Community divided following IGA supermarket owner posting video of 'shoplifting' kids on social media
A fed up Adelaide supermarket owner's decision to publish CCTV footage of a group of kids allegedly shoplifting from his store has sparked backlash.
IGA Elizabeth Downs, in the northern suburbs of the SA capital, shared the CCTV footage to its Facebook page on Friday - with some viewers praising the move but others claiming 'naming-and-shaming' children should be off-limits.
In the video, which has since been taken down, two kids could be seen stuffing shopping items down their pants while a third stood nearby holding a packet of noodles apparently as a distraction.
The footage shown on news broadcasts blurred the children's faces, but they were reportedly visible in the original post by the store's owner.
'Can parents of these kids teach them not to steal?' the store owners wrote in a caption alongside the video.
'Name-and-shame them.'
While many agreed with the owner's decision to post the footage on the basis it would discourage other offenders and teach the culprits a lesson, others argued the move could be seen as irresponsible.
South Australia's acting commissioner for children and young people Mimi Crowe told Seven News publicly calling out children was 'not only a breach of privacy, it's ineffective'.
Ms Crowe argued a different approach would be more effective in minimising the store's rate of theft.
'Children need support, not humiliation.'
It is not the first time the store has shared vision of alleged young offenders.
In June last year, it posted a CCTV screenshot of a group of kids alongside a caption which read: 'Gang of Shop Lifters. Parents [please] contact in at IGA Elizabeth Downs. Otherwise, we go to police with video recording.
'They all stole around $100 worth of groceries.'
The store alleged it was the third time the group of kids had done so.
Five months later, the store posted an image of two young boys whose faces were clearly identifiable and alleged they had attempted to steal before shattering a window during a confrontation with staff.
'They tried to steal from [the] store and when staff stopped them they kicked the glass. [Please] help us to find these two boys culprits.
'Reported to police for theft and property damage. Name them, shame them.'
Unlike the most recent CCTV footage, the two earlier posts remain visible online.
'You shouldn't be posting photos of children! You are not judge and jury!' one user wrote in response a post shared in June.
Then, as now, however, the majority of viewers defended the store's decision.
'I'd be taking their photos and enlarging them and putting them at the front of the store for everyone to see, name and shame,' a man said in response to the June incident.
In response to the October post, one woman said: 'I'm all for naming and shaming. These kids need to be humiliated.
'Let them feel ashamed and embarrassed by their actions.
'That's the problem these days. It's too soft. That's why they get away with it.'
IGA Elizabeth Downs and IGA Australia did not respond to Daily Mail Australia's request for comment.
It is understood no charges have been laid.
A South Australia Police spokesperson said they were not aware of the incident but urged anyone involved or who witnesses similar incidents to contact them.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
27 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Another agonising blow for family of Channel Nine sports reporter who was killed in a Thailand motorcycle crash
The family of former Channel Nine sports reporter Nicole Fitzsimons, who was killed in a crash more than a decade ago, has been left devastated again after her mother died in a traffic accident. Julie Fitzsimons, 65, was hit by a vehicle on Wednesday across from Wyoming Rib & Chop House in Sheridan, Wyoming. She was taken to Sheridan Memorial Hospital where she died from her injuries, The Sheridan Press reported. The driver who struck the Australian mother spoke to local police and an investigation is ongoing. It comes more than a decade after Nicole Fitzsimons, Julie's daughter, died in Thailand. The 24-year-old was riding a motorbike in October 2012 when a speeding rider on the wrong side of the road collided with her. The Fitzsimons family launched the Nicole Fitzsimons Foundation following her death to help raise awareness of travel safety and supporting passionate athletes. Following the tragic news about Julie, the family released a statement through the foundation's social media page. 'With broken hearts we share the devastating news that we lost our beautiful mum and the heartbeat of Nicole's Foundation,' it said on Instagram. 'She was the rock of our family, a joy to be around and adored by all who knew her. 'We are absolutely shattered and ask for space as we navigate the difficult process of bringing her back home.' The family said details of the celebration of her life would be released later. 'For now, we find some solace in knowing she's reunited with her beloved daughter, Nicole,' the statement said. 'The Fitzy family will never be the same, but we will rebuild once again in their honour - just like they would want us to.' In the wake of Nicole's death 12 years ago, her sister Kate quit a corporate job to dedicate her time to the foundation's work of raising awareness to how many Australians have died while travelling. 'I began researching how many other poor families had suffered what we've been through,' she said in 2016. 'And I soon realised far too many Aussies are compromising their safety in foreign countries.' Ms Gladdin (born Fitzsimons), who is an author, life coach and speaker and lives in Sheridan, took to Instagram to share a personal tribute to her mother. 'I am so broken, but through the depth of my love for you and Nicole, I will do my best to rebuild and live as fully as I can in honour of you both,' she said on Thursday. 'You truly were a rainbow to everyone who knew you, always brightening their day in anyway you could. 'I will forever love and miss you Mum. Please hug my sister for me so, so tight. My broken heart beats for you both now.'
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Fugitive accused of murdering dog walker 'planted her phone miles away to fool detectives' who arrested wrong man, court told
A 'cunning' fugitive convict battered a dog walker to death before tricking police into arresting an innocent man by leaving his victim's phone in a public place, a court heard today. Roy Barclay, 56, allegedly took the phone off mother-of-six Anita Rose, 57, along with her distinctive pink jacket, after he attacked her and left her for dead as she walked her dog early one morning. He later read a media report on his own phone saying how Ms Rose's missing mobile and jacket were 'key' to the police investigation, jurors heard. Prosecutor Chris Paxton KC told the jury how the report was 'a signal to Roy Barclay that he had to get rid of the phone'. The defendant, who had been living 'off-grid' for two years to avoid recall to prison for a previous offence, decided to dump it to 'set a false trail for the police, throwing them off his scent'. Barclay was filmed by a CCTV camera three days after the attack on Ms Rose as he walked towards 'a small seating area' in Ipswich town centre with a rucksack on his back and a carrier bag in his left hand, said Mr Paxton. He was seen crossing the road towards the seating area in Upper Orwell Street and then walking back 'after a short while' with images showing he no longer had the bag, Ipswich Crown Court hard. Several minutes later, a couple named in court as Mr Ichim and Miss Baiculescu entered the same seating area, while CCTV showed Barclay seeming to 'hang around walking up and down'. Mr Paxton told the jury: 'He was looking into the seating area. We say he is checking if someone has picked up Anita's phone and making sure his phone drop has been successful.' Mr Ichim and Miss Baiculescu were seen on CCTV emerging from the area a few minutes later and appeared to pass the phone 'from one to the other' as they walked away and turned it on. Mr Paxton said: 'The police were alerted to Anita's phone being switched on for the first time since the morning of the attack and, as soon as it was, numerous police officers flooded the area.' The 'unsuspecting' couple were found in the nearby iMobile phone and vape shop where they had paid for it to be factory reset as they were 'looking to sell it', he added. Mr Ichim was arrested on suspicion of the attempted murder of Ms Rose - who died in hospital the following day - and treated as a suspect before being released without charge. Mr Paxton described the dumping of the phone as an example of 'Barclay's cunning and his attempts to distort and throw the police off his track.' He told the jury: 'In some ways, it was clever as he must be to have evaded recall to prison for over two years.' Ms Rose died from her traumatic head injuries in Addenbrooke's Hospital, Cambridge, on July 28, four days after the attack. Barclay who has a white beard, thinning hair and glasses was wearing a grey tracksuit as he sat impassively in the glass-fronted dock flanked by three security guards. He denies the murder of Ms Rose. Jurors heard how he had been living rough in the countryside while he was 'unlawfully at large' and trying to evade police and authorities because he was wanted for recall to prison. The court was told how Ms Rose had left her home in Brantham shortly after 5am to walk her Springer Spaniel called Bruce as she usually did on a network of nearby footpaths. She was subjected to a 'vicious and brutal attack' with 'numerous, kicks, stamps and blows' to her face, head and body as she walked beside a sewage works in the village. Mr Paxton suggested that Barclay, who had a makeshift camp nearby, was drawn to the sewage works to use a toilet and wash basin on the site and might have been seen entering or leaving by Ms Rose. The fatal assault could have been because he feared she might report him or as a reaction to something she might have said, he added. Ms Rose was found unconscious with her dog's lead wrapped tightly around her leg at around 6.25am by Jerome Tassel who had been cycling to Manningtree railway station. Mr Paxton suggested that Barclay was a dog lover who often carried around dog biscuits and might have tied the lead around her to avoid her pet running away. The court has heard that Ms Rose's pink jacket was eventually found in Barclay's nearby camp with his semen around the neckline, suggesting he had kept it as a 'trophy' Mr Paxton said that a pair of walking boots 'which amounted to a murder weapon' were also found at the camp. A forensic scientist found 'support for the conclusion' that the marks on Ms Rose's face were made by the boots which Barclay had earlier bought from Amazon and had delivered to a locker near a Premier Inn in Ipswich, he added. Her Samsung earbuds, carrying DNA from her and Barclay, were found in box with his possessions in a second hideaway the defendant allegedly used near the Orwell Bridge in Ipswich. Jurors have heard that a CCTV camera on a house filmed Barclay near the scene on July 21 and at 5.33am on the morning of July 24, less than an hour before Ms Rose was found seriously injured. He has denied being the man on the CCTV but a facial recognition expert had concluded that it was him, Mr Paxton said. A blue sweatshirt matching the one worn by the man in the images was also found at Barclay's camp. The prosecution has also claimed internet searches by Barclay showed his interest in the sewage works at Brantham. He also made a search three days after the attack on Ms Rose, asking 'How long does DNA last at a crime scene?'. The following day he asked in a search: 'How are outside objects swabbed for DNA?', and 'Can barbed wire be swabbed for DNA?'. Mr Paxton said the searches were 'important 'as Ms Rose was found just feet away from the barbed wire fence at the sewage works which had been cut. Barclay also made further internet searches about the attack in the months after her death so he could 'follow the twists and turns of the police investigation on media websites', he said. The court heard today that he had made more searches to find out how long DNA remained in samples of faeces, suggesting that he might have used the toilet in the sewage works and was worried about having left evidence there. Other searches done by him related to other local killers including the case of a dog walker murdered in Norfolk. The trial continues.
Times
2 hours ago
- Times
Castle Combe villagers swarmed by tourists' drone cameras
When you live in 'the prettiest village in England' you expect to share it with tourists clogging the streets. What you do not expect is one of their drones to film you taking a bath. The residents of Castle Combe, a village in the Cotswolds, have had to place 'no drone zone' signs in their windows, the local church and public car park after being repeatedly buzzed by camera-wielding aircraft flying over their gardens, streets and in one instance by their bathroom window. Police were called last month when one drone pilot refused to land his aircraft after filming children playing in a back garden and flying laps up and down the high street at first-floor window level. After verbally abusing residents who asked him to respect their privacy, police officers were called and forced him to delete his video. Hilary Baker, 69, a retired police officer who has lived in the village for 35 years, said: 'It's almost like some of the visitors have lost their moral compass, they have lost their boundaries.' She added that since the Covid-19 pandemic there had been an increase of drones flown over the Wiltshire village by tourists for their social media channels. 'When you go into your back garden and put your washing out and there is a drone hovering 20 yards above your head, it really quite rankles,' she said. 'Another neighbour had been working in his garden and jumped in the bath and there was a drone at his bathroom window, watching him in the bath. You just think, really? 'I should think on a monthly basis I will get verbal abuse [for asking them to stop].' Even before the drones appeared, tourists have been overstepping boundaries in the village for years. There are handwritten signs asking visitors not to pick flowers planted outside homes and not to walk down the side alleys of houses. 'Gateways can be locked but people still climb over them and picnic on the private lawns by the river,' Baker said. 'Most people are lovely but they have got to get 'the picture'.' Castle Combe has been a tourist destination since the 19th century. People have been drawn to the historic centre of the village where a new house has not been built since about 1600. It has also been the setting for films such as Doctor Dolittle, released in 1967, and Steven Spielberg's War Horse in 2011. A major pull for the thousands of tourists who visit each week are the videos of the village they see on social media sites such as Instagram, YouTube and TikTok. ALAMY Lydia Chia, 27, and her sister Deborah, 24, from Singapore, were visiting this week, posing for a plethora of photos against the small honey-coloured stone houses as well as on the bridge over the tranquil brook. 'I saw it on my friend's Instagram and a little bit on TikTok,' Lydia, a customer success manager, said. 'It's really pretty. I pick where to visit based on pictures and aesthetics, and whether or not it's instagrammable.' Her sister, who is studying marketing at the University of Stirling, said the village was 'relatively less crowded than London city centre' and 'more chilled'. Fred Winup, a retired bank director who has been the chairman of the parish council for 18 years, conducted a visitor survey last year which found that 51 per cent of visitors came after seeing the village online. Winup once had a drone follow him along the high street 'just five feet above my head', he said, adding: 'It was a Californian [piloting it], he was a nice guy who didn't know the rules and said he was sorry.' The parish council has persuaded Wiltshire council to erect a sign at the public car park, built 730 metres up steep and narrow roads from the centre, warning drone pilots: 'If you use these devices where people can expect privacy, such as inside their home or garden, you are likely to be contravening CAA [Civil Aviation Authority] guidelines'. ADRIAN SHERRATT FOR THE TIMES The rules and guidelines around flying different types of drones can be complicated but usually involve having a line of sight of the drone, not getting close to crowds or buildings, and respecting people's privacy. 'People do lose control of drones and they could take an eye out,' Winup said. Some drone operators have crashed their devices onto the church roof and one ended up stuck in a tree in a resident's back garden. Mike, a renewable energy consultant who moved to the village 20 years ago from Clapham, London, said his daughters would sunbathe in bikinis in the back garden and that it was a 'gross invasion of privacy' when a drone flew over his garden several times at close range. 'I have said to people, 'Go and perv somewhere else',' he said. 'The back gardens are our little havens of privacy.' There are only 39 full-time residents living in lower Castle Combe, where the tourists congregate, whereas 20 years ago, residents said, the houses were almost all occupied by people who had lived there for decades. ADRIAN SHERRATT FOR THE TIMES Some have been bought up by Americans and Australians, whom few locals have seen in the decades since they turned the properties into holiday rentals. Others are second homes for Britons. Anna, a local business owner, said: 'If I didn't have a business here I would be seriously pissed off. It's lost its community and I think one day we will get fed up with it.'
