Ukraine should get limited EU membership, former Commission chief Juncker says
Ukraine is not ready for full-fledged membership in the European Union, and instead should be offered a limited one, says former European Commission President Jean Claude Juncker.
In an interview with Euronews, Juncker cautioned that the EU needs to be 'very careful' about admitting new members.
Corruption, a weak economy and a lack of state structure make Ukraine inadmissible for membership for now, said Juncker.
He advised Brussels to offer a second-tier membership which would include access to the single market, a voice on crucial debates, but no vote at the table.
Juncker said he accepted Kyiv was making progress on tackling corruption and "de-oligarchisation" but says he'd be more in favour of a 'membership which would not be a total membership.'
Ukraine could have access to the EU but not have a vote at the European Council, where all 27 member states debate and vote on crucial matters affecting the bloc, he added.
"No vote in the Council, but participation in European debates on issues of interest and concern for Ukraine," Juncker told Euronews.
"We don't want to give them the impression they are far away from membership but show they are on the way to membership without having all the rights and all the possibilities of real membership," he said.
Juncker, who presided over the EU's top executive body from 2014 to 2019, said he regretted how the Commission dealt with problematic member states such as Hungary and Slovakia, who were often criticised for breaching EU laws.
"This was a failure, both by those countries and by the European Union," he said.
"We treated the situation with benign neglect. You have to be very strict, as recent experiences have shown, when it comes to the respect of rule of law. It's of the essence of European unification and integration," Juncker concluded.
The EU leaders have backed Ukraine's membership bid as recently as Monday, with European Council President Antonio Costa saying that Ukraine's accession to the block would be the most important security guarantee for the future of the country.
Ukraine formally applied to join the EU on 28 February 2022 — mere days after Russia launched its full-scale invasion, now in its fourth year — and is hoping to join by 2030.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
LeMonde
an hour ago
- LeMonde
In Greenland, Macron criticizes Trump's annexation threats: 'That's not what allies do'
French President Emmanuel Macron on Sunday, June 15, criticized US President Donald Trump's threats to annex Greenland, as he made a visit to the Danish autonomous territory. "That's not what allies do," Macron said as he arrived in Nuuk, Greenland's capital. Macron is the first foreign head of state to visit the vast territory, located at the crossroads of the Atlantic and the Arctic, since Trump's annexation threats. Trump, since returning to the White House in January, has repeatedly said America needs the strategically located, resource-rich island for security reasons, and has refused to rule out the use of force to secure it. Denmark has also repeatedly stressed that Greenland "is not for sale." Macron said his visit was aimed at conveying "France's and the European Union's solidarity" for "the sovereignty and territorial integrity" of Greenland. Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen, Greenlandic Prime Minister Jens-Frederik Nielsen, and dozens of Greenlanders waving their territory's red-and-white flags, were on hand to greet the French president. Macron kicked off his six-hour visit with talks on board a Danish frigate with Frederiksen and Nielsen. He was to later visit a glacier to see firsthand the effects of global warming. A visit to a hydroelectric plant was initially scheduled but was canceled at the last minute. Macron's trip to Greenland was "a signal in itself, made at the request of Danish and Greenlandic authorities," his office said ahead of the trip. 'Not for sale' The Danish invitation to Macron contrasts sharply with the reception granted to US Vice President JD Vance, whose one-day trip to Greenland in March was seen as a provocation by both Nuuk and Copenhagen. During his visit to the US Pituffik military base, Vance castigated Denmark for not having "done a good job by the people of Greenland," alleging they had neglected security. The Pituffik base is an essential part of Washington's missile defense infrastructure, its location putting it on the shortest route for missiles fired from Russia at the United States. Polls indicate that the vast majority of Greenland's 57,000 inhabitants want to become independent from Denmark – but do not wish to become part of the United States. Unlike Denmark, Greenland is not part of the European Union but is on the list of Overseas Territories associated with the bloc. The Arctic has gained geostrategic importance as the race for rare earths heats up and as melting ice caused by global warming opens up new shipping routes. Copenhagen in January announced a $2 billion plan to boost its military presence in the Arctic region. NATO also plans to set up a Combined Air Operations Centre (CAOC) in Norway above the Arctic Circle, as Russia aims to bolster its military presence in the region. Arctic security During his visit, Macron plans to discuss Arctic security and how to include the territory in "European action" to contribute to its development, while "respecting its sovereignty," his office said. Macron scheduled glacier visit was to Mount Nunatarsuaq, about 30 kilometers from Nuuk, to see firsthand the effects of global warming on the frontlines in the Arctic. The Arctic is warming four times faster than the rest of the planet, according to a 2022 study in the scientific journal Nature, and Greenland's ice sheet melted 17 times faster than the historical average during a May 15-21 heatwave, a recent report showed. France intends to "massively reinvest in the knowledge of these ecosystems," following in the footsteps of famed French explorer Paul-Emile Victor who carried out multiple expeditions to Greenland, Macron's office said. Greenlandic authorities recently designated Victor's hut, built in 1950 in Quervain Bay in the north, as a historic structure.
France 24
an hour ago
- France 24
Israel's strikes on Iran were years in the making: analysts
Israel said it hit hundreds of targets on Friday alone, and has since continued its attacks, striking a defence facility and fuel depots on Sunday. The fiercest-ever exchange of fire between the arch foes came in the midst of ongoing talks between Tehran and Washington seeking to reach a deal on Iran's nuclear programme. "Israel has been following the nuclear programme for 15 years," Israeli analyst Michael Horowitz told AFP. "The strikes we see are the result of years of intelligence gathering and infiltration of the Islamic republic." Israel has previously carried out more limited attacks against Iranian military sites, including in October last year. "It seems that this week's operation had been in preparation for months, with an acceleration after the operation last year significantly weakened Iranian air defences," Horowitz said. The United States and other Western countries, along with Israel, accuse Iran of seeking a nuclear weapon. Tehran denies that, but has gradually broken away from its commitments under a 2015 nuclear deal it struck with world powers, which the United States withdrew from during President Donald Trump's first term. The landmark accord had provided Iran sanctions relief in exchange for curbs on its atomic programme. 'Impressive' precision Israel is long believed to have carried out sabotage operations inside Iran through its Mossad espionage agency, but the attacks that started on Friday are by far the broadest in scope. The campaign has shown Israel to be capable of precisely locating and taking out high-ranking Iranian officials and nuclear scientists. A European security source said the strikes showed "an impressive degree of precision and mastery". Israel says it has killed 20 military and security targets, including the armed forces' chief of staff and the head of Iran's Revolutionary Guards, as well as nine nuclear scientists. Danny Citrinowicz, of the Tel Aviv-based Institute for National Security Studies, said the ability to take out high-ranking officials showed "intelligence, but also operational superiority of Israel over Iran". "It's highly connected to the ability to collect information, intelligence in Iran for years, excellent intelligence that actually allows you to detect where they're living, the seniors, also the nuclear scientists," he told AFP. The latest targeted strikes come after Israel killed Ismail Haniyeh, the political leader of the Palestinian militant group Hamas, in a Tehran guesthouse in July last year. Haniyeh had been in town for the inauguration of Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian, and was reportedly killed by an explosive device that Israeli operatives had placed in the guesthouse weeks before. Analysts at the time saw the attack as a major intelligence failure by Iran. But "still Iran didn't learn and didn't have the ability to lock the holes in their system", said Citrinowicz. Smuggled drones News site Axios reported that Mossad agents inside Iran helped prepare Friday's strikes, pre-positioning weapon systems near air defence targets, including by hiding them inside vehicles, and launching them when the attack started. An Israeli intelligence official told Axios that Mossad had "established an attack drone base inside Iran with drones that were smuggled in long before the operation". A former Israeli intelligence official told The Atlantic that "Iranians opposed to the regime make for a ready recruiting pool", and that "Iranians working for Israel were involved in efforts to build a drone base inside the country". Alain Chouet, the former number three in the French intelligence, said he was convinced Israel had "half a dozen cells capable of acting at any moment" inside Iran. Iran regularly executes people it accuses of spying for Israel. It is unclear what role, if any, Israel's key military and diplomatic ally the United States had in the latest strikes. Before the attack early on Friday, Trump publicly urged Israel to allow time for diplomacy, as a sixth round of US-Iranian nuclear talks were set to be held in Oman at the weekend. The US president on Sunday said Washington "had nothing to do" with ally Israel's campaign. But Iran's Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi on Sunday said Tehran had "solid proof of the support of the American forces and American bases in the region" for the attacks. And Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said on Saturday his country was acting with "the clear support of the president of the United States".
France 24
an hour ago
- France 24
Macron, on Greenland visit, berates Trump for threats against the territory
"That's not what allies do," Macron said as he arrived in Nuuk, Greenland's capital. Macron is the first foreign head of state to visit the vast territory -- located at the crossroads of the Atlantic and the Arctic -- since Trump's annexation threats. Trump, since returning to the White House in January, has repeatedly said America needs the strategically located, resource-rich island for security reasons, and has refused to rule out the use of force to secure it. Denmark has also repeatedly stressed that Greenland "is not for sale." Macron said his visit was aimed at conveying "France's and the European Union's solidarity" for "the sovereignty and territorial integrity" of Greenland. Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen, Greenlandic Prime Minister Jens-Frederik Nielsen, and dozens of Greenlanders waving their territory's red-and-white flags, were on hand to greet the French president. Macron kicked off his six-hour visit with talks on board a Danish frigate with Frederiksen and Nielsen. He was to later visit a glacier to see firsthand the effects of global warming. A visit to a hydroelectric plant was initially scheduled but was cancelled at the last minute. Macron's trip to Greenland was "a signal in itself, made at the request of Danish and Greenlandic authorities", his office said ahead of the trip. 'Not for sale' The Danish invitation to Macron contrasts sharply with the reception granted to US Vice President JD Vance, whose one-day trip to Greenland in March was seen as a provocation by both Nuuk and Copenhagen. During his visit to the US Pituffik military base, Vance castigated Denmark for not having "done a good job by the people of Greenland", alleging they had neglected security. The Pituffik base is an essential part of Washington's missile defence infrastructure, its location putting it on the shortest route for missiles fired from Russia at the United States. Polls indicate that the vast majority of Greenland's 57,000 inhabitants want to become independent from Denmark -- but do not wish to become part of the United States. Unlike Denmark, Greenland is not part of the European Union but is on the list of Overseas Territories associated with the bloc. The Arctic has gained geostrategic importance as the race for rare earths heats up and as melting ice caused by global warming opens up new shipping routes. Copenhagen in January announced a $2 billion plan to boost its military presence in the Arctic region. NATO also plans to set up a Combined Air Operations Centre (CAOC) in Norway above the Arctic Circle, as Russia aims to bolster its military presence in the region. During his visit, Macron plans to discuss Arctic security and how to include the territory in "European action" to contribute to its development, while "respecting its sovereignty", his office said. Mount Nunatarsuaq Macron scheduled glacier visit was to Mount Nunatarsuaq, about 30 kilometres (19 miles) from Nuuk, to see firsthand the effects of global warming on the frontlines in the Arctic. The Arctic is warming four times faster than the rest of the planet, according to a 2022 study in scientific journal Nature, and Greenland's ice sheet melted 17 times faster than the historical average during a May 15-21 heatwave, a recent report showed. France intends to "massively reinvest in the knowledge of these ecosystems," following in the footsteps of famed French explorer Paul-Emile Victor who carried out multiple expeditions to Greenland, Macron's office said.
