logo
The Vancouver Whitecaps Are A Fan's Dream — And A Marketing Nightmare

The Vancouver Whitecaps Are A Fan's Dream — And A Marketing Nightmare

Forbes03-05-2025

Vancouver Whitecaps striker Brian White celebrates his goal during a 3-1 victory at Inter Miami on ... More Wednesday night in Leg 2 of the Concacaf Champions Cup semifinals. Vancouver advanced to the final by a 5-1 aggregate victory.
There is an undeniable poetry to the nature of Inter Miami's most noteworthy tournament defeats since the arrival of Lionel Messi and several of his former FC Barcelona teammates.
In the 2024 Concacaf Champions Cup, the Herons exited in the quarterfinals to a CF Monterrey squad that has decisively been the best in Concacaf competition over the last decade-and-a-half, and seem intent on showing it would not be supplanted easily.
In the 2024 MLS Cup Playoffs, Miami fell to an Atlanta United side that would not have even qualified for the postseason without an expansion of the playoff format meant to satisfy new streaming partner Apple TV. The outcome no doubt cost the company hundreds of thousands of viewers over the rest of the postseason.
Now comes the demolition of Messi's Miami over two legs of their Concacaf Champions Cup semifinal series against the Vancouver Whitecaps, a team that is the polar opposite of the Herons, in that they are a hard-core fan's dream, but a marketing professional's nightmare.
For fans, there's everything to love.
The Whitecaps have talent in its prime in Ryan Gauld and Brian White. They have youth and promise for the future, particularly in budding stars Sebastian Berhalter, Jayden Nelson and Ped. They have a coach in Jesper Sorensen who appears capable of getting the very best from his players. And they have a front office that was willing to pay to send several hundred of its fans to the return leg to witness what may have been the biggest moment in club history.
Matches are also among the more accessible in the league, with games rarely sold out even in the lower bowl when Messi isn't in town.
And yet, if you were in MLS offices brainstorming the traits you'd want the best team in your league to possess, the Whitecaps fall short in so many ways it's almost comical. Consider the following attributes – or lack thereof.
That Vancouver have accomplished their run to the final without Scottish playmaker Ryan Gauld for the last two rounds is nothing short of remarkable. But even if he's the 'Caps best player, he's barely an established name in Scotland, with only six caps for a senior national team that hasn't qualified for a World Cup since 1998.
Brian White is a far better forward than most people realize, but his name feels like it was lifted straight out of your 2043 Football Manager roster. Then there's the emerging Sebastian Berhalter, the second-most famous Berhalter in MLS.
In North American sports, there is both Canadian bias and West Coast bias against clubs in the Pacific Time Zone and north of the border, and the Whitecaps are the lone MLS team lucky enough to combat both. Many home league matches don't finish until after midnight Eastern Time. Traveling to visit even the closest rival requires a passport.
At roughly 2.6 million people, the Vancouver metro area is also the smallest of the three Canadian metros in MLS, about two-thirds the size of Montreal's and less than half that of Toronto's.
The team is literally for sale, with significant concerns that it could relocate. What's more, although the current ownership group publicly confirmed its intention to sell last December, there hasn't been any reported movement in that search for a new buyer. Compare that to Real Salt Lake, whose sale was completed to a new local buyer only a few weeks after the potential transaction was first reported.
The only good news on this front is that the obvious strong foundation of the current ownership group should make the club a more appealing property to investors.
B.C. Place is a modern stadium and a 2026 World Cup host site. But the Whitecaps' status as the secondary tennant behind the CFL's B.C. Lions is probably the second-least-adventageous arrangement in all of MLS, behind only New York City FC's alternating baseball stadiums. And NYCFC will soon have its own venue.
The CFL schedule starts two months before the NFL, meaning it intersects with a much larger segment of the MLS schedule. And of the two teams that share a venue with a CFL team, only Vancouver plays indoors and on a synthetic surface.
The point of this exercise isn't to take the air out of the Vancouver balloon, although some fans will probably feel that way. Everything the Whitecaps have achieved so far has been thoroughly deserved, and the MLS league office and all of its clubs – even the Cascadia rivals – should be rooting for Sorensen's group in the June final.
The lesson here – again – is that the kind of dynastic sporting brands MLS so clearly seems to want Messi and Inter Miami to become can't be syntheitcally engineered. Star power and spending power clearly play a role in pro sports, but in the end the results always have to be earned in a competitive arena that also rewards intangibles that Vancouver has in spades and Miami currently lacks.
That doesn't mean Inter Miami can't or won't earn them; they did, after all, win the 2023 Leagues Cup and 2024 Supporters' Shield. But so much of how MLS (and in one case FIFA) has operated feels designed to foster such successes at the expense of using Miami's rising tide to lift all boats.
We've seen the introduction of a cumbersome postseason that cheapens league play and is supposedly designed to diminish first-round upsets, the placement of the Herons in the 2025 FIFA Club World Cup based on suspicious criteria, and the conspicuous absence of a Miami match during this March's FIFA international window, during which 28 other MLS teams played on.
The Vancouver Whitecaps, and all of MLS' marketing nightmares relative to the Miami Messi Machine, deserve better.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Christian Pulisic: 'I don't regret' skipping Gold Cup, calls some criticism 'way out of line'
Christian Pulisic: 'I don't regret' skipping Gold Cup, calls some criticism 'way out of line'

Yahoo

time20 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Christian Pulisic: 'I don't regret' skipping Gold Cup, calls some criticism 'way out of line'

Christian Pulisic, speaking for the first time since opting to skip this summer's Gold Cup, said Thursday that he doesn't regret the decision, and called questions about his commitment to the U.S. men's national team "way out of line." Pulisic, in an interview with CBS Sports Golazo's "Call It What You Want," also revealed that he "did want to be a part of" the USMNT's two pre-Gold Cup friendlies, and asked coaches to be included for those games against Türkiye and Switzerland. "And they said no, they only wanted one roster" for both the friendlies and the Gold Cup, Pulisic said. "I fully respect that. I didn't understand it, but it is what it is." Advertisement As for why he didn't to play in the Gold Cup, a biennial regional tournament, Pulisic said that, "toward the end of the season" with his Italian club AC Milan, "my body just started talking to me, and my mind. And I started to think, 'What is gonna be best for me leading into next year and going into the World Cup?' And was that to play eight more games, and then get no rest at all, go straight into preseason, and grind another season, and go straight into the World Cup? "I had the make the best decision for myself, and also in the long run for my team," Pulisic continued, "even though clearly some people haven't seen it that way." The decision sparked fierce criticism from both fans and former players. Landon Donovan, perhaps the most famous player in program history until Pulisic came along, rekindled the controversy on Sunday while watching Cristiano Ronaldo and Portugal celebrate their UEFA Nations League title. "This is what it means to represent your country," Donovan said on the Fox broadcast. "[Ronaldo's] 40 years old. He's played a long-ass season. He's tired. He's out there grinding, hurt himself in the process. And I can't help but think about some of our guys on vacation, not wanting to play in the Gold Cup. It's pissing me off." Those comments triggered a response from Pulisic's dad, Mark, who, in an Instagram post, cited Donovan's late-career break from soccer and told the USMNT legend to "look in the mirror + grow a pair." Christian Pulisic liked the post. Advertisement In Thursday's interview, Pulisic did not name Donovan, but seemed to implicitly address Donovan's comments. "You can talk about my performances, whatever you want," Pulisic said. "But to question my commitment, especially towards the national team, in my opinion, that's way out of line." He later added: "I just don't understand why also so many people are so big on just wanting to give out these takes when they've been through tough moments themselves. I don't understand the idea of wanting to divide this fan base, and bring a negative light over it in any way. But we tend to do that a lot." Pulisic also admitted that, in general, the criticism from former players "is tough. You know, I looked up to those guys growing up. Some of these guys were my idols. I respect them so much as players." He said that, privately, some of the former players talk to him "and clearly want to show support, and be your friend and everything. And then they say something slightly different publicly." This story will be updated.

Christian Pulisic has his say as USMNT past, present debate his summer decision
Christian Pulisic has his say as USMNT past, present debate his summer decision

New York Times

time24 minutes ago

  • New York Times

Christian Pulisic has his say as USMNT past, present debate his summer decision

After weeks of discourse about Christian Pulisic's decision not to play for the U.S. men's national team in the upcoming Concacaf Gold Cup, the Milan winger finally addressed his absence. On Thursday morning, Pulisic appeared on CBS's Call It What You Want podcast, a show hosted by ex-USMNT players Tony Meola, Jimmy Conrad and Charlie Davies. Advertisement 'It sucks for me to miss out with the team,' Pulisic said. 'I want to be a part of the team always. But to be honest, towards the second half and the end of the season, my body just started talking to me, and my mind. I started to think, you know, what's going to be best for me leading into next year and going into the World Cup. Is that to play eight more games, get no rest at all, go straight into preseason and then grind another year, and go straight into the World Cup? That's not what I felt was best for my body.' Throughout a lengthy interview, Pulisic repeatedly backed his decision as being best for his body and mind. He drew a direct link to his fitness and his ability to perform at his best, and that this rest would ultimately benefit him during a World Cup on home soil. He also revealed that he asked to be part of the team during its recent friendlies against Turkey and Switzerland, which the USMNT lost 2-1 and 4-0, respectively, but was told that Mauricio Pochettino and his staff only wanted one roster for the summer. 'The only point I would make with that is that I did want to be part of at least the two friendlies,' Pulisic said. 'I did speak with the coaches, and I asked and I wanted to be part of the team in whatever capacity I could. They said no; they said they only wanted one roster, and that's a coach's decision. I fully respect that. I didn't understand it, but it is what it is. I wanted to be a part of that, but that's just the way things went. I had to make the best decision for myself, and also, in the long run, my team — although, clearly, some people haven't seen it that way.' "I did want to be a part of at least the two friendlies, but they said no… I had to make the best decision for myself and, in the long run, for my team." Christian Pulisic opens up on his decision to sit out the 2025 Concacaf Gold Cup 🇺🇸 — Golazo America (@GolazoAmerica) June 12, 2025 Stated as a wry disclaimer, it was the first of a few references to the backlash which followed his decision to skip the Gold Cup. A chorus of detractors have since questioned his loyalty to the USMNT, perhaps most vocally from program legends Landon Donovan and Tim Howard, who now co-host a podcast together. Advertisement In an episode released on May 28, Donovan compared Pulisic's decision to when he took a lengthy sabbatical in 2013. Infamously, Donovan's 'break' was among the top reasons why Jurgen Klinsmann ultimately omitted the program's joint-record goalscorer from his 2014 World Cup squad. However, Donovan said he felt Pulisic's decision lacked the same 'this is why' component that he himself had presented over a decade ago. Donovan also alluded to Pulisic's decision when appearing on FOX's UEFA Nations League final studio show and lauding 40-year-old Cristiano Ronaldo for continuing to turn out for his national side. When asked directly about Donovan, Howard and outside noise from former U.S. players, Pulisic continued to back his decision. 'To question my commitment, especially towards the national team, in my opinion that's way out of line.' Christian Pulisic responds to the criticism he has received from former players including #USMNT legend Landon Donovan 🗣️ — Golazo America (@GolazoAmerica) June 12, 2025 'I've always said you guys would probably be surprised with how little (discourse) actually gets to me,' Pulisic said. 'I try to stay away from it as much as I can. When it comes to those guys, I don't know… It is tough, because I looked up to those guys growing up. Some of those guys were my idols, and I respect them so much as players. It's tough, especially when — some of them, as well, privately, the way they talk to me and clearly want to show support and be your friend and everything. And then it goes, and they say something slightly different publicly. That's fine. It doesn't hurt me. 'Am I surprised by it? I don't know, not really. People are always going to have their opinions, but in the end, I'm focused on how can I better myself? What am I going to do for bettering myself and, ultimately, the best thing for the team. That's what I do. Of all things: you can talk about my performances, whatever you want, but to question my commitment, especially towards the national team? In my opinion, that's way out of line. But you know how it is: people forget really quickly. Once I'm back with the national team — I hope — once I'm back with the national team and can play again, score a goal and win a game, people will forget all about this quickly.' This story will be updated.

Christian Pulisic speaks on USMNT hiatus, Pochettino relationship, public criticism
Christian Pulisic speaks on USMNT hiatus, Pochettino relationship, public criticism

NBC Sports

time34 minutes ago

  • NBC Sports

Christian Pulisic speaks on USMNT hiatus, Pochettino relationship, public criticism

Christian Pulisic broke his relative silence on Thursday morning when he met with Jimmy Conrad, Charlie Davies, and Tony Meola on a CBS Sports podcast to speak about his break from the United States men's national team. The USMNT captain tried to strike a calm, composed, and assured demeanor but has clearly been bothered by the grief that's been thrown his way for stepping away from the team one year before they host a World Cup. And it's clear that he's been further fueled for both club and country. 'You guys will see,' he said late in the interview. 'I'm hungrier than ever, truly. I'm looking forward to big things to come.' Pulisic says his body and mind needed the break in order to best ready him for the club season and ensuing World Cup, and he also left some things in between the lines that we'll analyze over time. The 26-year-old said he initially asked USMNT coach Mauricio Pochettino to be allowed to play in the two friendlies prior to The Gold Cup but was rebuffed by the coach, who wanted to have one roster for the whole summer. That was a surprise to Pulisic, and perhaps lifts the lid on the status he believes he has in the program. After all, several other players in the squad have been going through a similar grind. Then again, Antonee Robinson was allowed to miss a couple of international windows after playing through an injury last summer with the USMNT. It's also very, very clear that Landon Donovan's comments criticizing Pulisic's decision having really stuck in his craw. That's not a surprise given Donovan also stepped away from the national team and it also likely cost the USMNT legend his place at the 2014 World Cup under Jurgen Klinsmann. For now, let's start with his answers to several questions from the podcast. On his career year at AC Milan, and taking on a leadership role: 'Even in my last days at Chelsea, I always felt confident and I was ready for the next step. Once I was able to have this platform and a team that really showed me a lot of trust. I felt good about it right from the start and I think I've just grown in confidence and all parts of my game. It's led me to where I am now going into this season I wanted to take it one step further, just keep growing as a player and improving.' What was this year like? 'It's definitely a combination, physically and mentally. It's always tough with the amount of games we play and everything going on at the club. It's hard for people to see from the outside. There's definitely a lot of pressure on us, especially at a club like Milan when things are going as they expect, and what they expect is for us to win games and trophies. It can take a big toll on you but I'm grateful to be in this position. I wouldn't want it any other way. To play for a team like Milan, it just makes me more hungry to bring us back to where we belong. I'm excited for the future.' Why did you decide to skip the Gold Cup? 'It sucks for me to miss out with the team. I want to be a part of the team always. But to be honest, the second half and end of the season my body just started talking to me and my mind. I started to think what is best for me leading into next year and going into the World Cup? Was that to play eight more games and get no rest at all, go straight into preseason, grind another year, and then go right into the World Cup? It's not what I felt was best for me and my body. The only point that I would make is that was I wanted to be at least a part of the two friendlies. I did speak with the coaches and I asked to be a part of the team in whatever capacity I could. They said no and they only wanted one roster. That's coach's decision. I fully respect it. I didn't understand it but it is what it is. That's just the way things meant. I had to make the best decision for myself and my team even though some people haven't seen it that way.' Given the criticism you've received, would you still make the same decision? 'I don't regret my decision. I think it's the right thing for me. The way I'm feeling right now is honestly really good. I'm excited to get back into training again this week and work on some things that I've really wanted to work on myself. I know it's going to put me into an amazing position leading into next season.' How was your conversation with Mauricio Pochettino? 'We had one phone call where we discussed everything. He understood where I was coming from and that's as much conversation as I've had with him. I'm supporting the team. I want the best for this team truly. I think it's a great opportunity for some players that are coming in as well and also some faces that have been around. I'm only wishing them the best.' Catching criticism from Landon Donovan, Tim Howard, and others? 'You'd be surprised at how little gets to me. I try to stay away from it as much as I can/ When it comes to those guys, it is tough because I looked up to those guys growing up, some of these guys were my idols, and I respect them so much as players. It's tough especially when some of them privately, the way they talk to me and clearly want to show support and be a friend and then they say something different publicly. Does it hurt me? Am I surprised by it? I don't know. Not really. In the end I'm focused on how I can better myself and ultimately for the best thing for the team. That's what I do. Of all things, you can talk about my performances, but to question my commitment to the national team, in my opinion that's way out of line. You know how it is, people forget really quickly. I'm sure once I'm back in the team, I hope if I can get back, once I score a goal and win a game people will forget about this quickly.' Would you like to hear more from Pochettino? 'I've had a lot of coaches in my short career. Some would say I'm the problem. What I've learned throughout all this time is that every coach is very different. I've had coaches who daily want to talk and get things off their brain and talk to their players. I've always appreciated that when people make an effort to care about the player and the person, too. This is who he is. I'm not a guy either who needs to speak to the coach. I'm a quiet guy. I'm not reaching out. Has it been different with some of my other national team coaches? Yeah but it's not something I'm looking into too much.' More on the decision to rest: 'I knew how I was feeling. I was dealing with a couple small things that kept lingering. To go straight into summer, play for six weeks, and then right into club season and into the World Cup. People can question my decision, I just don't understand why also so many people are so big on wanting to give out these takes when they've been through tough moments themselves. I don't understanding wanting to divide the fan base against the players. I don't let it affect me too much. This is the right decision for myself and the team. People will say that. ... You guys will see. I'm hungrier than ever, truly. I'm looking forward to big things to come.' Feeling pressure to captain a host nation at a World Cup? 'I'm so excited about it. I think it's going to be an incredible event for us. To play a World Cup in your own country — not a lot of people get to do that. It's something on the brain but I'm just focused on me and what's next.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store