Michael Vaughan claims England would be ‘selfish' to give Ben Stokes white-ball captaincy
Michael Vaughan believes it would be 'selfish' to hand Ben Stokes England's ODI captaincy, with reports suggesting he and Harry Brook could be offered a white-ball job split.
Brook recently served as deputy to Jos Buttler before the latter stood down and looks increasingly likely to take the reins of the T20 side.
The Yorkshireman is also a candidate for the 50-over job but it is almost impossible to play a leading role in all three England teams given the demands of the schedule.
Enter Stokes, who has proved a natural skipper in the Test arena and was publicly mooted as a cross-format option by Rob Key, the director of men's cricket.
While there is an obvious temptation to extend his partnership with Brendon McCullum in the limited-overs arena, where England have struggled badly since their heyday under Eoin Morgan, he is currently recovering from his second hamstring tear in the space of six months.
He retired from ODI cricket in 2022 to manage his workload and prioritise the Test team, later agreeing to return for the 2023 World Cup.
Vaughan has no doubt the 33-year-old would answer the call again but thinks it would be an irresponsible move.
Speaking at the MCC's Cowdrey Lecture at Lord's, he said: 'In a way, I think it's quite selfish to even consider him. He will say yes because he is Ben Stokes. He will do whatever England ask him to do. Just don't ask him and let him be.
'He gives absolutely everything, not just when he's playing for England but when he's training. He is all or nothing. It's an absolute nonsense to think that Ben Stokes is going to play white-ball cricket.'
England's first game of the summer is a one-off Test against Zimbabwe from 22-25 May, with their white-ball campaign beginning four days later against the West Indies.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
39 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Thomas Tuchel is right to ignore tedious talk of burn-out by calling up Chelsea stars for latest England squad, writes DANNY MURPHY
Five Chelsea players are in Thomas Tuchel 's England squad, squeezing in games against Andorra and Senegal between winning a European final and competing at the Club World Cup. They will resume the Premier League in mid-August and go again for 11 months, culminating in the real World Cup. Given the schedule, it's been suggested Tuchel should have allowed Reece James, Cole Palmer, Levi Colwill, Noni Madueke and Trevor Chalobah to spend time with their families rather than calling them up. I'm firmly on the England manager's side. His responsibility is to win the World Cup, not protect clubs about to play in an additional tournament in America for greed. Physically, England's double-header won't demand a lot of intensity from the players and it's a rare chance to spend a full week together in the Spanish sunshine and benefit the squad in terms of camaraderie. Having the Chelsea boys involved is a help, not a hindrance, to our chances of glory next year. They will get a chance to disengage mentally after the Club World Cup and I think the other arguments regarding player welfare and too many games are overblown. I find the argument about player burn-out a bit tedious, and I speak as someone who experienced the demands of competing at a high level. With the size and strength of squads these days, very few players are used in every minute of every match. Palmer, for example, sat out Chelsea's group fixtures in Europe and the Conference League final was only his 48th game of the season for club and country — not excessive or likely to cause fatigue. There has never been a better time to be a footballer. With the facilities and sport science available to them, no stone is left unturned when looking after them physically and mentally. Tuchel doesn't have any obligation to alter his plans to accommodate the Club World Cup, a contrived competition which is more exciting to those clubs raking in prize-money than the players themselves. For Palmer and the other Chelsea lads, having spent a week in Barcelona, going to the Spanish Grand Prix and enjoying a barbecue before a game against Andorra won't be draining or detrimental to next season. If any of them do start to feel sorry for themselves, they should look at Mo Salah and Lionel Messi as two examples of top professionals who are always available and able to maintain exceptional standards. And if Chelsea are concerned about some of their players next season, they can give them time off at the start of the Premier League, as Pep Guardiola has done for Manchester City. What would have been unfair is Tuchel making concessions and not picking his strongest squad. The manager has very limited time with his players and this has been an important week for Team England, off the pitch as much as on it as manager and team-mates get to know each other properly. He has shown a single-mindedness I think augurs well for the World Cup.
Powys County Times
an hour ago
- Powys County Times
Michael O'Neill takes positives from Northern Ireland's narrow defeat to Denmark
Michael O'Neill saw plenty of positives to take from Northern Ireland's 2-1 friendly defeat to Denmark as he kept his sights firmly on the World Cup qualifying campaign that starts in September. Christian Eriksen's second-half strike completed a come-from-behind win for the Danes as Northern Ireland suffered a second straight defeat after March's 5-1 loss to Sweden. But Saturday's match was not about the result for O'Neill, who wanted to give his young squad another tough test away to top-level opposition with a trip to Germany looming after they open their qualifying campaign in Luxembourg. From that point of view there was plenty for Northern Ireland to be happy with. After taking the lead through Pierre-Emile Hojbjerg's early own goal, O'Neill's men did not allow Denmark a shot on target until Gustav Isaksen's fine strike in first-half stoppage time. Thank you for your support here in Denmark and back at home 👏🏻💚🤍 #GAWA — Northern Ireland (@NorthernIreland) June 7, 2025 However, Northern Ireland did not do enough going the other way, and ended the match not registering a shot on target themselves. 'I thought it was a game that wasn't really played like a friendly game,' O'Neill said. 'I thought it had a little bit of an edge to it, which was good. 'We couldn't have got off to a better start. I thought we started the game very well and obviously we get ahead. I thought we thought we defended really well in the first half, we knew we'd have to defend our box well. 'It was a bit of individual brilliance from Isaksen that gives them the equaliser before half-time so half-time has a little bit of a different feel… What a start for Northern Ireland! ⚽ Shea Charles arrives at the back post to head into the net 🎯 #BBCFootball — BBC SPORT NI (@BBCSPORTNI) June 7, 2025 'We lost the second goal but then I thought we really dug in.' Denmark, ranked 50 places above Northern Ireland, had a huge edge in quality and experience and that was what eventually told. But O'Neill recognises there is still more they can do to make themselves competitive. 'We were never going to be a dominant possession-based team against any of these teams,' O'Neill added. 'We're asking players who play their football at League One or Championship level to go out against players from the top five leagues in Europe. 'The way we have to try to close that gap is to be what we are, a team that's well-organised, well-structured, difficult to beat, that comes to frustrate the opposition, but obviously to carry a threat as well. The best no matter the result 👏🏻🟢⚪️ #GAWA — Northern Ireland (@NorthernIreland) June 7, 2025 'There's no shame in coming here and losing the game 2-1, not at all. But in terms of where we need to get to as a team, we need to be able to retain the ball a little bit better, maybe find a little bit more in terms of level of possession and that will help us carry a bigger threat.' The scoreline would have finished more strongly in Denmark's favour were it not for a number of saves made by 19-year-old goalkeeper Pierce Charles, who came on at half-time in place of Conor Hazard who was hurt in a first-half collision with Rasmus Hojlund. 'It's not an easy situation for young Pierce coming in and playing but I thought he dealt with it well,' O'Neill said. 'He's a very good young goalkeeper. You're defending your box at that point in time but the game gets a bit stretched, we're physically tired in the game. But it's important you keep the game at 2-1 because that's how you may get an opportunity.'
Scottish Sun
an hour ago
- Scottish Sun
Newcastle ready to rescue Jack Grealish from Man City hell but will only consider loan transfer for £300k-a-week star
All recommendations within this article are informed by expert editorial opinion. If you click on a link in this story we may earn affiliate revenue. Grealish appeared to take dig at Guardiola with social media post GREAL GOOD CHANCE Newcastle ready to rescue Jack Grealish from Man City hell but will only consider loan transfer for £300k-a-week star Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) NEWCASTLE will try to rescue Jack Grealish from his Manchester City hell - but only on loan. The Toon are keen on Grealish, 29, who is on his way out of the Etihad. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 7 Jack Grealish is a loan target for Newcastle after being snubbed by Man City Credit: Getty 7 Pep Guardiola snubbed Grealish in the FA Cup final to give Claudio Echeverri his debut Credit: Reuters The £100million man was snubbed when City named their Fifa Club World Cup squad. Magpies boss Eddie Howe will turn his interest into an approach if City look at sending Grealish and his £300,000-a-week wages elsewhere for the season. And that will become even more of a Newcastle priority if offers come in for Anthony Gordon over the summer. Grealish will have a few clubs after him. READ MORE ON JACK GREALISH Pep's the word Grealish told his Man City career is OVER and he can go for cut-price fee WATCH EVERY MATCH OF THE CLUB WORLD CUP 2025 LIVE ON DAZN But it is unlikely that any will pay a fee and take on his monster salary. Even a straight loan is a challenge for most. So City may have to sponsor a deal and pay part of his wage for a year. As previously reported by SunSport, the Citizens face taking a £60m hit on their record transfer. CASINO SPECIAL - BEST CASINO BONUSES FROM £10 DEPOSITS Grealish - who managed just one Prem goal and one assist in 2024-25 - has been told there is no way back for him under Pep Guardiola. And the playmaker appeared to take a swipe at his boss on social. Jack Grealish chokes back tears in heartbreaking interview as Man City ace pays tribute to brother who died 25 years ago He responded to comments from ex-Aston Villa team-mate Gabriel Agbonlahor regarding the gaffer's decision to give Claudio Echeverri his City debut in the FA Cup final - and leave Grealish on the bench. Agbonhalor said: "I think towards the end of the season, it felt to me like it got a bit personal. "Bringing on a young kid for his debut in an FA Cup final when you're chasing a goal, when you've got someone who's had the career Jack's had just seemed a bit odd. "That seemed a bit personal to me, like a last little dig to get you out, to upset you, to (make) you want to move. But we've seen this before from Pep. 7 7 TRANSFER NEWS LIVE: ALL THE LATEST FROM THE SUMMER WINDOW "Pep can be ruthless at times. If he feels that you're not part of his future plans, he will get rid of you." When talkSPORT posted the clip to Instagram, Grealish commented, appearing to point to how many sub appearances he's made: "What u want me to do score a hatty in 20?" Kevin De Bruyne suffered a similar fate by being pushed out by the Spanish manager - with Kyle Walker and John Stones likely to follow suit. AC Milan playmaker Tijjani Reijnders is on his way for £46.2m and City are understood to have agreed a £30m deal for Lyon ace Rayan Cherki. Rayan Ait-Nouri's £34m move from Wolves should also be finalised in time for him to fly out with City next week. 7 Grealish responded to comments on social media Credit: Instagram @talksport 7 Eddie Howe is preparing in case Anthony Gordon leaves Credit: Getty
