
Complexities of Balochistan
Listen to article
Mehrang Langov is in jail. She was arrested while inspecting the dead bodies recovered after the Jaffar Express operation that killed hundreds, including innocent men, women, and children, alongside scores of security personnel. According to state media, she stormed into the hospital to claim the bodies, defying the image of a so-called pacifist.
For years, Mehrang has been at the forefront of protests against enforced disappearances, something that she and many in Balochistan believe is part of a state policy aimed at suppressing the separatist movement. This movement, simmering since decades, has grown increasingly violent over the past decade. While Mehrang presents herself as a human rights activist, Pakistan's state institutions see her as a pawn in the hands of foreign forces, particularly India.
She has been accused of supporting the Balochistan Liberation Army (BLA), a group that has not only waged war against the state but has also slaughtered thousands of innocent people, particularly those of Punjabi origin. She has also openly backed the Pashtun Tahaffuz Movement (PTM) despite its known anti-Pakistan rhetoric and activities. Repeatedly asked in media interviews to condemn the BLA and PTM, Mehrang has consistently dodged the question, instead doubling down on the narrative of enforced disappearances.
The question arises: whose bodies was she looking for at the morgue? Were they passengers, personal acquaintances, or fellow members of the Baloch Yakjehti Council (BYC), which she leads? Why was she so concerned about retrieving them? According to state sources, the bodies Mehrang sought to claim belonged to BLA militants killed in the Jaffar Express ambush. If she insists that these individuals were linked to her and the BYC, does that not imply an implicit endorsement of their violence? If, in her view, the state's alleged "kill and dump" policy is unacceptable, then why does she not extend the same moral standard to terrorist organisations?
It is undeniable that the state's heavy-handed response to the grievances of the people of Balochistan has, at times, exacerbated the crisis. When Baloch families marched to Islamabad in 2023 seeking answers about their missing loved ones, their concerns should have been met with dialogue rather than force. A more diplomatic approach, one balancing "carrot and stick", could have prevented the situation from reaching this point, where even terrorists are being painted as victims.
However, it is also essential to dismantle the false victimhood narrative surrounding Mehrang Langov. Contrary to claims that she was deprived of educational opportunities, Mehrang, a doctor by profession, received her degree from Bolan Medical College on a full scholarship. The story that her mother had to sell her clothes to raise a meager Rs5,000 annual fee is nothing but a fabrication designed to bolster the illusion of systematic oppression. Balochistan, like the rest of Pakistan, has undeniable educational challenges, but the claim that Baloch youth are entirely deprived of opportunities is misleading.
The very activists leading the BYC today — educated, articulate and well-versed in political discourse — received their education in Pakistan, not in India, Afghanistan, or the West. If they now stand against the state, it is not because they were denied education but because separatist elements have hijacked their cause.
The BLA of today bears little resemblance to the separatist movement of the early 2000s. It has devolved into a terrorist outfit, run by thugs rather than ideologues. If their real concern was the well-being of the Baloch people, why would they sabotage CPEC? Why would they attack passenger trains and buses carrying innocent civilians? Why would they keep Balochistan in a perpetual state of violence, suffocating its economic potential under the pretext of resistance? The BLA's actions have only worsened the very conditions they claim to oppose.
Pakistan's federal structure is not without fault, but it is essential to ask: who truly holds the power in Balochistan? The province has long been controlled by feudal lords and tribal chieftains, who perpetuate a cycle of exploitation. Elections, governance, and even insurgency revolve around the same elite families. One tribal chief wins an election and enters the assembly. His rival? His own brother. Meanwhile, another family member leads an armed rebellion against the state. They control both power and insurgency, ensuring that no real progress is ever made — only the common people of Balochistan continue to suffer.
When BLA terrorists recruit Baloch daughters and sisters for suicide bombings, Akhtar Mengal remains silent. His sudden decision to use the "women's rights" card for a so-called Long March is nothing more than a desperate attempt to revive his dwindling political career.
Despite the complexities, Balochistan's problems cannot be solved through brute force alone. The province needs a genuine healing touch, one that emerges from within its own sociopolitical framework. Someone from within the warring factions must take the lead in dousing the flames of separatism before the propaganda becomes too deeply entrenched to counter.
Mehrang Langov and others like her are doing no service to Balochistan or Pakistan. Instead, they are acting as useful instruments in the hands of foreign powers intent on destabilising the country. If Balochistan is to progress, it must first identify its real oppressors - not in Islamabad, but within its own feudal hierarchy.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Express Tribune
3 days ago
- Express Tribune
Sindh bans 4-seater rickshaws; amends vehicle registration rules
Sindh government on Friday approved a ban on four-seater rickshaws and online as well as on the counter sale of tinted windows, police lights, and sirens. The meeting chaired by Home Minister Ziaul Hassan Lanjar discussed amendments to the Motor Vehicles Rules also approved outsourcing the motor vehicle fitness check. IGP Sindh, and secretaries of law, transport and mass transit, excise and taxation, along with the DIG traffic were present in the meeting. They approved mandatory fitness certification for commercial and non-commercial vehicles, It was decided that a draft would be prepared and submitted to the government for approval and ratification of the amendments. Participants approved a complete ban on four-seater rickshaws, and decided to make it mandatory for water tankers and dumpers to install trackers and sensors. Minister Lanjar stated that third party services will be engaged to issue fitness certificates to commercial and non-commercial vehicles, with formal Memoranda of Understanding (MoUs) signed with them. Violation fines were also approved, including Rs200,000 fined for wrong-way driving of government vehicles, Rs25,000 for motorcyclists driving against traffic, and Rs100,000 for four-wheelers violating one-way rules. Motorcyclists driving without a license are to be fined Rs25,000, while car drivers are to be fined Rs50,000 for the violation. Meanwhile, first-time offenders of one-wheeling or drifting are to be fined Rs100,000, increasing to Rs200,000 and Rs300,000 for repeat offenses. Minister Lanjar also approved the installation of at least five cameras in heavy/load-carrying vehicles. Additionally, e-challans for traffic violations will be delivered to vehicle owners' registered home addresses, and vehicles with unpaid fines will not be approved for sale or transfer. The minister further stated that the traffic, transport, and excise systems will now be interlinked and operated online, while a dedicated Traffic Magistrate will be appointed to handle traffic law violation cases. Excise Minister Mukesh Kumar Chawala assured the department's full support in enforcing traffic regulations and emphasised that no registration or route permit will be issued to four-seater or larger rickshaws, and a crackdown will be launched against any such vehicles on the roads. He further stated that all organisational steps to establish the vehicle fitness service structure will be completed promptly, after which strict enforcement of fitness requirements will follow.


Express Tribune
3 days ago
- Express Tribune
Five AVLC cops held for kidnapping
Malir Cantt police raided the Anti-Vehicle Lifting Cell (AVLC) office in Khawaja Ajmer Nagri, rescuing an abductee and arresting five AVLC personnel, including a sub-inspector. Reportedly, the victim, Madad Ali, had gone missing from near his residence in Bilawal Jokhio Goth. After failing to locate him, his family registered a complaint at the police station. Then, acting on intelligence, police raided the AVLC office and recovered Madad Ali, who had been detained on the station's rooftop for three days. The arrested personnel were identified as Constables Abdul Ghaffar, Riyaz, Khalid, Naeem, and Sub-Inspector Rashid Ali. They allegedly demanded a ransom of Rs500,000 from the victim's family for his release. Another individual reportedly involved was also taken into custody. During interrogation, the officers confessed to keeping the victim in illegal detention and attempting to extort ransom money. Further investigations are ongoing.


Express Tribune
3 days ago
- Express Tribune
Only 14% MNAs attend all sittings of 16th NA session
Two supplementary resolutions were adopted by the house which were about paying tributes to the sacrifices of the armed forces on Defence Day and condemning terrorism in Quetta and Mardan. PHOTO: FAFEN The 16th session of the National Assembly that spanned over 13 sittings between May 5 and 22, 2025, saw only 14% members making 100% attendance, while 9% of the members were absent during the entire session, the Free and Fair Election Network (FAFEN) said in its report on Thursday. Fafen is a civil society network focused on strengthening democracy. It said in its latest report that consistent with the previous sessions, female attendance was generally higher than that of their male counterparts during the session last month. "The highest attendance was recorded during the first sitting, with 237 members (76%) present. During this sitting, the House suspended its regular agenda to discuss the recent Pakistan-India conflict," the report said. The lowest attendance was recorded during the last sitting, with 174 members (55%) present. This sitting was initially adjourned after just 13 minutes because of the lack of quorum. The House reconvened after 15 minutes and passed The Off the Grid (Captive Power Plants) Levy Bill, 2025. Fafen said that 150 members of the National Assembly (MNAs) skipped sittings without advance leave request; 118 (44%) submitted a leave application, including 25 (21%) in advance and 37 (31%) applied ex-post facto after returning from their leave. It added that 268 members (86%) missed at least one sitting during the current session. The report said that 16 female MNAs, including 14 on reserved seats, attended all the sittings, while five female MNAs, including two on the reserved seats, recorded zero attendance. Region-wise, Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa and Islamabad Capital Territory lawmakers recorded the highest percentage of MNAs attending more than half of the sittings, it said, adding that majority of lawmakers from the SIC, the PML-N, the JUI, and independents attended more than half of the sittings. A lack of ministerial presence weakened legislative oversight, Fafen said in the report. Among the 29 federal ministers, who were expected to be present during the Question Hour to respond to queries from lawmakers, only 15 (52%) were marked present during the sittings.