Mental health law 'won't stop detentions'
Campaigners are warning that a new mental health law covering Wales will not reduce the "unnecessary" detention of disabled people in secure hospitals.Health is the responsibility of the Senedd but the Welsh government is relying on a Westminster bill to improve how people with learning disabilities and autism are supported during a crisis.Welsh disability rights campaigners were among those who staged a protest in Westminster against what they say are significant shortcomings in UK Labour's Mental Health Bill.The UK government said the proposed law "will ensure people get the support they need in the community".
An independent review in 2018 found that "too often" the "outdated system" was being used to detain disabled and autistic people for lengthy periods, often due to a lack of community support.The UK government wants to change the law so that disabled and autistic people cannot be detained under the act in most circumstances, unless they have a co-occurring mental health disorder.It said the numbers were "unacceptable" but insisted that the reforms it was proposing would ensure that more people are treated in the community.
Campaigners say the proposals will only have a limited impact on the numbers being detained, unless additional support is also provided in the community.Dawn Cavanagh, from Hook, Pembrokeshire, founder of the Stolen Lives campaign, told BBC Wales that she believed people would still be detained via other laws including the Mental Capacity Act.She added: "People with learning disabilities often end up in hospitals because there's a breakdown in housing and community care and it's the only place they can go."So, if that community care isn't there, there is nowhere for them to go and they'll still be detained."
Her concerns were echoed by Sophie Hinksman, a 39-year-old woman with fetal alcohol syndrome who was sectioned in 2016 after her mental health declined.She said she will "probably never get over" the trauma of being detained, which she believes could have been avoided if she'd been given more effective help in the community.Ms Hinksman, from Pembrokeshire, said: "If I'd got the right support at home and somebody to... reassure me everything should have been okay."The Welsh government said that 135 people with a learning disability are being treated in specialised inpatient services in Wales but it disagrees people are "systematically detained inappropriately".In England, NHS figures show over 2,000 people with learning disabilities or autism are being held as hospital inpatients, and about half of them have been detained for over 2 years, which the UK government said was "unacceptable".
Disability rights groups, including People First Wales, have also accused UK ministers of refusing to meet with them to discuss concerns about the bill.People First Wales chief executive, Joe Powell, said: "There are too many policies being written and implemented by people who don't really understand what they mean to the people who need them."Welsh government sources previously said they were adopting the UK's Mental Health Bill to avoid a "fragmented approach", with different policies in Wales and England.But earlier this month, the Senedd's legislation, justice and constitution committee said this had the effect of "sidelining the Senedd" and limiting the Welsh Parliament's scrutiny of the bill.
'Unacceptable'
A Department of Health and Social Care spokesperson said: "The number of autistic people and people with a learning disability in mental health hospitals is unacceptable."Through our proposed reforms to the Mental Health Act, we will ensure people get the support they need in the community, closer to home, improving care and keeping people out of hospitals."We welcome stakeholders' contributions, including through the public consultation, and will engage further as the bill progresses through Parliament."A Welsh government spokesperson said: "We take the care of vulnerable people very seriously and are committed to reducing the number of people with a learning disability who are housed in hospital."We do not agree that people with learning disabilities are being systematically detained inappropriately in mental health units. When this does happen, it is vitally important they receive appropriate care, which includes a care plan that is reviewed regularly and options around future accommodation are fully considered."Health boards and local authorities continue to work to ensure suitable accommodation is provided in communities to facilitate step-down provision for those leaving inpatient accommodation."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Statesman
36 minutes ago
- New Statesman
Labour's unlikely strategy for beating Reform
Photo by Chris Ratcliffe/Bloomberg via Getty Images It's April. It's a few weeks to the Runcorn and Helsby by-election. Organisers know it's tight. Activists know it's tight. Some estates and a few villages are looking good for Labour. Others are looking dreadful. The Labour campaign is searching for a winning strategy. Keir Starmer is not to be found. Labour threw a lot of strategies at the Runcorn and Helsby by-election. But one stays with me. As the activists piled in for their morning briefings before taking to the doors, the advice was simple, and surprising: 'Don't say Reform.' Instead, campaigners were encouraged to ask what voters on the doorsteps thought of Nigel Farage himself. But why elevate Farage, some wondered. Why even mention his name? Activists discarded the advice immediately, adamant they knew better. But others saw the sense. Counterintuitively, it's a sound strategy. And there is public data to talk about it. Reform is polling in the lead right now. And the local elections prove it: the party didn't just win the coastal region of Lincolnshire, or Ashfield in Nottinghamshire, it won in what were traditional Con-Lab battlegrounds. Projecting what these numbers would mean in a General Election is a fool's errand. First past the post is not made for four/five party politics. So Reform could win as few as 150 seats in the House of Commons. Or as many as 350. That's where we are right now. But Nigel Farage, who polls better than anyone for voter favourability, is floundering on one key metric. He trails as a prime minister in waiting. Britain needs Reform? Yes, say most voters. But does Britain need Farage? There is surprising reluctance. Survation and YouGov have both done the polling and while Reform has party poll leads, Keir Starmer still – somehow – leads the country as the public's preferred prime minister. Subscribe to The New Statesman today from only £8.99 per month Subscribe This all exposes something critical: Farage struggles on the question of officialdom. He is the Wat Tyler of our time. He speaks for the many. He speaks for the rabble. But the many do not see him becoming one of the chosen few. Did the peasantry wish to elevate Mr Tyler to Kingship? Which brings us to the Labour strategy. Farage is both a strength and a curse for Reform. The more the voters and media take Reform and Farage seriously, the more the voters will have to give consideration to the rising reality that Reform and Farage may very well form the next government. This is a weak point for the party. 'Don't say Reform. Say Farage.' Reform is a sentiment. It arouses sympathy. Farage has his fans. But he has his detractors. Prompting him on the doorstep could concentrate voters' minds in a way 'it's us or Reform' doesn't. 'It's this government or reform' – the results write themselves. But 'it's us or Farage' – now that's a strategy. [See more: Nigel Farage chases the Welsh dragon] Related
ITV News
2 hours ago
- ITV News
Wales' poverty crisis deepening as more than 1 in 5 living in hardship, new report reveals
Poverty in Wales is deepening, according to a new report from the Joseph Rowntree Foundation (JRF) and the Bevan Foundation. The study also claims there has been little progress in reducing poverty in Wales over the past 20 years, with poverty rates remaining at around 21–22%. According to the 'Poverty in Wales' report, published on Tuesday, more than 1 in 5 people in Wales (22%) – which is around 700,000 people – are living in poverty. Of these, 400,000 are working-age adults (21%), 200,000 are children (31%) and 100,000 are pensioners (16%). The report warns that if no action is taken, child poverty in Wales could reach 34% by 2029-30, which would make it the highest rate of all UK nations. The highest child poverty rates by local authority are Blaenau Gwent (34%), Merthyr Tydfil, Ceredigion and Newport (32%), and the Isle of Anglesey and Pembrokeshire (31%). The Welsh Government says it is determined to do all it can to prevent people from going into poverty and to help those who need support the most. The findings also reveal that nearly half a million people in Wales lived in deep poverty in 2020-23, with 310,000 in very deep poverty. Households below 50% of the median household income are defined as living in deep poverty and those living below 40% are defined as being in very deep poverty. Dr Victoria Winckler, Director at the Bevan Foundation, said: "It is shocking that there has been no progress reducing poverty in Wales in the last twenty years. "Even worse, more people are in deep poverty than ever before, forced to use food banks, unable to heat their homes, watching every penny. 'The report shows that the root causes are many years of cuts to social security coupled with a severe shortage of decent jobs and affordable housing. The steps taken by the Welsh Government to alleviate poverty are welcome, but there is much more to do. 'As political parties gear up for the next Senedd election, we urge them to commit to practical, deliverable action to end poverty." Chris Birt, JRF Associate Director for Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland said: "Deepening poverty and a child poverty rate of almost one in three in Wales should be a stark wake up call to both the UK Government and all parties aspiring to form the next Welsh Government. "The Senedd has significant powers that contribute to improving people in Wales's standard of living. Driving down costs, better connecting communities, providing affordable housing and breaking down barriers to employment are all things they can do to reduce poverty. 'But the scale of the challenge needs to be met by the scale of the response. The same is of course true of the UK Government. The threadbare social security system is their responsibility, and it drives much hardship. A good place to start reversing that would be casting the two-child limit into history as quickly as possible. 'There is much work to be done by both the Welsh and UK Governments, but the prize is a Wales where people are able to explore their potential and be free from hardship – something that is miles from reality for far too many people today.' In response to the report, the Welsh Government says it recognises that it is a "challenging time" for many children, families and communities in Wales, and is determined to do all it can to prevent people from going into poverty and help those who need support the most. A Welsh Government spokesperson said: "Our commitment is backed by substantial investment of nearly £7bn between 2022-2026 to reduce costs and maximise incomes for Welsh families. "Our child poverty strategy sets out how we will use the levers we have to deliver against our ambitious objectives to support families most in need. "We will continue to call for positive changes in social security policy to tackle child poverty, particularly seeking a commitment to end the two child benefit rule."
South Wales Argus
2 hours ago
- South Wales Argus
How has the Heads of the Valleys road helped communities?
The Bevan Foundation and the Taxpayers Alliance have come to radically different conclusions on the project. Work concluded in May this year, at an official cost of £1.4bn. The road's dualling of the A465 section was conducted by Welsh Government and cost some £500 million. The complex project ran over budget. The ambitious sections between Gilwern and Brynmawr, running through the deep Clydach Gorge, delayed the project by three years and inflated costs by nearly£150 million. Welsh Think tank The Bevan Foundation, attempting to make sense of the Welsh Government's brake on road building and squaring it with the costs of the mega-investment, concluded the road means yet more investment across the whole area, which is essential to upskill the population and drive growth. In its report, the foundation concluded that much of the poor land and poor built environment needed upgrading, training and skills needs to be led by the Welsh Government and local authorities. By just building a road that has few users in a deindustrialised area, the whole region could be stuck in what economists call the Middle-Income Trap, where countries just reassemble complex goods and add little value and create few high-skilled jobs. Meanwhile, the Taxpayers' Alliance questioned the Welsh Government's whole 'muddled' approach to transport and development. Thay argue it isn't even whether the road cost £1.4 billion or £2 billion, due to a 'dissembling bureaucracy.' They warn Wales needs to learn lessons or it will become saddled with a series of 'sunk cost fallacies.' A spokesman for the group said: "While Welsh taxpayers will be relieved to see roadworks finally completed, they will be aghast at enormous costs and absurd time it has taken to get the project over the line.' Mocking the outcome of a 50mph road after 23 years and a fortune spent, the group said: "Twenty three years and billions spent - upgrading a single stretch of road while essential infrastructure maintenance in other parts of Wales has been ignored! "Ministers in Cardiff need to get their act together and ensure that future projects are kept on time and within budget!" Welsh Government was approached for a comment. They said they will unveil their vision for development of the area surrounding the road network on Thursday, June 12. The Bevan Foundation's report is called A Route to Prosperity.
