'7 police officers raided my house while I tried to resuscitate my baby'
A leading abortion charity shares the gut-wrenching stories of three women who have been accused of having an illegal abortion under Britain's "archaic" abortion laws
On the back of an MPs debate over an e-petition calling for the decriminalisation of abortion in the UK, the British Pregnancy Advisory Service (BPAS) has shared three harrowing cases of women affected under what have been described by campaigners as 'archaic' laws around women's bodily autonomy.
Each year, around 60,000 babies are born prematurely in the UK, according to the NHS. One was born to Sammy*, who went into premature labour at home. But as she resuscitated her baby, seven police officers searched her bins, before the paramedics had even arrived.
Sammy was then interviewed by police under caution for a suspected illegal abortion and her phone and computer were seized. Her home was sealed off 'like a crime scene'. She was left in the clothes she was admitted to hospital in, and was barred from contacting her partner.
Despite providing forensic samples that did not show the presence of abortion drugs, she remained under police investigation for a year. Her baby had luckily survived despite the traumatic birth. However, Sammy was only allowed limited, supervised contact with them.
As horrific as this scenario sounds, it's one that has been made possible through the current laws surrounding abortion in the UK. The Abortion Act was introduced in 1967 and allowed women to terminate a pregnancy up to 28 weeks with the certification of two doctors. In 1990, the limit was changed to 24 weeks.
Meanwhile, the punishment for abortion can be severe. Abortion laws in the UK still fall under the 1861 Offences Against the Person Act, which means that undergoing an abortion without the permission of two doctors, or after 24 weeks, can carry a life sentence.
In the 10 years leading up to April 2022, England and Wales recorded at least 67 cases of procuring an illegal abortion, according to data obtained by The Guardian under the Freedom of Information Act.
Katherine O'Brien, a spokesperson for BPAS, says that more than a hundred women have been investigated by the police over recent years. She told The Mirror: "These include women who have experienced a late miscarriage or a stillbirth, and women who were pressured to take abortion medication by abusive partners. Women have been arrested straight from hospital wards, their homes searched, their children taken away, all under our cruel and archaic abortion law."
In December 2024, an e-petition calling for the decriminalisation of abortion in the UK. It received 102,855 signatures, before being brought to the UK parliament in April. The petition stated: 'I am calling on the UK government to remove abortion from criminal law so that no pregnant person can be criminalised for procuring their own abortion.'
These laws affect women at all different stages in life. For example, Laura*, already the mother to a toddler, was studying at university when she pled guilty to ending her own pregnancy using illicit medication.
She was told by prosecution that if she didn't plead guilty she would likely be jailed for life. She ended up being sentenced to more than two years in prison.
She reported to BPAS at the time that she was in a physically, sexually, and emotionally abusive relationship, and that her partner told her not to go to the doctor. After she was arrested, he told her that he would kill her if she told anyone he was involved. He was never investigated by the police.
Meanwhile, Sophie* was just a teenager when she was arrested at midnight and held in custody for 19 hours. She was suspected of ending her own pregnancy using illicit medication. In fact, the police raid was the first time her parents learnt that she had been pregnant.
She was described by the prosecution as 'being vulnerable'. Despite this, she faced two trials. Throughout the proceedings, she maintained that she had had a traumatic stillbirth after only finding out she was pregnant after 24 weeks. The charge that she had ended her own pregnancy was dropped, but only after six years, and she still received a criminal record.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
2 hours ago
- The Independent
Police launch investigation into NHS hospital heart op deaths
Police are investigating the deaths of patients who died following heart operations at an NHS hospital. A report by the BBC suggests patients at Castle Hill Hospital near Hull suffered avoidable harm, and alleges that in some cases, death certificates failed to disclose that the surgery contributed to deaths. Humberside Police confirmed to the PA news agency that an investigation into the deaths is in its very early stages and no arrests have been made. Documents seen by the BBC raise concerns about the care of 11 patients who underwent transcatheter aortic valve implantation, which is known as a Tavi procedure. It usually takes between one and two hours and is performed on older patients. Tavi is used to replace damaged valves in the heart in people with aortic stenosis, which causes the aortic valve to narrow. It is less invasive than open heart surgery and involves guiding a new valve to the heart through a thin, flexible tube known as a catheter through a blood vessel in the groin or shoulder. Concerns about Castle Hill Hospital's Tavi mortality rate led to a number of reviews, none of which were made public, according to the BBC. The Royal College of Physicians (RCP) was asked to assess the whole cardiology department in 2020, including two of the Tavi deaths. The report was completed in 2021 and led to a second review by consultants IQ4U. This recommended a third review of all 11 deaths, which was carried out by the RCP and completed last year, reports suggest. Some 10 deaths happened between October 2019 and March 2022 while one took place in May 2023. The final review highlighted poor clinical decision-making in one male patient, which included the incorrect positioning of the Tavi valve. His death certificate also failed to include an accurate description of what had happened, it was reported. There were also criticisms of death certificates issued to two other patients, claiming crucial details were missing. A spokesperson for NHS Humber Health Care Partnership said the hospital's Tavi service 'retains the confidence of the Care Quality Commission (CQC), the regional Integrated Care Board (ICB), the Royal College of Physicians, and the trust'. They added that the three separate external reviews have 'shown that mortality rates associated with Tavi are similar to national mortality rates over a four-year period'. 'The Royal College report concluded that the Tavi service is essential for the Humber and North Yorkshire region and needs to be expanded,' they added. 'It stated however that the design of the service should be reviewed and invested in. The report offered a number of actions for improvement and we have delivered against all of those since it was shared with us. 'A key improvement has been the dramatic reduction in the length of time patients wait to have their Tavi procedure, which was shown in the Royal College report to have been too long, like many other T I services across England.' The spokesperson said: 'We would never discuss an individual patient case in the public domain but we understand families may have questions and we are happy to answer those directly. 'We have previously written to families who have lost a loved one following Tavi treatment with an invitation to meet and discuss the specific circumstances of their case, and we would reiterate that offer.'
Telegraph
5 hours ago
- Telegraph
Police investigate 11 heart operation deaths at NHS hospital
Police are investigating the deaths of 11 patients who died after the same heart procedure at an NHS hospital. Families have criticised Castle Hill Hospital, near Hull, for failing to tell them about the complications during surgeries which were found to have contributed to several of their deaths despite not appearing on their death certificates. The dead patients suffered avoidable harm after staff made errors during operations, according to documents seen by the BBC. Humberside Police said an investigation was 'in the very early stages' but that no arrests had been made. The patients had been receiving a Transcatheter Aortic Valve Implant, or TAVI, in a procedure which replaces damaged heart valves between 2019 and 2023. Patients and families were said to have been unaware of the department's TAVI mortality rate – which was three times higher than the UK average. A review from the Royal College of Physicians (RCP) in 2020 was the first of three to highlight the level of concern. Families of patients only became aware of the complications after being approached by the BBC following the publication of the reports. Dorothy Readhead, 87, died after medics put a catheter in a blocked artery which then tore a major blood vessel. She was on the surgery table for six hours, lost five litres of blood and had been awake throughout as only local anaesthetic is used. However, her death certificate made no mention of the procedure. This was criticised by the RCP's second review in 2024, when they said the procedure had 'led to the patient's death'. 'A guinea pig' Christine Rymer, her daughter, told the BBC: 'None of that was told to us. None of it. 'It just feels as if mum was a guinea pig, which is not nice to think about.' Seven cardiac consultants wrote they were 'very concerned about the safety and transparency of the TAVI service' in a letter to the hospital's chief executive in 2021, following the deaths, in less than six months, of four of the 11 patients. The RCP's second review of all 11 deaths found there had been 'poor clinical decision-making', that crucial details were missing from some death certificates alongside a failure to include 'an accurate description' of what happened. Brian Hunter, from Grimsby, died in October 2021. His daughter, Tracy Fisher, said: 'We were led to believe that dad had a heart attack on the table and unfortunately passed away. 'To find out three years down the line that what your father actually passed from wasn't the truth is torturous.' Hull University Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust (HUTH), which runs the hospital, told the BBC: 'We understand families may have questions and we are happy to answer those directly.' 'The report offered a number of actions for improvement and we have delivered against all of those since it was shared with us.' It added that its TAVI-related mortality rates were now in line with national figures.
BBC News
8 hours ago
- BBC News
Police launch investigation into heart operation deaths at NHS hospital
Police have launched an investigation into the deaths of patients following heart operations at an NHS hospital, the BBC has seen by us suggest patients suffered avoidable harm - and that in some cases their death certificates failed to disclose that the procedure contributed to their woman's operation at Castle Hill Hospital near Hull - that should have taken no more than two hours - has been described as a "disaster" by one spent six hours in surgery and lost five litres of blood - all while under local none of this was mentioned on her death certificate, which recorded her as dying from pneumonia. Her family were also not told what had NHS body that runs Castle Hill, the Humber Health Care Partnership, told the BBC it had delivered improvements suggested by the Royal College of Physicians (RCP). In a statement, it said it was happy to directly answer any questions from the patients' Police said an investigation was "in the very early stages" and no arrests had been made. 'Very concerned about safety' The documents raise concerns about the care that 11 patients received during a TAVI - Transcatheter Aortic Valve Implant - a procedure to replace a damaged valve in the heart, similar to adding a department's TAVI mortality rate at the time was three times higher than the UK average, something patients and families were also unaware concerns within the hospital led managers to commission several reviews - but none was made public. In 2020, the RCP was asked to assess the whole cardiology department, in which the TAVI team was operating, including two of the TAVI report, completed in 2021, led to a second review conducted by consultants IQ4U, which recommended a third review of all 11 deaths, which was also conducted by the Royal College and completed in early BBC has been passed copies of all three inquiries. The patients' families only found out they had taken place when we contacted in 2021, seven cardiac consultants wrote they were "very concerned about the safety and transparency of the TAVI service" in a letter to the hospital's chief executive. It followed the deaths, in less than six months, of four of the 11 patients. Used instead of open-heart surgery, the TAVI procedure involves inserting a new valve via a catheter through a blood vessel, often in the groin. The catheter guides the new valve to the heart and replaces the damaged procedure, which typically lasts between one and two hours, is usually carried out under local anaesthetic and is mainly performed on older Readhead, from Driffield, went to Castle Hill to undergo a TAVI in summer 2020. The 87-year-old, an active member of her local church and a keen gardener, had been suffering bouts of breathlessness which doctors had blamed on a heart not suitable for open-heart surgery, Mrs Readhead was keen to take up the option of the less-invasive procedure. "She thought it would give her a [better] quality of life," says her daughter, Christine the operation went care Mrs Readhead received formed part of both RCP reviews carried out on behalf of the hospital trust. Pre-op checks had indicated Mrs Readhead's left side was to be used for the TAVI, as her right side had some blockages because of calcified manufacturer of the TAVI device that was to be implanted had also written a technical report clearly stating that access via the patient's right artery was the day of the operation however, the TAVI medics went in through Mrs Readhead's right leg by mistake. Realising their error, they paused to consider their options but decided to continue - despite the procedure being an elective rather than an emergency attempted to deploy the TAVI three repeated efforts resulted in a significant tear in Mrs Readhead's femoral artery, a major blood vessel. By now, she had been on the surgical table for six hours, lost five litres of blood, and had been awake throughout. Mrs Readhead's care was "graded poor" by the RCP in its 2021 report. It concluded this because of the use of an "inappropriate access site" during a procedure, stating this "unfortunately resulted in an avoidable vascular complication".The TAVI team's decisions "resulted in a disaster for this patient", an anaesthetist called in to rescue the situation wrote two days after the operation in an email - seen by the described it as "a change of plan without weighing the risks vs benefit for the patient, but having a 'have a go' approach".Dr Thanjavur Bragadeesh, then-clinical director of the cardiac unit, suggested the case should be declared a serious incident (SI) when he was made aware of it a few days later. This would mean a full investigation by the hospital. But this suggestion was initially rejected by the vascular surgeon who had been part of the TAVI team."These were recognised complications which were anticipated as of significant risk... The aim of the [forthcoming] meeting is to celebrate and reinforce what went well," he wrote in an head of the TAVI team, agreed, replying it was "an unfortunate but well recognised complication".The hospital did, however, investigate Mrs Readhead's case as a serious incident. While it noted that her death, a week after the operation, provided areas for learning, "these would not have prevented the incident from occurring". It concluded the team had "worked collaboratively and well together".This conclusion was shared with Mrs Readhead's family, with no mention of the TAVI manufacturer's warning or the failure to deploy the device on three attempts. Mrs Readhead's death certificate also makes no mention of the cause of death is listed as "hospital-acquired pneumonia and severe aortic stenosis" - the condition the hospital had been attempting to the second RCP review in 2024 strongly disagreed with the death certificate wording."The vascular injury during the TAVI procedure should have been detailed, as this led to the patient's death," it Readhead's daughter says she had no idea what her mother had endured until the BBC showed her the documentation."None of that was told to us. None of it," says Christine Rymer. "It just feels as if mum was a guinea pig, which is not nice to think about."The 2024 review looked at the deaths of 11 patients in total - seven women and four men who all had TAVI procedures, including Mrs Readhead. Ten deaths occurred between October 2019 and March 2022 - the other happened in May 2023. The review's findings included:"Poor clinical decision-making" at every stage of the treatment of a male patient, aged 73 - including incorrect positioning of the TAVI valveThe same patient's final death certificate failing to contain an "an accurate description" of what happened. He was issued with two certificates - the first one mentioning a "failed TAVI" was withdrawn, while a second one weeks later stated he died from pneumonia and didn't mention the TAVICriticism of death certificates issued to two other patients, both women who died within six weeks of each other, saying crucial details were missing, making them inaccurateNo mitigation for a female patient, aged 84, who had an "elevated risk" - which led to a complication "that might have been avoided under more experienced operators" The BBC has also seen the 2021 letter from the "very concerned" cardiac consultants to the hospital's chief executive, Chris Long, and chief medical officer, Dr Purva one death that year, the consultants said they had been "alarmed to read" that the coroner had not been informed of a serious complication during the operation, with the cause of death recorded as a heart Bragadeesh, who was one of the signatories, says he believes the TAVI service at Castle Hill should have been suspended at that time because the mortality rate was so high compared to most other UK hospitals. Former fisherman Brian Hunter, from Grimsby, was another of the 11 patients who died. He had faith in the NHS, say his family, although rarely visited a lived by the maxim that "a hot curry or a paracetamol" would cure all ailments - and "if that didn't work you, you just got on with it," according to his daughter, Tracy diagnosis of a heart problem therefore, at the age of 83, shocked his four daughters. But they and Brian were reassured a TAVI procedure would soon allow him to resume his gardening and cooking his Sunday there was "a lack of urgency" to treat him, according to the 2024 RCP review - and by the time he underwent the operation, in October 2021, he was "a high-risk case… with an increased risk of complication and little margin for error". The TAVI team had made technical errors, concluded the review, failing to properly deploy the device which then wrongly allowed blood to leak back into the Hunter didn't survive the operation - the Royal College graded his care as "very poor". His daughters - just like Dorothy Readhead's family - had no idea what had happened during his operation until we showed them the report."We were led to believe that dad had a heart attack on the table and unfortunately passed away," said Mrs Fisher. "To find out three years down the line that what your father actually passed from wasn't the truth is torturous."I feel angry as well, and so does the rest of the family, that [the hospital] just outrageously lied. At no point do any of us find it acceptable. It's just not." After raising concerns about Mrs Readhead's case in 2020, Dr Bragadeesh was asked to step down from his role as clinical director of Castle Hill Hospital's cardiology department as part of a wider leadership the rationale for the reorganisation was challenged, the trust asked the RCP to conduct its 2021 review, including assessing whether the decision to change the management team and his role was were poor working relationships within the cardiology department, found the RCP at that time, with reviewers adding that they "positively acknowledge the decision to step down the cardiology leadership roles".Dr Bragadeesh continued to work at Castle Hill but took the trust to an employment December 2023, the tribunal dismissed three of his 29 complaints and said of the remaining 26 that they were out of time, concluding he should have brought his case now works at a different NHS trust. He says the failures identified in the 2024 Royal College of Physicians review "show I was right to raise concerns about the TAVI procedure".The Humber Health Care Partnership - which runs Castle Hill through Hull University Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust (HUTH) - said in a statement: "We understand families may have questions and we are happy to answer those directly."It said that following a 2021 review, the RCP concluded the TAVI service was essential for the region, but said the design of the service should be reviewed and invested in."The report offered a number of actions for improvement and we have delivered against all of those since it was shared with us," it said its services retained the confidence of the healthcare inspector, the Care Quality trust added that three separate external reviews had been undertaken "and shown that mortality rates associated with TAVI are similar to national mortality rates over a four-year period".The mortality data it shared with the BBC indicates that the unit remains above the UK national reporting by Tara Mewawalla
