logo
An irrelevant bourgeois ritual: this year's Turner prize shortlist is the soppiest ever

An irrelevant bourgeois ritual: this year's Turner prize shortlist is the soppiest ever

The Guardian23-04-2025

Remember when controversy was fun? If not, that's because you're too young. But back in the 1990s, my child, Britain got itself in hilarious knots about conceptual art, the readymade and whether a pickled shark or elephant dung can be art, with the Turner prize as battleground. It was a culture war but with laughs, because no one's identity was at stake and it wasn't like Brian Sewell was going to become prime minister and have Rachel Whiteread jailed.
It is by embracing the earnestness of today's high-stakes culture wars that the Turner prize has lost its edge, the art getting more careful as the ideologies loom larger. This year's shortlist is the soppiest yet. Two of the artists nominated are painters. Painters, I ask you! This makes some sense of the shortlist announcement taking place on JMW Turner's 250th birthday. But as painters go, do Mohammed Sami and Zadie Xa (who also creates bland installations) compare with the boldness of Mr Turner? Neither is pushing back the boundaries of what a painting might be, or redefining this art for the 21st century in scale, freedom, audacity.
I honestly don't know why Xa has been shortlisted. She's one of those artists whose mildly impressive but pointless work you see at every art fair and Biennial. Her figurative fantasy paintings framed by rambling, decorative installations mix up the myths of Vancouver and Korea, but the lack of rawness or shock or surprise is stultifying.
Sami is in another league, and the quality artist on the shortlist. His large landscape paintings meditate on the horrors of war and agonies of enforced migration with a disconcerting poetry rooted in an impressionistic mistiness. You look at a blue sky over water, or trees above a rocky cliff, tenderly painted with whiffs of Monet and Cézanne, but then notice a refugee camp through the woods, or starbursts of ordnance in the Iraq sky.
Surely he's a shoo-in to get the Turner prize. He is not only the best artist on this list but a real international talent whose seriousness and subtlety are obvious. So why am I not more thrilled? I suppose because this is good for you. Sami is important but he's not shocking. His art embraces skill instead of setting out to scandalise or create a new language. I would like it more if it had no moral value at all.
So what about the non-painters? Will they provoke us with … balls of coloured paper and wool? That's what Nnena Kalu makes, hanging her multicoloured tangles of streamers and strands in poetical arrangements. These craftily wrought sculptures won't scare, or amaze, anyone. Kalu's work has a familiar appearance, and that's not just because she's been doing this stuff for two decades before recently getting recognition. It's because this kind of post-minimalist, found yet handworked sculpture has dried-out, attenuated roots in art movements that started way back in the 1960s. Nice, academic, dull.
The artist who makes most sense as a Turner candidate, even firing the old flames of raw controversial reality, is Rene Matić, whose photographs portray intimate moments with family and friends – and report on skinhead subculture. Sadly these close, fragmentary images don't have great emotional pull on a stranger – it's a bit like looking at someone else's family snapshots. To make that work takes more flamboyance and poignancy than Matić shows. Rene's not a laugh. Yet there's something in their work that you don't get from the others: a glimpse of life in Britain right now.
I think this goes to the heart of this Turner shortlist's fragility. It is determinedly globalist, reflecting a jury made up exclusively of curators who have shortlisted the kind of stuff they see all the time on the international circuit – Xa, for instance, has been shortlisted for work at the Sharjah Biennial, in the United Arab Emirates.
Sign up to Art Weekly
Your weekly art world round-up, sketching out all the biggest stories, scandals and exhibitions
after newsletter promotion
Clearly the jury are striking a blow against Brexity Little Englanders by shortlisting an artist from Vancouver whose art reclaims her Korean heritage – but who meets the rules by being resident in the UK. If Xa was a better artist this would be a more powerful gesture.
But this shortlist's lack of connection with the realities of contemporary Britain is just another way to dig the ailing Turner prize deeper into irrelevance and empty bourgeois ritual. This year's exhibition will be in Bradford, far from the liberal elite metropolis this shortlist reeks of. So we'll go to Bradford, applaud these right-minded artists, approve of art without borders and ignore the rising vote for Reform outside this introspective event.
Obviously there's good in all these artists but not enough to make the Turner matter again. Only one gives you a glimpse of what's going on in the streets, as opposed to the Biennials. I hope they win. Speak for England, Rene!

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

One of JMW Turner's first paintings rediscovered after 150 years
One of JMW Turner's first paintings rediscovered after 150 years

BBC News

time5 days ago

  • BBC News

One of JMW Turner's first paintings rediscovered after 150 years

Turner's first ever exhibited oil painting is to be put up for auction after being lost for more 150 Rising Squall, features a dramatic view of a former hot spring and spa in Bristol seen from east bank of the River Avon, before Clifton Suspension Bridge was built. It made its way around the world and returned to the UK but was unknown as a Turner masterpiece for more than a century. His signature was revealed after the painting was cleaned last artwork will displayed in a public exhibition at Sotheby's, in London, between 28 June and 1 July before it is auctioned with an estimated value of up to £300,000. Julian Gascoigne, Sotheby's senior specialist, said: "It's a fascinating and very instructive insight into his early style."He added the painting represents Turner, famed as a watercolourist, as a teenage artist with "ambition and skill" in his early experiments an oil painting made its debut at the Royal Academy in 1793, three days after Turner's 18th birthday, before being bought by Reverend Robert Nixon, a customer of his father's barber Nixon's son inherited the painting after his death, Mr Gascoigne said, adding it then fell "into obscurity" having last been exhibited in Tasmania, Australia, in 1858. Mr Gascoigne said: "Bristol would have been a very natural place for a young artist based in London to get to relatively easily and relatively cheaply, but would provide him with the sort of dramatic, sublime, picturesque landscape that he was seeking."There was early mention of the painting in obituaries of Turner's life but for at least a century it was mistaken for a watercolour, meaning it was missing from the catalogue of his exhibited oil until the discovery last year during a restoration project, experts believed Turner's earliest exhibited oil was the Fisherman at Sea painting.

Five Turner works to be auctioned on 250th anniversary of painter's birth
Five Turner works to be auctioned on 250th anniversary of painter's birth

Wales Online

time6 days ago

  • Wales Online

Five Turner works to be auctioned on 250th anniversary of painter's birth

Five Turner works to be auctioned on 250th anniversary of painter's birth Born in 1775, Joseph Mallord William Turner was a painter and printmaker during the English romantic period and was most famed for his landscapes, often of a nautical theme The Wreck Buoy, first exhibited 1849, JMW Turner Five of JMW Turner's works are to be auctioned across three sales on the 250th anniversary of the painter's birth. Born in 1775, Joseph Mallord William Turner was a painter and printmaker during the English romantic period and was most famed for his landscapes, often of a nautical theme. ‌ Christie's auction company, which sold a Turner watercolour for £5.8 million in 2006, will present several of his works for auction this July. ‌ Among the pieces being sold is a watercolour titled, Lake Brienz, With The Setting Moon, during the Old Masters Evening Sale on July 1. It is estimated to fetch between £600,000 and £800,000. There is also View Of Stoke House, which carries an estimated selling price of £20,000 to £30,000, and depicts a figure sketching what is thought to be a self-portrait in the foreground. Article continues below This piece, along with two others will be put for sale as part of the Old Masters, 19th Century Paintings And Drawings From A Private Collection: Selling Without Reserve event taking place on July 2. Another of the pieces in this sale depicts the Cornish coastline around Pendennis Castle and carries an estimated selling price of £60,000 to £100,000. One other Turner work, a pencil and watercolour on paper, will be part of Christie's Old Masters To Modern Day Sale: Paintings, Drawing Sculpture, also taking place on July 2. Article continues below These sales are part of Christie's Classic Week, which forms part of the auction company's programme of events for its London summer season. Earlier in the year Tate Britain announced it would celebrate the 250th anniversary of Turner's birth with a new room showcasing his work and also said it would open a new video installation about Turner's travels across Europe, among other things. Every other year the gallery hosts a prize ceremony for a prestigious contemporary art award named after the painter which is awarded to a British artist annually.

Jenny Eclair backs £3.8m fundraiser to ‘save Hepworth artwork for the nation'
Jenny Eclair backs £3.8m fundraiser to ‘save Hepworth artwork for the nation'

Wales Online

time6 days ago

  • Wales Online

Jenny Eclair backs £3.8m fundraiser to ‘save Hepworth artwork for the nation'

Jenny Eclair backs £3.8m fundraiser to 'save Hepworth artwork for the nation' Sculpture With Colour (Oval Form) Pale Blue And Red, created in the 1940s, was auctioned by Christie's in March last year for millions of pounds (Image: (Image: BBC) ) Comedian Jenny Eclair and sculptor Sir Antony Gormley are among the backers of a £3.8 million fundraiser to save a Dame Barbara Hepworth artwork "for the nation". Sculpture With Colour (Oval Form) Pale Blue And Red, created in the 1940s, was auctioned by Christie's in March last year for millions of pounds. ‌ Toward the end of 2024, the sculpture was given a temporary export bar to prevent it from leaving the UK, allowing time for a UK gallery to acquire it. ‌ The Hepworth Wakefield art museum and national charity Art Fund have launched an appeal to acquire it, with the aim of permanently and publicly displaying the sculpture in Wakefield, West Yorkshire, where artist Dame Barbara was born. Artists and creatives including Jonathan Anderson, Richard Deacon, Katy Hessel, Sir Anish Kapoor, Veronica Ryan, Joanna Scanlan and Dame Rachel Whiteread have backed the appeal. Sir Antony, 74, said: "Barbara Hepworth's work remains a luminary example of both an engagement with modernism and a return to direct carving. Article continues below "The opportunity for the museum named after her to acquire this important work is precious and should be supported." Sculptor Sir Anish, 71, who won the Turner Prize in 1991, said: "Barbara Hepworth's Sculpture with Colour (Oval Form) Pale Blue and Red must be saved for the nation. "Art fund has put up a quarter of the value of this important sculpture in an extraordinary bid to keep this work in a public collection and accessible to all. ‌ "This sculpture comes from a period of work by Hepworth in which she explores form and emptiness and looks forward to radical modernity." Simon Wallis, director, The Hepworth Wakefield, added: "We established The Hepworth Wakefield 14 years ago to celebrate, explore and build on Barbara Hepworth's legacy. "This sculpture is the missing piece, a masterpiece which deserves to be on display in the town where Hepworth was born." Article continues below The museum is home to Wakefield's art collection, including significant works by Dame Barbara but excluding her finished works from the 1940s. The art work is made of painted wood and string and is part of a larger series in Dame Barbara's oeuvre, which she developed throughout the Second World War after she settled with her family in St Ives, Cornwall.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store