Appeals court grants Anwar temporary stay in Yusoff Rawther suit
PUTRAJAYA: The Court of Appeal has allowed an application by Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim to temporarily stay the hearing of a lawsuit filed by his former research assistant Muhammed Yusoff Rawther over allegations of sexual harassment.
In a unanimous decision, a three-judge panel chaired by Justice Supang Lian said Tuesday (June 10) the appellate court was empowered under Section 44 of the Courts of Judicature Act 1964 to make an ad interim order to preserve the integrity of Anwar's stay application pending the disposal of his appeal against the High Court's decision that dismissed his application to refer eight legal questions to the Federal Court.
"Accordingly, we hereby make an ad interim order to stay all proceedings, including the full trial at the High Court," Justice Supang said in online proceedings.
ALSO READ: High Court denies Anwar's request to refer questions to Federal Court
The hearing of the main lawsuit by Yusoff was initially fixed to begin on Monday (June 16).
Other judges on the bench were Justices Faizah Jamaludin and Ahmad Fairuz Zainol Abidin.
Earlier, the panel heard from Anwar's counsel, Alan Wong, that if the full trial proceeds, the effects would be "irreversible".
"The constitutional issues raised (in the application) would have been overtaken by events," he said.
Wong submitted that, as the appellant was a sitting prime minister, he would be required to divert his attention and resources from government business to attend to the trial, disrupting his official function.
"To assist the court in appreciating the scale of this disruption, I have instructions to tender a copy of the Prime Minister's schedule during the trial period," he said, requesting that the document be received under seal.
ALSO READ: Anwar files appeal against High Court's dismissal of bid to refer immunity questions to apex court
Lawyer Muhammad Rafique Rashid Ali, who represented Yusoff, objected on the grounds that any introduction of a material should have been done in an affidavit form.
Rafique also submitted that the trial dates were fixed a year ago on June 6 and this meant the appellant had "very well known" he was due in court.
"The trial is supposed to commence next week. He (Anwar) has had more than enough time to prepare for this trial, knowing fully well that everyone has to submit to the court system," he said.
Rafique also submitted that the court should consider whether or not the appeal has any chance or prospect of success.
"Simply put, the appeal is doomed to fail. There are no special circumstances (to warrant the stay)," he said, adding that the trial must proceed.
On the application to insert the Prime Minister's schedule, the panel said it took judicial notice of the matter.
ALSO READ: Anwar: It was never about immunity
"We take judicial notice that the Prime Minister is busy and has a full schedule on any day. Therefore, there is no necessity to tender the schedule as proposed," Justice Supang said.
Anwar is applying for a stay of the main trial in the lawsuit pending his appeal against the High Court's decision that rejected his application to refer eight legal questions to the Federal Court, including whether he is immune from lawsuits.
The questions include whether, under Articles 39, 40 and 43 of the Federal Constitution, a sitting prime minister enjoys limited immunity from lawsuits involving allegations of personal conduct that occurred before his appointment.
The application by Anwar was concerning a sexual harassment lawsuit filed by Yusoff, who claimed sexual assault in 2018.
On June 4, High Court judge Justice Roz Mawar Rozain dismissed Anwar's application on the grounds that the questions failed to meet the threshold for referral under the Federal Constitution and the Courts of Judicature Act.
On July 14, 2021, Yusoff filed the lawsuit against Anwar, who contended in his defence that the plaintiff had lied under oath to authorities regarding the alleged assault.
Anwar then filed a counterclaim on Sept 28, 2021, alleging that Yusoff had fabricated the story to tarnish his political career and prevent him from becoming prime minister.
The hearing for a full stay application has been fixed for July 21.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Malaysiakini
3 hours ago
- Malaysiakini
MPs have the right to criticise their own party
YOURSAY | 'PKR is on the path towards self-destruction under Anwar.' Quit if you're no longer aligned with party, Subang PKR tells MP EmEmKay: In the realm of politics, the pressures can be overwhelming. As representatives, politicians often bear the weight of their constituents' hopes and frustrations. A holiday, especially one designated for thoughtful reflection, is not only deserved but necessary. Subang MP Wong Chen's time away offers him the chance to recharge mentally and emotionally while considering the direction of his political career amid continuous demands and expectations. He has not shied away from discussing the realities facing the Pakatan Harapan coalition and the government. He has rightly pointed out that many reforms promised by PKR remain unfulfilled, and as we reach the halfway mark of the federal government's mandate, it is crucial to assess what has been accomplished and what lies ahead. His statements underscore the need for accountability - not only for party supporters but for the Malaysian people who desire tangible improvements in governance. The acknowledgement of the gap between promises and performance highlights Wong's commitment to genuine progress. By speaking truthfully about the shortcomings of his party, he aims to spur necessary conversations that could ultimately lead to constructive change. Some within the PKR grassroots might feel frustrated with him for his candidness, but it is essential to realise that speaking the truth is not a fault but rather a responsibility. Open dialogue about the challenges faced by the party cultivates an environment where constructive criticism can flourish. Wong's reflection on these issues is rooted in his desire for the party to succeed and fulfil its commitments to the people. PKR activists and supporters should understand that his honesty aims to strengthen the party and not undermine it. His insight into the current state of PKR and the Madani government should be recognised as a courageous step toward fostering accountability and progress. As he reflects on his political future, one can hope that his experience abroad will empower him with a renewed focus on how best to serve the people of Subang and contribute to Malaysia's political landscape. Meerkat: Wong is still aligned with the original PKR aspirations. If he's now deemed as not aligned with the party, it's only because the party has shifted. The party should do a lot of soul-searching and get back on track. Otherwise, it will lose the support of many. Sure, they won't vote for Harapan, but they are not obliged to vote for Subang PKR deputy chief Dr Wan Hasifi Amin Wan Zaidon either. PurpleJaguar0553: Why should Wong quit? He was elected by the people based on PKR's promise of reforms. If PKR president Anwar Ibrahim is unable to or fails to fulfil this promise, then the MPs are entitled to demand an answer and question him on his failure. These unelected PKR divisional leaders should understand that MPs owe a duty to the public, not the party. When the party fails to live up to its promises to the public, they have every right and a duty to raise this. Anwar's minions seem to be working overtime to shut down all dissent within PKR. The effort is bound to fail. The non-Malays already realise PKR's failure and that this party is a family dynasty. The non-Malay vote is going south, and Harapan will fall in the 16th general election unless promises are fulfilled. GP2025: Country undergoing a reform process? What a laugh! What reforms can it boast about? This is enabling unqualified people without the support of the majority to seize power. Is that acceptable to reformists? What a joke. Anyway, I'm in your constituency, Wan Hasifi. You won't get my vote, but Wong might. BluePanther4725: Why can't a PKR MP criticise his own party? Seems like PKR only wants Pak Turuts (yes men). PKR has lost all its vision for 'reformasi' and does not practise democracy. PKR is rapidly morphing into Umno. PKR is getting rid of those who dare to speak out, like former deputy president Rafizi Ramli, former vice president Nik Nazmi Nik Ahmad, and now Wong Chen. PKR is on the path towards self-destruction under Anwar. RedMarlin1833: PKR was always the 'weakling' in a few coalitions it was in before. Not much grassroots support, and now it is going to face a huge backlash in the next general election! The infighting continues, and now another one in the party will probably give up his post. Good luck! Pink: Endless fight for positions in PKR. I heard that Anwar would spend more time with the party to meet and consolidate the grassroots. This does not seem to be happening. This is what happens when the mission for reforms is no longer firmly upheld by the members. Nothing in common to hold them together. Every man fights for himself to grab the war loot. The process of attrition has started in the party. Gasinggeorge: You could easily defend his points, but the truth is that he came out criticising his party while at the same time announcing planned reflections on his career at an expensive foreign retreat. This is weird, to say the least. OrangeJaguar9341: Rejecting hard truths and then maligning the person who expressed them is immature and pathetic. Those in PKR who want to continue to live in a fantasy Madani-ville should not be so threatened by those who are more evaluative and realistic. The above is a selection of comments posted by Malaysiakini subscribers. Only paying subscribers can post comments. In the past year, Malaysiakinians have posted over 100,000 comments. Join the Malaysiakini community and help set the news agenda. Subscribe now. These comments are compiled to reflect the views of Malaysiakini subscribers on matters of public interest. Malaysiakini does not intend to represent these views as fact.
The Star
5 hours ago
- The Star
Asean News Headlines at 10pm on Tuesday (June 10, 2025)
Malaysia * Mandatory heavy vehicle speed limiter policy being drafted * Remand order for UPSI bus driver pending hospital discharge * Gerik bus crash: Driver wouldn't slow down despite our pleas, student claims * Gerik bus crash: Injured UPSI students in stable condition * Another bus crash carrying uni students, luckily no one is hurt * Appeals court grants Anwar temporary stay in Yusoff Rawther suit * Tougher action on road accident accountability needed, says Azalina * East-West Highway safety concerns to be addressed, says Loke * Solar-powered streetlights to be installed on East-West Highway * Gerik bus crash: 'I'm sorry, the brakes stopped working' says driver * Gerik bus crash: Driver has 18 summonses, says Bukit Aman * Cop charged with fatally shooting man gets July 9 court mention date * Security guards do not have authority to ask for MyKad, says NRD * Anwar: Madani govt committed to reforms, but needs time * Contraband worth over RM16.6mil seized in Sepanggar Port raids * Bus driver tests positive for drug at JPJ roadblock * Construction of Penang's Mutiara Line LRT project to start soon * Gerik bus crash: No truth to claims damaged road led to accident, says Ahmad Maslan * Eight-year-old Harsheetaa has died, says grieving father * Anwar: Madani govt committed to reforms, but needs time * PKR'S leave to appeal bid in Zuraida's bond payment case set for hearing on June 24 Singapore * Newly married man jailed 28 days for taking upskirt photos at Tampines MRT station * Singapore's projected carbon tax revenue for 2024 lower than expected after five-fold hike in tax rate * Singapore property tycoon Ong Beng Seng to plead guilty on July 3 in case involving former transport minister * Swipe right on at least 180cm? Tinder tests height filter that users say dooms 'short kings' * Singapore's Mediacorp sacks male employee found 'behaving suspiciously' in female toilet on its premises * Singapore's Changi Airport Group awards S$999mil contract for underground tunnels at Terminal 5 * Teen, 16, convicted of rioting with deadly weapon after attacking victim at MRT station in Singapore Indonesia * Jakarta to trial car-free night at end of June * Indonesia revokes nickel ore mining permits in Raja Ampat after protest * Two Indonesians arrested in Los Angeles immigration raids Thailand * Snakes on a plane highlight Thailand-India trafficking: NGO * Thai immigration files complaint after Chinese tourist filmed officer, alleged bribes can ease entry into country * Indian smuggler on flight from Thailand stopped with possums, lizards, tarantulas * Thailand at risk of 'deflation' as economy stagnates, investment and consumption fall * The billion-Baht casino empire: How Thai-Cambodia border tensions expose hidden networks of power * From rides to learning: Thai elephant camps reinvent themselves to survive * DP World ready to invest in land bridge, says Thai Transport Ministry source Philippines * On the edge of hope: Life on Philippines' quiet front line in the South China Sea * Marcos mulls quarterly performance reviews for Cabinet members * Philippine senators prepare to be jurors in Sara Duterte's impeachment trial * Philippine VP Sara Duterte's Malaysia trip won't stall impeachment process – House spokesman Vietnam * Hanoi ready to cash in on growing halal tourism market * Vietnam exports first African swine fever vaccine batch to Indonesia Myanmar * Myanmar polls: 77 parties register, 56 approved so far Cambodia * Forces to resume previous posts * Cambodia tourism minister suggests additional South Korean air links * Cambodia approves investment projects worth US$4.2bil in January-May period Laos * Lao Aussie Chamber of Commerce marks 20 years with glamorous 'Roaring 20s' ball * Lao lawmakers begin National Assembly session with focus on economic recovery, key reforms Brunei * Brunei strengthens Asean-Russia security ties at international summit * Bruneian man jailed over a year for assault and mischief Aseanplus * Four injured in explosion * South Korea and Japan make pact to strengthen ties * Lee's election law violation hearing postponed indefinitely * China to make all hospitals offer epidurals to incentivise childbirth * Megaquake talk scaring tourists * K-pop megastars RM, V released from army, promise BTS reunion * HK action star Sammo Hung, 73, joins Douyin, posts three-generational family photo * Ringgit slightly up against US dollar amid cautious sentiment * Fire near South Korea's Jogye temple contained, treasures spared, officials say * Trump says China 'not easy' as trade talks to resume Tuesday * Singer Jacky Cheung's encore concerts at Singapore Indoor Stadium slated for Nov 21 to 23 * Asian markets extend gains as China-US talks head into second day * Chinese national gets five years' jail for causing death of Sabah State Courts director * Japan's PM Ishiba pledges 50% pay rise by 2040 ahead of elections * South Korean model-actor Kim Jong-seok dies at 29 * Honda Malaysia recalls 87,490 vehicles for fuel pump replacement * FBM KLCI holds steady as selective buying supports market * Australian accused in mushroom murders disputes accounts of fatal lunch * Sarawak to work with Chinese companies to develop floating solar power on Bakun reservoir * Xi urges South Korea's Lee to help safeguard free trade in call * Australia has stabilising role amid rising global division, says PM Albanese * Zii Jia turns down RTG offer, citing recovery from injury * Fire near South Korea's Jogye temple contained, treasures spared, say officials (update) * Malaysia, Poland to boost defence cooperation, explore partnership in trade, green energy, says PM Anwar * Sivasangari, Man-Tee get into RTG for first time as final list released * Chinese managers take reins at TikTok Shop in US as sales miss goal * Asian stocks climb, FX steady as US-China trade talks set to continue * Gold holds steady as markets eye US-China trade talks * Shubhanshu Shukla, first Indian in space in 41 Years, will blast off in a Musk rocket * Malaysia's palm oil stocks hit 8-month high in May as output jumps * China bans bank from luring depositors with popular Labubu dolls * Taiwanese actress Ruby Lin makes a trip to Singapore, with fellow celeb Vivian Hsu playing tour guide * Police going undercover to close gaps in Malaysia-Thailand border * FBM KLCI ends in red on late-day sell-off * Pearly-Thinaah reach world No. 3 while men doubles dominate at top * Chong Wei advises injured Tze Yong to seek treatment abroad * China thanks Indian Navy, Coast Guard for swift rescue of its nationals from burning vessel off Kerala coast * US-China trade talks on export controls to resume for a second day * South Korea appoints ex-trade chief Yeo Han-koo as new trade minister * HK actress Osanna Chiu seeks job opportunities outside TVB while awaiting new dramas * Beijing woos US influencers with free trip to show 'real China' * Ringgit weakens as US-China trade talks continue in London * Asean Higher Education Ministers' Roundtable in Langkawi on June 19 * Human-sized Labubu figure sells for over US$150,000 at Beijing auction * Japanese Immigration agency to tighten visa requirements for foreign entrepreneurs; move eyed as Chinese nationals increasingly obtain status * Residential building explosion in Fujian, China, kills two, injures five * India intensifies expulsion of suspected foreigners to Bangladesh * Johor Regent and Singapore agree to land swap at Holland Road * HK-born actor Chapman To celebrates 20th wedding anniversary with ex-TVB star Kristal Tin * Malaysia defeats Vietnam 4-0 in third-round qualifiers
New Straits Times
10 hours ago
- New Straits Times
PKR's leave to appeal bid in Zuraida's bond payment case set for hearing on June 24
PUTRAJAYA: The Federal Court will hear on June 24 an application by Parti Keadilan Rakyat (PKR) to seek leave to appeal against a Court of Appeal's decision which reduced the bond payment to be made by the party's former vice-president, Datuk Zuraida Kamaruddin, in a breach of party bond case. PKR's lawyer, Navpreet Singh, when contacted, told Bernama that the hearing will proceed via online proceedings. "A final case management was held before the Federal Court deputy registrar Husna Dzulkifly today, he said, adding that all parties have updated the court pertaining to compliance with pre-hearing directives relating to their submissions. The case revolves around a civil suit filed by former PKR secretary-general Datuk Saifuddin Nasution Ismail, on behalf of the party, claiming that Zuraida, who was then the Ampang member of parliament, had breached the bond she had signed. The terms of the bond, among others, required Zuraida to pay PKR RM10 million within seven days of winning an election on the PKR ticket, should she resign from the party, join another political party, or become an independent representative. In June 2023, the High Court ruled in favour of the party and ordered Zuraida to pay the RM10 million, with the court finding the bond to be valid and enforceable. However, in December last year, the Court of Appeal agreed with the High Court that there was a breach of bond but reduced the bond amount to RM100,000, citing that the RM10 million is not a reasonable amount of compensation. This prompted PKR to file a leave to appeal. In her defence, Zuraida contended that she was forced to sign the bond with the party to be able to stand for election as a candidate in the 14th General Election (GE14) in 2018. The Federal Court will now decide whether PKR can proceed with its appeal against the Court of Appeal's decision. In civil cases, litigants must obtain leave before they can proceed with their appeals in the Federal Court.
