Senior NHS nurse who was told to remove 'anti-Semitic fruit bowl' from video call background launches legal action
A British-Palestinian NHS nurse who says he was told to remove a background on his video calls because it could be perceived as 'anti Semitic' has launched legal action against his employer.
Ahmad Baker, a senior nurse, claims hospital bosses complained about the image of a fruit bowl containing watermelons - which have been adopted as a symbol of Palestine.
Barts Health NHS trust, which runs Whipps Cross hospital in north London where Mr Baker works, has banned staff from displaying symbols seen as politically or nationally affiliated.
The ban was introduced in March this year and applies to uniform, workstations, laptops and iPads.
However, Mr Baker and two other members of staff have argued that the measures are disproportionate and discriminatory to those with pro-Palestinian beliefs.
He claims he was threatened with disciplinary action for displaying the watermelon symbols on his wallpaper as they could be seen as 'anti Semitic'.
Mr Baker told The Guardian: 'As a Palestinian, I should be able to express my identity and solidarity with my people, especially during a humanitarian crisis.
'Being told that a still-life painting containing a watermelon could be perceived as antisemitic and being threatened with disciplinary action is deeply upsetting.
'I've worked for the NHS for over a decade – this is not the inclusivity I thought we stood for.'
Mr Baker has launched the legal action alongside other trust employees Dr Aarash Saleh, a respiratory consultant at Whipps Cross, and Dr Sara Ali, a haematology registrar.
The group is arguing that the policy amounts to indirect discrimination under the Equality Act 2010 and is disproportionate to those with pro-Palestinian beliefs.
They have also pointed to the fact that Barts Health NHS trust has openly supported Ukraine amid the ongoing conflict with Russia.
The group have started a CrowdJustice page to help them raise money to fight the case. More than £16,000 has already been raised of a £50,000 target.
On the page they wrote: This legal case is about how senior executives at Barts Health NHS Trust have imposed a new uniform policy to ban any visible expressions of support for Palestinians as they suffer unprecedented potentially amounting to a genocide.
'Barts Health's decision has followed direct pressure from UK Lawyers for Israel (UKLFI), a pro-Israel lobby group.
'Please support us in opposing this discriminatory policy which contravenes NHS core values and basic rights of expression.'
A spokesperson for Barts Health NHS trust said: 'We recognise the distress that global conflict has for our diverse workforce and continue to support their wellbeing as they serve our patients.
'However, as an NHS organisation our primary responsibility is care for patients.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
23 minutes ago
- The Guardian
UK sickle cell patients ‘get worse care than sufferers of similar disorders'
People living with sickle cell disease face substandard care as its treatment significantly lags behind advances relating to other genetic disorders such as cystic fibrosis, a report has found. The study, commissioned by the NHS Race and Health Observatory and carried out by researchers at Imperial College London, analysed various measures of care for sickle cell disease between 2010 and 2024, including clinical trials, approved drugs and reviews of existing studies. The findings indicated that sickle cell care across the UK does not have parity with other genetic disorders, such as cystic fibrosis, with there being only 0.5 specialist nurses per 100 patients for sickle cell, compared with two per 100 for cystic fibrosis. The report also found that there is 2.5 times more research funding for cystic fibrosis than for sickle cell, meaning the former has more treatment options and breakthrough drugs than the latter. Evidence of substandard care for people with sickle cell was also found, with 20% of babies with the condition not being seen by a specialist by three months of age, despite the NHS screening programme guidelines that 90% of babies should be seen by this milestone. Prof Habib Naqvi, the chief executive of the observatory, said sickle cell care 'significantly lags behind' that for other rare genetic conditions. He added: 'These inequalities are stark and, despite being a common genetic disorder, sickle cell has endured years of inadequate attention and investment that has resulted in the experiences we then see play out for people living with the condition. 'We do highlight the stark inequalities that exist for people with sickle cell in comparison with other rare conditions, but we also offer evidence-based solutions for meaningful change.' The report also found that these disparities in care for people with sickle cell disease were not due to a lack of need, given that hospital admissions for sickle cell rose by 42% between 2013 and 2022. These disparities exist despite the fact sickle cell disease is just as prevalent as other rare genetic disorders. The disorder primarily affects people from an African-Caribbean background. In England, about 17,000 people are living with the disease, an inherited blood disorder, with 250 new cases a year. Sickle cell disease changes the shape of blood cells into crescents, hindering blood flow. People with the condition experience severe painful episodes, which can require hospital admission. Approximately 11,000 people in the UK have cystic fibrosis, a condition which causes breathing and digestive problems due to mucus. The median age of death for sickle cell is 47. For cystic fibrosis, it is 48. John James, the chief executive of the Sickle Cell Society, said the landmark report 'makes it impossible for anyone to ignore the existence of deep inequalities faced by people with sickle cell – in healthcare, research funding and wider recognition'. He added that the findings were sobering. 'It is unimaginable that these disparities have, beyond all reason, continued for so long. 'However, by analysing how other long-term conditions are supported and resourced, it is clear to see the tangible difference that investment in healthcare makes.' Prof Bola Owolabi, NHS England's director for the National Healthcare Inequalities Improvement Programme, said: 'It is unacceptable that people with sickle cell disease face worse outcomes than those with other conditions, which is why the NHS England has stepped up with its sickle cell and thalassemia quality improvement project. 'Patient care has also been boosted by introduction of digital care plans so they don't need to repeat their stories to healthcare staff, and we have launched a campaign to boost awareness of key signs and symptoms of the disorder called Can You Tell It's Sickle Cell?'
Daily Mail
28 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
EXCLUSIVE I discovered I was expecting after doctors gave me a terminal diagnosis - mother shares 'miracle' pregnancy journey on new Mail podcast
Podcast All episodes Play on Apple Spotify A young mother has shared the extraordinary story of her 'miracle' pregnancy while facing a terminal diagnosis, in the latest episode of the Mail's The Apple & The Tree podcast. Fiona Hinton, 42, spoke to her father, Steven Speakman, 71, about the challenges of balancing motherhood with advanced pulmonary fibrosis. The podcast, hosted by the Reverend Richard Coles, brings together parents and their adult children to answer questions about their shared family history. Pulmonary fibrosis is a progressive lung disease where scar tissue builds up in the lungs, making it increasingly difficult to breathe and ultimately proving fatal as the lungs lose their ability to transfer oxygen to the blood. 'I was 35 and I had a cold that just rambled on and on', Fiona said. 'Doctors told me I had asthma, but it didn't feel like asthma. Nothing would relieve this cough – I tried inhalers and various other things. 'I was a client director, so I would go to London a lot to present at conferences. It got to this point where I would get breathless going up on stage. 'I would never say I was the pinnacle of athletic health – but this seemed very odd, the breathlessness kept getting worse and worse.' Fiona revealed her symptoms reached a crisis point during a business meeting when she couldn't catch her breath after climbing just one flight of stairs. 'The CEO turned to me and said: "Fiona, you look really uncomfortable", she recounted. 'I could barely breathe in this meeting - he told me to go home and go to A&E. 'My dad took me to the hospital, and we had to petition for the nurses to take me seriously. I remember saying: 'I can't go home, I can't breathe, I can't wait and see – I think I'm dying.' After being transferred to a specialist treatment centre, doctors told Fiona she had pulmonary fibrosis, an 'extremely rare' diagnosis for her age. Steven, a former teacher from Manchester, told the podcast that he has struggled to accept the devastating news. He said: 'It's this slow and ratcheting thing to conclude that your daughter's life is going to be limited. 'I still hold out hope for a cure because it's been difficult for me. I think of myself as physically robust and you're my junior; I struggled to accept it. 'I have come to terms with it now: we're all limited in life – there is a beginning and an end and there's a brevity to your life that's hard upon us to accept.' While coming to terms with her terminal diagnosis, Fiona 'miraculously' fell pregnant despite having previously struggled to conceive. 'Something that lifted the mood for us all was the arrival of Harry', she said. 'I have a two-year-old and he came about quite miraculously after the diagnosis. My husband and I had IVF for several years and had no success. We decided to give up. 'By some miracle, we fell naturally pregnant – my son arrived in 2022, and he's been the light of lives, raising everybody's spirits.' Fiona broke down when candidly discussing the challenges of new motherhood while facing her own mortality. She said: 'I have to plan ahead all of the time now - that is tedious sometimes. I am a strong person, but it's difficult being put in that vulnerable position all the time. 'Disease doesn't discriminate – it gets you wherever you are and whoever you are. 'It's not guaranteed I will grow old with my husband or see my son grow up – and that's hard. Sometimes, it's too awful to contemplate. 'All I see is Harry's little face and that's a dagger to heart. Nobody loves you like your mum loves you. 'I just have to think one day at a time because the alternative is total and utter despair. 'I want to play a role in Harry's life – to let him know who I was, because I won't necessarily be there to do that forever.' To listen to full episode, search for The Apple & The Tree, wherever you get your podcasts. New episodes are released every Thursday.
Sky News
2 hours ago
- Sky News
I felt I had to go back to help Gaza's hospitals, says British plastic surgeon
Dr Victoria Rose is a consultant plastic surgeon who worked in Gaza hospitals for two separate periods last year. This is her first-hand story of the war in Gaza. The word "dire" does not adequately describe the situation in Gaza's hospitals. On a daily basis when I was working there, I had a list of at least 10 patients, and 60% of them were under the age of 15. These were tiny children with life-threatening burns and limbs blown off, often losing significant family members in the attacks and left to cope with their life-changing injuries alone. I first joined the charity IDEALS, which helps medical professionals during crises, in Gaza in 2019. I returned last year, working with orthopaedic surgeons. I felt compelled to go back after becoming aware that a plastic surgeon from Gaza who trained with me in London had been inundated with complex trauma cases since the war broke out in October 2023. Our aim was to deliver essential surgical equipment and assist our colleagues with the increasing trauma workload they faced. But as the war progressed, it became apparent that we had a third objective: to bear witness. I worked at the European Gaza Hospital in March 2024 and then returned in August of that year for a month, working at Nasser Hospital. The transformation of the landscape during these two visits was staggering. The streets were unrecognisable, just pile after pile of dust and rubble. Such a scale of destruction could only be justified if every single building in Gaza was part of Hamas's infrastructure. In February 2024, we were denied entry by COGAT – part of the Israel Defence Forces (IDF) controlling activities in the occupied territories – which, regrettably, has become a standard outcome for 50% of foreign doctors attempting to gain access. However, we managed to regain access in May. This mission was intended to last four weeks at the European Gaza Hospital. However, due to its bombing on the day we arrived and its subsequent decommissioning by the IDF, we were redirected to Nasser for three and a half weeks. The population had now been relentlessly displaced, bombed in their tents, deprived of water and sanitation, and ultimately starved. I remember thinking it couldn't get any worse – and then they cut the internet. We ploughed on without essential equipment such as painkillers and antibiotics, patching the patients up, knowing that they were likely to be bombed again. When we left the hospital we went into the red zone – an area of active fighting that needed to be evacuated. This meant that nothing could enter without the journey being "deconflicted" by the IDF. Minimal journeys have thus far been deconflicted. Patients struggle to gain entry, and staff cannot leave, as equipment continues to be depleted. Nasser is the only hospital in the south equipped with a CT scanner, a blood bank, ICU capabilities and an oxygen generator. I work with two orthopaedic surgeons who run the IDEALS charity. They have been travelling to Gaza since 2009. IDEALS started the lower limb reconstruction programme in 2013, visiting Gaza every other month and bringing four orthopaedic surgeons back to the UK for short periods of training. In 2021, I arranged for a plastic surgeon from Gaza to come to London to train with me. He was an incredible trainee and returned to Gaza in February 2023 to take up the post of chief of plastic surgery at Shifa Hospital. 0:54 Shortly after the war broke out, I felt compelled to help him. All eyes are now on Israel's next move.
