miss a story — sign up for to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories. Immediately after Lochridge joined OceanGate in 2016, when Titan was still in development, he could see things weren't adding up: 'The emperor,' he says, 'had no clothes.' In his first meeting with Rush, the CEO declared he didn't want underwater communication equipment. 'I genuinely thought he was joking, but he was deadly serious,' Lochridge says. 'It blew me away.' Though Rush relented, Lochridge says his safety questions were 'always met with resistance.' Lochridge's unease grew as construction on Titan began. The vessel's end caps, made of titanium, were affixed to the hull with glue. 'Four guys ... were applying it with spatulas,' he says. 'There was nobody verifying there were no voids. It was like somebody putting icing on a birthday cake.' Worse, Rush refused to get the vessel 'classified,' or safety-inspected by an independent agency. 'It would have cost a lot of money,' Lochridge says. Carl saw the company was far from solvent: When an $800,000 check came in from a woman who signed up for a Titanic trip, she used it to pay outstanding bills. Lochridge's conflict with Rush erupted in January 2018, after he shared his concerns in an internal report. Rush — who Carl says idolized billionaire entrepreneurs like Jeff Bezos and Elon Musk, referring to them as 'big swinging d----'—was ­furious at the perceived lack of loyalty. He told Lochridge, 'I'm sure the industry thinks I'm a f------ idiot. That's fine. ... But I'm not going to force people to join my religion.' He fired Lochridge and told Carl she'd be head pilot. 'Are you nuts?' she thought. 'I'm an accountant.' She left as well. Rush forged ahead with Titan, despite worrying signs from an onboard warning system that detected the sounds of carbon fibers popping, likely weakening the structure of the hull. 'If I'd heard noises like that in a sub, I would never go on it again,' says Lochridge. Rush, on the other hand, was promoting his project with infomercials and hired as a guide the renowned Titanic expert P.H. Nargeolet, whose 35-plus years of experience lent gravitas to the venture. By 2021 OceanGate started taking its sub to the Titanic and charging six-figure tickets per person to join as a 'mission specialist' — a safety work-around 'to have passengers appear to be crew,' says the Coast Guard's Jason Neubauer, who was preparing to retire when he decided to lead the Titan probe. The company also skirted regulation by not 'flagging,' or registering, Titan with a country. The sub continued with dives in 2022, and the carbon fiber pops grew more frequent, culminating in a crack that year loud enough to be heard by the surface crew, according to Neubauer. 'That data was completely ignored,' he says, likening the decision to a 'smoking gun.' Instead of investigating, OceanGate left Titan in a parking lot for most of the winter, where it was covered by snow. 'It was baffling,' Neubauer says. 'Especially since carbon fiber is susceptible to the elements.' After more than six months outside, Titan was back in use in 2023. On the morning of June 18, Rush was joined for another expedition by Nargeolet, 77, businessman Shahzada Dawood, 48, and his son Suleman, 19, and explorer Hamish Harding, 58. Just over 90 minutes into their descent, as Titan drew close to the Titanic and said it was shedding weight, they lost contact. Seconds later Rush's wife, Wendy, who was on the support ship, heard a boom. Investigators now believe it was the implosion — a calamitous crunch. Weeks after that, remote-operated vehicles recovered remnants from inside the sub, much of which had been compressed into what one investigator termed 'sludge.' Among the identifiable artifacts: a scrap of Rush's diving jumpsuit and 'Titanic Expedition' stickers. Little else remained of the man who promised to open up the oceans' dark depths to the world — or the passengers killed in his attempt. 'I still question it every day: How could he not see this was dangerous?' Carl says. 'In my opinion, he clearly wanted fame. Stockton had his mind set. He was going to do this no matter what.' Read the original article on People

Family's dog ‘Zeus' dragged into Florida pond by massive alligator and miraculously comes out alive: ‘I don't know how he survived'
Family's dog ‘Zeus' dragged into Florida pond by massive alligator and miraculously comes out alive: ‘I don't know how he survived'

New York Post

time14 hours ago

  • New York Post

Family's dog ‘Zeus' dragged into Florida pond by massive alligator and miraculously comes out alive: ‘I don't know how he survived'

A family dog named Zeus summoned the strength of his namesake and managed to escape the literal jaws of death when an alligator dragged him from his backyard into a nearby pond, the dog's owners said. 'The vet told us the gator had just missed his jugular — it looked like Zeus's entire head had been in the gator's mouth. The fact that he made it out alive is nothing short of a miracle,' the family wrote in a GoFundMe post. Even the vet said, ''I don't know how he survived,'' the family added. 3 Zeus, a German Shepherd who survived a gator attack, wears the cone of shame while he recovers. GoFundMe Zeus, a German Shepherd, heard a noise on the night of June 2 and scooted through his doggie door out of his home in Wesley Chapel, Fla., to investigate, the family said. In an instant, an alligator came crashing through their backyard fence, snatched Zeus and dragged him to a pond, they said. 'My dad came in frantic. I'd never seen him like that. He's a tough guy. He said, 'The alligator just took Zeus,'' Zeus' owner Susan Alkhatib told WFLA. The family watched in horror as Zeus struggled while the alligator thrashed with the German Shepherd's head in its mouth. Finally, Zeus managed to escape the beast and the alligator swam off. 3 The alligator that attacked Zeus has managed to elude trappers on the hunt for him. GoFundMe 'The alligator had just let go of Zeus,' Alkhatib told WFLA. 'We started yelling at him to come toward us. When he got closer, he got tired. So we had to kind of go into the pond a little bit to get him.' Susan's mom waded into the pond and grabbed the battered pet and they rushed him to a veterinarian hospital for an emergency surgery. After the attack, Alkhatib said they don't feel as safe at home anymore. 'We have a doggy door, and Zeus will go in and out of it whenever he wants,' Alkhatib said. 'We have it covered right now because of what happened.' The family had taken a video of the scaly culprit earlier in the day when the gator had been lurking along the banks of the water. The family told WFLA that the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission has sent out trappers, but so far, the guilty gator has avoided capture. 3 Zeus suffered a broken jaw and underwent surgery after an alligator attacked him and dragged him into a pond near his home in Florida. GoFundMe Meanwhile, Zeus is slowly but surely recovering, according to the family. He sustained a fractured jaw, puncture wounds, and the vet needed to manually realign his jaw and wire it together. He's on a liquid diet fed to him with a syringe until he has another surgery in about 8 weeks. He'll also need to wear a muzzle for at least another month. A picture of the recovering miracle pup shows him post-surgery with his wounds around his neck and face, with much of his fur shaved off from the surgery. 'Despite it all, Zeus continues to be such a trooper,' the family wrote in a recent update on GoFundMe. 'He's getting tons of love, snuggles, and care.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store