Primary school deputy head who bit and scratched child avoids teaching ban
A primary school deputy headteacher has been allowed to continue working in the profession after she bit, slapped and scratched a child.
Claire Herbert, who worked at the Red Rose Primary School in Chester-le-Street, County Durham, got into an argument with the girl that became physical on June 18 2022, leaving the child with reddening and bruises on her skin, according to a Teaching Regulation Agency (TRA) tribunal.
When visited by a police officer three days later, the girl said the teacher had caused two bite marks to her hand and head, scratched her with false nails and called her fat.
Photographs of the child's injuries showed various red marks, scratches and bruising to various parts of her body, including her face, neck, leg and hand, the tribunal heard.
The incident took place outside the education setting where there appeared to be alcohol involved.
In an email responding to the incident in October last year, Miss Herbert said: 'I have read and considered the attached paperwork and I will admit to all allegations listed although it is a blur.'
She had worked at the school since April 2019 and also held the role of deputy safeguarding lead, the tribunal heard.
Miss Herbert accepted a conditional police caution in December 2022 for the offence of common assault on the child.
A TRA panel found the teacher guilty of unacceptable professional conduct that could bring the profession into disrepute.
But it stopped short of recommending a permanent banning order for Miss Herbert as she 'otherwise appeared to have an unblemished record'.
'The panel was mindful that this was an isolated incident which it considered, taking into account the mitigating circumstances and wider context, sat at the less serious end of the possible spectrum of severity,' it said.
'The panel took account of the mitigating factors that were present and the contribution Miss Herbert had made, and could continue to make, to the education sector.'
A number of character references provided to the panel commented positively on Miss Herbert's abilities as a teacher and that she normally demonstrated high standards of personal and professional conduct.
Miss Herbert, who also sustained injuries from the incident, had shown 'genuine and significant regret, remorse and insight' for her conduct and had been honest about what happened, the panel said.
Decision maker Marc Cavey, acting on behalf of the Education Secretary, said: 'In my judgment, the extent of the insight and remorse demonstrated by Miss Herbert, when considered alongside the isolated nature of the misconduct found and the mitigating circumstances that were present, means that there is only a very limited risk of the repetition of this behaviour.
'I have therefore given this element considerable weight in reaching my decision.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
44 minutes ago
- The Independent
Body found in search for missing woman Reanne Coulson
Police officers searching for missing Reanne Coulson have found a body, with a man also charged with murder. The 34-year-old was last seen in Coventry in May, with her family becoming increasingly concerned she failed to make contact with them on her birthday on June 17. West Midlands Police said officers searching for Ms Coulson found a body in Binley Woods on Friday afternoon. A force spokesman said formal identification will need to take place, but the family of Ms Coulson have been informed. Mohammed Durnion was arrested as part of the investigation into her disappearance and has now been charged with murder. The 42-year-old will appear at Coventry Magistrates' Court on Saturday. A second man has also been charged with assisting an offender, police said. Adam Moore, 38, from Coventry, will appear before the same court on Saturday. Detective Superintendent Jim Munro, from the force's major crime unit, said: 'We've been focused on doing all we can to find Reanne and our thoughts remain with her family at this deeply distressing time. 'While formal identification still needs to take place, we do believe it is Reanne. 'We've charged a man with murder, and another for assisting an offender, but our inquiries to establish exactly what happened and why are ongoing. 'We'll continue to update and support Reanne's family.' Ms Coulson's older brother Ashley would like to thank the public for everything they have done to help find her, police said. He has asked that the family are left alone to grieve. A dedicated website has been set up where information can be given at or you can call 101 quoting log 6621 of June 18. Information can also be given anonymously via the independent charity Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111.
Sky News
an hour ago
- Sky News
Mylo Capilla: Body found in search for 13-year-old boy believed to have entered the River Tees
A body has been discovered in the search for a missing 13-year-old boy thought to have entered the River Tees. A major operation was under way on Friday to find Mylo Capilla, as police appealed for information. The 13-year-old boy was last seen at around 9pm on Thursday in an area known as the "Muddies" in the Teeside town of Ingleby Barwick, near the River Tees. Cleveland Police said on Friday evening that a boy's body had been found. "Very sadly, police and partner agencies searching the river for 13-year-old Mylo Capilla at Ingleby Barwick have found the body of a boy," officers said. "Whilst formal identification has yet to take place, Mylo's parents have been informed and they continue to be supported by specially trained officers. "All our thoughts are with Mylo's family and friends as well as with the wider community at this extremely difficult time." Earlier, police said they thought Mylo had gone with his friend to the river near Ramsey Gardens and entered the water. An extensive search was carried out, involving specialist teams using a police drone and dogs. Officers also had support from Cleveland Fire Brigade, National Police Air Service, as well as marine and mountain rescue teams. The Muddies was described by one local as a large area stretching along the riverbank and was a known place for children and young people to play.
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Record number of rare hen harriers killed or missing in the past five years, RSPB warns
Record numbers of hen harriers have been killed or gone missing under suspicious circumstances in the last five years, according to the RSPB. The protected bird species is one of the rarest in the UK, known for their acrobatic 'skydancing' courtship display over the uplands, such as Forest of Bowland in Lancashire and the Yorkshire Dales. A total of 102 the protected birds of prey were illegally killed or went missing between 2020 and 2024 – mostly in areas where grouse shooting takes place, the RSPB says. Some hen harriers were shot and their chicks being stamped on, while others were poisoned or illegally trapped, according to the charity. In Scotland, grouse moors are licensed, and conservationists have repeatedly pressured Westminster governments to do the same. When Labour was in opposition, it indicated that it would consider licensing grouse shooting in England. MPs are due on Monday to debate calls for a ban on driven grouse shooting after a petition launched by campaign group Wild Justice attracted more than 100,000 names. But in its response, the government said it had no plans for a ban. It said: 'Well-managed grouse shooting can be an important part of a local rural economy, providing direct and indirect employment.' The RSPB's report, called Hen Harriers in the Firing Line, highlights a strong overlap between deaths of the bird of prey and the extent of grouse moors. A recent study of illegal killings found that survival rates were unusually low, with birds surviving for an average of just 121 days after leaving the nest. Persecution accounts for 75 per cent of deaths in birds aged between one and two years. Hen harriers, a red-listed species that breeds in Britain's uplands, is the most persecuted bird of prey in the UK for its population and numbers are heading towards local extinction, the wildlife charity says. Numerous studies confirm that illegal killing limits their recovery. But no one in England has ever been convicted of killing one because most kills happen in remote areas and a criminal burden of proof near-impossible to secure, campaigners say. James Robinson, of the RSPB, said: 'This species will not recover until the criminal activity stops, and for this to happen we need regulation of the grouse shooting industry – specifically the introduction of a licensing system for shoots in England, so estates proven by the police and Natural England to be linked to raptor persecution would lose their licence to operate.' Andrew Gilruth, chief executive of the Moorland Association, disputed the RSPB report, saying the data has been assembled without independent checks and that the allegations 'poison perceptions of gamekeepers'. The British Association for Shooting and Conservation said the report presented 'unproven allegations as evidence'. Its statement said: 'Proposals for a licensing system based on a civil burden of proof risk punishing the law-abiding without due process. 'Instead, we support constructive, evidence-led solutions such as Natural England's Hen Harrier Action Plan.' A Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs spokesperson said: "Hen harriers are a rare and precious feature of our national landscapes. 'It's why through our work with the National Wildlife Crime Unit, the Hen Harrier Taskforce is using innovative technology such as drones and specialised detection dogs to help tackle illegal persecution.'
