
Major twist as judge acts after shock tip-off about one of the jurors in the Erin Patterson trial
The Erin Patterson trial has suffered the surprise loss of a juror mid-trial after the judge was given new information about him.
Justice Christopher Beale discharged a male juror on Thursday after the judge was alerted that the man had been discussing the trial outside of court.
Bringing the jury in late, Justice Beale explained why the juror would no longer be seated alongside them for the duration of the trial.
'I'm not going to ask you questions, I just want to give you some information,' he said.
'Under Section 43 of the Juries Act I have the power to discharge a juror if it appears to me a juror should not continue to act as a juror.'
The jury was told the juror would not be coming back.
'A few moments ago, I discharged juror 84, I did so because, and as I explained to him, I received information that he had been discussing the case with family and friends, contrary to my instructions,' Justice Beale said.
He told the jury the information he received about the juror seemed 'credible' and therefore had no choice but to let him go.
'I was of the view that it was, at least, a reasonable possibility that the information I received was credible,' he said.
Justice Beale reminded the jury to refrain from talking about the trial to anyone other than other jurors.
'I want to remind you of my directions that you should only discuss the case with your fellow jurors in the privacy of the jury room (and) not discuss it with anyone else, it's vital to the administration of justice,' he said.
Justice Beale described the incident as an 'unhappy note' and urged the jurors to continue to perform their jobs diligently.
'I hasten to add that I have not made a positive finding that juror number 84 discussed the case with family and friends but neither could I dismiss the possibility that he had.
'As I said, I was of the view that it was a reasonable possibility that he had breached my instructions,' he said.
'I've directed him not to contact any of you, directly or indirectly, and I likewise give you the similar direction.
'You are not to contact him directly or indirectly whilst this trial is continuing, alright, on that unhappy note we're now ready to resume the trial.'
JURIES ACT 2000 - SECTION 43
A judge may, during a trial, discharge a juror without discharging the whole jury if:
(a) it appears to the judge that the juror is not impartial; or
(b) the juror becomes incapable of continuing to act as a juror; or
(c) the juror becomes ill; or
(d) it appears to the judge that, for any other reason, the juror should not continue to act as a juror.
The original 15-person jury had been selected from a pool of 120 people from in and around the Gippsland area where the trial is taking place.
While the loss of the juror comes as a major inconvenience, the trial needs just 12 jurors to make it until the end.
The remaining jurors will then be balloted off.
When the trial recommenced, the jury heard from child protection practitioner Katrina Cripps.
Ms Cripps told the jury she believed Patterson had eaten 'half' of her portion of beef Wellington during the fateful lunch.
Ms Cripps had spoken to Patterson in the days after the lunch.
'I don't believe she ate it all,' Ms Cripps said.
Ms Cripps said Patterson told her the lunch guests chose their plates and she took the last one.
Patterson also indicated she put two plates aside for her children.
Patterson has pleaded not guilty to murdering her estranged husband Simon Patterson's parents Don and Gail Patterson, and Gail's sister, Heather Wilkinson.
They died after consuming death cap mushrooms served in a beef Wellington during lunch at her Leongatha home in the state's east.
Pastor Ian Wilkinson was the only guest to survive the toxic lunch.
He appeared in court on Thursday seated at the front of the court room after concluding his own evidence in the opening days of the trial.
Ms Cripps said she visited the children and Patterson's estranged husband Simon at the Monash Children's Hospital on August 2.
The jury heard Ms Cripps said she spoke to Patterson at 2.55pm - which was the first time she had ever talked to her.
She said Patterson told her she had the children during the week and Simon had them on weekends.
Patterson told Ms Cripps the children talked about not wanting to stay at their dad's on weekends anymore because he was 'sleeping a lot'.
Patterson said Simon had become 'mean and nasty' after an issue with child support was raised, the jury heard.
Ms Cripps said Patterson told her Simon had been 'controlling and emotionally abusive', which caused her to doubt her ability as a mother and dented her self-esteem.
The jury also heard from Doctor Dimitri Gerostamoulos, head of forensic science at the Victorian Institute of Forensic Medicine and the state's chief toxicologist.
Dr Gerostamoulos told the court just three table spoons of death cap mushrooms would be enough to kill an adult weighing 70kgs.
The jury heard the devastating effects death caps had on the body once consumed.
Dr Gerostamoulos said poisoning victims would experience vomiting, diarrhoea and progressively get worse without treatment.
He told the court that the body was unable to process the toxin as it would a normal drug.
Dr Gerostamoulos told the jury no trace of the toxin had been found in Patterson or her children.
Nor was it found in Heather Wilkinson or Gail Patterson.
However, it was found in Don and Ian Wilkinson.
The jury was shown images of two beef Wellington's retrieved from Patterson's home after the lunch.
An analysis of the contents found mushroom paste within the paste-sized Wellingtons found traces of beta-amanitin - the calling card of death cap mushrooms.
Several samples from the dehydrator tested positive for both alpha and beta amanitin.
The trial continues.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Guardian
41 minutes ago
- The Guardian
‘The danger gap is so big': woman who witnessed Sydney light rail death calls for safety upgrades
A woman who says she witnessed a pedestrian fatally struck by a Sydney tram earlier this month is calling for safety upgrades to the city's light rail network. Annalise Gasparre, 27, said she was standing on the opposite platform at a light rail stop on Devonshire Street in Surry Hills to the man in the moments before he died on 5 June. Police said last week their initial inquiries, including reviewing CCTV footage, showed the man was attempting to cross the light rail track between two carriages when the tram began moving and trapped him. The man was the second pedestrian to die after being struck by a tram on Sydney's light rail in two years, after the 2023 death of a teenage girl who became trapped underneath a tram while attempting to cross a street in the CBD. The Sydney Light Rail network includes the L1 Dulwich Hill, L2 Randwick and L3 Kingsford lines, all of which run into the CBD. A new line opened in December, connecting Parramatta with Carlingford. The L2 and L3 routes use the Citadis X05 Light Rail Vehicles, built by the French manufacturer Alstom. While they are 33m in length, these trams are coupled together on the L2 and L3 routes to form a 66m-long vehicle. The fatal incident in Surry Hills prompted debate about whether it was safe to operate coupled trams. Gasparre, who said she saw the pedestrian die, suggested sensors or cameras be added to trams to alert drivers if a person was trapped underneath before they started moving away from a light rail stop. She also suggested that the yellow line at the edge of the platform at light rail stops should be moved further back. Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email She said 'you could fit two people' in between the platform and the joinery between the trams. 'To be honest, I think the light rail design needs to be changed,' she said. 'The danger gap is so big.' Gasparre said she did not believe the man was trying to cross the tracks, and thinks instead that he had tripped forward and fallen off the platform. 'I hope something in terms of safety will come out of this,' she said. NSW police on Thursday said the man's death was now a matter for the coroner, who would be reviewing statements from all witnesses. Dr Liam Davies, a lecturer in sustainability and urban planning at RMIT University, said the two light rail deaths were 'terrible accidents' but the network was 'overwhelmingly' safe. Sign up to Breaking News Australia Get the most important news as it breaks after newsletter promotion However, he said additional safety measures could include installing something to block the gap between the tram carriages, or putting a barrier in the middle of a light rail stop to discourage people from trying to cross the road. 'It would have to be a lower cost, lower tech intervention, like fitting something to the existing trams,' he said. 'The other option is simply to not run them as coupled trams, but that would require a large amount of reorganisation to get more drivers and to redevelop all the timetables to be able to run more trams during peak hour.' Davies said Sydney's light rail network was much smaller and less complex than Melbourne's, where trams only run in a single fashion rather than being coupled together to form a longer vehicle. 'There's no right or wrong answer,' he said. 'It's got to be really context specific, and usually the context that these types of couple trams get run in are very busy corridors that have a lot of passengers.' Transport for NSW (TfNSW) said in a statement that the Surry Hills death was 'extremely distressing' 'This incident is now under investigation by NSW Police and Transport for NSW and the operator Transdev are giving their full support,' the statement said. 'The investigation will review what controls were in place, and we can not speculate further on any controls or conditions at this time. 'While the matter is investigated, we are unable to comment further.' Guardian Australia sought comment from the light rail's private operator, Transdev, on Thursday.


The Guardian
41 minutes ago
- The Guardian
OneFour on prison, police and their long-awaited debut: ‘We wouldn't be who we are today if we didn't go through that'
As evidence of what's changed for the Australian hip-hop act OneFour, the group's Jerome 'J Emz' Misa points to the blue sky behind him. 'Right now I'm going for a midday walk – I never used to do this back in the days!' the rapper laughs, his Zoom screen shaky as he puffs through the streets of western Sydney. 'Physically and mentally, I feel like there's been a lot of positive changes.' For one, while OneFour made their name as the first in Australia to embrace drill, a Chicago-born genre that tells often-nihilistic tales of street violence, J Emz no longer identifies as a driller. 'I'm an artist and a musician – and [my music] comes from that perspective,' he says. The group, who grew up together in Mount Druitt, were teenagers when they first started making music in a local youth centre. They're now in their mid-to-late-20s and have had 'a lot of time to reflect' on where young adulthood in one of Sydney's most disadvantaged postcodes took them. 'If you're Polynesian, you grow up in church, and you have certain principles and morals that you live by, that you're taught by parents,' J Emz says. 'But what we all had to go through in the street went against those principles or morals.' What they went through has been well documented. In 2019, the same year the group enjoyed breakthrough success with their single The Message, OneFour hit two major setbacks. First, three of the group's members were jailed over a violent pub brawl. Second, their lyrics were taken by New South Wales police as evidence the group were engaged in gang warfare. Strike Force Raptor, a specialised police squad created to tackle outlaw motorcycle gangs, made it their mission to stop OneFour from ever performing in Sydney – and have, so far, more or less succeeded. Despite the group's repeated denials of involvement in gang violence, the police have cancelled their tours, barred them from entering the Aria awards on the night they were nominated, and arrived with metal detectors and undercover officers to the premiere of their 2023 Netflix documentary. What should have been the start of a brilliant career sputtered and stalled, and maintaining momentum has been an issue. But it hasn't stopped them becoming heroes. As local hip-hop manager and tastemaker Christopher Kevin Au puts it: 'With OneFour, people are buying into much more than the music – they're attached to the story. The trajectory of OneFour has seen them become the ultimate underdog tale.' Now, OneFour are chewing over their journey on their long delayed debut album, Look At Me Now. 'The album is based on a story of overcoming the obstacles that we've had to experience, growing from the people we were when we first started making music to the people we are today,' J Emz says. 'Look at us now – and look at where we are with our careers now.' Today, OneFour are arguably the biggest act in Australian hip-hop (bar their friend and collaborator the Kid Laroi), with several multi-platinum singles to their name. While they have always been proudly independent, the group recently struck a distribution deal with Sony Music subsidiary The Orchard, lending them more institutional backing than they've ever had. It's at Sony's Sydney office that I meet three of the band's four core members for an initial group interview: J Emz, Dahcell 'Celly' Ramos and Spencer 'Spenny' Magalog. There have been some lineup shifts in recent years. As of 2023, all members of the band are now out of prison, though Salec 'Lekks' Su'a, who was born in Samoa but holds New Zealand citizenship, was deported to New Zealand after finishing his sentence. Last year the group's longtime manager stepped down from his role, and original member Pio 'YP' Misa (younger brother of J Emz) left to join the priesthood, a decision he discussed in a tearful Nine News interview. A condition of this interview was that YP's departure not be discussed, and with some awkward topics to skirt around, there is sometimes a stiffness in our conversation. But one thing the group is happy to talk about is the album. Look At Me Now packs plenty that will feel familiar to OneFour fans – eshay slang, gunshot samples, quintessentially Australian references to Coles, Penrith Panthers and Honda Civics, and pithy lines like 'They put money on our heads / We call that shit an op shop' (a reference to a recent alleged murder plot). But there's also a new introspection to many of the tracks. 'We show a different side of ourselves – we get a bit vulnerable,' J Emz says. That includes Phone Call, the group's first love song, featuring the R&B singer Mabel. But other tracks tackle big topics like the environments that raise us, how easy it can be to get caught up in the system, and what it means to pull yourself out of one sort of life and into another. There are bars about the young kids let down by our schools and the friends who've been sucked in by drugs and landed in prison. On the album opener Change, J Emz implores young listeners to learn from his mistakes; elsewhere, Spenny raps about waking up in cold sweats from the memories of things he's done. J Emz says he doesn't want to be a role model for anyone ('I don't want that spotlight'), but he's aware there is a younger generation who look up to OneFour, not just as hitmakers but as representatives of Mount Druitt and Pasifika people on the world stage. When I talked to fellow Mount Druitt hip-hop act Kapulet in 2020, he described the group's influence on the young people of their neighbourhood: 'Before, everyone used to want to be footy players. Now everyone wants to be a musician.' 'We know our music goes a long way, and it reaches a lot of people,' says J Emz. 'So when it came to the album itself, I feel like it is the right thing to do … to be that positive role model.' OneFour say the album is 'for those who want more' from life, and hope it motivates their listeners. They're disappointed they won't get to share it live with fans in their home town; while the group is set to visit the rest of the country as part of their album tour, a Sydney show still isn't possible: 'We've tried,' J Emz says. Instead, the group staged a listening party at a secret location in western Sydney on Thursday, where the album was played over a soundsystem. To date, the only times they've been able to perform in their home city are in festivals or supporting act slots. In their war against OneFour, NSW police have often hit venues hosting the band with prohibitive user-pays police bills that effectively force the gig's cancellation. Guardian Australia understands that the group's Sydney show with the Kid Laroi in November only went ahead after the payment of a six-figure police bill, funding several riot squads, horseback patrols, plus police at the perimeter of the show and at Parramatta station. In fact, across a seven-year career, OneFour have only played about 20 shows – a number any other artist would do within six months of an album tour. The official police line is that they fear 'antisocial behaviour' should OneFour be allowed to perform, which is exasperating for the band. 'We haven't had any major incidents involved with our shows,' says J Emz. 'Everything's gone safely. It's tough when you've been doing it for years, and it's just a matter of them [the police] just letting go of whatever they got against us.' It doesn't feel coincidental that this extraordinary level of police intervention has been exercised against a group of Pasifika men; for their part, NSW police have described their own actions as 'lawfully harassing' the band. When I ask the usually chatty J Emz if it feels like discrimination, he has only one word in answer, which arrives to the awkward laughter of his bandmates: 'Yes.' But OneFour are surprisingly positive about what they have gone through and what's to come. 'We wouldn't be who we are today if we didn't go through that stuff, if it was just a walk in the park,' says J Emz. 'I feel like that's why people resonate with our music and find it so authentic.' OneFour are, J Emz feels, 'a living example of what's possible with music'. Spenny agrees: 'Without music I would have ended up on a different path, a whole different lifestyle … music for me, changed me – and basically saved my life.' Now, he just wants people – and the police – to understand what most other artists don't have to spell out: 'We're musicians. We love our craft, and we're just trying to get our story out to the world.' Look At Me Now is out 13 June (Sony Music). OneFour are touring Australia from 21 June.


The Guardian
41 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Three teenage girls plead guilty to killing of 75-year-old man in north London street
Three teenage girls have pleaded guilty to the 'senseless' killing of a 75-year-old man in a street attack in north London filmed on a mobile phone. Fredi Rivero, a Bolivian national, was attacked by the teenagers, aged 15, 16 and 17, in Islington on 27 February, and died in hospital the next day. Rivero, who has been described as a 'much-loved family man', was near a bus stop on Seven Sisters Road when the girls got off a bus and surrounded him. His glasses were stolen, and he was pushed, shoved, kicked and punched while one of the teenagers filmed the incident on her phone. Police officers later recovered CCTV footage of the assault in which the 17-year-old girl could be seen punching Rivero in the head, causing him to fall backwards. He was found unconscious by police with a severe head injury and in cardiac arrest at 11.25pm on the night of the attack. DI Devan Taylor from Scotland Yard said: 'Mr Rivero was a much-loved family man who died in a truly tragic incident. I know how much his death has impacted those close to him and the wider community. 'I would like to offer my heartfelt sympathy to Mr Rivero's family for their loss and express my admiration for the dignity they have shown throughout the investigation. I also wish to thank the members of public who went to Mr Rivero's aid as he lay injured. 'The young defendants have now accepted they were responsible for the killing of Mr Rivero, in what was a senseless and completely out of the blue attack on a lone, elderly man. The age of the defendants adds to the devastating nature of this incident and they will now have to deal with the enormity of their actions.' Appearing before the Old Bailey via video link, the teenagers, who cannot be identified because of their ages, pleaded guilty to manslaughter. They will be sentenced by judge Judy Khan KC on 5 September. The victim's daughter, ex-wife and cousins were in court for the hearing. Khan ordered reports and remanded the defendants into custody, to be sentenced on 5 September.