Trump's Image of Dead ‘White Farmers' Came from Reuters Footage in Congo, Not South Africa
Reuters file photo
U.S. President Donald Trump shows a copy of an article that he said is about white South Africans who had been killed, in the Oval Office of the White House in Washington, D.C., U.S., May 21, 2025.
JOHANNESBURG, May 22 (Reuters) – U.S. President Donald Trump showed a screenshot of Reuters video taken in the Democratic Republic of Congo as part of what he falsely presented on Wednesday as evidence of mass killings of white South Africans.
'These are all white farmers that are being buried,' said Trump, holding up a print-out of an article accompanied by the picture during a contentious Oval Office meeting with South African President Cyril Ramaphosa.
In fact, the video, published by Reuters on February 3 and subsequently verified by the news agency's fact check team, showed humanitarian workers lifting body bags in the Congolese city of Goma. The image was pulled from Reuters footage shot following deadly battles with Rwanda-backed M23 rebels.
The blog post showed to Ramaphosa by Trump during the White House meeting was published by American Thinker, a conservative online magazine, about conflict and racial tensions in South Africa and Congo.
The post did not caption the image but identified it as a 'YouTube screen grab' with a link to a video news report about Congo on YouTube, which credited Reuters.
The White House did not respond to a request for comment. Andrea Widburg, managing editor at American Thinker and the author of the post in question, wrote in reply to a Reuters query that Trump had 'misidentified the image.'
She added, however, that the post, which referred to what it called Ramaphosa's 'dysfunctional, race-obsessed Marxist government', had 'pointed out the increasing pressure placed on white South Africans.'
The footage from which the picture was taken shows a mass burial following an M23 assault on Goma, filmed by Reuters video journalist Djaffar Al Katanty.
'That day, it was extremely difficult for journalists to get in … I had to negotiate directly with M23 and coordinate with the ICRC to be allowed to film,' Al Katanty said. 'Only Reuters has video.'
Al Katanty said seeing Trump holding the article with the screengrab of his video came as a shock.
'In view of all the world, President Trump used my image, used what I filmed in DRC to try to convince President Ramaphosa that in his country, white people are being killed by Black people,' Al Katanty said.
Ramaphosa visited Washington this week to try to mend ties with the United States after persistent criticism from Trump in recent months over South Africa's land laws, foreign policy, and alleged bad treatment of its white minority, which South Africa denies.
Trump interrupted the televised meeting with Ramaphosa to play a video, which he said showed evidence of genocide of white farmers in South Africa. This conspiracy theory, which has circulated in far-right chat rooms for years, is based on false claims.
Trump then proceeded to flip through printed copies of articles that he said detailed murders of white South Africans, saying 'death, death, death, horrible death'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Asahi Shimbun
41 minutes ago
- Asahi Shimbun
Two Chinese aircraft carriers seen in Pacific for first time, Japan says
The Chinese Navy aircraft carrier Liaoning takes part in a naval parade off the eastern port city of Qingdao, to mark the 70th anniversary of the founding of Chinese People's Liberation Army Navy, China, April 23, 2019. (REUTERS) Two Chinese aircraft carriers were spotted conducting simultaneous operations in the Pacific for the first time, Japanese Foreign Minister Takeshi Iwaya said on Tuesday. Japan's Defense Ministry has confirmed the Liaoning and Shandong operating in separate locations in the Pacific on Saturday, both near remote southern islands belonging to Japan. Iwaya said the ministry had communicated with Beijing through China's embassy in Japan and that it would take further 'appropriate steps' as needed. He stopped short of condemning China for the operations. Japan had said a day earlier that Liaoning sailed in the sea within Japan's exclusive economic zone near Minamitorishima, a remote island east of Iwo Jima.
Yomiuri Shimbun
an hour ago
- Yomiuri Shimbun
California Gov. Gavin Newsom Says Trump Is Stepping toward Authoritarianism
Joshua Lott/The Washington Post National Guard soldiers stand in front of a federal building as protests continue on Monday following raids by Immigration and Customs Enforcement. LOS ANGELES – The relationship between the leader of the United States and the country's most populous state reached a near-breaking point Monday, as President Donald Trump said that he thought California Gov. Gavin Newsom should be arrested, a claim that Newsom described as an unmistakable step toward authoritarianism. The back-and-forth came as Trump stepped up the military's presence on the streets of Los Angeles, against Newsom's will, as the two men traded recriminations. Trump repeatedly ridiculed Newsom, a Democrat, saying that he is 'grossly incompetent' and had done 'a terrible job.' Asked about a threat made by his border czar Tom Homan to arrest the governor, Trump said, 'I would do it if I were Tom.' 'I think it's great,' Trump added, without specifying any alleged criminal wrongdoing or charges. 'Gavin likes the publicity, but I think it would be a great thing.' 'That's an American president in 2025, threatening a political opponent who happens to be a sitting governor,' Newsom said in an interview Monday. 'That's not with precedent in modern times. That's what we see around the globe in authoritarian regimes.' Newsom's comments reflected a broader frustration for Democratic leaders, who have been unable to counter what they see as an escalation of Trump's antidemocratic actions in his emboldened second term. Newsom has tried all methods: He was a face of the resistance in the first term and a welcoming greeter during Trump's initial visit to California in his second term. All the while, he continued suing Trump, while keeping up a cordial back-channel relationship. On Monday, he sounded like he was at his end with Trump, calling him 'unrestrained' and 'unhinged.' 'Trump is a very different president than his first foray in office,' Newsom said Monday. 'You've seen that as it relates to how he has completely obliterated any oversight from Congress; how he seeks to obliterate oversight from the judicial branch by threatening impeachment of judges and running up to the edge as it relates to court orders.' The newest break in the historically tumultuous relationship between Newsom and Trump unfolded over a chaotic 72-hour period that began with raids by federal immigration officials in Los Angeles on Friday that led to the arrests of 44 people, including two people whom state officials believe to be minors. Trump, who had arrived at his golf club in Bedminster, New Jersey, for the weekend, left a message for Newsom on his cellphone Friday night. The two had spoken intermittently since Trump's inauguration, including during a meeting in the Oval Office in February as Newsom sought tens of billions of dollars in federal funding to help L.A. rebuild after the January wildfires. While they sparred publicly, their interactions in private during both Trump terms were more productive. On Friday, the Immigration and Customs Enforcement arrests had triggered protests, with the Los Angeles Police Department reporting that agitators had hurled chunks of concrete at law enforcement officers. The Democratic governor assumed that was why Trump was calling. He was hoping to reassure him when they spoke after 1:30 a.m. Eastern time that state and local officials had protests under control. But he could scarcely get in a word. Trump talked about trivial subjects, according to people familiar with the call who spoke on the condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to discuss details of a private conversation. Newsom unsuccessfully tried to steer the president toward serious subjects, including reports that the administration was preparing to terminate California's federal funding. In an interview Monday, Newsom said Trump was 'gracious' but never warned that he was about to federalize the National Guard, as the president later claimed, and never asked about the law enforcement response to that night's protests. Risking complaints from some Democrats that he had been too accommodating, the California governor had been restrained in the months since inauguration, avoiding personal attacks. But by Sunday, when Newsom arrived in Los Angeles, crowds of protesters in the city's downtown had swelled to thousands. California Highway Patrol officers under Newsom's command were arresting people who had blocked the southbound lanes of the 101 Freeway, a major artery through the city, and throwing objects at local law enforcement officers as several Waymo vehicles were set on fire. The gripping and chaotic scene in a Democratic-run city was, in Newsom's view, the kind of made-for-television crisis that Trump had always hoped to manufacture. Newsom, who blamed Trump for the escalation, said Sunday on social media that Trump's actions had diverged into those of 'a dictator, not a President.' 'This is an act of recklessness that quite literally puts people's lives at risk,' Newsom said of Trump's decision to federalize the National Guard. From Trump's perspective, the situation in Los Angeles County had gotten out of control – leaving him no choice but to step in. A White House official briefed on the administration's response to the protests, who spoke on the condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to comment publicly, said that the president had hoped that calling Newsom would compel him to take more aggressive law enforcement action – something Trump stressed in the phone call, the official insisted. Throughout Saturday, according to White House officials, the president and his advisers were being briefed about what was happening on the ground – and watching provocative images on social media and television. They saw images of agents with lacerations, and of rocks being thrown at law enforcement vehicles. By around 9 p.m., Trump had signed a memorandum authorizing the National Guard. That decision was announced in the early evening in Los Angeles, a time that a White House official said was designed to deter further protests that evening. 'You watch the same clips as I did. Cars burning all over the place, people rioting,' Trump said on Monday afternoon. He cast himself as the savior of the state, and said he had no choice but to intervene, mocking those who disagreed as 'politically correct.' 'If we didn't do the job, that place would be burning down, just like the houses burned down,' he said, comparing it to other protests like those in Minneapolis in the aftermath of George Floyd's killing. 'There's so many different places where we let it burn. We want to be politically correct. We want it to be nice. We want to be nice to the criminal. And what you're doing is destroying the fabric of our life in this country.' He said that he should be credited. 'And I think Gavin, in his own way, is probably happy I got involved,' Trump said. Later on Monday, a senior administration official said that about 700 active-duty U.S. Marines would be deployed from Camp Pendleton to Los Angeles on Monday night 'in light of increased threats to federal officers and federal buildings.' Newsom called the act 'un-American.' 'U.S. Marines have served honorably across multiple wars in defense of democracy. They are heroes,' Newsom wrote on X. 'They shouldn't be deployed on American soil facing their own countrymen to fulfill the deranged fantasy of a dictatorial President.' While Trump expressed support for arresting Newsom, he did not have an explanation for what crime he thinks the governor committed. 'I think his primary crime is running for governor, because he's done such a bad job,' he said. 'What he's done to that state is like what [Joe] Biden did to this country. And, that's pretty bad.' White House officials later suggested that Trump was serious about his threats to have Newsom arrested. 'No one, regardless of status as elected official is above the law,' a White House official said. 'If Gavin Newsom is obstructing federal law enforcement, he may face consequences.' The relationship between Newsom and Trump, never strong, has long seemed headed this way, according to observers. 'This is a symbiotic relationship right now,' said David Axelrod, a former adviser to Barack Obama, noting that both Trump and Newsom are 'improvisational politicians who are habitually trying to read the room.' 'But at the end of the day, Newsom clearly wants to run for president. And to be president, he has to be the Democratic nominee,' Axelrod said. 'And when this kind of provocation takes place – when the president of the United States is sending Marines to L.A. – yeah, you damn well better have something to say.' Newsom said he would have a hard time keeping up the cordiality. 'He just threatened my arrest. One would assume, or presume, that's the point of no return,' Newsom said. 'I'm constitutionally capable of working with people, even those that call for my arrest. So I remain resolved in that respect, as I remain resolved to have the backs of kids, whose lives are being threatened by his authoritarian tendencies.'
Yomiuri Shimbun
2 hours ago
- Yomiuri Shimbun
700 Marines Deployed to L.A. as Immigration Protests Continue
Joshua Lott/The Washington Post Protesters are seen outside the Metropolitan Detention Center on Monday in Los Angeles. The Pentagon on Monday ordered a battalion of 700 Marines to Los Angeles as protests of the Trump administration's immigration policies spilled into a fourth day, escalating a confrontation between the White House and the country's most populous state. The Marines, summoned from an infantry unit typically trained for overseas warfare, will assist more than 300 National Guard members that President Donald Trump deployed to the city over the weekend, the first wave of roughly 2,100 activated so far for the mission, according to the Defense Department. The deployments follow demonstrations against immigration raids that at times turned violent. The Marines, stationed east of Los Angeles in Twentynine Palms, had started moving out Monday afternoon, a defense official said, speaking on the condition of anonymity to discuss ongoing operations. This marks the first time in six decades an American president has ordered such a military intervention without the approval of a state's governor. State and local officials in California – a frequent target of Trump's ire – denounced the move as incendiary. 'This is unprecedented that the president is using the military against his own people in this way,' said Los Angeles City Council member Hugo Soto-Martínez, whose district adjacent to downtown encompasses a range of immigrant communities. Most protests have been peaceful, state and local officials have said, even as they spread to cities across the country. 'U.S. Marines have served honorably across multiple wars in defense of democracy. They are heroes,' California Gov. Gavin Newsom (D) said on social media. 'They shouldn't be deployed on American soil facing their own countrymen to fulfill the deranged fantasy of a dictatorial President. This is un-American.' The Marines will deploy from a military base in Twentynine Palms, a three-hour drive east of Los Angeles in the Mojave Desert. They will focus on 'protecting federal personnel and federal property,' the Pentagon said in a statement, and they will partner with National Guard members who have been trained in crowd control and de-escalation. The mobilization is a significant move by the Pentagon. Typically, National Guard members, rather than active-duty troops such as the Marines, are mobilized for civil unrest missions at the behest of governors or the president. The Marines and Guard members under federal orders will serve in a support role and cannot participate in direct immigration or law enforcement operations. That would change if Trump invoked the Insurrection Act, which gives the president broader powers to conduct policing operations with troops under federal control. Troops being sent to Los Angeles are 'trained in de-escalation, crowd control, and standing rules for the use of force,' Northern Command, which oversees operations in North America, said in a statement. The activated units so far are drawn from combat units, not military police personnel, who specialize in civil disturbance response. The move was met with skepticism among some of the protesters in downtown Los Angeles on Monday. Amaris Leon, a 35-year-old lawyer from Sacramento, said he interpreted the deployment of Marines as an effort to set 'the military on civilians for exercising their First Amendment rights.' Trump is trying to rile people up, said Teri Merrick, a retired professor, 'so he can have an excuse to come in and stomp everybody down.' The protests began after a week of immigration raids in Southern California, which resulted in more than 100 arrests at workplaces that neighbors described as normally calm, including a doughnut shop and Home Depot stores. Demonstrators took to the streets in response, lighting the fuse that sparked days of widely broadcasted dust-ups. Portions of the 101 Freeway closed over the weekend when protesters clogged its southbound lanes, snarling already notorious traffic. Protesters hurled rocks at police cruisers, tear gas filled the air and phones captured videos of rioters torching self-driving vehicles, leading one robotaxi company to suspend part of its Los Angeles services. More than 50 protesters have been arrested, according to local law enforcement. The National Guard members had already improved the situation in Los Angeles, Trump said Monday. 'Thank goodness we sent out some wonderful National Guard – they really helped,' he said. 'A lot of problems that we're having out there, they were afraid to do anything. And we sent out the troops, and they've done a fantastic job.' But local officials said the deployment was unnecessary. The chaos from the protests was contained to 'a few streets downtown' that looked 'horrible,' Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass said on CNN. But there has not been, she added, 'citywide civil unrest.' California sued the Trump administration Monday over the deployment of California National Guard members to Los Angeles without Newsom's consent. The fallout from the protests appears to have deepened the political feud between Trump and Newsom, a potential 2028 Democratic hopeful. The Trump administration has been weighing the cancellation of California's federal funding, an unprecedented move that would decimate the state's budget. And Trump endorsed arresting Newsom on Monday after arriving on the South Lawn of the White House. 'I would do it if I were Tom,' Trump told reporters as he returned to the White House, referring to border czar Tom Homan. 'I think it's great. Gavin likes the publicity, but I think it would be a great thing.' Newsom responded minutes later in a social media post on X, calling it 'an unmistakable step toward authoritarianism.' 'The President of the United States just called for the arrest of a sitting Governor. This is a day I hoped I would never see in America. I don't care if you're a Democrat or a Republican this is a line we cannot cross as a nation – this is an unmistakable step toward authoritarianism,' he wrote. After a chaotic weekend, downtown Los Angeles residents woke to a jarring combination of calm streets and graffiti-marred buildings. Just outside the city's core, in the coffee-shop-studded neighborhood of Silver Lake, people casually walked dogs and sipped cortados as the workweek started. Yet the national spotlight remained glued to Hollywood's backyard, which was caught in the crosshairs of dueling political narratives: While right-leaning media looped videos of burning cars and street skirmishes, Democrats insisted that most protesters remained peaceful. Protests spread across the country after the Friday arrest of David Huerta, the 58-year-old head of the Service Employees International Union's California branch. Huerta was arrested after sitting in the path of federal agents targeting Los Angeles warehouse workers, and he now faces a felony conspiracy charge. The Service Employees International Union, which represents thousands of janitors, cooks, security guards and other service workers, organized rallies in more than a dozen states, with members and their supporters condemning immigration-enforcement tactics they cast as inhumane. Huerta was released from custody Monday on a $50,000 bond. Bill Essayli, the U.S. Attorney for the Central District of California, wrote in a post on X that Huerta had 'deliberately obstructed' federal agents who were executing a warrant. 'No one has the right to assault, obstruct, or interfere with federal authorities carrying out their duties,' Essayli wrote. Some Los Angeles residents are bracing for more protests. Christian Frizzell, owner of the downtown Redwood Bar, was trying to decide whether to close early Monday. They usually stay open until 2 a.m. But he noticed a nearby credit union had boarded up its windows in anticipation of more protests. Back in 2020, his bar was damaged during Black Lives Matter protests. Still, he wasn't sure if Marines were the best choice to protect his property. 'It seems like a large escalation,' he said of the coming deployment. 'I wish they would try to cool it down.'
