Relocation not an option for grizzly that has divided public opinion on small island, say B.C. officials
On May 25, Mark Robert was out for a drive with his girlfriend and their two dogs when they saw something unusual in the distance.
"We just said holy sh--, that's a grizzly," the 51-year-old Texada Island resident recalled.
Home to about 1,000 people, the 300-square kilometre island doesn't usually play host to large predators as it sits between the Sunshine Coast and Vancouver Island in British Columbia's Strait of Georgia.
But this particular bear, which likely swam to the island, seems to be settling in, dividing public sentiment.
"Half the island wants it moved off or destroyed, the other half wants to save it," said Robert, taking note of the near-daily updates on the bear's location on local community Facebook groups.
Robert said he was at first hesitant to post publicly about seeing the bear but as a fire chief, he worried about the consequences if someone were to surprise it out on a trail.
"I have a pretty big commitment to the safety of my community," he said. "I would like to see it move somewhere by itself."
For now, that's also the hope of wildlife officials who say they have been closely monitoring the bear's behaviour — and are quite familiar with its history.
In a statement released Friday afternoon, the province revealed the adult male grizzly, estimated to be five years old, has already been relocated after it was found wandering near schools and downtown areas of Gibsons and Sechelt, on the B.C. mainland last year.
Keeping people safe
After being moved up the coast to Vancouver Bay — which is north of Quadra Island and near Bute Inlet — the grizzly returned to the Sunshine Coast. Once again, it was relocated further north.
"We want to be very clear: there is no 'kill order' on this bear," reads the statement, which is attributed to the Minister of Environment and Parks Tamara Davidson and Minister of Water, Land and Resource Stewardship Randene Neill.
"However, it is also our responsibility to keep people safe and if further behaviour by the grizzly bear occurs that threatens public safety, Conservation Officers will respond to those situations."
The statement also says that because the bear has twice been relocated, doing so a third time would "not be in the interest of public safety."
The statement also included a list of problematic behaviour the bear has engaged in this year, including:
Stalking two residents while walking on a trail in Powell River on May 22. The residents escaped into the water while the bear paced on shore for half an hour, tearing up one of their jackets;
Stalking a resident walking with her horse and dog for half a kilometre on Texada Island on May 28;
Reportedly chasing livestock on June 10 and 11 on Texada Island.
The statement also said there have been multiple sightings of the bear near a school, store and farms on Texada.
According to conservation group WildSafeBC, the province is home to about 15,000 grizzlies, or approximately one quarter of the entire North American population. The bears are considered a species of " special concern" by the federal government.
The greatest threat they face, is intrusion from humans. People are urged to keep garbage and other attractants locked up or inaccessible in order to avoid habituation of bears.
The province says it is working with First Nations and the Grizzly Bear Foundation to monitor the Texada grizzly and "we are doing our very best to ensure grizzly bears continue to endure and thrive in our province."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
3 hours ago
- CBC
Rare spirit bear cub living near B.C. highway stirs excitement, concern, as word of its existence spreads
Shelley Lindaas has long dreamed of seeing a Kermode bear cub in person. An amateur wildlife photographer based in Terrace, near B.C.'s north coast, she spends much of her free time hiking the backwoods and camped out with camera equipment in one spot for hours at a time, waiting to catch a glimpse. But her goal of seeing the rare, light-furred variant of a black bear came almost accidentally this year as she was driving along the highway and spotted the cub, with its family, just off the road. "They were sitting right on the highway," Lindaas said. "I get unusually excited when I see any wildlife ... but I was off the charts excited." Kermodes, also known as spirit bears, are a subset of black bears that live in B.C.'s North and Central Coast regions. Their unique colouring occurs due to a recessive gene passed on through black bears. The official animal of British Columbia, a recent survey estimated their population to be fewer than 500, making them one of the rarest bear sightings in the world. For generations, First Nations limited information about the bears out of concern they would be targeted for hunting and trapping, but in more recent years some groups have taken to highlighting their existence as a way of raising wider awareness about the need for ecosystem management on B.C.'s coast. And that debate, about how best to handle it when an animal many dream of seeing is discovered, is playing out in miniature in Terrace where many are celebrating sightings of the cub while others worry posting photos and video of it will put the animal at risk by drawing too many people to the region. Concerns over habituation Lindaas, who grew up in the northwest and whose father was a hunter and trapper, didn't see her first Kermode until 2023, after years of exploration in the region. Since then, she's managed to track a few bears and document them through her Instagram account and a calendar she sells locally. But, she said, she doesn't generally share her photos until after she's confident the bears have moved away from the area she spotted them in. "I always wait until August before I post pictures, and I get bombarded by other wildlife photographers about where I took them," she said. "If I have friends in the area, I'll tell them, but I try to keep it quiet." She made an exception in posting the photo of the cub because there had already been so many other sightings and posts on social media that it seemed "everyone knew." Indeed, a search through local Facebook groups reveals multiple photos and videos of the bear, along with its mother and two black bear siblings. Along with those posts are comments from locals worried about too many people getting too close to the bear, a concern that has been amplified by the conservation officer service, which put out a message urging people to give the bears space and not do anything — such as feeding — that might acclimatize them to human contact. "It's natural for people to be curious if they see a white bear on the side of the road, I understand," said Sgt. Micah Kneller of the Terrace conservation officer service. "We just encourage people that if they see the bear, or bears in general ... they move on fairly quickly." He said some of the most concerning behaviour would be rolling down windows to make noise to try and get the bear's attention, as well as anything that might lure them toward the highway or other people. He said while there'd been no reports of people feeding the bears yet, he worries it will become a greater risk as more tourists less familiar with wildlife behaviour came to the region over the summer. "Inevitably some traveler ends up throwing food toward some of these bears so they can get a better picture of them," he said. Even without the food, he said, frequent vehicle stops would get the bears used to traffic, leading to a greater likelihood to them getting hit or, in a "worst-case scenario," crawling onto vehicles, forcing them to be killed by the conservation officer service. Hundreds of black bears killed annually Provincial statistics show hundreds of black bears are destroyed each year as they are deemed a risk to humans, with more than 8,000 over a 14-year span from 2011 to 2024. Statistics are not kept specifically for Kermodes, but hunting the rare white bears is illegal, with penalties of up to $100,000 and/or one year in prison. Lindaas said it is important for members of the public to understand that although the photos she takes look like she's up close and personal with the bears, she uses specialized equipment that lets her zoom in and enhance images from great distances. "It's a heavy, heavy edit," she said. "It's really frustrating when you're giving them a respectful distance but then people pull up, like, two feet from it with their iPhone and they're leaning out the window, stressing the animal out." She encouraged people to get familiar with animal behaviour and follow the advice of wildlife officials to stay far away when encountering any wild animals.
CBC
7 hours ago
- CBC
Toronto should allow sixplexes to bring 'gentle density' to city, council committee says
Toronto has moved one step closer to allowing fiveplexes and sixplexes in neighbourhoods across the city. At its meeting on Thursday, the city's planning and housing committee approved recommendations from city staff to allow multiplexes with five and six dwelling units in detached residential buildings in low-rise neighbourhoods city-wide. A report to the committee said the move would help to bring "gentle density" to residential neighbourhoods in Toronto. Coun. Gord Perks, who represents Parkdale High Park and is committee chair, said the city is trying to add different housing types to neighbourhoods. He said most of the housing stock in Toronto is either single-family dwellings or apartment and condo units. "We're trying to build more of this sort of intermediate type housing," he said. "I think it's very important that we arrange to have a whole array of different housing types in our neighbourhoods. We need places for young families. We need places for people who are getting their first apartment. We need places for seniors who maybe can't maintain a big place all by themselves and want to stay in the same neighbourhood in a smaller unit. It's very important for the health of our neighbourhoods that we have a variety of housing types." The sixplexes would not be allowed in semi-detached houses or townhouses. A large group of Torontonians turned up to express their views at the committee meeting. Many said they were in favour of the changes, but some said the changes would be too much too fast. Last September, council decided to permit multiplex housing across the city. In February in Ward 23 as part of a pilot project, staff studied the potential of permitting low-rise multiplexes with up to six dwelling units and with heights of up to four storeys. As part of the sixplex item, the committee approved a recommendation on the height permissions of multiplex buildings. The committee will recommend to council that the city amend its zoning rules to increase the maximum height of buildings containing multiplexes from 10 metres to 10.5 metres. Such a move would allow an increase in basement ceiling heights "to improve liveability and access to daylight" for basement units that will be part of the fiveplexes and sixplexes, city staff said. "Expanding multiplex permissions will increase new low-rise housing options for Torontonians. New residents in low-rise neighbourhoods can help stabilize declining populations, optimize the use of existing infrastructure, and support local retail establishments and services," a report by the chief planner Jason Thorne says. Adopting the recommendations would mark a "significant milestone" in meeting Toronto's commitments under the federal Housing Accelerator Fund to allow more low-rise, multi-unit housing development through as-of-right zoning bylaws in its neighbourhoods, according to the report. As-of-right means developers do not need obtain individual zoning approvals in these areas. 'This is about housing equity and liveability' Residents came to the committee meeting with prepared statements. Blair Scorgie, a registered professional planner, urban designer and managing principal of Scourgie Planning, told the committee he supports the recommendations from city staff. "These reforms are a natural and necessary evolution of the city's existing multiplex framework," he said. The recommendations respond "to what residents, planners and housing providers across the city have all recognized — that our low-rise neighbourhoods must evolve if we are to remain equitable, liveable and resilient," he said. "This is about housing equity and liveability. Allowing up to six units in detached buildings will unlock ground-related homes for families, seniors, newcomers and multigenerational households — people who are too often excluded from neighbourhoods built around a single housing type." 'Sixplex in a sea of bungalows sticks out like a sore thumb' Natalie Pihura, a Toronto resident, told the committee that approving sixplexes is not a good idea because residents already have many issues with multiplexes, including parking, privacy, flooding, "neighbourhood fabric deterioration" and school enrolment problems. Residents of Martin Grove Gardens in Etobicoke have gathered 500 signatures on a petition opposed to multiplexes and sixplexes, which Pihura said she will resubmit the petition to council. "A sixplex in a sea of bungalows sticks out like a sore thumb," she said. "Using the as-of-right paintbrush rams the wants of developers who only care about making money over the actual residents who have already invested in their community," she continued. "Right sized housing in the right areas is the right decision." Carolyn Whitzman, a senior housing researcher at the University of Toronto's school of cities, said in an interview after the meeting that the changes being proposed to council are in step with the moves made by city councils across Ontario and Canada. "I think that it's becoming increasingly obvious to city councils across Canada, including Toronto, that there's no way that they are going to be able to meet their housing targets without making fairly radical changes to zoning," Whitzman said. Council will consider the sixplex item at its meeting that begins on June 25.
CBC
14 hours ago
- CBC
Hanlan's Beach is getting a bubble zone to keep away motorized boats and vehicles
Toronto police's marine unit will create a bubble zone around Hanlan's Beach as a pilot project this summer to improve safety for swimmers, kayakers and paddleboarders. The "motorized watercraft exclusion zone" will extend 200 metres off the shoreline of Hanlan's Beach, the marine unit said in a news release on Friday. The pilot project is being introduced with the help of the city and Ports Toronto, the marine unit added. All motorized vessels, including personal watercrafts such as Sea-Doos and Jet Skis, powerboats and sailboats, will be banned from entering the designated area. The marine unit says "clearly marked buoys" will be set out on Monday to make the boundaries of the zone clear and marine unit officers will patrol regularly to ensure there is compliance, using education, safety checks and enforcement when necessary. "The Toronto Police Service Marine Unit remains committed to the safety and security of our waterways and beaches," the marine unit said in the release. As well, a 400-metre "quiet zone" is in effect along Hanlan's Beach, which means boaters must keep music and amplified sound at reasonable levels, the marine unit said. "Sound travels further on water, and this measure is intended to preserve the enjoyment of all beach and water users," the marine unit said. According to the marine unit, the exclusion zone is supported by the Canada Marine Act and will be formally listed in the PortsToronto Rules and Procedures, Port Authority Regulations.
