Innocent Arizona grandmother arrested and hauled away to jail while gardening after being mistaken for fugitive
An innocent Arizona grandmother wrongfully arrested by US Marshals is suing the government after she was bundled into the back of an unmarked car while gardening.
Penny McCarthy, 67, had been working in her front yard last March when six agents approached her with their guns drawn and arrested her.
The 67-year-old had been misidentified by the authorities as a 'Carole Rozak' and despite her desperate pleas she was taken in.
In a federal lawsuit filed June 10, McCarthy says she spent the next 24 hours in their custody as she begged with agents they had the wrong person.
According to the filing, McCarthy said she was fingerprinted and had her DNA taken before she was bused to a federal detention center in Florence.
McCarthy said in the filing that over the course of those 24 hours she was strip searched three times.
During a press conference in which she recalling the incident McCarthy started to cry and described to reporters how she is a survivor of domestic child abuse.
She said: 'I have to be strip searched by one woman for something I didn't do, and then I'm told I'm going to be detained.'
She filed her suit under the Fourth Amendment which protects citizens from unreasonable false arrests.
The filing says she has asked for compensatory and punitive damages against the US Marshals Service for their 'tortious and unconstitutional acts and omissions'.
She is also filing under the Federal Tort Claims Act, which allows people to sue the federal government when federal officers cause them harm.
McCarthy says she was kept in a 'cold cell' overnight before being back in court the next day for an identity hearing, the complaint adds.
Her attorneys said in the filing: 'Eventually the government confirmed that Penny's fingerprints and DNA do not match Rozak's and ended the proceedings.'
The judge released her after prosecutors asked for more time to get the results of her fingerprints and DNA.
The government then dismissed the case against her. She now says she fears being left alone and taking her dog for a walk.
McCarthy added that the psychological effects from the ordeal caused her to sell her home and move out of the state.
She said: 'I'm still afraid that one day I will be pulled over and again mistaken for a criminal.
'I'm suing because I don't want this to happen to anyone else. Unless someone is held responsible, someone else will go through this same nightmare.'
McCarthy spoke with ABC15 after the incident, telling the outlet: 'I truly felt like I was being kidnapped.'
Terrifying body camera video showed the moment she was arrested by rifle-wielding officers who barked commands at her.
The federal agents rolled up to McCarthy's Phoenix home with guns drawn and immediately told her to put her 'hands up!'.
'We have an arrest warrant,' a federal agent is heard saying on the video. 'For me?' McCarthy responded. 'Yes. For you,' the officer said.
'Who am I?' she asked, seemingly wanting the officers to confirm that she was in fact the person they were looking to apprehend.
Multiple agents can be heard in the clip screaming at her and giving her conflicting orders.
'Turn away. Turn around. Turn away. We'll discuss it later. Turn away. You're gonna get hit,' they said.
McCarthy is being represented by the Institute for Justice, a nonprofit law firm, who specialize in cases involving abuses of power.
Senior Attorney Paul Avelar said: 'The officers' misidentifying Penny was inexcusable and violated state and federal law.
'To make matters worse, even if Penny had been the fugitive they were looking for, the officers' over-the-top display of force was uncalled for, given that the fugitive was wanted only for failing to check in with a probation officer after being released from prison twenty-five years ago for nonviolent crimes.'
Rozak, the woman agents said Penny was, was wanted for an outstanding parole violation from 1999.
All the crimes she served time for were non-violent in nature, but after her release, she failed to meet with any federal probation officer, according to records.
In a statement the US Marshals Service in Arizona said: 'The US Marshals Service acknowledges that Ms Penny McCarthy was mistakenly arrested.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
38 minutes ago
- Reuters
Russian cryptocurrency firm founder avoids further US prison time for fraud
BOSTON, June 12 (Reuters) - A Russian-born founder of a cryptocurrency financial services firm avoided having to spend any further time in a U.S. prison on Thursday for participating in a wide-ranging scheme to manipulate the market for digital tokens on behalf of his company's clients. Federal prosecutors in Boston had argued that Aleksei Andriunin, the founder and CEO of cryptocurrency "market maker" Gotbit, deserved a 15-month prison sentence after he pleaded guilty in March to charges that he conspired to commit market manipulation and engaged in wire fraud. Instead, U.S. District Judge Angel Kelley sentenced him to just eight months in prison, which he was deemed to have already served based on the time he spent in jail following his arrest in October in Portugal, prosecutors said. Portugal extradited him in February. He now faces deportation. His company Gotbit was meanwhile ordered to forfeit $23 million worth of cryptocurrency as part of a separate plea deal. "We're incredibly gratified by the sentence, and he's looking forward to getting home to his wife and family," Roger Burlingame, his lawyer at Dechert, said. Andriunin and Gotbit were among 15 people and three firms charged last year following a novel investigation dubbed "Operation Token Mirrors," in which the FBI for the first time directed the creation of its own digital token to help catch fraudsters in the crypto market. Before the charges were filed, Gotbit was a premier "market maker" in the cryptocurrency industry, making tens of millions of dollars in annual revenue and employing over 200 people, prosecutors said. Prosecutors said that from 2018 to 2024, Gotbit engaged in "wash trading," a form of sham trading, and market manipulation on behalf of several cryptocurrency clients to help artificially inflate trading volume for their tokens. Prosecutors cited a 2019 interview published online in which Andriunin described developing a code to wash trade cryptocurrencies to artificially inflate trading volume so they could become listed on larger cryptocurrency exchanges.
The Independent
43 minutes ago
- The Independent
LA protests live: California Senator Alex Padilla dragged out of press conference after confronting Kristi Noem
Pinned Here's what you need to know today... Los Angeles enforced a second consecutive curfew to curb criminal activity amid ongoing protests against ICE raids, with 700 Marines expected to join 4,000 National Guard troops in the city. California Governor Gavin Newsom criticised President Trump's deployment of troops as "theater, madness, unconstitutional," and accused Trump of fabricating a conversation about federalizing the National Guard. Protests have erupted in at least 37 cities since last Friday, with more planned, including 1,800 'No Kings' demonstrations nationwide on Saturday. Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem held a press conference on Thursday morning, and in shocking scenes, Democratic Senator Alex Padilla was forcibly removed, restrained, and handcuffed when he tried to ask a question, sparking widespread outrage. A federal court hearing is scheduled to test Trump's authority to deploy military troops to protest areas, with Newsom seeking to block the administration from using the military to enforce immigration laws. Oliver O'Connell12 June 2025 11:09 How ICE is becoming more aggressive in arresting migrants Ramming cars, sledgehammering windows and raiding churches in pursuit of migrants appears to be the new norm for Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents in Trump's America. Democratic lawmakers have questioned 'the appropriateness, proportionality, and execution of ICE tactics, ' while immigration attorneys say the agency's approach has escalated after a series of high-profile incidents over recent weeks. Rhian Lubin reports. Ramming cars and raiding churches: ICE getting more aggressive in arresting migrants Tactics deployed by ICE agents to detain migrants are becoming more aggressive, a catalogue of recent high-profile incidents show Oliver O'Connell12 June 2025 22:13 Speaker Johnson suggests Padilla could be censured House Speaker Mike Johnson accused Senator Alex Padilla of 'charging' at Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem and suggested that his behavior 'rises to the level of a censure.' 'My view is it was wildly inappropriate,' Johnson told reporters outside the U.S. House chamber, as Democrats walking past shouted over him, 'That's a lie!' 'A sitting member of Congress should not act like that,' Johnson said, loudly speaking over reporters' questions. 'It's beneath a member of Congress. It's beneath the U.S. senator.' Watch the moment below: Oliver O'Connell12 June 2025 22:01 Trump insists 'not a king at all' as he's pressed on abuse of power concerns over tank-adorned DC birthday parade Days ahead of the militaristic parade he has ordered up for his 79th birthday, President Donald Trump has denied having any monarchical pretensions even as he continues to face questions over his use of American soldiers and marines to help put down protests over his harsh immigration enforcement efforts. Speaking in the East Room during an impromptu press conference after signing legislation to block California 's ability to regulate vehicle emissions and push for more electric vehicle sales in an effort to protect the state's air quality, Trump was asked about protests planned for Saturday as part of what organizers are calling 'No Kings Day' to coincide with the parade, which is ostensibly meant to mark the 250th anniversary of the U.S. Army. Andrew Feinberg reports on what the president had to say. Trump insists 'not a king at all' as he's pressed on tank-adorned DC birthday parade President also attacked Gov. Gavin Newsom and denigrated Ukraine's self-defense efforts at signing of bill to overturn California's longstanding ability to set its own car emission standards Oliver O'Connell12 June 2025 21:57 FBI releases statement on removal of Padilla The FBI released the following statement after Sen. Alex Padilla was forcibly removed from a news conference at which Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem was speaking. 'During a press conference today held at the FBI's Los Angeles Field Office, Senator Alex Padilla was detained by members of the U.S. Secret Service assigned to Secretary Noem's detail when he became disruptive while formal remarks were being delivered,' the FBI said. 'Secret Service Agents were assisted by FBI Police who are in Los Angeles at this time. Senator Padilla was not wearing his Senate security pin; however, was subsequently positively identified and released.' Oliver O'Connell12 June 2025 21:54 'Missing' poster for mother 'abducted by ICE' seen in downtown LA Noah Goldberg, City Hall correspondent for The Los Angeles Times, posted a picture of a 'Missing' poster supposedly for a mother, in the U.S. legally, who was 'abducted by ICE.' Oliver O'Connell12 June 2025 21:51 Ken Martin, the chair of the Democratic National Committee, joined in the criticism of what he called 'the sickening assault' on Senator Alex Padilla. Ken Martin, the chair of the Democratic National Committee, has also decried 'the sickening assault' on Sen. Alex Padilla, adding that 'Trump is out of control ... using federal law enforcement to silence those who are exercising their rights.' Here's his full statement: This assault on U.S. Senator Alex Padilla has sent a violent message to all of America: If you dissent against Donald Trump and openly disagree with the government, then you are not safe in our country. It doesn't matter if you are a duly elected official — if you ask questions, if you stand up to Trump and Kristi Noem's abuse of power, then government thugs will come after you. Make no mistake: This horrifying escalation of violence is straight out of an authoritarian playbook. Trump is a weak man, yet he's desperate to look strong as more Americans become enraged by the chaos he's inciting in California. His dangerous approach to immigration enforcement stokes fear, profiles Black and Brown communities, rips families apart, and sows violence. Trump is out of control. He's now using federal law enforcement to silence those who are exercising their rights. This has nothing to do with law and order — it's a disgusting abuse of power. Oliver O'Connell12 June 2025 21:46 Court hearing over Trump's use of the National Guard to help with immigration raids begins The court hearing over President Donald Trump's use of the National Guard to help with immigration raids in California has begun. The courtroom is packed and spills into an overflow room. U.S. District Judge Charles Breyer opened by saying, 'The issues are extremely significant.' He said he intends to act 'expeditiously.' Oliver O'Connell12 June 2025 21:46 Reports: Stephen Miller's meeting with ICE officials was spark for LA protests White House aide Stephen Miller has repeatedly branded the Los Angeles protests an 'insurrection' after fierce backlash to immigration raids. California 's leadership is now 'siding with insurrectionist mobs,' and Democratic officials are 'in open rebellion' against the government, according to Miller. But the far-right architect of Donald Trump's anti-immigration agenda appears to have himself lit the fuse, after reportedly rallying Immigration and Customs Enforcement officials to 'just go out there and arrest illegal aliens.' Alex Woodward reports. Trump's anti-immigration architect reportedly told ICE to 'just go out there and arrest aliens' Oliver O'Connell12 June 2025 21:38 Raskin decries Padilla restraint as 'affront to democracy' Rep. Jamie Raskin says of the restraint and handcuffing of Sen. Alex Padilla in Los Angeles: 'The brutal handcuffing of Senator Padilla is an affront to democracy. I'm joining House Democrats to march to Senator Thune's office and to demand that he protect his Colleagues from this out-of-control authoritarian onslaught.'
BreakingNews.ie
an hour ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Combs' lawyer complains about secrecy as famous rapper's name goes unmentioned
A lawyer for Sean 'Diddy' Combs protested at the rising tide of secrecy at the hip-hop star's federal sex trafficking and racketeering trial on Thursday, after Combs and the public were excluded from lengthy arguments over whether another famous rapper's name could be disclosed. Defence lawyer Marc Agnifilo complained to Judge Arun Subramanian after Combs was left out of an hour-long meeting in a private room outside the New York court, where lawyers and the judge discussed a hotel room 'event' in January 2024. Advertisement That meeting added a two-hour delay to the start of the sixth and final day of evidence from a woman identified in court only by the pseudonym 'Jane', who dated Combs from 2001 until his arrest last September. Combs, 55, has pleaded not guilty to charges that carry a potential prison sentence of 15 years to life in prison if he is convicted. Prosecutors say he used his fame, fortune, violence and threats to manipulate girlfriends into sex with paid sex workers in multi-day events that they later said they regretted. Defence lawyers say the government is trying to prosecute consensual sex between adults. Advertisement Under cross-examination, Jane said on Thursday that she flew to Las Vegas in January 2023 with a famous rapper and his girlfriend. Defence lawyer Teny Geragos did not identify the rapper, but asked Jane if he was 'an individual at the top of the music industry as well, an icon in the music industry?' 'Yes,' Jane replied. Once in Las Vegas, Jane said, she went with a group including the rapper to dinner, a strip club and then a hotel room party, where a sex worker had sex with a woman while half a dozen others in the room watched. Advertisement She said there was dancing in the room and the rapper said, 'hey beautiful', and told her that he had always wanted to have sex with her. Jane said she did not recall exactly when she did it, but said she flashed her breasts in the room as she danced. The evidence came soon after the closed-door session on Thursday, when lawyers discussed what facts could be disclosed about the hotel room encounter. Mr Agnifilo said the need for a public trial was 'an important issue, a constitutional issue' and objected to so much happening out of the earshot of his client. Advertisement In response, the judge offered more secrecy, saying: 'If your client wishes to be heard, we can clear this courtroom if need be to address it.' Sean 'Diddy' Combs in Los Angeles in 2022 (Richard Shotwell/Invision/AP) Mr Agnifilo turned down the offer. 'Part of the reason trials are fully public is so if other people realise they know something about an event discussed in a public courtroom, they can come forward and share their recollection of it,' the lawyer said. He added: 'That is kind of the practical side of the constitutional right to a public trial.' Advertisement A monitor that is used to show exhibits to spectators has been shut off throughout Jane's evidence, although lawyers, the judge, Combs and jurors can view them. Some sidebar conversations between lawyers and the judge during the evidence have been sealed. The judge also has banned the public from viewing any exhibits containing sexual content, even though the defence has said images from the group sex episodes proves they were consensual acts between adults, and not proof of crimes. And many of the letters to the judge from lawyers each day are filed under seal, preventing the public from quickly knowing, for instance, the grounds under which prosecutors are trying to get a black juror ejected from the jury in mid-trial. The judge has said he will rule on the request on Friday. Defence lawyer Alexandra Shapiro has called the prosecution's effort a 'thinly veiled effort to dismiss a black juror'. Jane and Casandra 'Cassie' Ventura, who gave evidence for four days in the trial's first week about her relationship with Combs from 2007 to 2018, both said they took part in the sex marathons for years, with Cassie calling them 'freak-off' nights and Jane referring to them as 'hotel nights'. Mr Agnifilo said the defence consented to Jane giving evidence with a pseudonym but did not consent to other events related to her evidence and the evidence of other witnesses not being public. Assistant US attorney Maureen Comey attacked Mr Agnifilo's rationale for disclosing more information publicly with the risk that it would be easier for someone to guess Jane's identity, saying it was an 'attempt to harass and intimidate this witness'.
