Carlos Sainz penalty statement issued after breaking same rule as Oliver Bearman
Oliver Bearman was handed a 10-place grid penalty at the Monaco Grand Prix for overtaking in red flag conditions during practice, but Carlos Sainz escaped punishment for doing so
The Monaco Grand Prix stewards have explained why Carlos Sainz was not punished despite breaking the same rule as Oliver Bearman. The Brit's weekend has already been ruined by a whopping 10-place grid penalty, handed to him after he was found guilty of overtaking under red flag conditions.
Such a move is seen as being highly dangerous and Bearman was duly punished for doing it in practice on Friday. And it seemed a similar punishment might have been heading Sainz's way after the Williams driver was reported for doing the same thing.
But after investigating what happened, the stewards have decided against punishing the Spaniard. That is despite them concluding that he did indeed overtake Franco Colapinto under red flag conditions during practice.
However, explaining their decision, the stewards pointed out how the circumstances were very different. While they felt Bearman should have reacted sooner to slow down, they concluded that Sainz did not have the time to avoid overtaking the Alpine of Colapinto.
The officials said: "Car 55 [Sainz] overtook Car 43 [Colapinto] at turn two. As Car 55 was going towards turn two, the session was red flagged. Car 55 was very close to Car 43 when that happened (42 metres).
"Car 55 was travelling at a significant speed, in excess of 250kph. Car 43, on the other hand, was on a slow lap on the left hand side of the track. As soon as the red flag was shown, Car 55 took immediate steps to slow down in a safe manner as required under Article 2.5.4.1 b) of Appendix H to the International Sporting Code.
"There was a significant speed delta between the two cars and the overtake was an inevitable consequence of that speed delta and the distance between the cars. In the circumstances, we took no further action."
In Bearman's case, however, the stewards found that there was "no mitigating factor" as the Haas driver had elected not to slow down straight away as soon as he saw the red flashing light, claiming that he had felt it would have been more dangerous to do so in the circumstances.
But the stewards did not agree and said: "The regulations require the drivers to 'immediately' reduce speed and proceed slowly back to their respective pits (Article 2.5.4.1 b)). The same regulations caution drivers of the fact that in a red flag situation, 'overtaking is forbidden' and that drivers should 'remember that race and service vehicles may be on the track'.
"We disagreed with his decision to not take steps to slow down sufficiently to avoid overtaking another car and instead proceeding slowly back to the pits, as required. The whole purpose of requiring drivers to slow down immediately is for safety – they will not know what is in front of them or the reason for the red flag being shown. This is particularly so in a track like Monaco."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Daily Mirror
Christian Horner slams Nico Rosberg after Max Verstappen disqualification demand
Nico Rosberg had suggested Max Verstappen should have been disqualified from the Spanish Grand Prix after the Red Bull Racing driver appeared to deliberately ram George Russell's Mercedes Christian Horner has snapped back at "sensationalist" Nico Rosberg after the Sky Sports pundit called for Max Verstappen to be disqualified. That request came shortly after the Spanish Grand Prix which ended in acrimony after Verstappen lost his head in the latter stages. Furious after contact with first Charles Leclerc and then Russell, the Dutchman believing the other driver had caused both, he then completely lost his temper when his Red Bull team, fearing that they were going to get a penalty for that first skirmish with Russell, asked him to cede a place to the Brit. Verstappen shouted furiously over the radio and then slowed down, appearing to comply despite his protests. But then, as Russell went around the outside of his Red Bull, the Dutchman appeared to deliberately turn to bang wheels with the Mercedes. Rosberg felt he had done it deliberately and said Verstappen should have been disqualified. The German said on Sky: "The first one, it was George's fault because he only complied with two out of those three things you have to comply with when you overtake, so Max could have stayed in front – he didn't have to give up that place. Sign up to our free weekly F1 newsletter, Pit Lane Chronicle, by entering your email address below so that every new edition lands straight in your inbox! "But then Red Bull told him to give up the place and that then caused his blood to boil over even more. And then it looked like a very intentional retaliation – wait for the opponent and then ramming into him, just like you felt he did to you. "And that is something that is extremely unacceptable, I think. The rules then would be a black flag, yes. If you wait for your opponent just to then ram into him, crash into him, that's a black flag." Asked about those comments, Red Bull chief Horner wouldn't be drawn into giving a full response, but made it clear what he felt of Rosberg's punditry style. The 51-year-old said: "Nico is quite sensationalist in the way that he commentates, so I'll leave it at that." Verstappen's moment of madness saw him slapped with a 10-second time penalty which dropped him to 10th place in the final classification. That meant he scored just one single point while his drivers' title rivals Oscar Piastri and Lando Norris accumulated maximum points by finishing first and second respectively. And the Dutchman is now also on the brink of a race ban. He now has 11 penalty points on his racing licence, having earned an extra three for his clash with Russell, meaning he will be forced to sit out one race if he picked up just one more point in the next two races. Two penalty points will then expire at the end of June, but the other nine he currently has won't begin to disappear until October, meaning Verstappen will had to tread a very fine line if he is to avoid that race ban.
Daily Mirror
2 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Alcaraz corrects French Open umpire and gives up point due to rarely used rule
Carlos Alcaraz showed his class in Paris as he corrected an umpire during his match with Ben Shelton at the French Open - handing a point to his opponent after he breached the rules Carlos Alcaraz displayed impressive sportsmanship as he corrected an umpire at the French Open - telling him to give his point to his opponent after breaching one of the rules of tennis. The Spaniard, who is also the defending champion at Roland Garros, was up against American Ben Shelton. Alcaraz took the first set on a tiebreak and was serving in the opening game of the second set. He produced an impressive net shot, but his American opponent responded with a sensational passing effort which looked destined to be a winner. Alcaraz threw himself at the ball, managing to return it as the crowd jumped up to applaud. But the Grand Slam winner quickly corrected the umpire and informed him that he'd thrown his racquet at the ball to win the point. Rules state that a player must be in control of his racquet when he makes connection with the ball. The umpire quickly informed the crowd that Alcaraz's honesty meant that his opponent was awarded the point with those inside the stadium acknowledging the classy gesture from the Spanish star. Alcaraz eventually made it through to the French Open quarter-finals after a four-set win over Shelton. The 22-year-old claimed a 7-6 (10-8) 6-3 4-6 6-4 victory on Court Philippe Chatrier after three hours and 19 minutes. After the win he said: "Honestly, today I fought against myself in the mind. I just tried to calm myself - in some moments I was mad. I was angry with myself, talking not good things. I'm happy that I didn't let that thought play against me. I tried to calm myself and tried to keep going." Alcaraz produced his best match of the tournament thus far, but has dropped a set in each of his last three matches. However he was happy with his level on Sunday. "Every time we face each other I said we brought the level to the top," claimed Alcaraz. "We entertained the people. He is a really powerful player. He can make any shots. I think we played really great tennis. Drops, coming to the net, big shots, and we stayed there the whole match. For me, it is great having Ben around, a great energy for tennis and for the people. I love watching him play." Alcaraz will face another American, Tommy Paul, in the last eight after the 12th seed beat Australia's Alexei Popyrin 6-3 6-3 6-3. The Spaniard remains on course for a semi-final clash with Lorenzo Musetti having dodged the likes of Jannik Sinner and Alexander Zverev until the final.
Metro
3 hours ago
- Metro
Will Max Verstappen get a race ban for deliberate George Russell crash?
Max Verstappen is on the verge of receiving a one-race ban from Formula 1 following his controversial collision with George Russell at the Spanish Grand Prix. In the final laps of Sunday's race, which was won by Oscar Piastri, the pair made contact at the safety car restart, with Verstappen subsequently cutting turn one. Red Bull asked the irate Dutchman to let Russell overtake him and initially he pulled aside at turn five, appearing to comply. But suddenly, Verstappen drove into the side of his rival's Mercedes, slightly damaging both cars before finally letting the Brit past. After the race, the four-time champion essentially confessed to deliberately causing the crash, with Russell and the rest of the grid left stunned by the incident. Stewards immediately investigated the crash and quickly slapped Verstappen with a 10-second time penalty. This meant that he dropped from fifth to 10th in the race result, costing him valuable points in the championship battle with Piastri and Lando Norris. Explaining their decision, they said: 'From the radio communications, it was clear that the driver of Car 1 [Verstappen] was asked by his team to 'give the position back' to Car 63 [Russell] for what they perceived to be an earlier breach by Car 1 for leaving the track and gaining a lasting advantage (in fact, we had later determined that we would take no further action in relation to that incident). 'The driver of Car 1 was clearly unhappy with his team's request to give the position back. At the approach to Turn 5, Car 1 significantly reduced its speed thereby appearing to allow Car 63 to overtake. 'However, after Car 63 got ahead of Car 1 at the entry of Turn 5, Car 1 suddenly accelerated and collided with Car 63. The collision was undoubtedly caused by the actions of Car 1. We therefore imposed a 10 second time penalty on Car 1.' However, the stewards also handed Verstappen three penalty points on his superlicence, bringing his tally up to 11. Crucially, if a driver receives 12 points over a 12-month period they will be handed a one-race ban. Fortunately for the Red Bull star, two of the points he's accumulated will expire soon on June 30. Unfortunately for him, there are two more grand prix before the end of the month – Canada on June 15 and Austria on June 29 – one more point at either will see him suspended. Since the penalty point system was introduced a decade ago, only one driver has received a race ban, namely former Haas star Kevin Magnussen last year. Max Verstappen was in no mood to discuss the incident post-race but appeared to confess that it was deliberate. Asked by Sky Sports whether the contact was intentional, the 27-year-old angrily replied: 'Does it matter?' Pushed again for an answer, he responded: 'Yeah, okay. That's great. I prefer to speak about the race rather than one single moment.' Read the full quotes and George Russell's reaction here. On commentary duty for Sky Sports, 2016 F1 champion Nico Rosberg, was left outraged by Verstappen's actions and immediately called for him to be disqualified from the race. 'Wow, that's bad bad bad. He just rammed him full on. You need to black flag him,' the German said. 'Max was right in the first instance and then the team went against Max and caused him to boil over. The first one was George's fault because he went in too hot, oversteered out and tapped Max who then had to use the escape road. More Trending 'In Max's eyes he's 100 per cent in the right. 'Why are you telling me to do this, watch this I will show you what he did'. Slowed down and rammed into him which is even worse. To slow down and ram into another driver is pretty bad. 'That [penalty] is a very lenient one from my point of view. Remember Sebastian Vettel against Lewis Hamilton in Baku 2017. Vettel got a 10-second stop and go penalty for that incident back then. 'It looked like a very intentional retaliation. Wait for the opponent, go ramming into him, just like you felt the other guy rammed into you at Turn 1. 'That's something which is extremely unacceptable and I think the rules would be a black flag yes. If you wait for your opponent to bang into him, that's a black flag.' For more stories like this, check our sport page. Follow Metro Sport for the latest news on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram. MORE: Spanish Grand Prix: McLaren on top but Lando Norris is still wary of Max Verstappen in F1 title race MORE: What Max Verstappen told Lewis Hamilton after Monaco qualifying clash MORE: Monaco Grand Prix: Plenty of horsepower in the car park as F1 stars enjoy working from home
