Trump's Alcatraz restoration plan gets cold reception
US President Donald Trump's plan to turn Alcatraz back into a federal prison has been summarily rejected by visitors to the tourist site in San Francisco Bay.
Trump revealed a plan over the weekend to rebuild and expand the notorious island prison, a historic landmark known as "The Rock" and operated by the US government's National Park Service.
It's "just an idea I've had," the president said.
"We need law and order in this country. So we're going to look at it."
Once nearly impossible to leave, the island can be difficult to get to because of competition for tickets. Alcatraz prison held fewer than 300 inmates at a time before it was closed in 1963 and draws roughly 1.2 million tourists a year.
US Bureau of Prisons Director William Marshall said he would vigorously pursue the president's agenda and was looking at next steps.
"It's a waste of money," said visitor Ben Stripe from Santa Ana, California.
"After walking around and seeing this place and the condition it's in, it is just way too expensive to refurbish."
"It's not feasible to have somebody still live here," agreed Cindy Lacomb from Phoenix, Arizona, who imagined replacing all the metal in the cells and rebuilding the crumbling concrete.
The sprawling site is in disrepair, with peeling paint and rusting locks and cell bars. Signs reading "Area closed for your safety" block off access to many parts of the grounds. Chemical toilets sit next to permanent rest rooms closed off for repair.
The former home of Al Capone and other notable inmates was known for tough treatment, including pitch-black isolation cells. It was billed as America's most secure prison given the island location, frigid waters and strong currents.
It was closed because of high operating costs. The island also was claimed by Native American activists in 1969, an act of civil disobedience acknowledged by the National Park Service.
Mike Forbes, visiting from Pittsburgh, said it should remain a part of history.
"I'm a former prison guard and rehabilitation is real. Punishment is best left in the past," Forbes said.
No successful escapes were ever officially recorded from Alcatraz, though five prisoners were listed as "missing and presumed drowned."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
an hour ago
- ABC News
California to sue Trump administration over National Guard deployment, LA braces for fourth day of protests
California's governor has said he will sue Donald Trump's administration after the National Guard was deployed to clamp down on protests in Los Angeles at the weekend. Gavin Newsom, a Democrat, said the order to send in troops was illegal, could have far-reaching consequences for other states and should be withdrawn. Sunday, local time, marked a third day of demonstrations against the administration's immigration raids, as protesters set fire to self-driving cars, blocked motorways and threw chunks of concrete and electric scooters at police officers, while police responded with tear gas and rubber bullets. About a dozen National Guard members, along with Department of Homeland Security personnel, pushed back a group of demonstrators outside a federal building in downtown LA, video showed. The city was braced on Monday for a fourth wave of protests. "This is exactly what Donald Trump wanted," Mr Newsom said, in a post on X. "He [Mr Trump] flamed the fires and illegally acted to federalise the National Guard. The order he signed doesn't just apply to CA. It will allow him to go into ANY STATE and do the same thing. "We're suing him." Mr Trump hit back in a post on Truth Social, saying he made a "great decision" to send in the National Guard, as he accused Mr Newsom of being "incompetent". "We made a great decision in sending the National Guard to deal with the violent, instigated riots in California. If we had not done so, Los Angeles would have been completely obliterated," said Mr Trump. Later, he blamed "insurrectionists" for the unrest. "The people that are causing the problems are professional agitators and insurrectionists," Mr Trump told reporters at the White House. "They're bad people, they should be in jail," he added. Despite Mr Trump's language, he has not invoked the Insurrection Act, an 1807 law that empowers a president to deploy the US military to suppress events such as civil disorder. He did not reply when asked several times by reporters whether he planned to invoke the act, nor give evidence as to why the street protesters were referred to by him as "insurrectionists". He went on to lash out again at Mr Newsom, who has been widely tipped as a possible 2028 presidential candidate, over the unrest. "He's done a terrible job. Look, I like Gavin Newsom, he's a nice guy — but he's grossly incompetent, everybody knows," Mr Trump said. At the weekend, Mr Newsom dared Tom Homan, the director of the Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), to arrest him. It came after Mr Homan said the governor and LA Mayor Karen Bass could face federal charges of trying to impede immigration agents. "I would do it if I were Tom," Mr Trump said when asked if his border tsar should arrest the governor. Mr Newsom called the president's response "an unmistakeable step toward authoritarianism". He posted on X: "The President of the United States just called for the arrest of a sitting Governor. "This is a day I hoped I would never see in America.I don't care if you're a Democrat or a Republican this is a line we cannot cross as a nation — this is an unmistakable step toward authoritarianism." Meanwhile, the mayor blamed the Trump administration for inciting tension by sending in the National Guard. She also condemned protesters after some burned cars and hurled bottles at police "We do not want to play into the [Trump] administration's hands," Ms Bass said, adding the administration's actions in LA had 'caused fear and panic'. "What we're seeing in Los Angeles is chaos provoked by the administration. Deploying federalised troops is a dangerous escalation." On Monday, the US Northern Command said 300 members of the California National Guard had been deployed to three spots in the Los Angeles area. Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem told CBS program Face the Nation that the National Guard would provide safety around buildings to people engaged in peaceful protest and to law enforcement. The unrest in LA has become a flashpoint in Mr Trump's signature effort to clamp down on illegal immigration. The Republican president has pledged to deport record numbers of people who are in the country illegally and to lock down the US-Mexico border, setting the ICE border enforcement agency a daily goal of arresting at least 3,000 migrants. The Trump administration's immigration enforcement measures have also included residents who are in the country legally, some with permanent residence, spurring legal challenges. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth said on Saturday the Pentagon was prepared to mobilise active-duty troops "if violence continues" in LA, and Marines at nearby Camp Pendleton were on high alert. Vanessa Cardenas, the head of the immigration advocacy group America's Voice, accused the Trump administration of "trumping up an excuse to abuse power, and deliberately stoke and force confrontations around immigration". Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum on Monday condemned violent acts committed during the protests. Ms Sheinbaum, speaking at her morning press conference, also called on US authorities to respect the rule of law in migration processes. "It must be clear: We condemn violence wherever it comes from," she said. "We call on the Mexican community to act peacefully and not fall for provocations." She did not specifically call for an end to the protests. ABC/Reuters
The Age
2 hours ago
- The Age
Nine reporter caught up in LA protests as governor hits out at Trump
The last time a National Guard was activated without a governor's permission was in 1965, when president Lyndon B. Johnson sent troops to protect a civil rights march in Alabama, according to the Brennan Centre for Justice. 'These are the acts of a dictator, not a president,' Newsom posted on X. 'The federal government is sowing chaos so they can have an excuse to escalate. That is not the way any civilised country behaves.' The White House disputed Newsom's characterisation, saying in a statement that 'everyone saw the chaos, violence and lawlessness'. Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass echoed Newsom's comments. 'What we're seeing in Los Angeles is chaos that is provoked by the administration,' she said in an afternoon press conference. 'This is about another agenda, this isn't about public safety.' Their admonishments did not deter the administration. 'It's a bald-faced lie for Newsom to claim there was no problem in Los Angeles before President Trump got involved,' White House spokesperson Abigail Jackson said in a statement. The protests began on Friday in downtown LA before spreading on Saturday to Paramount, a heavily Latino city south of the city, and neighbouring Compton. Federal agents arrested immigrants in LA's fashion district, in a Home Depot parking lot and at several other locations on Friday. The next day, they were staging at a Department of Homeland Security office near another Home Depot in Paramount, which drew out protesters who suspected another raid. By midday on Sunday, hundreds of people had gathered outside the Metropolitan Detention Centre, chanting 'shame' and 'go home' to members of the National Guard, who stood shoulder to shoulder, carrying long guns and riot shields. After some protesters closely approached the guard members, a different set of uniformed officers advanced, shooting smoke-filled canisters into the street. Minutes later, the Los Angeles Police Department fired rounds of crowd-control munitions to disperse the protesters. Police declared an unlawful assembly, and by early evening many people had left. But those who remained grabbed chairs from a nearby public park to form a makeshift barrier, throwing objects at police on the other side. Others standing above the closed southbound 101 Freeway threw chunks of concrete, rocks, electric scooters and fireworks at highway patrol officers. Video footage showed the National Guard troops were largely refraining from clashing with the demonstrators, The New York Times reported. Trump called the demonstrators 'violent, insurrectionist mobs' in a social media post on Sunday and said he was directing his cabinet officers 'to take all such action necessary' to stop what he described as 'riots'. Speaking to reporters in New Jersey, he threatened violence against demonstrators who spit on police or National Guard troops, saying, 'They spit, we hit'. He did not cite any specific incidents. 'If we see danger to our country and to our citizens, it will be very, very strong in terms of law and order,' Trump said as he headed to Camp David. 'We're going to have troops everywhere, we're not going to let this happen to our country. 'Last night in Los Angeles, we watched it very closely, there was a lot of violence there – there was a lot of violence, and it could have gotten much worse.' Why did Trump send in the National Guard? Trump border tsar Tom Homan told NBC News that Newsom and Bass, the mayor, should be thanking the president for helping restore order, and warned the leaders they could be arrested if they obstructed immigration enforcement efforts. Trump's decision to send in troops and bypass Newsom keeps with promises he made during last year's election campaign to deploy the military more aggressively in the nation's cities. During his first term of office, in the summer of 2020, Trump pushed to send active-duty military troops to quell racial protests across the US, former defence secretary Mark Esper told a House committee years later. Esper said that he and others had to convince Trump there was no predicate for that use of the military. At the time, Trump felt that the civil unrest following the murder of George Floyd in Minnesota made the US look weak, Esper told the committee. During an election campaign event in Iowa in 2023, Trump labelled several big cities 'crime dens' and said he had previously held back from sending in the military. 'You're supposed to not be involved in that – you just have to be asked by the governor or the mayor to come in. The next time, I'm not waiting,' Trump said at the Iowa event. To deploy the National Guard, Trump invoked a legal provision that allows him to deploy federal service members when there is 'a rebellion or danger of a rebellion against the authority of the government of the United States'. The White House cited what Trump described as credible threats of violence that could obstruct enforcement efforts and 'constitute a form of rebellion' against the US government. But the legal basis for the decision could face challenges. Federal law strictly limits the deployment of federal troops within US borders. The 1878 Posse Comitatus Act, along with amendments and supporting regulations, generally bars the use of the active-duty US military – the army, navy, air force and marines – from carrying out domestic law enforcement. The law doesn't apply to state-controlled National Guard forces. Trump directed US Northern Command to assume control of the National Guard and dispatch 2000 soldiers to the area 'for 60 days or at the discretion of the secretary of defence', the White House said in a statement. About 300 soldiers have since been deployed to three locations in greater Los Angeles, according to US Northern Command. The deployed troops are part of the California National Guard's 79th Infantry Brigade Combat Team, primarily a combat unit, although it has previously been called up to support civilian authorities, and a unit that most recently responded to the wildfires in LA this year. Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth said on Saturday (Sunday AEST) that Marines could be sent next if protests intensified. Newsom called Hegseth's suggestion of deploying the Marines from nearby Camp Pendleton 'deranged'. Hegseth countered overnight that Newsom had allowed violence to get out of hand. 'Deranged = allowing your city to burn & law enforcement to be attacked,' Hegseth said in a post on X. 'There is plenty of room for peaceful protest, but ZERO tolerance for attacking federal agents who are doing their job.' Vermont senator Bernie Sanders said the order by Trump to deploy the Guard reflected 'a president moving this country rapidly into authoritarianism' and 'usurping the powers of the United States Congress'. LA Police Chief Jim McDonnell has stressed that his officers are not working with federal agents on civil immigration enforcement and the department follows a long-standing policy that bars officers from stopping people solely to determine their immigration status. 'Everyone has the right to peacefully assemble and voice their opinions,' the department said in a statement on X. 'However, vandalising property and attempting to seriously injure officers, whether Federal or LAPD, is not peaceful.' Loading What is ICE? Facing mounting pressure from the White House, US agency ICE – Immigration and Customs Enforcement – has ramped up immigration arrests in recent weeks, averaging about 2000 detentions a day nationwide, but still falling short of the administration's goal of at least 3000 daily arrests. The stepped-up enforcement is part of Trump's vow to carry out the largest deportation campaign in US history. In the Los Angeles area, ICE reported 118 arrests last week, though the agency had not released updated figures on Sunday morning. Congresswoman Nanette Barragan, a Democrat whose district includes Paramount and other parts of Los Angeles County, said ICE agents were stopping 'anybody at a bus stop that's going to shop' and she had been warned to expect 30 days of stepped-up enforcement. She accused the Trump administration of using federal troops to suppress dissent and said by the time the more violent skirmishes broke out on Saturday night, the original protesters had already cleared out, and the 'unruly folks' had arrived. 'It's going to escalate the situation,' she said on CNN's State of the Union overnight. 'People are going to protest because they're angry about the situation. And we have to just reiterate, [to] the people to do it peacefully.'
Perth Now
2 hours ago
- Perth Now
Albanese to lay out political vision for second term
Anthony Albanese is set to lay out his second-term agenda in a key speech, as he prepares for potential talks with Donald Trump. In his first major address since an emphatic election win in May, the prime minister will speak at the National Press Club about his priorities for when parliament resumes in July. After securing an expanded mandate among voters at the election in which Labor increased its parliamentary majority, Mr Albanese will say delivering on promises will be his priority. "Delivering these commitments matters for every Australian, regardless of who they voted for. It matters for our economy, for the jobs, skills, technology, infrastructure and energy we need to grow and thrive in the years ahead," he will say in the speech. "It also matters for our democracy. We are living in a time of significant global uncertainty - and that reaches beyond just economic instability." May's federal poll was the first time since 1966 an incumbent government retained all the seats it held at an election. Mr Albanese will say promises of expanding urgent care clinics, cheaper childcare and an increase in affordable housing will remain central to his government's priorities. "Our government's vision and ambition for Australia's future was never dependent on the size of our majority. But you can only build for that future vision if you build confidence that you can deliver on urgent necessities," he will say. Labor will have a responsibility in its second term to disprove voter cynicism with governments, the prime minister will say. "To recognise that some of this frustration is drawn from people's real experience with government - be it failures of service delivery, or falling through the cracks of a particular system," he will say. "And to counter this, we have to offer the practical and positive alternative." The speech comes days before Mr Albanese flies to Canada for the G7 summit, where a one-on-one meeting with US President Donald Trump is on the cards. Tariffs imposed by Mr Trump on other countries are set to dominate discussions at the international forum, with Australia trying to carve out an exemption to the economic measure. Australia had been slapped with a 10 per cent tariff on all exports to the US, with steel and aluminium products having a 50 per cent tariff. Mr Albanese will say Australia will still be able to play a critical role in global affairs amid the instability. "Our vision is for a society that is a microcosm for the world, where all are respected and valued and our diversity is recognised as a strength," he will say. "Our international relationships in the fastest growing region of the world in human history benefit us, but also provide a platform for us to play a positive a stabilising global role in uncertain times."
