Vegetarians May Be Less Benevolent Than Meat Eaters, Study Claims
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources.
Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content.
A new study suggests that people who follow a vegetarian diet may place less importance on certain social values—like caring for close others and conforming to societal norms—than those who regularly eat meat.
In his paper, published in the journal PLOS ONE, psychologist professor John Nezlek of the College of William and Mary in Virginia conducted a meta-analysis of three past studies from both the United States and Poland to assess how core human values differ between vegetarians and non-vegetarians.
"The present results suggest that vegetarians hold values consistent with being members of a social minority who are willing to stand by their principles," he wrote.
A stock image showing a vegetarian salad.
A stock image showing a vegetarian salad.
VeselovaElena/iStock / Getty Images Plus
What The Study Did
Nezlek analyzed three past studies involving adult subjects: one in the U.S., where vegetarians were oversampled (514 vegetarians vs. 540 non-vegetarians); and two in Poland (68 vegetarians and 1,943 non-vegetarians).
Their responses were valued against Schwartz's Portrait Value Questionnaire that measures ten "basic human values," such as Benevolence (looking after friends and family), Security (seeking safety and stability), and Self-direction (valuing independence).
Participants in the U.S. study completed the 57-item Portrait Values Questionnaire–Revised (PVQ-RR) to assess Schwartz's model of basic human values, while respondents in both Polish samples completed the shorter, 21-item PVQ.
In each version, participants compare themselves to a gender-specific "person" described in terms of various aspirations and goals—for example: "Thinking up new ideas and being creative is important to her; she likes to do things her own original way," or "Being very successful is important to him; he likes to impress other people."
These gendered formulations are intended to strengthen respondents' ability to relate to the comparison figure.
Across all studies, participants rated each item on the standard six-point scale: 1 = not like me at all, 2 = not like me, 3 = a little like me, 4 = moderately like me, 5 = like me and 6 = very much like me.
Key Findings
Lower benevolence : Across all three samples, vegetarians rated benevolence (concern for those close to you) significantly lower than meat eaters did. This suggests vegetarians, on average, place less emphasis on nurturing personal relationships than non-vegetarians .
: Across all three samples, vegetarians rated benevolence (concern for those close to you) significantly lower than meat eaters did. This suggests vegetarians, on average, place less emphasis on nurturing personal relationships than non-vegetarians . Reduced security and conformity : Vegetarians also scored lower on security (valuing safety and harmony) and conformity (following social norms).
: Vegetarians also scored lower on security (valuing safety and harmony) and conformity (following social norms). Higher stimulation, achievement, and power: those who avoid meat rated values like stimulation (seeking excitement), achievement (personal success), and power (control over resources) higher than meat eaters.
Why Does This Matter?
These findings challenge the common perception that vegetarians are uniformly more "benevolent" or community-oriented.
Instead, the data indicates that adopting a vegetarian diet may reflect a broader willingness to break from tradition and assert personal independence—perhaps even to seek power or achievement in non-traditional ways.
However, study focused on two Western countries; whether these patterns hold in other continents remains unknown.
Nezlek argues that choosing a minority diet is a deliberate act of individualism.
"The present results suggest that although vegetarians may be more sensitive to the pain and suffering of animals and may be more aware of threats to the environment than non-vegetarians, this sensitivity and awareness do not reflect basic human value of benevolence," he explained.
Do you have a tip on a science story that Newsweek should be covering? Do you have a question about vegetarianism? Let us know via science@newsweek.com.
Reference
Nezlek, J. B. (2025). Rethinking vegetarianism: Differences between vegetarians and non-vegetarians in the endorsement of basic human values. PLOS ONE, 20(5). https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0323202
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Newsweek
an hour ago
- Newsweek
Scientists Make World's Smallest Violin
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. Scientists in the United Kingdom have made what may be the world's smallest violin, using advanced nanotechnology. The microscopic instrument, measuring 35 by 13 microns, and constructed from platinum, is less than the width of a human hair, said Loughborough University researchers. Why It Matters The tiny violin was created to demonstrate the accuracy and versatility of a state-of-the-art nanolithography system. Kelly Morrison, the head of Loughborough University's Physics Department, said the system would allow scientists "to design experiments that probe materials in different ways—using light, magnetism, or electricity—and observe their responses." Scientists said the technology could accelerate breakthroughs in sectors such as computing and energy, allowing researchers to build and study materials at the smallest scale. The 'world's smallest violin' created by Loughborough University physicists. The 'world's smallest violin' created by Loughborough University physicists. Loughborough University What To Know The miniature violin was made using a NanoFrazor, a system that employs thermal scanning probe lithography. This technique uses a heated, needlelike tip to sculpt material at nanometer precision. According to the university's press release, the process began with a chip being covered in two layers a gel-like material. The pattern was then etched, washed and coated in platinum, then cleaned again to show the final form. Each violin took about three hours to produce after the fabrication sequence was determined, but it took months of development. The violin, which is only an image at microscopic scale, cannot produce sound. The institution said the violin had not been officially confirmed as the world's smallest, though it is smaller than the diameter of a human hair, which typically measures 17 to 180 microns (a micron is a millionth of a meter). Research projects using the nanolithography system to investigate applications—such as developing energy-efficient and faster data storage by combining advanced materials and nanoparticles—are underway at the university. Other research explores quantum materials to make next-generation memory devices smaller, faster and more reliable, and the nanolithography system helps to produce accurate test structures. The team said the knowledge gained from the violin process was vital for these advances. The expression "world's smallest violin" is often used to mock exaggerated complaints. It is believed to have originated in a 1978 episode of M*A*S*H when Major Margaret Houlihan, rubbing her thumb and forefinger together, said: "It's the world's smallest violin, and it's playing just for you," According to ClassicFM. Professor Kelly Morrison, left, with Dr. Naëmi Leo, in front of the Loughborough University nanolithography system. Dr. Leo holds the chip that features the image of 'the world's smallest violin'. Professor Kelly Morrison, left, with Dr. Naëmi Leo, in front of the Loughborough University nanolithography system. Dr. Leo holds the chip that features the image of 'the world's smallest violin'. Loughborough University What People Are Saying Kelly Morrison, the head of Loughborough University's Physics Department, said in a press release: "Though creating the world's smallest violin may seem like fun and games, a lot of what we've learned in the process has actually laid the groundwork for the research we're now undertaking." She added: "I'm really excited about the level of control and possibilities we have with the setup. I'm looking forward to seeing what I can achieve—but also what everyone else can do with the system." What Happens Next The researchers plan to use the experience and protocols established during this project in ongoing work on data storage and quantum material studies, furthering research into advanced computing technologies.
Newsweek
2 hours ago
- Newsweek
American's Trip to Italy Leads to Shocking Revelation About US: 'So Much Resentment'
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. An American traveler who went to Italy on a two-week trip returned with a new perspective—and a lot of resentment—regarding American food. Sharing her experience on Reddit this week, user Temporary-Night-275 said she was able to eat foods in Italy that would have triggered bad reactions back home. Dietary Changes Felt "My mood was better, my awareness was better," the original poster (OP) wrote. "I could eat wheat (I'm extremely gluten intolerant and it messes with my autoimmune disease if I eat it among a multitude of other symptoms) with gluten pills with minor bloating. "I had some of the best food, best health feelings (other than muscle soreness from walking so much) I've ever had in my life." Stock image: Dishes of processed food. Stock image: Dishes of processed food. Photo by carotur / Getty Images Processed food has been shown to "most likely" shorten your life. According to researchers, Americans are "addicted" to it. 'I want to move' The difference, the Redditor believes, lies in how food is produced and regulated. "Sugar and wheat and whatever else is just so much harder on my body here than Italy," she wrote. The OP added that she generally eats healthy, even at home. "I want to move," she wrote, adding, "It sucks here. Government sucks, food sucks, work sucks. "I got the freshest food at a market (quite a bit of it too) for so cheap. Food that would cost me $20-25 was roughly $11. "I hate it here." 'Infinitely better' User Temporary-Night-275 elaborated that the food tasted "fresher" and the texture was "infinitely better," in response to an invitation to comment from Newsweek. "Things just had way better flavor and texture overall and I could tell I was eating better food just by the lack of sugar taste," she wrote, adding, "Even the chips just tasted like quality. "My skin cleared up significantly and I was neglecting my skin routine," she added. The OP said she did have some bloating from the gluten, but no additional symptoms like itching and diarrhea. "So I still felt symptoms, but when you [haven't eaten] gluten for 10 years and have some light bloating after eating pizza, a cornetti and then pasta, I'll take that as a win," she wrote. 'The quality of our food is garbage' Many Reddit users agreed with the OP, amid 1,300 comments within two days online. "My brother's [significant other] is from Singapore," an individual shared, "They regularly mention how sugary and sweet everything is in the U.S. "With health trends like fasting and keto, I almost feel like that speaks for itself. Our food is so bad here people choose to not eat, or completely cut out certain foods they sell here because it will help lose/manage weight. "But the issue isn't even the type of food. It's what's in our food. Other countries have diets that are extremely carb heavy and you'll still see people that are skinny and relatively healthier. "The quality of our food is garbage." A fellow contributor said they spent three weeks in the U.S. and took them 3-4 months to recover: "It's the land of the free: free to sell crap to the customers." Another critic said that their Canadian mother has "endless gut issues" and is gluten intolerant. "Every time she goes to Spain, her stomach stays flat and she feels great. It's terrifying!" Other Factors at Play? Fellow Redditors argued that other factors could be at play. "The U.S. ranks third in the world for food quality and safety. Check out the Global Food Security Index," a user commented. "Most people don't feel good in the U.S. because we're overworked and have barely anything to show for it. Our cities being entirely centered around cars is the biggest issue aside from the lack of cheap and accessible health care here." 'Depressed in America' User Temporary-Night-275 told Newsweek that she was serious about moving and it may be in her 5-year plan. "Between health care, better food, better work-life balance in a lot of other countries, I just want something that makes me feel well," the OP continued. "I'm depressed in America, learning more what happens every day in our government and the s*** food were given [...] "It was magical being able to eat good food again. I definitely am planning my next trip to Italy." Newsweek's "What Should I Do?" offers expert advice to readers. If you have a personal dilemma, let us know via life@ We can ask experts for advice on relationships, family, friends, money and work, and your story could be featured on WSID at Newsweek. To read how Newsweek uses AI as a newsroom tool, click here.
Newsweek
4 hours ago
- Newsweek
'Doomsday Fish' Discoveries Spark Fears Of Impending Natural Disaster
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. The recent discoveries of two rare deep-sea dwelling oarfish have sparked fears of a looming natural disaster. The fish were discovered in separate incidents in India and Tasmania within the last week. In the first incident, fishermen in Tamil Nadu, India, pulled a 30-foot oarfish from the water. The massive fish required seven men to hold it for the video. Stock image of an oarfish. Stock image of an oarfish. Photo by Eric Broder Van Dyke / Getty Images On June 2, a dogwalker named Sybil Robertson encountered a dead nine-foot specimen washed up on a Tasmanian beach and posted photos to a citizen scientist group on social media. "I just knew it was something unusual and weird," Sybil Robertson told The Daily Mail, describing the oarfish's markings as "fabulous". A 'Doomsday' Fish? Oarfish are sometimes known as "doomsday fish"—a reputation that stems from interpretations of the oarfish in Japanese folklore. As per Forbes, at least a dozen oarfish washed up onto Japan's coastline in the year before the 2011 Fukushima earthquake and tsunami, which brought the deep-sea creatures back to the forefront of the imagination. Doomsday fish have been found in Tamil Nadu, India. — ಸನಾತನ (@sanatan_kannada) May 31, 2025 Ben Fraber, an ichthyologist and the marine vertebrate collection manager at Scripps Institution of Oceanography in San Diego, told Newsweek in a phone interview that the mythology was "compelling enough" to capture the public's attention. "You do see when there's a big change in pressure on land, birds and other animals will move out of the way," Fraber said. However, researchers in Japan took a closer look at the phenomenon, bringing in data points that included beached whales and anglerfish, as well as known natural disasters and earthquakes dating back to the early 1900s. "They found almost no correlation whatsoever," Fraber noted. "It's really interesting to think about, but it doesn't seem to have a statistical link that we can find." A Rare Find Fraber has seen oarfish in person—last year, two oarfish were discovered by employees of Scripps Institution of Oceanography who were out snorkeling for the day. The employees notified lifeguards, and the institute was able to work with the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) to bring the oarfish in. Fraber preserved the fish in formaldehyde and alcohol, and members of the public can see one of them currently in the Birch Aquarium at Scripps in San Diego. Fraber said oarfish sightings are relatively rare in Southern California—the two his team encountered were only the 21st and 22nd discovered since 1901. "Having the samples in person instead of just a video allows us to look at their stomach contents, look at their genetics, we'll get nitrogen and carbon isotopes that can tell us where they are in the open ocean food web," Fraber said. "And we preserve them so people in the future can continue asking questions from them." According to Fraber, oarfish are filter feeders whose jaws are modified so they can push them forward and vacuum water in, creating suction that traps food similar to bass or large whales. Oarfish primarily eat krill and small fish, which may be confused by the oarfish's silvery body that refracts light. "You're a little school of fish, you're swimming around, you see this thing, but it kind of just looks like a big jelly or gelatinous organism, something you're not too concerned about because a jellyfish is not going to try to eat you," Fraber said. "So you swim up and it's actually not that. It's this big fish that has a highly modified mouth that can protrude and create a kind of vacuum cleaner. It slurps up all these fish." A "Wow" Reaction Having handled and seen oarfish in person, Fraber understands the hype. "I think part of it is the size," he said. "Part of it is the look, they have this beautiful bright red fin, big silvery body, large eyes. "And part of it is the scale. We're not used to seeing animals that big—with the exception of sharks, dolphins and whales—so it elicits this kind of 'wow' reaction." Fraber noted that the mythology of sea serpents is probably related to misidentified oarfish long ago. "It's like actually getting to see this semi-mythological thing in person, it's not a myth, it's a real animal that's living with us on our planet, I think that makes it really amazing," he said. "Even though I've worked on fish for almost 20 years, and have handled many oarfish specimens, these two last year were the first time I actually got to see them fresh and unpreserved in person, and it was pretty magical."
