Mourne Gondola: National Trust insist project cannot go ahead
The National Trust has said it will not lease land it manages in the Mourne Mountains for the development of a cable car up Slieve Donard, Northern Ireland's highest mountain.The proposed £44m project would have involved the development of a 1km cable car structure from Donard Park up to a disused quarry.But the National Trust have said the project should not go ahead in light of the "fragile and threatened" state of the Mourne landscape. In a statement, they said their responsibility is to "restore nature in the Mournes, whilst balancing safe and sustainable access for people".Last month, there were almost 150 wildfires causing a devastating impact on habitats in the mountain range.
'Never endorsed the project'
The National Trust is responsible for the land in the Eastern Mournes Special Area of Conservation including Slieve Donard and Thomas Quarry - the site earmarked for the proposed gondola station and visitor centre. In a statement on Thursday, the Trust confirmed that the proposed project would "risk placing additional pressures on already degraded upland habitats".It would therefore "not be considering a lease at Thomas's Quarry".It said that it has engaged with Newry, Mourne and Down District Council on the projects proposals but have "consistently expressed our serious concerns" as far back as eight years ago and "encouraged other options to be considered"."We have never endorsed the project and have not been a partner in its development," it added.
The Trust said their concerns about the upland habitats not being in a "favourable condition" are shared by local people. Last year, a petition of about 6,000 signatures opposing the Newcastle project was presented to the Stormont Assembly.It was allocated £30m of funding from the Belfast Region City Deal.Those behind the petition said they have environmental and economic concerns about the viability of the scheme that hopes to attract about 350,000 annual visitors.There was also a number businesspeople who supported the project as they believed it would help create a year-round tourist economy for the region.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Belfast Telegraph
3 hours ago
- Belfast Telegraph
National Trust had ‘significant' concerns about £44m Mournes cable car project after seeing environmental report being hidden from public by council using NDAs
An environmental report which potentially led to the collapse of the Mourne Gateway cable car project was the subject of a Non-Disclosure Agreement (NDA). Newry, Mourne and Down District Council (NMDDC) has finally confirmed the confidential status of the report to the Local Democracy Reporting Service (LDRS) a month after a media query.
Daily Mail
15 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Locals win war with National Trust by stopping 'abhorrent' building planned for internationally important nature reserve on Norfolk coast
Plans for a massive visitor centre at a popular beauty spot have been withdrawn by the National Trust after it capitulated in the face of a huge public backlash over the 'abhorrent' building. The charity had been accused of putting money over nature with the scheme at Morston Quay in north Norfolk, claiming it would provide much-needed facilities for visitors, staff and volunteers. But more than 150 formal objections were lodged over the threat it posed to 'one of the few relatively untouched places remaining along the coast'. Only three people approved. Locals argued it was intended to generate more income and act as an administrative hub by 'introducing office space and adding retail space' at the spot, which sits within Blakeney National Nature Reserve and is a vital haven for wildlife including ground-nesting birds and England's largest Grey Seal colony. One objector said: 'Morston Quay and the marshes beyond are a precious natural resource which need protection, not exploitation. 'It is wild and beautiful and should not be regarded as an opportunity for the expansion of administrative facilities or opportunities for raising funds.' Morston Parish Council also waded into the dispute, accusing the Trust of creating 'spurious' arguments in favour of the visitor centre when its aim was simply to commercialise the spot. 'There are no benefits to the residents of Morston from this plan,' it wrote. 'Almost everything about this proposal is abhorrent. It is the wrong building, in the wrong place, for the wrong purpose.' Early last year, the Trust's application for a food truck at the beauty spot was blocked by councillors who questioned why it was needed when there was already a café in the Lookout. The existing visitor centre is a modest grey and white wooden building with steps up to a viewing room topped by a weathervane. Toilet facilities are provided in two portacabins, which would have been removed under the plans for the proposed structure - a huge single-storey building made from natural wood cladding with a glass side that would be 85ft long and 27ft wide. This would house a new 'visitor welcome point' and space for 'staff and volunteer welfare', while the Lookout building would continue to offer food and drinks. But the Trust has now confirmed it has cancelled the move, with a spokesman saying: 'We are grateful to everyone who engaged with our planning application for improved visitor facilities at Morston Quay. 'We have taken on board comments from the local community and have decided to withdraw our current planning application, with the intention of resubmitting a revised application to North Norfolk District Council by the autumn or winter.' No further detail was given about the amended application but local media reported a 'well-placed source said it had abandoned the visitor centre and would now confine its proposals to upgrading toilet facilities at the site'. The trust insisted the development would have created a more pleasant experience for the 100,000 people who visit Morston Quay every year. But the parish council added in its objection: 'We have been presented with an enormous and unnecessary new development which will fundamentally change the character of Morston Quay and seems designed to create a full-time visitor and administrative hub for the National Trust as a priority, introducing office space and adding retail space, while also providing new toilets.' Matthew Rice, a Norfolk painter, designer and writer to contributes to Country Life magazine, warned the introduction of a new centre with 'delineated parking spaces' and 'bonded surfaces' would place a 'barrier' between people and the area's natural beauty. He said: 'There are no tall forests, craggy rocks or mountains to absorb the impact of new buildings or to dilute the suburbanising effect of 'bonded surfaces'. 'The whole appeal of this wild place is its lack of boundaries and its apparent unplanned layout. Imposing a one-size-fits-all National Trust solution can destroy all this at a stroke. 'The desire for neatness, street furniture and lighting in the name of safety is all around us and, if great care is not taken in delivering improvements, it can suddenly make Norfolk look like everywhere else.' Another objector to the visitor centre plan said: 'The vast majority of visitor traffic is generated by the local, family-run businesses on Blakeney Point. These families offer a fantastic welcome and expertise on the local flora, fauna and history. Other objections included: 'It promotes unnecessary overdevelopment of what is one of the few relatively untouched places remaining along the coast. 'But perhaps what is most important is the sheer contempt with which the community has been treated throughout the process. 'The Quay is not just a space from further afield but also for the local residents that live and work there.' The Trust has also faced anger from locals at nearby Brancaster, who accused it of trying to 'monetise' the harbour there with new rules and charges, including £60 fees for mooring dinghies. There has been another backlash a few miles away in Burnham Overy Staithe, near Wells, where the charity has been accused of neglecting an iconic windmill after it emerged plans to restore the building didn't include replacing the sails. West Norfolk Council has told the Trust the sails must be replaced when the work is complete. NT has faced a turbulent few years, amid complaints it adopted a 'woke' agenda by forcing staff to wear gay pride badges and listing nearly 100 properties with links to slavery and colonialism.
Belfast Telegraph
5 days ago
- Belfast Telegraph
Gondola relocation plan a slap in the face for the people of Rostrevor, says protest group
The plan by Newry, Mourne and Down District Council was revealed on Wednesday afternoon. The local authority said it was 'exploring' the option of moving the gondola, also called the Mourne Gateway Project, to Kilbroney Forest Park. The project was originally earmarked for Newcastle, only to be axed earlier this month. Doubts were raised over the future of £30m in project funding offered through the Belfast Region City Deal (BRCD) after the National Trust refused to lease the council land on Slieve Donard for the project. The council said retaining the funding would require the agreement of all BRCD partners, and any proposal 'must meet the BRCD objectives to enhance the attractiveness of Northern Ireland as a world-class visitor destination'. Kilbroney Forest Park is owned and run by the council, which said the gondola had the potential to become a 'transformative visitor experience', with 'environmental sensitivity'a key part of the plan. The council added: 'The cable car route is yet to be determined, but it will not pass through the ancient oak woodland and development would be carried out in a sustainable manner that protects the park's natural assets.' The council also pointed out that the project was supported by the Warrenpoint, Burren and Rostrevor Chamber of Commerce, which described it as 'a game-changer for tourism in the region'. Others in the area, however, are staunchly opposed. Bronagh Vos, from Rostrevor, started the 'Say NO to Gondola in Rostrevor' Facebook page on Wednesday evening, with more than 150 people joining the group overnight. A poll on the page shows overwhelming opposition to the project. Bronagh, who uses the park daily, said the council's decision to announce the project without community consultation showed a 'complete disregard' for the people of Rostrevor. 'The proposal to relocate the failed gondola project to Rostrevor, without any form of public consultation with the local community, existing businesses and clubs, is unacceptable and alarming,' she added. 'This decision shows a complete disregard for the people who live here, the integrity of our landscape, and the principles of transparent, community-led planning.' She said Rostrevor was not a 'dumping ground' for rejected projects, and called for the 'abandonment of any plans being advanced behind closed doors without local community input'. Independent councillor Mark Gibbons said he was notified of the plan just minutes before the announcement was made. He said the council's lack of transparency was 'demoralising' and the decision was a 'hurried mess'. 'There are many other things this money could be spent on, such as the renovation of Warrenpoint Baths, a community centre for Warrenpoint and the upgrading of Kilbroney Park pitches, to name just a few,' he added. 'The people of Warrenpoint and Rostrevor have waited long enough and have paid enough rates over the decades to warrant proper respect. 'This project seems to be a hurried mess of disrespect and squander.' Mr Gibbons warned that his confidence in the council was 'at tipping point' and described the authority's lack of notice as worrying. 'I would call for a public consultation on this matter immediately. It really should have been done before it was announced,' he said. 'There needs to be measures put in place where the community is not being kept in the dark and the council can provide us with basic information, not just hoodwink us into these ludicrous decisions. 'St Bronagh's GAA and the Rossowen soccer club have been campaigning for changing facilities for the past few years, and are getting nowhere. 'The irony of this is that if it goes ahead, the first thing people will see on their gondola ride is young children getting changed in a ditch on the side of the pitches because the money was not spent on what is needed most.' Bronagh's GAA secretary Richy Byrne said his club and Rossowen FC had been campaigning for changing facilities for the past five years. He described the announcement as a 'total shock' and said it was 'hugely frustrating' after lobbying for basic facilities for half a decade. Mr Byrne continued: 'It makes us wonder, was there any intent on behalf of the council to fulfil the needs of young kids in the area, or are they just concerned with looking elsewhere?' The clubs asked the council to 'make this project an urgent priority, to take a firm grip of the application, and bring it to planning for a decision without any further delay so that work can begin to give the local area, our members and community a facility that is fit for purpose, on par with other council lead facilities across the country, and something we can be proud of'. However, Sinn Fein's Sinead Ennis welcomed the relocation plan. The South Down MLA said: 'It is welcome news that Newry, Mourne and Down District Council are doing all they can to secure the £30m BRCD investment in the area. 'This would be a game changer, helping to unlock the full tourism potential of Kilbroney Forest Park. 'Sinn Fein is ambitious for Kilbroney. We want to work with others to build on its well-established popularity and ensure it continues to thrive as a destination for locals and visitors alike. 'I believe that, with the right investment Kilbroney Park, could become the number one adventure tourism destination on the island of Ireland.' Ms Ennis added that this development, on top of the upcoming opening of Narrow Water Bridge, would draw visitors to the area. 'This ambitious project could have huge social and economic benefits for the area,' she continued. 'Protecting the environment is central to this proposal. The exact route for the cable car is still under consideration, but it will not cross the ancient oak woodland. 'Any development will follow sustainable practices to safeguard the park's natural features. 'I look forward to seeing how this project develops and the positive impact it will have on Rostrevor, Warrenpoint and the wider South Down region.' Newry, Mourne and Down District Council was asked if it would launch a public consultation. While it did not address this directly, it said: 'The Council is now actively exploring a proposal to deliver the Mourne Mountains Gateway project in Kilbroney Forest Park and looks forward to working closely with community stakeholders, environmental experts, BRCD and tourism partners to develop the Kilbroney Park proposal to ensure it reflects the shared ambition for a vibrant, inclusive, and sustainable future.'
