Children's Health Ireland may be merged into HSE following recent controversies
Minister for Health
Jennifer Carroll MacNeill
is actively considering subsuming
Children's Health Ireland
(CHI) into the
Health Service Executive
(HSE) following recent controversies at the operator of paediatric healthcare in the State, The Irish Times understands.
CHI was established in 2019 to govern and operate paediatric services in Ireland, and currently operates Temple Street, Crumlin and Tallaght hospitals. Upon completion, it will operate the new
National Children's Hospital
.
However, there have been a number of issues in the hospital in recent years, including the
implantation of unapproved springs into children with scoliosis
; the threshold for
hip surgeries
; and surgical outcomes for children in the orthopaedic service.
Sources have said there is a 'lack of confidence' in the body in light of these issues, with senior Government and healthcare figures expressing concern about the organisation's ability to run the new children's hospital in its current format.
READ MORE
Four members of the board have resigned
over the past week – Mary Cryan, Dr Gavin Lavery, Brigid McManus and Catherine Guy. This follows the resignation of board chairman Jim Browne last month.
Ms Carroll MacNeill said she has moved to strengthen the governance and oversight at CHI and will appoint two members of the HSE board to that of CHI.
In relation to the vacancies created by the recent resignations, the Minister told RTÉ she 'will be looking to make similar appointments over the next number of days'.
'Further measures are also under consideration,' the minister said in a statement. Several sources have confirmed the measures include subsuming CHI into the HSE.
The takeover would be supported by the HSE, with
Bernard Gloster
, chief executive of the body, at the weekend stating this option 'has to be' one of the moves considered.
This is not the first time the takeover has been considered by Government.
Last December, The Irish Times reported that then Minister for Health
Stephen Donnelly sought legal advice
on the powers available if the State considered it had to take over the operation of children's services.
It is understood the legal advice was that such a direct intervention could only take place if an independent review identified serious governance or other failings.
Since then, the
Health Information and Quality Authority
published an independent report on the implantation of non-surgical springs into three children with scoliosis in Temple Street hospital.
[
Watchdog report to criticise surgeon over use of unauthorised springs in spinal operations
Opens in new window
]
The report found the use of these springs were 'wrong' and the systems in place in CHI meant 'children were not protected from the risk of harm'.
An independent audit published last Friday found that almost 500 children who underwent hip operations in two hospitals should be recalled, as close to 70 per cent of the sample of operations examined in these healthcare facilities were not necessary.
[
Hip surgery audit: Almost 70% of operations in two children's hospitals 'unnecessary'
Opens in new window
]
The audit examined only 147 cases over three years – 2021 to 2023 – and a wider inquiry into the issue will be commenced.
Another report, by UK expert Selvadurai Nayagam, is also being conducted into paediatric orthopaedic surgery service at CHI Temple St, CHI Crumlin, the National Orthopaedic Hospital, Cappagh, and other relevant sites in Dublin. This report has not yet been completed.
Following the publication of the audit, CHI chief executive Lucy Nugent said the organisation is 'currently standardising care across all CHI sites, so all children receive the same high-quality treatment no matter where they are seen'.
Mr Gloster said the audit findings 'raise significant concern', adding that the HSE will 'now oversee the implementation of the recommendations and the comprehensive response by way of follow up with the children that the recommendations outlined in this report are implemented in full'.
Separately, the Minister has also written to the CHI Board seeking an action plan in relation to an internal unpublished report concerning a
consultant who allegedly referred public patients to his private clinics
.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
42 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Man caught with child sex abuse and anime images on hard-drive avoids jail
A Co Donegal man caught with child sex abuse and anime images on a hard-drive has avoided jail. John Sweeney (60) appeared at Letterkenny Circuit Court on Wednesday where he pleaded guilty to possession of the images when his house at Dore, Bunbeg was raided by gardaí on July 24th, 2019. Det Garda Enda Jennings and Michelle Kelly were acting on information forwarded by the Garda National Protective Services Bureau. It followed information they received that a user had uploaded child pornography from an internet account traced to Sweeney. READ MORE Gardaí visited the house and seized three mobile phones and a hard-drive. All the images, including a total of 139 child abuse images and 94 anime images – a style of Japanese film and TV animation – were found on the hard-drive. He was arrested and taken to Milford Garda station where he co-operated and told gardaí he had been going through a difficult time and was drinking heavily. The court heard Sweeney lived alone and had no previous convictions. However, because of a backlog in investigating such cases around the country at the time, it wasn't until November 2023 that a plea could be made. A number for the One in Four counselling service was given to Sweeney and he went about getting counselling. Barrister for the accused, Patricia McLaughlin, SC McLaughlin said it was not the case that her client shared any of the images and had no great sophisticated knowledge of computers but was accessing adult pornography over a period of time. Child pornography then began to pop up and he developed some curiosity on this, saying her client had an 'unsophisticated fall' into it. A probation service report dated May 29th, 2025, said he was at a low risk of reoffending and noted he has expressed remorse and is aware the images are wrong and was happy to go under the supervision of the service. Ms McLaughlin asked Judge John Aylmer to consider dealing with the offence by way of a non-custodial sentence considering the overall amount of images, the amount of time the accused man had them in his possession – estimated to be two months – and how he came upon the images. Judge Aylmer said on the very early plea and the number of images involved, he placed the offence at the lower end of the scale and one which merited a sentence of two years before mitigation. In mitigation, the judge said Sweeney had no previous convictions, had co-operated fully with gardaí and had entered an early plea. He reduced the sentence to 18 months in prison and accepted the advance by Ms McLaughlin, that there were similarities to another case, the McGinty case. He agreed that this was one of those unusual cases where the court can suspend the entirety of the 18-month sentence and ordered Sweeney to go under the supervision of the probation services.
The 42
an hour ago
- The 42
Galway still leaning on the same few warriors as Micheál Donoghue searches for consistency
BACK IN 2016, when Micheál Donoghue undertook his first tour of duty as Galway manager, the jigsaw pieces were already on the table. The team had come off a second All-Ireland final defeat in four years. Still, the players saw room for improvement, judging by the acrimonious vote of no confidence which put paid to Anthony Cunningham's tenure. They had come close to the mountain top and were now launching a mutiny to climb even higher. For their first league outing, an impressive six-point win over Cork, Donoghue sent out a team featuring a dozen of those beaten finalists of the previous September. Eleven who played that day would feature a year and a half later when Donoghue led Galway to the promised land. This time around, Donoghue returned to the hot seat with seven debutants and a 12-point defeat to Tipperary. What Donoghue witnessed fell far short of the minimum requirements for work rate, which the Clarinbridge native has emphasised at every opportunity across the subsequent four months. Only five of the starting team survived to face Kilkenny the following week. None of the 10 excluded have regained their places in his preferred championship team. However, that game could neither be counted as a turning point nor has progression been linear since then. That 12-point margin of defeat has recurred three more times; against Limerick, Cork, and Kilkenny in consecutive road trips across March and April. In that time, Donoghue has trialled a whopping 57 players, giving game time to 40. The experimentation has continued into championship, particularly in their attack. He called on 29 players in the Leinster round-robin. Galway's defeat to Kilkenny prompted a rethink. Leah Scholes / INPHO Leah Scholes / INPHO / INPHO Compared to their position of strength back in 2017, when they pocketed Liam MacCarthy and the first of four consecutive All-Ireland minor titles in one memorable afternoon, their squad looks callow. Six of those All-Ireland winners remain ever-present cogs. But those minor teams have been slow to produce senior dividends. The first of those champion sides developed the likes of Darach Fahy, Darren Morrissey, Cianan Fahy, Ronan Glennon, and recent debutant Colm Molloy. Of the 2018 victors, however, only Dónal O'Shea has featured at any stage for the Tribesmen this term. Even the transition to U20 hasn't quite worked. They haven't won an All-Ireland at that grade since 2011, and were beaten by double-digits in both finals they've reached in the meantime. Perhaps the defining characteristic of Donoghue's 2017 champions was the combination of size, power, and ball-winning ability, plus the sharp scoring touch, of their forwards. An attack built around Joseph Cooney, Joe Canning, Johnny Glynn, Conor Whelan, Conor Cooney, and Cathal Mannion was an imposing mix for any opponent. Advertisement Currently, Galway have a rotating cast of inside snipers. Declan McLoughlin bagged 2-2 against Kilkenny in the league as a late call-up. The next day, Anthony Burns stepped forward with 2-3 against Clare on his first start. That same evening, Evan Niland nailed 0-9 from 10 shots. Against Offaly, Molloy was a late change for his first start and raised 0-5 from play. They have each been in and out of the team as Donoghue seeks the right mix of grafters and scorers. Making the ball stick is the first imperative. Then, the score-taking comes in. Whelan and Mannion remain the heartbeat of their forward line as the players who best perform both roles. Similarly, Pádraic Mannion and Daithí Burke have filled in as the full-back-line anchors, while David Burke has provided the midfield shield. They still need those warriors to compensate for inexperience elsewhere. Conor Whelan signs autographs after the victory over Dublin. Laszlo Geczo / INPHO Laszlo Geczo / INPHO / INPHO Donoghue pointed to players 'learning the trade' after Dublin pilfered a couple of late goals to take the gloss off an eye-catching result at Parnell Park. Transition and evolution remain part of the vocabulary at this early stage. 'We're still only a short time here and everything is still evolving for us,' he added. 'We're still trying to get the magic number, if you like, of lads in their best positions.' All along, there has been hit-and-miss progress. Where they lost four games by 12 points, they have now taken care of business in the last four by an average margin of 14 points per victory. Where Mannion accounted for 49% of their scoring total in the first three championship games, they managed to construct an appropriate haul in his absence against Antrim and suitably diversified responsibility against Dublin. Where they didn't reach the 30-point barrier in their first seven games, they have broken it in three and clocked 0-29 in their fourth match since then. The goal-scoring balance remains an issue. They have only kept one clean sheet in 11 games this year. At the other end, they have been shut out four times themselves; even if Donoghue's side didn't need goals back in '17 either. They will be tested at both ends by Kilkenny in the Leinster final. There remains a significant distance to travel before Galway could be classed as Liam MacCarthy contenders. But should they smuggle the Bob O'Keeffe Cup back across the Shannon after six years characterised by near misses and flops, their prize would be an All-Ireland semi-final. One that avoids the Munster champions too. From there, a return to the biggest stage wouldn't look so far. They have cast off one hex by beating Dublin, and with that, accomplished a significant marker of progress from the early elimination that ended Henry Shefflin's reign. Donoghue, as the Dubs' head honcho, was responsible for that downfall. His return has reinstituted the minimum acceptable levels of performance for this new-look group. Consistency is the next marker. Then, a Leinster title. Then, we would get a better sense of what's achievable in the rest of Donoghue's four-year term.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Ryanair to boost Shannon winter services
The Government should expand the State's regional airports programme, Ryanair argued after announcing that it will base a new aircraft at Shannon and offer new routes from the mid-western gateway this winter. The carrier said it would base one of its new Boeing 737 'gamechanger' aircraft at Shannon for winter 2025/26, calculating that this should boost passenger numbers there by 100,000. Ryanair will add new routes to Lapland, Madeira and Spanish capital Madrid. The airline intends to increase the number of flights a-week to existing destinations including Alicante in Spain, Lanzarote in the Canaries, Kraków and Wroclaw in Poland, and Edinburgh and Manchester. READ MORE Ryanair estimates that the additional jet amounts a $400 million (€350 million) investment in Shannon. The additional 100,000 passengers will bring the airline's numbers at Shannon to 1.6 million a-year, a statement said. It will also add more than 1,500 jobs, including 350 pilots, cabin crew and engineers. Jason McGuinness, Ryanair's chief commercial officer, said the airline wanted to grow business at Shannon, Knock and Kerry. But he argued that the Government needed to support these gateways by expanding its regional airports programme to cover those that handle up to three million passengers a-year. Mr McGuinness added that this would allow regional airports to 'grow traffic without being penalised for doing so'. Currently the programme is limited to airports with scheduled services that handle up to one million passengers a-year. Mary Considine, chief executive, Shannon Airport Group, said Ryanair's investment was a powerful endorsement of its potential. 'We see a huge potential for growth and believe there is a real opportunity for Shannon Airport to lead the way in re-balancing the national landscape,' she said. Shannon grew passengers by 7 per cent to 2.1 million in 2024, the first time it passed the two-million mark in 15 years.
