Archbishop of York admits mistakes as he survives bid to stop his Synod speech
The Archbishop of York admitted he has 'made mistakes' but vowed he is determined to 'lead the change we all know we need' in the Church of England which has been plagued by abuse safeguarding failures.
Stephen Cottrell has resisted calls from some quarters to quit, and survived a vote to stop him giving a presidential address as the General Synod began on Monday.
A lay member of a gathering of the Church's parliament argued Mr Cottrell's position as the most senior bishop following the resignation of Justin Welby as archbishop of Canterbury was 'no longer tenable'.
Just over a fifth of Synod members (73) voted in favour of Sam Margrave's motion to stop Mr Cottrell from giving the speech, with 239 voting against and 43 abstentions.
Putting forward his motion, Mr Margrave said there had been suggestions from some that there should be a walkout, and that his motion was 'about sending a message to the nation and the Church'.
He said: 'An archbishop faces calls by another bishop to resign amid credible allegations of bullying, poor judgment and safeguarding failures, including a priest allowed in post despite a ban from being alone with children, and compensation being paid.
'Synod, do we allow an archbishop to stand before this chamber and the nation in a presidential address?
'Do we continue as if nothing is wrong?'
He added: 'At the very least, a period of stepping back and an investigation is needed.'
Getting to his feet to begin his address, Mr Cottrell thanked Mr Margrave for 'presenting your motion so courteously'.
The archbishop recognised the 'difficult and challenging times' faced by the Church, as he acknowledged the 'anguish, anger, sadness, and regret' of victims and survivors of abuse about safeguarding failings.
Professing his love for the Church, he also insisted there must be change, adding that he was 'deeply mindful of the feelings of anguish, anger, sadness, and regret present in this chamber – not least among victims and survivors of abuse'.
After beginning his address, Mr Cottrell paused while there was a period of prayerful reflection and silence among those gathered, in an effort to acknowledge the feelings of abuse survivors.
Bishop of Newcastle Helen-Ann Hartley, who sat at the back of the room, has been the only bishop to publicly call for Mr Cottrell's resignation, saying he is 'the wrong person' to be leading the Church.
Mr Cottrell took over most of the archbishop of Canterbury's responsibilities when the latter resigned after a damning report concluded prolific serial abuser John Smyth might have been brought to justice had Mr Welby formally reported him to police five years before his death.
Mr Cottrell has himself been under pressure in recent months, accused of not acting quickly enough in his then-role as bishop of Chelmsford over priest David Tudor, who was allowed to remain in post despite having been barred by the Church from being alone with children and having paid compensation to a sexual abuse victim.
He has previously insisted he had inherited a 'horrible and intolerable' situation, and 'acted immediately' when fresh complaints were made about the priest in 2019, adding that he had 'no legal grounds' to suspend him before then.
Separately, Mr Cottrell has also 'categorically rejected' allegations that he bullied members of a committee to secure John Perumbalath's appointment as Bishop of Liverpool.
Mr Perumbalath resigned as bishop last month following media coverage of sexual assault and harassment allegations against him, which he denies.
Mr Cottrell told the Synod: 'I know that trust has been broken and confidence damaged. And I am more sorry about this than I can say.
'I know mistakes have been made and I know that I have made mistakes.'
He said he is 'determined' to do what he can to work with others 'to lead the change we all know we need'.
He said the Church had 'failed greatly' on safeguarding and that he had 'long believed that greater independence is the missing piece in the safeguarding jigsaw'.
Tuesday will see Synod members debate and vote on a new safeguarding model for the Church, one version of which proposes all safeguarding officers currently working in dioceses, cathedrals and the national Church be transferred to work for a new independent organisation.
Synod is also debating the Makin Review, which led to Mr Welby's resignation and which Mr Cottrell said had 'laid bare' Church failings on safeguarding.
He said Mr Welby had done the 'honourable thing by standing down'.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Wall Street Journal
18 hours ago
- Wall Street Journal
Church of England, Disestablish Thyself
The Church of England has always been a hybrid entity. Since its establishment by King Henry VIII in 1534, the church has adroitly juggled piety with politics to conserve its role as Britain's moral center. Yet last week Parliament passed two policies so rebarbative to the Christian principle of human dignity—the decriminalization of self-administered abortion at any time, for any reason, and the legalization of assisted suicide for the terminally ill—that even this adaptable church will struggle to reconcile them with its mission. Christian doctrine prizes the dignity of all and the duty to care for the vulnerable. Early Christians were noted for rescuing unwanted babies, routinely abandoned in Roman times. Through European history the establishment of hospitals and houses for poor relief was associated with the Christian faith.
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
Church of England praying for peace but preparing for war
The Church of England is preparing for how it might respond should 'serious conflict' break out, including looking back to the leadership shown by senior religious figures during the Second World War. The Bishop to the Armed Forces has said the Church wants to 'take seriously' the potential challenges ahead, warning that it does not want to be caught short in a similar way to the lack of preparedness there was for the pandemic. The Church's parliament – officially known as the General Synod – will, in a rare occurrence, hear from a senior military figure when it meets next month. Brigadier Jaish Mahan, a Christian who served in Kosovo, Sierra Leone, Iraq and Afghanistan, will address Synod members on the current global climate and the challenges for the UK, as well as speaking of his own experience in the military. A Synod paper states: 'While a conflict directly involving the UK is not an immediate risk, given the very serious impact such a conflict would have on every person in the country, we must be prepared.' Reverend Hugh Nelson, Bishop of St Germans and Bishop to the Armed Forces, said he had been hearing from military personnel for the past two years 'rising concern about the threat of very, very serious conflict, including conflict that involves the UK'. During a briefing with reporters on Thursday, he referenced the Government's national security strategy, published earlier this week, which warned the UK must actively prepare for a 'wartime scenario' on British soil 'for the first time in many years'. Ministers said the UK now finds itself in 'an era in which we face confrontation with those who are threatening our security'. Mr Nelson said: 'As a Church, we want to take seriously those challenges, both to do everything that we can to pray for and work for and advocate for peace, because the kingdom of God is a kingdom of justice and peace, and to face the reality and to put in place, or at least to begin to have conversations towards plans about how the Church might need to respond and to be if there were to be a serious conflict. 'We do not want to be in the situation that we were all in – Church and wider society – pre-pandemic, when those that knew things said there will one day be a pandemic, and none of us had done anything in preparation for that. So we want to take that seriously.' Legislative changes are due to be brought before Synod, which would allow Armed Forces chaplains, when operating in their roles, to minister under an Archbishops' licence without also having to hold diocesan PTO (permission to officiate). The current rules add a serious administrative burden and make it more difficult for chaplains to deploy within the UK at the pace required by their roles, a Synod paper states. Mr Nelson described this as a 'tidying up exercise to enable chaplains to get on and to do what they need to do without having to go through quite a lot of administrative and bureaucratic steps in order to have permission to do that in any particular place'. While he declined to go so far as to say the work was putting the Church on a war footing, he noted that consideration is being given to how religious leaders acted in previous wartime scenarios. He said: 'We're encouraging the Church to pray for peace and to prepare for, or to begin to do some thinking and some work around, what it might mean for us to be a Church in a time of conflict. 'We have looked back at some of the ways in which senior Church leadership – archbishops and bishops – led, the things that they said, particularly in the Second World War.' Asked about ethical issues surrounding artificial intelligence (AI), robotics and drone warfare, he said these 'pose very serious challenges, both to the practice of war, but for us particularly, to the theology and the ethics of peace and conflict' and added that there are 'many serious pieces of work that need to be done theologically in the face of changing technology as it impacts on warfare'. Resources, including around working with schools on issues of peace, war and conflict, and practical suggestions for making churches hospitable and welcoming to Armed Forces personnel and their families, are expected to be published shortly after Synod. Across the Royal Navy, Army and Royal Air Force, there are almost 200 Church of England chaplains, serving as both regulars and reservists. The Church said its chaplains 'have provided spiritual, moral and pastoral care to military personnel and their families for more than 150 years and remain a highly valued part of the Armed Forces, often witnessing to Jesus Christ in complex and difficult contexts.'
Los Angeles Times
2 days ago
- Los Angeles Times
Faith leaders and families sue to block Texas' new Ten Commandments in schools law
AUSTIN, Texas — A group of Dallas-area families and faith leaders have filed a lawsuit seeking to block a new Texas law that requires copies of the Ten Commandments be posted in every public school classroom. The federal lawsuit, filed Tuesday, claims the measure is an unconstitutional violation of the separation of church and state. Texas is the latest and largest state to attempt a mandate that has run into legal challenges elsewhere. A federal appeals court on Friday blocked a similar law in Louisiana. Some families have sued over Arkansas' law. The plaintiffs in the Texas lawsuit are a group of Christian and Nation of Islam faith leaders and families. It names the Texas Education Agency, state education Commissioner Mike Morath and three Dallas-area school districts as defendants. 'The government should govern; the Church should minister,' the lawsuit said. 'Anything else is a threat to the soul of both our democracy and our faith.' Ten Commandments laws are among efforts, mainly in conservative-led states, to insert religion into public schools. Supporters say the Ten Commandments are part of the foundation of the United States' judicial and educational systems and should be displayed. Texas Republican Gov. Greg Abbott signed the Ten Commandments measure into law on June 21. He also has enacted a measure requiring school districts to provide students and staff a daily voluntary period of prayer or time to read a religious text during school hours. Opponents say the Ten Commandments and prayer measures infringe on others' religious freedom and more lawsuits are expected. The American Civil Liberties Union, Americans United for Separation of Church and State, and the Freedom From Religion Foundation have said they will file lawsuits opposing the Ten Commandments measure. Under the new law, public schools must post in classrooms a 16-by-20-inch or larger poster or framed copy of a specific English version of the commandments, even though translations and interpretations vary across denominations, faiths and languages and may differ in homes and houses of worship. The lawsuit notes that Texas has nearly 6 million students in about 9,100 public schools, including thousands of students of faiths that have little or no connection to the Ten Commandments, or may have no faith at all. The Texas Education Agency did not immediately respond to an emailed request for comment. The law takes effect Sept. 1, but most public school districts start the upcoming school year in August. Vertuno writes for the Associated Press.
